Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?

616 replies

00100001 · 13/02/2022 22:35

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

OP posts:
NandorTheRelentlessCleaner · 16/02/2022 12:01

Hmmm yes and no, the avocado trope is boring

BUT

In the 90s, earning £850 a month (DH a bit more) with 70% of our joint income going on rent, we still saved £200 a month for 5 yrs, we did not eat out, go on holidays, or do nails etc

It was a very frugal existence, and hard to do, but it saved us the deposit for a flat after 5yrs, and after that we started earning more and paying less and having more fun

But she 25-30 was just work and frugal fun (pic nice with friends, drinking cheap wine in the park Grin sort of stuff.

Yes we were lucky that flats were affordable (95k for a 1 bed flat in East End) and yes I don’t begrudge young people their lifestyles, and yes I think house prices now are insane….. BUT, young people are definitely more about enjoying the moment and not taking the long view in terms of finances

I think

Jemineye · 16/02/2022 11:59

We were literally told years ago by my DHs moderately well off parents that "you'll be getting nothing." Nothing. We hadn't even asked! They're completely disinterested in us or their grandchildren despite having had lots of help themselves when they were raising their own children.

Unfortunately I have inlaws that genuinely think they are doing us a favour by 'toughening us up' by not giving us any support whatsoever despite getting it from their own parents. Hey ho.. shan't miss them when they're gone!

User639710 · 16/02/2022 11:43

A lot of people can't easily live with parents anyway as it might not be where their workplace is, DS didn't come back home after university and got his job in the city where he was, he carried on house sharing, did his part time supermarket job full time whilst applying for accounting jobs.

Coffeetree · 16/02/2022 11:18

The whole avocado and nails thing is just another way for well-off people to bash others.

The first person who brought it up here boasted that they saved for a mortgage "without help" --except for living rent-free with mummy and daddy.

Lovinglife45 · 15/02/2022 20:07

Mrsbaubles
On average gel nails/extensions cost £30/£40 every few weeks. Just over £1000 a year. £10,000 in a decade which would barely touch the sides. I can imagine many women would think "fuck it, I will never be able to save enough for a deposit, let me do the small things that will bring me joy/pleasure"

There is no benefit to scrimping and suffering if it does not pay off in the long run. There are simply some things that are out of reach for many, no matter how much they cut back.

MrsBaublesDylan · 15/02/2022 19:39

I am Gen X and would say that those who left University and got well paid jobs could easily afford to buy a flat in London by their late 20s.

Quite a few of my friends got inheritances from GPs.

Whereas Millennials need a very well paid job, a partner with a well paid job and some help from their baby boomer parents (either through living at home rent free to save or through a lump sum gift) to be able to buy in their early 30s.

I am very suspicious of those who claim they got a hefty deposit by shunning false nails and avocados.

It obliterates the logic that in order to save, you need:

a) money
b) lower outgoings

Not denying of course, the power of an avocado.

weansu · 15/02/2022 16:22

The Bank of M&D certainly has an impact.

"In 2020, gifts from parents, grandparents, friends and relatives were behind more than half of house purchases among the under-35s, according to a study by Legal & General"

Bringsexyback · 15/02/2022 16:02

@Iamthewombat

Yes, but the PP isn’t going to admit that when she sells to her son, is she? And I bet she doesn’t know that rule either. I think that she just doesn’t understand how capital gains work.
You don’t get a lot of choice in the matter when you apply for the mortgage it’s a concessionary mortgage so the deposit is being gifted out of money that actually in theory doesn’t exist because it’s on paper equity, the result HMRC insist on a valuation and that’s the number the tax you on. So basically you pay capital gains tax on money that doesn’t exist I mean you’ve got to admire the system really.
Iamthewombat · 15/02/2022 15:35

Yes, but the PP isn’t going to admit that when she sells to her son, is she? And I bet she doesn’t know that rule either. I think that she just doesn’t understand how capital gains work.

Kazzyhoward · 15/02/2022 15:33

@Iamthewombat

How will you have capital gains tax to pay if you are selling your buy to let house to your son for less than you bought it for? You pay CGT on gains. Not proceeds.

CGT is on market value, not actual value, when selling an asset to a connected person.

Iamthewombat · 15/02/2022 15:28

@caringcarer

Not sure if I'm a baby boomer as born in 61 but only have 2 years of mortgage left to pay. I have been passing on money/help to my children whilst I'm still alive and can see them benefit. I have helped dd out with extortionate nursery fees so she can go back to work full time twice. I helped DS with giving him £8.5k deposit and now with youngest son we are going to sell a btl to him for less than we bought it for 15 years ago so he will have the equity in it and can therefore afford to pay mortgage on it. We will have to pay approximately £28k capital gains and pay of small mortgage but it seems pointless him having to live at home saving £7k a year when house prices are going up £10k each year or more. I will be adjusting my will to make sure he gets a little less in our will.
Yes, you are in the baby boomer cohort but you’re only 61 or 62. Not sure why you write as if you are 91 I have been passing on money/help to my children whilst I'm still alive and can see them benefit

How will you have capital gains tax to pay if you are selling your buy to let house to your son for less than you bought it for? You pay CGT on gains. Not proceeds.

Are nursery fees ‘extortionate’? How much do you think nursery should cost? Should the staff work for free?

Lovinglife45 · 15/02/2022 15:06

I am in no way deliberately being insensitive but I am confused when people mention a parent had to die for them to receive their inheritance/house. Those who do not receive inheritances also suffer the loss of parents and have to go through a grieving process.

Bringsexyback · 15/02/2022 14:53

@Iamthewombat

The OP is correct. If all parents in a position to inject cash from the bank of mum and dad took a stand and said no, we’re not going to feed insane house prices by giving our children big deposits to ‘get ahead of the game’, then less money would be chasing the same assets and prices would have to come down.

But that would require all parents to make the same sensible decision, wouldn’t it? And to take a long term view for the common good.

The same people sending their children to private school for a perceived advantage over every other child or move into OFSTED outstanding areas pushing the house prices up and again quashing any chance of equality or levelling up.
EdithRea · 15/02/2022 14:34

First house - saved for 12 years for deposit.
Second house - saved for 9 years for deposit plus selling the first house.

No one had to die.

caringcarer · 15/02/2022 14:26

Not sure if I'm a baby boomer as born in 61 but only have 2 years of mortgage left to pay. I have been passing on money/help to my children whilst I'm still alive and can see them benefit. I have helped dd out with extortionate nursery fees so she can go back to work full time twice. I helped DS with giving him £8.5k deposit and now with youngest son we are going to sell a btl to him for less than we bought it for 15 years ago so he will have the equity in it and can therefore afford to pay mortgage on it. We will have to pay approximately £28k capital gains and pay of small mortgage but it seems pointless him having to live at home saving £7k a year when house prices are going up £10k each year or more. I will be adjusting my will to make sure he gets a little less in our will.

Calennig · 15/02/2022 14:23

I've wondered this for years.

We're mid 40s had to wait till early 30s to buy and it took huge amount of sacrifice hard saving, lucky and planning getting to a place we could afford only to have prices drop couple of years after buying and first house to cost a fortune as nothing had been done to it for years - so for less than we paid for it. It's only with second house we've got on an even keel.

We didn't have parental handouts becuase they weren't in a position to give us any - and I was by time I was an adult priced out of bit of midlands I grew up in and large swaths of the country.

We can't afford to live in the city DH works in - so he has a long commute. Even here prices have risen since we bought as we wouldn't be able to buy this house now.

There are parts of the UK where property prices are still affordable but I have to wonder if there will be any left by time our kids are needing to buy and if they'll be able to match jobs and locations or at least manage long commutes like we managed.

caringcarer · 15/02/2022 14:15

I agree places where houses are cheaper often wages is a lot less too. Also unless in a city maybe less employment.

caringcarer · 15/02/2022 14:11

I agree with poster who said there are still parts of country where it is possible for a couple to get 3x salary and buy a house. My son bought in Hull a 2 bedroom terrace house for £75k only last year. He moved from Midlands as he could not afford a house there. He took a £750 net pay cut when he makes bed but he can afford his mortgage which is 25 years and he could not afford a house in Midlands even with a good deposit.

StEval · 15/02/2022 13:57

@BulletTrain

Few FTB are buying 650K houses for a start.

Yes. I may be repeating myself but the £500k houses here are going to people on their 2nd or 3rd move who have been paying mortgages for 10-15 years. I'm 37 and we've been homeowners for 14 years, paying down a repayment mortgage as opposed to interest-only. My parents lent us 6k as a deposit back in the day but that's not really having an impact right now on what we can afford.

If people don't take their equity and move then essentially the starter homes are all full. Which is what would happen if there was a price crash.

Precisely. Once the FTB move up to more expensive properties then its equity that forms their deposits. I remember in the 2008/9 crash there was a dearth of FTB homes, threads on here about it. There was nothing to buy as many in negative equity simply stayed put.
BulletTrain · 15/02/2022 13:49

Few FTB are buying 650K houses for a start.

Yes. I may be repeating myself but the £500k houses here are going to people on their 2nd or 3rd move who have been paying mortgages for 10-15 years. I'm 37 and we've been homeowners for 14 years, paying down a repayment mortgage as opposed to interest-only. My parents lent us 6k as a deposit back in the day but that's not really having an impact right now on what we can afford.

If people don't take their equity and move then essentially the starter homes are all full. Which is what would happen if there was a price crash.

StEval · 15/02/2022 13:48

@Iamthewombat

You sound quite put out and petulant

The OP started a discussion which I, and I’m sure many others, enjoyed reading and taking part in. No need to be insulting because you don’t like her point of view.

Shes blaming a whole group of people via generalisations rather than actually looking at the whole picture and the actions of the government. Its unpleasant and as usual these types would be biting your arm off if money was offered to them!
Iamthewombat · 15/02/2022 13:44

You sound quite put out and petulant

The OP started a discussion which I, and I’m sure many others, enjoyed reading and taking part in. No need to be insulting because you don’t like her point of view.

StEval · 15/02/2022 13:39

[quote 00100001]@StEval

Well, yes in away i do blame them,as it's clear lots of people are getting help from their parents etc. Essentially 3-4 people are involved in buying a house, instead of 1-2.

Pretend that nobody was able to live fire free or given large money gifts in order to help buy houses... This would mean that house prices wouldn't be as high, because nobody would buy them.[/quote]
Im afraid I think thats quite a simplistic POV.
I and many others I know have received zero help.
Not all BB are rich, many particularly women who have poor pensions.
Few FTB are buying 650K houses for a start.

You sound quite put out and petulant, I take it if you were offered 20K for a house deposit you would turn it down?
Yeah right !

Iamthewombat · 15/02/2022 13:35

The OP is correct. If all parents in a position to inject cash from the bank of mum and dad took a stand and said no, we’re not going to feed insane house prices by giving our children big deposits to ‘get ahead of the game’, then less money would be chasing the same assets and prices would have to come down.

But that would require all parents to make the same sensible decision, wouldn’t it? And to take a long term view for the common good.

00100001 · 15/02/2022 13:25

@StEval

Well, yes in away i do blame them,as it's clear lots of people are getting help from their parents etc. Essentially 3-4 people are involved in buying a house, instead of 1-2.

Pretend that nobody was able to live fire free or given large money gifts in order to help buy houses... This would mean that house prices wouldn't be as high, because nobody would buy them.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread