Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?

616 replies

00100001 · 13/02/2022 22:35

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 16/02/2022 19:52

What did we blame for everything we didn't approve of before Instagram?

People don't buy nice houses for Instagram, they buy nice houses because it's more enjoyable to live in a nice house.

00100001 · 16/02/2022 19:51

@joydivisionovengloves71

The average property is £268,349
Meaning, that, generally a FTB would need to find £26.8k + fees, let's just round it to £30k for convenience.

A significant sum.

Also, why should people be forced to buy "fixer uppers" because the good properties are so very expensive (which might be partly due to Bank of Mum and Dad) when they just shouldn't be

An average person on average income should be able to afford an average prices house. But they just can't, without saving for an incredibly long time, or getting help from someone.

OP posts:
joydivisionovengloves71 · 16/02/2022 19:45

@DrSbaitso

Also years ago people were happy to buy a cheap doer upper in a less desirable area and progress from there.

Many people feel very stressed living in a fixer upper and do not have the time or skills to make it decent. It shouldn't be the case that FTBs are expected to live in a building site because nothing else is affordable.

I'm talking about very dated, needs some modernisation but not actually falling down. But that's not suitable for the insta posts
balalake · 16/02/2022 19:38

An amount must come from people who have a house moving to another. There is no way I could afford a house that cost twice the price I paid for mine 12 years ago, yet I can get almost twice the amount now for it.

lopape · 16/02/2022 19:35

@Seashor

My son has just bought a house with his girlfriend. 70 thousand deposit. They worked their arses off, didn’t spend on false nails, hair, etc. They lived at home and they didn’t decide to have children and then bleat on about how the ‘Boomers’ had it so easy. They didn’t! They were also prepared to move to a cheaper area.
You're getting a lot of shit but I agree with you. We're millennials as well and bought young. We had no external help and we didn't live with parents either. I know couples with extremely similar salaries who are complaining about boomers had it easy but they're not making any sacrifices.

And before anyone jumps on me as well I know a lot of people actually cannot afford it but at the same time there are so many professionals who could if they just saved more (including the famous avocado 🥑)

StEval · 16/02/2022 19:32

@XjustagirlX

Average deposit in the U.K. is £40k. Average salary is £25k. This results in take home pay of £1,700 a month.

If average person manages to save £250 a month from their £1,700 wage and their partner does the same, they can save £6000 a year.

If they had both started saving 6 years ago they would now have a total of £36,000. With the LISA bonus this results in a deposit of £45k.

It’s much easier to buy a house if you have a partner and you have an average or higher wage. But it can be done for the average person. Also it assumes you start saving a few years before you actually want to buy a house not the year before.

I really feel sorry for people under say 21 as they can’t really save quicker than house prices are increasing.

But for a lot of people over say 28 they could have started saving years ago. Obviously there will always be people who had a shitty hand and circumstances were not in their favour. Also if you have children before buying a house it’s even harder.

Totally agree! The trope that a lipstick or an avocado wont buy you a house is ridiculous. No one said it would. However The amount of discretionary spending on appearance in the UK is phenomenal. High end lipsticks like CT are £25 not £15, palettes are around £36-£60. Your average, very attractive, tanned, glossy haired, beautifully made up young woman has spent a fortune to look like that unless very lucky. Hair extensions, eyebrows, lashes, spray tan, high end make up, botox, filler,nails, waxing or laser, spa days. Gym, PT or peloton. Dyson hairdryers and hair wraps

What people spend their money on is entirely up to them but you cant spend it twice!
Many of the above things are considered essential,so no that money wont be available to save.
Add in holidays and an expensive car on PCP and you are stuffed.
No not everyone earns enough for those things anyway highlighted so its not missed and therefore wont be able to save that money but the industry is huge.
Bizarre to keep denying it.

Several of my colleagues all in couples, both earning 25-28k have all saved and bought houses recently, no parental help.
All cut back massively and prioritised buying
a house over other things.

joydivisionovengloves71 · 16/02/2022 19:31

@Boombastic22

It’s simply wonderful how many posters seem to miss the point that people can save for deposits because they live with their parents…, it’s not rocket science!!
Yes but they don't, then moan on here
DrSbaitso · 16/02/2022 19:30

Also years ago people were happy to buy a cheap doer upper in a less desirable area and progress from there.

Many people feel very stressed living in a fixer upper and do not have the time or skills to make it decent. It shouldn't be the case that FTBs are expected to live in a building site because nothing else is affordable.

joydivisionovengloves71 · 16/02/2022 19:28

[quote LittleGwyneth]@joydivisionovengloves71 Even if you remove the laughable part of your hypothesis where someone automatically has the privilege of living at home for five years, 18K as a deposit for a small flat?

The average house price in London is £514K. You'd need to live with your parents until you were nearly 30 at that rate. Not everyone lives in an area where you can buy a small flat for less than 200K. You'd be hard pressed to get one for less than 350K where I live. Which happens to be where my job, family and friends are.

No-one is denying that there is an element of sacrifice in saving for a deposit and always has been, but trying to save £50K is no joke, and isn't achieved by giving up a few lipsticks and holidays.[/quote]
Well your average young single person isn't going to be looking for a house in central London 🙄 Also years ago people were happy to buy a cheap doer upper in a less desirable area and progress from there. But that's not acceptable these days.

Dmsandfloatydress · 16/02/2022 19:20

It's utterly shit for millenials. I'm generation x and bought a flat with a 100% mortgage in 2006. That mortgage was so much cheaper than renting it was a no brainer. 10 years later it provided the deposit for my milenial husband and my first house which is a decent family home in a good area. My husband is a higher rate tax payer so would have eventually been able to save a deposit to buy a small flat but he would have been in his mid thirties before that happened. I am an average earner but it was easy for me to get on the first rung of the ladder.
My parents did scrimp and save to buy , but they bought a three bed semi as their first house at 22 which was twice my dad's income!!

ParsleySageRosemary · 16/02/2022 17:27

@XjustagirlX sorry I’m always a bit irritable after coming across the financial corruption. The U.K. is an embarrassment now imo.

00100001 · 16/02/2022 17:16

@LittleGwyneth

I completely agree. When facing the prospect of saving for 10 years, whilst you scrimp and watching prices go up quicker than inflation...it's must be a seemingly impossible task!

OP posts:
XjustagirlX · 16/02/2022 17:15

Averages obviously used for purposes of average calculation! I can’t go through every scenario. In my area average house deposit would be about £20k.

ParsleySageRosemary · 16/02/2022 17:11

Averages mean nothing in a country with income inequality, weren’t you taught that in primary school?

ParsleySageRosemary · 16/02/2022 17:09

Let’s not forget the other small matter pushing up house prices in the capital, which then pushes up the nearby regions, which then push up more distant ones - corruption in London, aka all that lovely ‘foreign investment’ in the financial markets. Thanks for the reminder BBC www.bbc.co.uk/news/60348046 I often think we’d all have been better off if London had followed through on its threat to declare independence after Brexit, it’s the place we all do want to get rid of.

But no, it doesn’t let local buy-to-let landlords off the hook, it’s merely another factor. And obligatory reminder again - not everyone has parents they can live with for free to save up deposit money. That should not mean such people are forced to labour for nothing for all of their lives, compounding their lack of privilege down into the next generation.

XjustagirlX · 16/02/2022 17:05

Average deposit in the U.K. is £40k. Average salary is £25k. This results in take home pay of £1,700 a month.

If average person manages to save £250 a month from their £1,700 wage and their partner does the same, they can save £6000 a year.

If they had both started saving 6 years ago they would now have a total of £36,000. With the LISA bonus this results in a deposit of £45k.

It’s much easier to buy a house if you have a partner and you have an average or higher wage. But it can be done for the average person. Also it assumes you start saving a few years before you actually want to buy a house not the year before.

I really feel sorry for people under say 21 as they can’t really save quicker than house prices are increasing.

But for a lot of people over say 28 they could have started saving years ago. Obviously there will always be people who had a shitty hand and circumstances were not in their favour. Also if you have children before buying a house it’s even harder.

BulletTrain · 16/02/2022 16:59

Another point is that it's really not advisable to spend every last penny on a house and legal fees. I would always advise keeping a little bit back as a redundancy cushion. Young people will not be getting any long service redundancy payouts.

Merryoldgoat · 16/02/2022 16:46

And 20 years ago my friend bought her flat. She was earning £22k and her flat was £165k.

Same job (graduate scheme still in operation) pays £26k now. Flat is work £400k.

Things are different and it’s ridiculous to pretend it’s not really hard now.

Wedonttalkabout · 16/02/2022 16:44

It also ignores the gap between earnings and mortgages

I've saved enough for a deposit but can't borrow enough to buy a house.

That's the same with lots of single people, or people on starter incomes.

LittleGwyneth · 16/02/2022 16:43

[quote 00100001]@LittleGwyneth

The thing about makeup was highlighting perhaps lifestyle choices, not about the one off incidental purchases.

Eg if Person A spends monthly; £20 mascara, £70 phone contract, £20+ TV streaming,£ £15 music streaming £100 eating out, £50 on hot drinks, £350 on car finance etc they're perhaps spending £600+ pcm on "luxuries"

Whereas person B might spend £5 mascara, £10 phone contract, no streaming, £10 on hot drinks, £40 eating out £100 on car finance etc they spending £200

So the difference could perhaps be quite large?

Obviously it's a simplistic view, but perhaps valid?[/quote]
These are terribly realistic figures as a young person's car finance is automatically far more expensive, getting a car for £100 a month doesn't really work, and even then you've got insurance etc for both parties. But putting aside some flaws in the figures, yes it would be quicker for person B to save a deposit. But person B only has an additional £400 a month to put into savings, which means (s)he is going to have to save for 125 months or 10.4 years to have the average house deposit.

I can see why saving for over ten years to be able to buy a small property - arguably too small if you want kids by this point - would be unappealing enough to make you think fuck it, I'll take a decade of nice lipsticks and a decent iPhone over scrimping.

Merryoldgoat · 16/02/2022 16:41

I completely agree with you. I saved the first 5k of my deposit between the age of 16 and 18 by working evenings/weekends/holidays while I was still at school doing A-levels

It’s comments like this that drive me mad.

It’s great you could do that. I worked evenings, weekends and holidays during my a-levels because my family were living in poverty and I needed to pay for my travel and clothes and some food.

Savings are completely out of reach for some.

WindyState · 16/02/2022 16:41

[quote LuckySantangelo35]@ManicPixie
Obviously I know there are other factors but I do stand by what I said about young adults accessing luxury brands etc spending on meals out etc more than what same age young people would have done 10 years ago.[/quote]
Just bollocks. The fact is that the gap between earnings and affordable housing has massively widened over the past 20/30 years.

Some young people will and will always fritter money away. The difference is that 20 years ago they might have stood a chance of buying a house whereas many, many more these days have no chance at all without the cash coming from somewhere other than their wages.

LittleGwyneth · 16/02/2022 16:36

@joydivisionovengloves71 Even if you remove the laughable part of your hypothesis where someone automatically has the privilege of living at home for five years, 18K as a deposit for a small flat?

The average house price in London is £514K. You'd need to live with your parents until you were nearly 30 at that rate. Not everyone lives in an area where you can buy a small flat for less than 200K. You'd be hard pressed to get one for less than 350K where I live. Which happens to be where my job, family and friends are.

No-one is denying that there is an element of sacrifice in saving for a deposit and always has been, but trying to save £50K is no joke, and isn't achieved by giving up a few lipsticks and holidays.

00100001 · 16/02/2022 16:32

@LittleGwyneth

The thing about makeup was highlighting perhaps lifestyle choices, not about the one off incidental purchases.

Eg if Person A spends monthly; £20 mascara, £70 phone contract, £20+ TV streaming,£ £15 music streaming £100 eating out, £50 on hot drinks, £350 on car finance etc they're perhaps spending £600+ pcm on "luxuries"

Whereas person B might spend £5 mascara, £10 phone contract, no streaming, £10 on hot drinks, £40 eating out £100 on car finance etc they spending £200

So the difference could perhaps be quite large?

Obviously it's a simplistic view, but perhaps valid?

OP posts:
MidnightMeltdown · 16/02/2022 16:30

@LuckySantangelo35

I’m not sure really…I do think twenty-somethings now do have a higher standard of living when it comes to ‘treats’ and seem to have more of a sense of entitlement around this. All the twenty somethings I know will buy makeup like Charlotte tilbury whereas when I’ll have bought brands like Rimell and Maybelline at their age. Stuff like meals out, hair extensions, botox/fillers, holidays abroad etc all seem pretty common place for today’s younger adults so it’s no wonder some cannot afford a mortgage. I think as well house sharing seems to have gone out of the window. Young adults seem to either live with their parents, rent alone or with a partner or buys. Sharing with friends or a house share a la Spareroom.com doesn’t seem to be as much of a thing any more?

I completely agree with you. I saved the first 5k of my deposit between the age of 16 and 18 by working evenings/weekends/holidays while I was still at school doing A-levels.

I would still spend some money going out with friends and having fun, but I wasn't spending £££ on clothes, luxury makeup, treatments, meals out etc that people seem to do these days.

I disagree with people saying that these things don't make a difference - they do really add up over a few years. As a teenager, I could easily have pissed that money up the wall, but it wouldn't even have occurred to me to do that.

5k might not be much, but even small amounts help when trying to get a deposit together. Unless you're buying in London or some areas of SE, you don't need a massive deposit to get a foot on the ladder.

Swipe left for the next trending thread