Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?

616 replies

00100001 · 13/02/2022 22:35

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

OP posts:
ParkingFeud · 17/02/2022 20:13

@User639710

I couldn't do A levels, I left school at 16 and got a job and paid board, my parents wouldn't have supported me to do A levels, this was mid 70s
That's not allowed though, despite the fact that many 16 year olds would probably be better off doing that and would like to have that option. There's also no way that someone on minimum wage for a 16 year old could afford to live. They'd get £4.62 an hour.
User639710 · 17/02/2022 20:02

I couldn't do A levels, I left school at 16 and got a job and paid board, my parents wouldn't have supported me to do A levels, this was mid 70s

Kennykenkencat · 17/02/2022 20:00

@Iamthewombat

In fact as a woman you weren’t on anywhere near the same salary as a man in the same job.

Come off it. The youngest baby boomers were born in 1964 and entered the workforce in the early 1980s. The equal pay act was passed in 1970. You weren’t living through the 1930s when women were paid less as standard.

Information was limited to what you could read in a library or what friends and family knew.

Er, newspapers? The Money Programme on BBC? It wouldn’t have taken much gumption to find out about mortgages, now, would it? Plenty of people did during the 1970s and 1980s!

University might have been free but very few people went because

A) very few people actually gained the required A levels to go

Well yes, that is why it was free! I went in 1989, when only 10-15% of school leavers went to university. But what has that to do with mortgages? There were more jobs available for school leavers then, who could start earning straight away.

B) A lot who would have gone on to do A levels had to go to work at 16 as it was pointless staying on for A levels as they wouldn’t have been able to afford the living expenses and books etc. Even just to start off with

What living expenses? Most kids doing A levels lived with their parents, then as now. Are you suggesting that the 1970s and 1980s were like a Victorian novel, with parents sending their children to work in the mill or sweep chimneys?

Or do you mean university living expenses? That’s what student grants were for, and they were very much available during the 1970s and 1980s.

It’s not an inter-generational struggle. It’s an economic problem. However, it’s irritating to read these ‘four yorkshiremen’ inspired hard luck stories from people who can’t see why the young have a right to be annoyed at the situation they find themselves in.

If you believe that the equal pay act suddenly meant in 1970 every woman was suddenly on the same salary as a man in the same job then you really are not getting the reality.

I do think there was definitely a class divide. Or even a race divide.

Even when I left school I knew girls who didn’t go on to do A levels as the family needed them to help out with money.
There was no sitting at home studying.
A few girls I know went back to their home country and returned with a husband.
Those that did go to work handed over their pay packet to their dad and were given back a bit of pocket money. My mother charged me so much that I moved out as I wasn’t able to pay the keep
I do laugh at the idea of people where I grew up pouring over the newspaper or watching the Money Programme. Most couldn’t speak English. Let alone have any money to invest.

Not 4 Yorkshire men that would indicate we were from the U.K.

BulletTrain · 17/02/2022 19:16

Come off it. The youngest baby boomers were born in 1964 and entered the workforce in the early 1980s. The equal pay act was passed in 1970. You weren’t living through the 1930s when women were paid less as standard.

Yes. My mum was 26 when she had me in 1984 and had been in the workforce for 10 years. She was head of accounts by then! They easily bought their first £9k bungalow in 1978.

Iamthewombat · 17/02/2022 15:19

In fact as a woman you weren’t on anywhere near the same salary as a man in the same job.

Come off it. The youngest baby boomers were born in 1964 and entered the workforce in the early 1980s. The equal pay act was passed in 1970. You weren’t living through the 1930s when women were paid less as standard.

Information was limited to what you could read in a library or what friends and family knew.

Er, newspapers? The Money Programme on BBC? It wouldn’t have taken much gumption to find out about mortgages, now, would it? Plenty of people did during the 1970s and 1980s!

University might have been free but very few people went because

A) very few people actually gained the required A levels to go

Well yes, that is why it was free! I went in 1989, when only 10-15% of school leavers went to university. But what has that to do with mortgages? There were more jobs available for school leavers then, who could start earning straight away.

B) A lot who would have gone on to do A levels had to go to work at 16 as it was pointless staying on for A levels as they wouldn’t have been able to afford the living expenses and books etc. Even just to start off with

What living expenses? Most kids doing A levels lived with their parents, then as now. Are you suggesting that the 1970s and 1980s were like a Victorian novel, with parents sending their children to work in the mill or sweep chimneys?

Or do you mean university living expenses? That’s what student grants were for, and they were very much available during the 1970s and 1980s.

It’s not an inter-generational struggle. It’s an economic problem. However, it’s irritating to read these ‘four yorkshiremen’ inspired hard luck stories from people who can’t see why the young have a right to be annoyed at the situation they find themselves in.

Kennykenkencat · 17/02/2022 15:06

@Blossomtoes

Also, why should people be forced to buy "fixer uppers" because the good properties are so very expensive (which might be partly due to Bank of Mum and Dad) when they just shouldn't be

Because that’s what the boomers of whom there’s such envy did. A lot of us bought houses that needed huge amounts of work and did them up gradually as we could afford it. We put up with living in sub optimal conditions because that’s what it took to buy a house. Nobody bought a four bed detached house as their first property.

I agree with this.

I am a “Boomer” and the way people blame us for how “lucky” we were. Yet living through it and actually being there you didn’t feel lucky.
Everyone posts about average incomes and average house prices which is what you can see on the internet.

The reality as ftb’s you weren’t on an average salary. In fact as a woman you weren’t on anywhere near the same salary as a man in the same job.
Food, clothing, public transport, utilities etc were eye wateringly expensive because there was no choice.

Information was limited to what you could read in a library or what friends and family knew.

University might have been free but very few people went because
A) very few people actually gained the required A levels to go

B) A lot who would have gone on to do A levels had to go to work at 16 as it was pointless staying on for A levels as they wouldn’t have been able to afford the living expenses and books etc. Even just to start off with

Housing might look cheap but multiples of 1.5 times the higher salary and 1x the lower with a 100% mortgage meant depending where you lived unless you had a really well paying job you still had to save up as those multiples might not get you the cheapest place on the market
There might have been higher multiples but unless someone told you about them then you had to go with the single local building society.

Personally I think making small studio flats unmortgageable created the biggest problem for first time buyers.

It meant that instead of scraping together a much smaller deposit and having much smaller mortgage payments and getting out of rented very quickly. When that first step was taken away. It meant more time in rented and the studio flats that would have been bought ended up as btl places

My first place I bought with dh was the tiniest studio flat that someone had painted the whole of the bathroom in black gloss
I mean the “whole” of the bathroom. Spent many hours peeling black gloss paint off the toilet, wash basin and shower. It was pretty grim but it did allow us a breather from the £170 per month rent we were paying.

Iamthewombat · 17/02/2022 14:57

This is the cause of the misery for first time buyers today. 100% mortgages, I remember 125% mortgages so you could furnish the house and buy a car on the mortgage

Yes, you are absolutely right. Northern Rock were the worst offenders. It was they who offered the 125% ‘together’ mortgage in the early 2000s.

Remember those queues outside Northern Rock branches in 2007, when everyone’s grandma wanted to get their money out? The first run on a British bank in decades? Thank reckless mortgage lending for that.

Until that point, the idiots who ran Northern Rock had been showing off about democratising home ownership and enabling young people to ‘get on the ladder’ etc. Magazines aimed at twenty and thirty something women were full of articles praising the ‘together’ mortgage and encouraging readers to take one out.

Look how that has ended up, 15 years later! Young people locked out of home ownership unless they have substantial parental help. No wonder they are angry and disenfranchised.

Really, the government should have allowed interest rates to do their thing naturally, even if it meant that some people lost their houses or went into negative equity, as happened in the early nineties. Short term pain for long term gain. But no, QE happened and it’s long term pain instead, and it does nobody any good. If you already own a house you’re no richer. If you want to move to a bigger house you’re saddled with a massive mortgage that saps your future wealth. The economy has adapted to lower disposable incomes, so there are fewer nice shops and fewer nice things to buy. All because of stupid, reckless lending. But The Big Short tells that story better than me.

Xenia · 17/02/2022 14:22

Anyone who has owned a property for 20 or 30 years as I have will have known all kinds of different situations from 14% interest rates to crashes and massive price rises up. Lincslady reminds me of when we started. My husband needed a relationship with a building society for many years before they would consider you for a loan and you could borrow 3x one salary or 2.5x joint salaries. You needed a sizeable deposit and it was not very easy for a woman on her own to buy due to sexism never mind lower pay for women. I certainly remember the days of 100% mortgages too although they have often come and then quickly gone rather than that they were a thing for decades. My parents could not have one. I don't think we ever could get one when we happened to be wanting to buy either.

I agree that state market interference has made things worse, not better. Eg the state introduced after the 2008 credit crunch much tighter requirements for lending, new stress tests etc so fewer could borrow. Interest rates have been kept right down so house prices have shot up. The days when I thought our 10 year fix at 13% was good are long gone. I pay 1.44% on my interest only mortgage currently.

WindyState · 17/02/2022 13:51

@Blossomtoes

Also, why should people be forced to buy "fixer uppers" because the good properties are so very expensive (which might be partly due to Bank of Mum and Dad) when they just shouldn't be

Because that’s what the boomers of whom there’s such envy did. A lot of us bought houses that needed huge amounts of work and did them up gradually as we could afford it. We put up with living in sub optimal conditions because that’s what it took to buy a house. Nobody bought a four bed detached house as their first property.

Generalising much?

Some did, some didn't.

You realise that the "fixer uppers" have gone up in price as much as everything else?

Blossomtoes · 17/02/2022 13:18

Also, why should people be forced to buy "fixer uppers" because the good properties are so very expensive (which might be partly due to Bank of Mum and Dad) when they just shouldn't be

Because that’s what the boomers of whom there’s such envy did. A lot of us bought houses that needed huge amounts of work and did them up gradually as we could afford it. We put up with living in sub optimal conditions because that’s what it took to buy a house. Nobody bought a four bed detached house as their first property.

Iamthewombat · 17/02/2022 12:12

Wouldn't have been able to afford the house we have without those schemes/offers

Actually, without those schemes (help to buy, etc) inflating prices you probably would have been able to buy at a lower cost.

internetpersonme · 17/02/2022 10:57

Yep.... if i could move in somewhere for practically free bet i could save up 70k too

Theladyinpurple · 17/02/2022 09:54

We saved, with the help of matched betting.
Govt help to buy.
Husband is military so also forces help to buy.
New build property - developer offered 5% nhs discount.

Wouldn't have been able to afford the house we have without those schemes/offers

Lincslady53 · 17/02/2022 09:26

@Dmsandfloatydress

It's utterly shit for millenials. I'm generation x and bought a flat with a 100% mortgage in 2006. That mortgage was so much cheaper than renting it was a no brainer. 10 years later it provided the deposit for my milenial husband and my first house which is a decent family home in a good area. My husband is a higher rate tax payer so would have eventually been able to save a deposit to buy a small flat but he would have been in his mid thirties before that happened. I am an average earner but it was easy for me to get on the first rung of the ladder. My parents did scrimp and save to buy , but they bought a three bed semi as their first house at 22 which was twice my dad's income!!
This is the cause of the misery for first time buyers today. 100% mortgages, I remember 125% mortgages so you could furnish the house and buy a car on the mortgage. House prices were rising fast so very soon your mortgage debt would be less than the house value. Lots of easy loans available to everyone, result, house price increase, everyone feels well off, the economy booms, the government claim that they have ended the boom and bust cycle, so everyone feels confident and borrows more money, so house prices continue to rise then..... An almighty crash. We were outside the S E and we had our house valued in 2007 just before the crash. When the next house like it was sold, several years later, the price was 25% lowers than that 2007 valuation, and it is only with the mad increase over the last couple of years that the value has exceeded that valuation. The government in the noughties should have clamped down on the money supply to keep house price increases reasonable, but when everyone feels wealthy they take the credit and get voted back in again. And by the time the crash came, the man at the top had left, and someone else took the blame. Mind you,he was chancellor through the boom, and did nothing to control it.
Lincslady53 · 17/02/2022 09:06

My partner worked for a building society back in the 70s. The mortgage market was tightly controlled, 10% deposit, and the amount you could borrow was 3x the main earners salary, plus once times the secondary salary. Mortgage rates were around 8%, and were decided at monthly meetings within the upper echelons of the mortgage providers. Fixed rate deals were rare. This kept a lid on house prices. As the mortgage market was opened up, interest rates fell to where they are today, and increased competition for loans made the money supply easier, result - house price inflation. It was particularly out of control in the noughties - watch The Big Short to get an insight into the madness in the mortgage market that led to the 2008 crash. I think there is a good chance that prices will start to ease, if not fall as interest rates start to rise to combat inflation. If mortgage rates go to 5%, which is historically low, that will add £4,000 per year on a £200k mortgage, on top of rising energy and food costs. It will be a hard time for a lot of people.

DrSbaitso · 17/02/2022 08:44

Haha.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?
Billandben444 · 17/02/2022 06:53

We live in a 2-bedroom flat (by choice, we downsized many years ago) and though the houses in our area are now silly money, half a million for a semi, the flat prices have stagnated and barely moved. If a FTB was hoping to use equity from one of these flats to move up the ladder, they'd be sorely disappointed and of course you can raise a family in a flat but I'm sure most would prefer a house and a garden. House prices in the south east are ridiculously high and no amount of cutting down on non-essentials will help a FTB.

joydivisionovengloves71 · 16/02/2022 22:43

[quote 00100001]@joydivisionovengloves71

The average property is £268,349
Meaning, that, generally a FTB would need to find £26.8k + fees, let's just round it to £30k for convenience.

A significant sum.

Also, why should people be forced to buy "fixer uppers" because the good properties are so very expensive (which might be partly due to Bank of Mum and Dad) when they just shouldn't be

An average person on average income should be able to afford an average prices house. But they just can't, without saving for an incredibly long time, or getting help from someone.[/quote]
That might be the average price but that includes houses too. Does you average young person want to live in a semi? Your average 1 bed flat is not that price. I'm not talking about families, I'm referring to people in their early to mid twenties who've lived at home and earned a minimum wage, are capable of saving but prefer to blow most of it. My son is almost 30 and owns his own house, but freely admits he wishes he'd not been so frivolous after university.

LittleGwyneth · 16/02/2022 20:33

@DrSbaitso

What did we blame for everything we didn't approve of before Instagram?

People don't buy nice houses for Instagram, they buy nice houses because it's more enjoyable to live in a nice house.

Women's magazines, I think. Apparently we've always been too shallow of a sex to like nice things because they are inherently nice, we must be told by some higher power what we like.
Bringsexyback · 16/02/2022 20:28

@pateu

Also years ago people were happy to buy a cheap doer upper in a less desirable area and progress from there. But that's not acceptable these days.

Says who? The problem I've found is the doer uppers are actually that cheap.

I found that they’re actually the same price as the ones that have already done or extremely close in price.
DrSbaitso · 16/02/2022 20:28

@isitthestew

There's a doer upper down the road from us that's just gone on sale for £750,000. It's a normal 1930s semi. You'd need a £75,000 deposit plus £27,500 stamp duty in your account, before you get to do it up.

You'd also need a household income of £150k to get a mortgage on it. Good luck!

Perhaps someone can fund it from their profits from Instagram.
isitthestew · 16/02/2022 20:18

There's a doer upper down the road from us that's just gone on sale for £750,000. It's a normal 1930s semi. You'd need a £75,000 deposit plus £27,500 stamp duty in your account, before you get to do it up.

You'd also need a household income of £150k to get a mortgage on it. Good luck!

isitthestew · 16/02/2022 20:13

I can't think of anyone on our street who could afford to buy their house if they had to start from scratch now.

pateu · 16/02/2022 20:10

Also years ago people were happy to buy a cheap doer upper in a less desirable area and progress from there. But that's not acceptable these days.

Says who? The problem I've found is the doer uppers are actually that cheap.

Iamthewombat · 16/02/2022 19:57

What did we blame for everything we didn't approve of before Instagram?

Woman’s Own, probably. Or shops. Or anything else giving those darned youngsters ideas above their station. And, for avocados, read ‘wine’ or ‘eating anything that isn’t tripe and onions’.

Swipe left for the next trending thread