Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?

616 replies

00100001 · 13/02/2022 22:35

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

OP posts:
PamelaDoov · 13/02/2022 23:35

@Totalwasteofpaper

Agree 70k doesn't just happen

I had 50k deposit (some of which was communion money!) I was a good earner and saver and was able to move home for for couple of years (which was what really made it happen) to get my first flat.
I also had a lodger for 6 years(!!!) And the market plus renovating meant I made 200k in 6 years.
Alongside this our careers took off.
We then mortgaged ourselves up to our tits to buy our niace house in our mid 30s1 Grin

We are unusual in our friendship group.

Looking at couple friends

  • couple A husband was given 250k for a flat at uni - it's now worth £1.2m so 950k tax free - they are 32 with decent jobs and own 3 properties now!!!
  • couple B. Wife was given 200k house at uni she has a good job he makes 30k or so. They now owns 4 properties
  • couple C. Were given around 600k EACH from parents as a wedding gift Confused live in hampstead in 1.5m flat which they then spent 200k renovating
  • couple D. No parental help in a one bed and can't afford to move up the ladder or start a family Sad
-couple E. no parental help and about 8 years older than us... live in 600k small terrace and are mortgaged up to tits like us Grin
I’m so glad to hear we’re not the only 30 something couple mortgaged up to our tits. It makes me feel less like I’m doing something wrong!
nightwakingmoon · 13/02/2022 23:34

@swissmummy12345

Because the baby boomer generation are beginning to die? In the next 10-15 years there will be the greatest transfer of wealth in history. Up to £5.5 trillion in the UK alone will transfer from those born between 1945 - 1965 down to younger generations. 2035 is predicted to be the peak year.
It’s extremely unlikely to transfer down. By 2035 most boomers will need to be spending most of their houses on health and social care, and to afford this they will be selling their houses into a declining market.

The increasing costs of energy, food, and just about everything will mean working adults’ income will be squeezed, and the prospect of raising taxes enough to pay for boomers’ end of life healthcare simply won’t be possible. Hence them needing to sell their houses to afford it. From the next few years onwards their housing wealth is likely to all go on care costs with little left to pass down.

The global economy is only just waking up to the reality that energy and food are going to get more expensive, and the one-off benefits of globalisation are coming to an end. Much of our apparent prosperity in the last two decades has been built on exploiting the difference between the costs of manufacturing and labour in Asia compared to the West. That’s going to come to an end and consumer items are going to start getting more expensive again just as energy and food do too across the globe.

We’ve been living in a kind of economic fantasy for the last 2-3 decades, in which we think we’re making money out of selling houses to each other at ever-increasing prices; but what we’ve been actually doing is creating a merry-go-round of increasing debt, and assuming that our living costs and interest rates will always remain as low as they have been since the millennium.

In the next decade we’ll see a lot of that fantasy unravel.

Kite22 · 13/02/2022 23:30

@Seymour5

Friend’s son and his girlfriend, early 20s have just bought their first home. Its a modest terrace, cost about £140k. He’s a mechanic, she’s a nurse, they’ve lived rent free with parents so they could save the deposit. They don’t plan on having children for a long time, and most of their furniture is second hand. There are affordable areas in the UK.

No idea how people in similar jobs afford housing in London and other expensive places.

I was going to say very similar. Talking about "average" is a nonsense, when you factor in a few houses worth £1m+

My dc and their friends, cousins, peers generally are buying their first properties now. No-one is borrowing 10x their salary.

Generally people are not buying as single people, so you are taking 2 salaries into account. Yes, obviously some get help with deposits, and others are subsidised by living with parents whilst they save (as has always happened). As pps have said, rising house prices mean that people who bought cheaper places previously have equity to move, for example from their first flat or small terrace to their first semi, etc.

GrolliffetheDragon · 13/02/2022 23:29

There are vast swathes of the country where people can still buy a starter house for 3x joint salary, even on low incomes. Full time joint salary is the key

No good if it's not where the jobs are. DH & I lived with my parents while we saved a deposit. I watched in horror as the houses in the area where I grew up climbed out of our reach - and it's a pretty crappy area. Then the surrounding, sightly crappier areas, were out of our reach.

So we had to look further away from where we worked, but that meant it had to be on a train line, which pushed prices up a bit, as otherwise we were getting into the realms of multiple buses taking three hours and for some inexplicable reason one of the buses only ran during term time.

Basically - there's a reason why some areas are cheap, and it's often that there are few job opportunities locally and public transport to places where there are jobs is awkward, expensive and not that reliable.

Totalwasteofpaper · 13/02/2022 23:29

Agree 70k doesn't just happen

I had 50k deposit (some of which was communion money!) I was a good earner and saver and was able to move home for for couple of years (which was what really made it happen) to get my first flat.
I also had a lodger for 6 years(!!!) And the market plus renovating meant I made 200k in 6 years.
Alongside this our careers took off.
We then mortgaged ourselves up to our tits to buy our niace house in our mid 30s1 Grin

We are unusual in our friendship group.

Looking at couple friends

  • couple A husband was given 250k for a flat at uni - it's now worth £1.2m so 950k tax free - they are 32 with decent jobs and own 3 properties now!!!
  • couple B. Wife was given 200k house at uni she has a good job he makes 30k or so. They now owns 4 properties
  • couple C. Were given around 600k EACH from parents as a wedding gift Confused live in hampstead in 1.5m flat which they then spent 200k renovating
  • couple D. No parental help in a one bed and can't afford to move up the ladder or start a family Sad
-couple E. no parental help and about 8 years older than us... live in 600k small terrace and are mortgaged up to tits like us Grin
Mildura · 13/02/2022 23:28

Cost of mortgage borrowing has had a significant impact, as well as mortgages over a longer term.

My first mortgage in 2001 was for £70k and cost £650 a month.

My mortgage today is £250k and costs £1100 a month.

Custardtartandcoffee · 13/02/2022 23:25

*or as air b and bs

Custardtartandcoffee · 13/02/2022 23:25

I think people who already have homes and money are buying the houses as investments and then renting them out to tenants, as Air B and Bs

I live in an street where the houses on either side of me are second homes. We have a three bedroom house and 3 DC. The big houses around us (4/5 bedrooms) are either second homes or have been bought by older people (over 60).

I have no idea why they need such big houses. I was talking to one of them who just moved in and he said to me that they have another house in our area by fancied this one, so decided to rent the first one out and move to the new one. I think these people bought a long time ago and built up lots of equity.

swissmummy12345 · 13/02/2022 23:24

Because the baby boomer generation are beginning to die? In the next 10-15 years there will be the greatest transfer of wealth in history. Up to £5.5 trillion in the UK alone will transfer from those born between 1945 - 1965 down to younger generations. 2035 is predicted to be the peak year.

nightwakingmoon · 13/02/2022 23:22

UK house price inflation has been fairly muted compared to many other countries in and outside Europe in the last couple of decades.

That’s completely wrong - the European Central Bank, unlike the Fed and the BoE, had a remit that included house price inflation in its interest rate policy, so adjusted rates accordingly. There were still property booms in many EU countries (not all), but less so than the U.K., US and Australia.

The difference is that after the financial crisis EU property bubbles were allowed to deflate much more so than in the U.K., where the governments (especially the Tory-led governments) deliberately tried to stop the bubble deflating at all.

FeliciaMcAspieGreer · 13/02/2022 23:21

Investors. I reckon lots of people are not buying them to live in themselves but to rent out and keep their equity in the property. Perhaps even overseas investors tempted by the weakness of the pound after Brexit and our ever rising property prices.

BulletTrain · 13/02/2022 23:20

Well, the expensive houses round here are not first-time-buyer houses. I have friends here in their late 30s/early 40s who, like us, would be on their third house if they moved now. Our home has increased in value by £100k in 9 years, but of course so has everything else in the area.

I wouldn't necessarily expect to sell our 4-bed townhouse to a first time buyer given 10% deposit and legal fees would be over £30k.

10% on our first house though - that would now be £15k which between 2 salaries may be relatively achievable.

whenwilliwillibefamous · 13/02/2022 23:19

It was 3x income1 + 1x income1 OR 2.5x joint income 20-30 years ago, but then we had none of these microscopic interest rates!
And if we end up again with fat interest rates and fat unemployment figures, no doubt prices, and the income multiples, will come down too - or stagnate while inflation "catches things up".

It's all about how much you can spare from your monthly income for 25-30 years...

Cosmois · 13/02/2022 23:18

My nan just gave us £70k to buy our 2nd house. We made quite a good chunk on our first house and now we can afford a 500k house on just my (slightly above average) husband's salary. We are in the South East so we don't get much for half a million here.

Seymour5 · 13/02/2022 23:17

Friend’s son and his girlfriend, early 20s have just bought their first home. Its a modest terrace, cost about £140k. He’s a mechanic, she’s a nurse, they’ve lived rent free with parents so they could save the deposit. They don’t plan on having children for a long time, and most of their furniture is second hand. There are affordable areas in the UK.

No idea how people in similar jobs afford housing in London and other expensive places.

PamelaDoov · 13/02/2022 23:17

Me and DH were lucky enough to buy a cheap new build house 7 years ago with a 10% deposit which was our savings combined. It’s now worth 60k more, and we’ve paid off just over 30k of the mortgage, so we are selling and getting 90k cash… all of which is the deposit for our next house. Absolutely no way would we get a mortgage now for a decent house big enough for our family with a 10% deposit, it’s more like 40% deposit. And the new mortgage is still 35 years.

DoubleFunMum · 13/02/2022 23:16

We just bought for 350Kish. Asking price was £275K. Was the 3rd house we went for and we weren't prepared to lose another one. BUT the house we sold went up by 83% in value in the 8 years we lived there. So deposit was all equity.

Plumface · 13/02/2022 23:15

It may end with greater rights for tenants. That's about as much as we can hope for. It's certainly not going to end with property becoming affordable again for owner occupiers. Those days are gone.

nightwakingmoon · 13/02/2022 23:15

@Alrightqueenie

A number of different factors have contributed to the house price inflation: * market value naturally rises * double income = higher mortgage pot * inheritance being used as deposits * parents helping out. * gentrification of areas *better transport links and facilities than before
Don’t you mean:
  • deliberate stoking of an asset bubble by central banks after 9/11 to avoid recession;
  • unconstrained speculation in asset bubbles during the long boom;
  • poor lending practices in the 2000s;
  • carry trade leverage in the 2000s;
  • low interest rates/ZIRP;
  • rentierism by landlords;
  • artificial propping up of the bubble after 2010 for political reasons, via government backed schemes and artificially low interest rates.

All just for starters.

It’s nearly all financial and really nothing to do with gentrification or market value always rising or transport links.

Sadly the bubble has been propped up too long to avoid the greedy British public facing the consequences of two decades of malinvestment and a grossly unbalanced economy. The upcoming (smaller) generations now literally can’t generate the income required to sustain the market at current prices; and Brexit means even less immigration to prop up the economy.

I don’t know where you think the money will come from to keep it all going like a perpetual motion machine, but the economy right now doesn’t look like our workforce is going to have lots of extra income to spend on houses for a while.

Merryoldgoat · 13/02/2022 23:14

And yes, obviously you can move area but that involves building a completely new life which isn’t always practical. Family responsibilities and ties often keep us in one area.

Merryoldgoat · 13/02/2022 23:12

To save £70k as a young couple is just massively out of reach for some and it’s disingenuous to pretend it’s easily achieved.

Not everyone has family to live with or a job that affords them the ability to save hard and a decent enough job that they can then get a mortgage.

It’s a fucking ludicrous state of affairs but I have no idea how it will end.

sst1234 · 13/02/2022 23:11

There will be a lot of comments on this thread about how buying a house is simply unaffordable for most young people. It’s not. There are vast swathes of the country where people can still buy a starter house for 3x joint salary, even on low incomes. Full time joint salary is the key. As for expensive parts of the country, it’s not exactly a shock that London and the southeast are expensive. UK house price inflation has been fairly muted compared to many other countries in and outside Europe in the last couple of decades. The narrative around this issue does have a whiff of hysteria sometimes.

SunAndSea37 · 13/02/2022 23:09

Big mortgages too. Ours runs until we’re over 70. I look very enviously across the street at owners who bought their (same) houses for a fraction of the price of ours a couple of decades ago and are already mortgage free!

nanbread · 13/02/2022 23:08

People who are 40+ may have bought when prices weren't so crazy and it was easy to get 100% mortgages. 20 years ago it was easy to get a house of some sort for £160k in most of the country.

They are then on housing ladder.

I imagine most FTB these days are either good earners, have help eg inheritance or living at home to save - where their parents have already paid off their relatively small mortgages or are higher earners because they are further into their career - or use shared ownership schemes.

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/02/2022 23:08

Lots of “boomers” are in pretty dire straits too, these days: whilst at the same time expected to be bank of mum and dad and Sunnydays residential home for elderly parents, too.
It’s not all fun and games and sports cars.
Dismissing a group of people as boomer is about as accurate as labelling another group as snowflakes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread