Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?

616 replies

00100001 · 13/02/2022 22:35

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

OP posts:
TwocatsX · 18/02/2022 11:44

@Xenia

I think my teacher mother who taught in the 1940s and 50s said some teachers have to leave work originally once they were even just married !! and then in her day when they got pregnant. It is one reason my parents put off babies for TEN years to have 2 full time professional salaries and buy a house before I came.

Anyway every generation can only deal with the hand dealt to them at the time. Hardly anyone ever owned in my family if you go back a bit and seemed to live happy lives in rented places. However those who do want to buy it is certainliy hard at present to raise a deposit even on the house my father grew up in which costs about £120,000 in 2022 in Bishop Auckland which is a bit like this one www.rightmove.co.uk/house-prices/detailMatching.html?prop=63960561&sale=13367566&country=england or my mother's rented childhood home in Sunderland which costs about £50k today. We also have relatives in places like Halifax where house prices are not that steep in 2022 either.

There are some 95% mortgages under certain schemes in 2022 eg www.santander.co.uk/about-santander/media-centre/press-releases/santander-launches-95-ltv-mortgages-as-part-of so if you were trying to raise 5% of a £100k property in the North that is £5000 and in a couple that is £2500 each - not impossible to save that. Whereas down South here one of my sons bought a small house in the SE for £350k last year - so much more expensive than NE England. 5% of that is £17500 and divided between 2 in a couple would be £8750 (a harder amount to save).

Well done to your son btw.

£8,750 shouldn’t be a difficult amount for a young person to save. IF they start saving early enough. I’m not sure if his age but using him as an example, if he started saving say 6 years ago it should be completely doable.

In my experience I see a lot if young people having a great life with holidays going out designer handbags. And then when they decide it’s time to buy a house they wonder why they don’t have a deposit. The saving needs to start many years before they are even considering buying.

Blossomtoes · 18/02/2022 11:37

@Iamthewombat

This is where you say, “it’s not a court of law” if Mumsnet is running true to form.
No, it’s where I stop engaging with you. Who needs it?
Iamthewombat · 18/02/2022 11:31

This is where you say, “it’s not a court of law” if Mumsnet is running true to form.

Iamthewombat · 18/02/2022 11:30

@Blossomtoes

I said that for anybody to claim that ALL women born between 1945 and 1965 were routinely paid less than a man doing exactly the same job is ridiculous. Because it is

Actually it isn’t. Perhaps if you spent a little less time being so tiresomely rude and a little more reflecting on the reality of the job market in the 70s and 80s, you might recognise what pp are saying. Oh, but you can’t because you’re too young to remember it. 🙄

Ok. Where is your evidence that ALL baby boomer women were paid less than men for exactly the same jobs in the 1970s and 1980s?
Iamthewombat · 18/02/2022 11:27

Yes, but if your mother was teaching in the 1940s and 1950s she wasn’t part of the baby boomer generation, the first of whom wasn’t born until 1945!
Nobody disputes that women were discriminated against in the past. Claiming that all women entering the workforce from the mid-sixties to the early eighties were routinely and, after 1970, illegally, paid less than a man for exactly the same job for their entire career is daft.

Kennykenkencat · 18/02/2022 11:25

we also need a mass social housing build. Not only the morally right thing to do, but also cheaper in the long run for taxpayers. The public health housing and homelessness emergency costs the taxpayer many many billions in direct and indirect consequences

I think that we do need to rethink the way we do things and not necessarily build more council housing.

I think that we need to focus people who have no disabilities and can work on having a council home for a certain length of time.
Having a sliding scale of how long people think they will need accommodation for to save enough to buy their own place.
Shorter terms = Cheaper rents
Longer term = Still cheaper than private rentals but paying a higher rent but still with a focus on after 10/20 years you need to move out.

I think we need proper lessons in school about finances. What it actually costs for rent, mortgages, food, bills etc.

Getting rid of this obsession with university being the be all and end all. Explore the possibility that plumbing, plastering, trades etc are perfectly good careers to have. Also get rid of the fact in order to go into a trade you have to be academic enough to be able to pass GCSEs in order to qualify.
(Ds’s trade course could put no one through to the 3rd year because they didn’t have the required GCSEs. However you can get your qualification privately which doesn’t help those who can do the trade but can’t pass an academic GCSE and don’t have the money to pay privately)

I would also make small studio flats and other places that are perfectly ok places but just not in the mortgage criteria mortgageable once again.

I know without starting off in a studio flat we would have been in rented for a lot lot longer and maybe never got a foothold. I worked in an office where most had started off/were living or saving up for that first rung.
Saw a studio today that would have been a perfect ftb but it is cash buyers only because of its size.

Blossomtoes · 18/02/2022 11:25

I said that for anybody to claim that ALL women born between 1945 and 1965 were routinely paid less than a man doing exactly the same job is ridiculous. Because it is

Actually it isn’t. Perhaps if you spent a little less time being so tiresomely rude and a little more reflecting on the reality of the job market in the 70s and 80s, you might recognise what pp are saying. Oh, but you can’t because you’re too young to remember it. 🙄

Xenia · 18/02/2022 11:19

I think my teacher mother who taught in the 1940s and 50s said some teachers have to leave work originally once they were even just married !! and then in her day when they got pregnant. It is one reason my parents put off babies for TEN years to have 2 full time professional salaries and buy a house before I came.

Anyway every generation can only deal with the hand dealt to them at the time. Hardly anyone ever owned in my family if you go back a bit and seemed to live happy lives in rented places. However those who do want to buy it is certainliy hard at present to raise a deposit even on the house my father grew up in which costs about £120,000 in 2022 in Bishop Auckland which is a bit like this one www.rightmove.co.uk/house-prices/detailMatching.html?prop=63960561&sale=13367566&country=england or my mother's rented childhood home in Sunderland which costs about £50k today. We also have relatives in places like Halifax where house prices are not that steep in 2022 either.

There are some 95% mortgages under certain schemes in 2022 eg www.santander.co.uk/about-santander/media-centre/press-releases/santander-launches-95-ltv-mortgages-as-part-of so if you were trying to raise 5% of a £100k property in the North that is £5000 and in a couple that is £2500 each - not impossible to save that. Whereas down South here one of my sons bought a small house in the SE for £350k last year - so much more expensive than NE England. 5% of that is £17500 and divided between 2 in a couple would be £8750 (a harder amount to save).

Iamthewombat · 18/02/2022 11:11

@Kennykenkencat

So you knew a bunch of people of your own age, when you were young, who couldn’t speak English. Why are you attempting to argue that this particular group represents and typifies everyone born between 1945 and 1965

Because when people talk about the Baby Boom generation it is as a whole. No exceptions. I was trying to point out that living through it for a lot of people in that generation there wasn’t the choice or opportunity that people think we “all” had
Things might have been available but discrimination was rife so if you didn’t look a certain way then doors were closed to you.

Eh? Are you seriously suggesting that ‘people’ think that anyone born between 1945 and 1965 shared exactly the same characteristics and were homogenous?

Of course not. Don’t be silly. I don’t know what point you are trying to make. This is a debate about the factors underpinning high house prices. Posters have noted, correctly, that houses were relatively more affordable in the past. Why are you personally insulted by this?

I haven’t seen any “OK boomer” type posts on this thread. Maybe you have seen them elsewhere and are over-sensitive? Anyway, if there I has to be inter-generational resentment, better for it to be focused on generation X, of which I am a member. We were extremely lucky. At least most of us can admit it!

Iamthewombat · 18/02/2022 11:05

@Blossomtoes

Why do we still have a gender pay gap *@Iamthewombat*? In 2022 - more than half a century after the Equal Pay Bill?
Do keep up. I didn’t say that there was no gender pay gap now.

I said that for anybody to claim that ALL women born between 1945 and 1965 were routinely paid less than a man doing exactly the same job is ridiculous. Because it is.

Kennykenkencat · 18/02/2022 10:51

So you knew a bunch of people of your own age, when you were young, who couldn’t speak English. Why are you attempting to argue that this particular group represents and typifies everyone born between 1945 and 1965

Because when people talk about the Baby Boom generation it is as a whole. No exceptions. I was trying to point out that living through it for a lot of people in that generation there wasn’t the choice or opportunity that people think we “all” had
Things might have been available but discrimination was rife so if you didn’t look a certain way then doors were closed to you.

Octomore · 18/02/2022 08:45

lenders will only offer something like 50% LTV on a mortgage

Lenders will offer a fair bit more than that. I've recently looked at remortgaging, and there were deals at 80% and 85% LTV listed. Obviously you get a better interest rate with lower LTV though.

Octomore · 18/02/2022 08:43

we also need a mass social housing build. Not only the morally right thing to do, but also cheaper in the long run for taxpayers. The public health housing and homelessness emergency costs the taxpayer many many billions in direct and indirect consequences

Totally agree. It's shameful that successive governments have allowed social housing stock to be depleted as it has.

fridgepants · 17/02/2022 23:39

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the user's request.

fridgepants · 17/02/2022 23:36

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the user's request.

Blossomtoes · 17/02/2022 23:26

Why do we still have a gender pay gap @Iamthewombat? In 2022 - more than half a century after the Equal Pay Bill?

Tealightsandd · 17/02/2022 23:22

You do realise that what you are asking for, I.e. relaxation of lending criteria, would inflate prices further, right?

Because they're not being inflated now? Help to Buy? Investors snapping up multiple properties?

Far better a slight relaxation (perhaps strictly for FTB only) - that takes into account for example a history of (high) rental payments, than taxpayer funded inflation of schemes like Help to Buy and investors buying multiple properties.

And like I say, we also need a mass social housing build. Not only the morally right thing to do, but also cheaper in the long run for taxpayers. The public health housing and homelessness emergency costs the taxpayer many many billions in direct and indirect consequences.

Iamthewombat · 17/02/2022 23:13

If you believe that the equal pay act suddenly meant in 1970 every woman was suddenly on the same salary as a man in the same job then you really are not getting the reality.

Who said that it did? You claimed that all women in the baby boomer generation were routinely and habitually ‘not being paid anywhere near the same salary as men doing the same job’. For women entering the workforce from the mid-1970s onwards, that is simply not true.

I do think there was definitely a class divide. Or even a race divide.

What has that to do with the price of houses relative to average incomes?

Even when I left school I knew girls who didn’t go on to do A levels as the family needed them to help out with money. There was no sitting at home studying.

I don’t know what point you are trying to make. Yes, some girls, and boys, didn’t stay in education as long as they wanted, and that is probably still the case now for a small minority, but trying to argue that this was the case for a significant number of teenagers in the 1970s and 1980s is just silly.

A few girls I know went back to their home country and returned with a husband.

And? How does that anecdote bolster your argument that the baby boomers had it harder?

Those that did go to work handed over their pay packet to their dad and were given back a bit of pocket money. My mother charged me so much that I moved out as I wasn’t able to pay the keep

Here we go again. The four yorkshiremen. Do you think that because your mother charged you more than you earned for board and lodging that it was the same for everybody in your generation?

I do laugh at the idea of people where I grew up pouring over the newspaper…

What were they pouring over the newspaper?

…or watching the Money Programme. Most couldn’t speak English. Let alone have any money to invest.

So you knew a bunch of people of your own age, when you were young, who couldn’t speak English. Why are you attempting to argue that this particular group represents and typifies everyone born between 1945 and 1965?

damelarue · 17/02/2022 23:09

@EmmaH2022 sorry I just saw this. My DH and I bought a house a couple of years ago and we paid over home report but we’re selling a house. Our lender wanted proof of where the money was coming from over the value of the home report and the mortgage advisor at the time was saying that the lenders weren’t keen on people receiving money from parents etc because it didn’t show an ability to pay/afford the mortgage.

I didn’t question it much more tbh because we weren’t in that situation

Iamthewombat · 17/02/2022 23:03

@Tealightsandd

One growing but often overlooked problem nowadays is mortgage affordability criteria. Most of the government and media focus has been on deposits. A big issue, yes, but for an increasing number of would be FTB the main barrier is actually income requirements. Of course we don't want to see another subprime crisis but the pendulum has swung too far the other way. There's an almost farcical system now where FTB are being turned away by mortgage lenders or Help To Buy schemes on income criteria - yet many are paying private rents that are much higher than they would in mortgages. People have posted about their experiences of this on other threads, and recent research suggested this was a problem for at least 40% of FTB.

We need two things. A) Slight relaxation of lender criteria, and b) Buy and build a lot more social housing (saving the taxpayer in the long-term).

You do realise that what you are asking for, I.e. relaxation of lending criteria, would inflate prices further, right?

It doesn’t matter that you can afford £x per month in rent when a mortgage would cost less at the current rock bottom interest rates. Lenders want to know that you can pay your mortgage if interest rates rise. Plus, if you own a house you have the cost of maintaining it.

Do you think that lenders are just being big old spoilsports for fun? No. They may lend recklessly (e.g. 35 and 40 year mortgages, which increase the amount of money chasing assets and hence inflate prices) but they aren’t going to risk default. They are businesses after all.

Tealightsandd · 17/02/2022 22:31

One growing but often overlooked problem nowadays is mortgage affordability criteria. Most of the government and media focus has been on deposits. A big issue, yes, but for an increasing number of would be FTB the main barrier is actually income requirements. Of course we don't want to see another subprime crisis but the pendulum has swung too far the other way. There's an almost farcical system now where FTB are being turned away by mortgage lenders or Help To Buy schemes on income criteria - yet many are paying private rents that are much higher than they would in mortgages. People have posted about their experiences of this on other threads, and recent research suggested this was a problem for at least 40% of FTB.

We need two things. A) Slight relaxation of lender criteria, and b) Buy and build a lot more social housing (saving the taxpayer in the long-term).

Tealightsandd · 17/02/2022 22:21

@Iamthewombat

Wouldn't have been able to afford the house we have without those schemes/offers

Actually, without those schemes (help to buy, etc) inflating prices you probably would have been able to buy at a lower cost.

This. The (taxpayer funded) Help to Buy schemes inflate the bubble.

Those concerned about younger vs older might be interested to know that the fastest growing group of private renters are the over 40s. Relationship breakdowns, and then there's those who never earned enough to buy when younger (including people too ill or disabled to work).

These people are in a quite dreadful predicament - given their age. It's a ticking time bomb actually. A potentially massive housing benefit bill when this group retires. And no, inheritance isn't the answer. Care home fees will see to that.

Blossomtoes · 17/02/2022 22:07

Come off it. The youngest baby boomers were born in 1964 and entered the workforce in the early 1980s. The equal pay act was passed in 1970. You weren’t living through the 1930s when women were paid less as standard.

You come off it. Women are still paid less than men.

www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwork/earningsandworkinghours/bulletins/genderpaygapintheuk/2021

Bringsexyback · 17/02/2022 21:48

@XingMing

Now, every young person has to remain in education or training or find work until they are 18. It doesn't change much for the clever, committed academic on target for A* A levels. The concept of sending 50% to get a university level education has turned out to be a pig in a poke. All it has meant is the proliferation of worthless degrees, and still only being able to find barista or supermarket jobs at the end, plus at least 27K debt. That's assuming the student lived at home and went to the local university. And meanwhile, you can't get a plumber or an electrician. I don't know about any other part of the country, but my very unreliable/busy plumber wants the customer to source and pay for all the parts needed so he can keep his turnover beneath the VAT threshold (IIRC it's £87,000) so only his labour cost counts. I completely understand why a sole trader would want to avoid the admin. But it suggests that his hourly rate and number of jobs are already taking him close to £85k annually. Which is fairly solid earnings.
You do realise that they if they go into any further education whatsoever they have to pay for it nowadays right ? So your Plumber will be in debt from day one
XingMing · 17/02/2022 20:39

Now, every young person has to remain in education or training or find work until they are 18. It doesn't change much for the clever, committed academic on target for A* A levels. The concept of sending 50% to get a university level education has turned out to be a pig in a poke. All it has meant is the proliferation of worthless degrees, and still only being able to find barista or supermarket jobs at the end, plus at least 27K debt. That's assuming the student lived at home and went to the local university. And meanwhile, you can't get a plumber or an electrician. I don't know about any other part of the country, but my very unreliable/busy plumber wants the customer to source and pay for all the parts needed so he can keep his turnover beneath the VAT threshold (IIRC it's £87,000) so only his labour cost counts. I completely understand why a sole trader would want to avoid the admin. But it suggests that his hourly rate and number of jobs are already taking him close to £85k annually. Which is fairly solid earnings.

Swipe left for the next trending thread