Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?

616 replies

00100001 · 13/02/2022 22:35

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

OP posts:
Octomore · 14/02/2022 08:44

You are thinking that FTBs will be single people age 20-25, but that simply isnt the case these days.

Octomore · 14/02/2022 08:43

But why would FTB generally be needing a 3 bed semi?

The cost of moving is huge, and most FTBs are older these days. If you are a couple, buying for the first time age 30, you are probably planning kids in the next 5 years. Why would you buy somewhere that would force you to move and pay stamp duty again?

weansu · 14/02/2022 08:42

And yes some of that help was living at home to save. That is help! Not everyone has the space or location or money to support that.

00100001 · 14/02/2022 08:42

ThisIsEngland

In wasn't an insult...it's a term of a generation born post war....Confused

OP posts:
weansu · 14/02/2022 08:41

Lots of people have huge amounts of equity just because they were able to buy at the right time. Equity is much harder to build these days & the climbing up the ladder concept doesn't really exist.

I had help, I don't know anyone who didn't.

00100001 · 14/02/2022 08:41

@JudgeRindersMinder

Yeah, but they had help being able to stay at home to save the 70k deposit

Only on mn is helping your kids seen as a bad thing. Meanwhile in the rest of the world it’s just what parents do

It's fine to help your kids.

But the parents are saying things like "my kid lived with us for 5 years rent free and saved £59k with no help"

OP posts:
ThisIsEngland · 14/02/2022 08:41

@00100001

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

Do you have to use the 'boomers' insult?

At least nowadays the woman's full wage is considered whereas previously, even if the woman earned twi e her husband's wage only half was considered. Also, iif you were a single woman it was next to impossible to get a mortgage.

Kazzyhoward · 14/02/2022 08:40

@00100001

The interesting thing is lots of these posters who are letting their kids live rent free/dirt cheap are also saying their kids had no help???

It's an arguable point. Most youngsters pay at least something towards the marginal (extra) costs their parents bear because they live at home, i.e. towards food, laundry, power, etc. So, for many, the contribution made will in fact cover the extra costs of living at home, i.e. parents no worse off because they'd have all the fixed costs to pay whether kids live at home or not, such as mortgage/rent, rates, insurance, etc. Yes, the children are "saving" money by not renting somewhere else, but there's not really any transfer of wealth/money from parent to child if the child is making a contribution towards their costs.

There's also an opportunity cost to the child of living at home, particularly if they're in a less prosperous area, as they could well be earning less money than they could be earning if they moved to a city with higher wages. Or even taking a job within walking/cycling distance of home to save commuting costs may make taking a low paid job viable (it's what my OH did - saved a fortune in not having to buy and run a car by taking a pretty low paid crap job a stone's thrown from home which more than compensated for the loss of income).

Lots of different ways to look at things really. Not all black and white.

Brainwave89 · 14/02/2022 08:40

In some areas, notably London, but also Manchester and the Midlands, money is coming in from abroad to invest in property. Tower Hamlets council noted that they had a large number of properties which had never been lived in- not rented, just left as new and foreign owned (mostly Chinese). It would be relatively straight forward to give councils powers to tax properties which have been empty for a long time period, but we do not currently do this. We also do not limit ownership to UK residents.

Octomore · 14/02/2022 08:39

@Thatsplentyjack

Either people are being given the money by someone, or a lot of people are dealing on the side. I just don't understand how people are managing it now. Also, if a house has been valued at a price, why would anyone pay tens of thousands more than that price. Its madness.
"A house being valued at a price" is nonsense though. Houses are literally worth what someone will pay for them. That's how the housing market works.

Estate agents do nothing more than estimate/suggest a price (not a value), taking into account similar recent sales in the area.

So if an estate agent prices at £250k, and then offers are made above that, with the highest being £275k, then the house is 'worth' £275k.

Similarly, if an estate agent prices at £250k, and then the highest offer made is £220k, then the house is 'worth' £220k.

00100001 · 14/02/2022 08:38

@Darbs76

I live in the south east. For a 3 bed semi you’re looking at upwards of 450k. That’s a lot of money to be a FTB. My kids will get a leg up the housing ladder through grandparents inheritance. They bought their house in North London for 30k ish and it’s now worth over £1 million. They have 3 sons and only one doesn’t own a property so far and the other 2 will use that money to help their children buy in London. Their dad has also been working overseas and has saved for their Uni. Very lucky, sadly my parents weren’t in a position to do that; and I think it was different times back then. My parents wouldn’t have even considered giving their inheritance to us instead of having the money for themselves and rightly so really. But I grew up in a very cheap area and you can still buy a house there for 150k
But why would FTB generally be needing a 3 bed semi? Surely the majority of FTB are young single adults or couples?

Maybe that's some of the problem? People expecting houses larger than "needed"?

OP posts:
wingscrow · 14/02/2022 08:36

Indeed.

The prices are completely out of sync with the average salary.

So it is either people who benefit from help from wealthy parents/grand parents, those who already bought a house when prices were lower and are trading for a new one. People who work in finance and other highly paid jobs. Then you have the buy to let landlords.

I appreciate that prices are different through the UK but a first time buyer with a normal job has no chance whatsoever to buy a house in many parts of the country. No matter how many lattes or avocados on toast they spend their money on or not...

Kazzyhoward · 14/02/2022 08:34

@cushioncovers

Because the baby boomer generation are beginning to die? In the next 10-15 years there will be the greatest transfer of wealth in history. Up to £5.5 trillion in the UK alone will transfer from those born between 1945 - 1965 down to younger generations. 2035 is predicted to be the peak year.

That's an interesting point Swiss, ** I have also wondered if sadly covid deaths have brought about a lot of early inheritance to people as well.

Covid deaths will be trivial in the big scheme of things. The number of deaths (for all reasons) was only slightly higher than average over the past couple of years. A lot of those who died of Covid will have died of something else soon afterwards anyway as they were very old or had serious health conditions.

I'm certainly not minimising the impact of Covid on the family/friends of those who died from it, as each death is a tragedy, but in a purely "numbers" point of view, a few tens of thousands of extra deaths in a country with a population of 60 million won't be having any significant impact.

BulletTrain · 14/02/2022 08:34

We did HTB in 2013. Remortgaged to pay it off in 2018. It cost us £8k more on the loan amount than we borrowed, but we'd been overpaying on the mortgage and the value went up, which took us under 60% loan to value, so the payments went down. You could make it work really well. Now though? Not so much. I'm not sure that properties will have massively increased by 2027.

00100001 · 14/02/2022 08:34

@Coffeetree

Sorry, quote fail. When people say "living at home" to save money, they mean grown men and women living for free or very cheaply with their parents?

I mean, that's great if the parents can afford it and allow it, but don't act like that is an option available to everyone!

The interesting thing is lots of these posters who are letting their kids live rent free/dirt cheap are also saying their kids had no help??? Confused
OP posts:
Cam77 · 14/02/2022 08:33

It's basically Downton Abbey write across 5%-10% of the country. With the bulk of the remaining 90% being renting serfs for life.

LakieLady · 14/02/2022 08:33

@Viviennemary

I have wondered the same. Those very very low interest rates have encouraged more borrowing and caused house price inflation.,
There's a lot of truth in that.

When I first bought (1982), I think the most I could borrow was 3 x my salary. The size of the mortgages younger friends have tell me it's a lot higher than that now.

Cam77 · 14/02/2022 08:31

They bought their house in North London for 30k ish and it’s now worth over £1 million.

... Another aspect of this is how it skews the landscape on terms of meritocracy. Basically making it even worse than it is already. Millions of kids today will be millionaires for life, not because of anything they achieved, or even anything their parents/g.parents achieved - but because their parents or grandparents bought a cheapish house in London/South East in the 80s or 90s which is now worth 20x what they originally paid.

StEval · 14/02/2022 08:30

Then surely you just sell up when approaching 5 years and use the equity as a deposit on a house you can afford?
To be clear Im not talking about buying mansions just a 2/3 bed.
How many people downsize at the 5 year mark?
None usually as thats when they are starting families.
My comments were also based around whats happening now with living costs about to soar dramatically and H2B loans payments kicking in.

Kazzyhoward · 14/02/2022 08:30

It's certainly more difficult for the ever increasing numbers going to Uni as they don't get the chance to start earning/saving until at least aged 21.

If they entered the workplace at 16 or 18 (like most did in previous generations) they'd have had the chance to start earning and saving at a much younger age.

As it is, Uni students have to work to pay their ruinously expensive accommodation costs, buying books, meals etc as maintenance loans often are nowhere near enough these days,

That's a lot different from previous generations who got jobs earlier, lived at home longer, so could save whilst giving a notional "rent" to their parents towards food etc.

Graduate starting salaries haven't kept up with inflation nor general pay increase rates over the past decade or two, so even when they finally get jobs, they're often on very low wages in the early years of their career, meaning they don't actually start earning decent money until mid to late 20's.

Blair's push to increase university attendance really wasn't thought out properly for so many reasons.

SavBbunny · 14/02/2022 08:28

Just an interesting statistic. I was told on Friday our market town had enjoyed a 20% growth on property values in 2020 & 2021.
It is not by the sea but an hours train journey from London. Add in a scarcity of property due to the stamp duty holiday (bung) and everything is snapped up within days. We have been gazumped more then once.
We had a 100% mortgage in the 1980s and also suffered losing our home in 2009.
We have paid over £300, 000 in rent. We are going back into property ownership due to hard saved pension funds.

PeeAche · 14/02/2022 08:27

We lived in a two-up-two-down for WAY too long with 2 kids who shared a room.

If it were council accommodation, we would have been told to stop making them share long before that. But we felt like overpaying on our tiny mortgage was a faster way to boost our deposit than to save in the bank.

Eventually we sold said two-up-two-down for £200,000. It meant we'd almost doubled our money on the house in just 12 years. 😦)

I still remember the day all the estate agents came around to value it and we'd estimated £170,000 but they all told us £210,000. We had to have a sit down and I even cried!

We bought something much bigger but ramshackle. Now all the kids have their own rooms... but everybody's room has at least 1 hole in the wall or roof! 🤦🏻‍♀️😅

Anyway, that's how we have afforded a suitably sized house.

The people that bought our old house were very young FTB with a decent (20%) deposit. We had no idea how the hell they'd managed it. At their age, I'm not even sure they'd like avocado...

VelvetChairGirl · 14/02/2022 08:23

The only person I know who "bought" houses never really did, they were still paying the mortgage and calculated that into the sale so the money got from the previous one finishes off paying the mortgage on it and leaves them with enough to buy and start the mortgage on the next, so they never actually buy a house just constantly paying mortgages.

I dont know if a lot of people do that, I live in London anyway we are full of god awful over priced towers that are bought up by foreign investors from China, Russia, SA etc.

the chinese I can understand as if they didnt put their money into property it has to go into the state run bank and the CCP can take all your money at a moments notice over any crime against the state, so the chinese desperately buy and sell property first in their own country and then the world when they have enough to, just to keep their money away from the ccp.

sst1234 · 14/02/2022 08:23

@catwomando

We've lived for so long hearing about austerity bullshit from this government that we've been brainwashed into thinking we live in a country with no money. We don't. The UK is a rich country with plenty of money sloshing around. At the top. Where it firmly stays and gets bigger.

If you are at the top, finding cash for deposits, fees etc is easily come by. There are a large number of high earners too, who can get stupidly large mortgages to buy these expensive places.

And for those lucky bastards (like me) who are older and started ages ago, it's just incremental spend , so more easily achieved. That said it's getting harder - when we went from flat to house 18 years ago, price difference was c £100k, it's now £400k difference (london, obvs) .

house shortages and prices will stay as they are until the government chooses to stop letting foreign investors to buy what they want and then leave empty , and to put much stronger rent controls and housing quality legislation and enforcement in place. It can be done but they just don't give a shit.

The attitude seems to be 'I'm alright Jack', and that housing is not a basic human right. It is a basic human need and right, and in such a rich county frankly it's a disgrace that we have such poor, expensive housing. We can do better but we keep electing politicians who just don't care about us.

What’s all that got to do with austerity? Do you want government to pay people’s mortgages?
MaggieMooh · 14/02/2022 08:22

Those saying young people can afford houses if they save and stretch themselves - what you don’t realise is that if they stretch too far to afford their first house they can never move further up the ladder.

Personally I will NEVER pay off my first mortgage. It took me so long to save up that I couldn’t buy a house till I was in my 30s, which only leaves me about 35 years to pay it off. If I’d been able to buy at age 20 I’d have had more like 50 years to pay it off. And it’s such a huge sum too. I will never be able to move up the ladder to a bigger or better house - I won’t even be able to pay off this starter home by the time I’m 70.