Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?

616 replies

00100001 · 13/02/2022 22:35

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

OP posts:
Nidan2Sandan · 14/02/2022 09:06

The only way we got on the property ladder in the early 00s was because of the keyworker scheme. We borrowed £9k for a deposit on a house in desperate need need of work. But at the time the only mortgages accepting the keyworker scheme we could use was variable rate mortgages.

Before we had even moved in our mortgage payments went up, within a couple of years it had doubled. We never really did manage to afford to do the house up properly.

Luckily for us, we bought a crap house in what became a mega desirable area and someone was chuffed to get a "bargain" in buying our house but for us it gave us over £100k profit.

Sadly, that £9k we borrowed was worked out on % so we had to pay back over £20k and had a large penalty on our mortgage, but we were still able to put down a large deposit on our dream house.

Proper mortgaged up to our eye balls, but we retire in 10 years with a very large pension payout so can pay any left over mortgage off then.

My friends all bought after us, but they managed with a mix of large gifted deposits from parents, living at home for years to save deposits, or huge inheritances.

SantaMonicaPier · 14/02/2022 09:06

I do worry for much of this generation and the next. I bought alone in 2003 with a graduate mortgage which meant I essentially didn't need a deposit. I put down £1000 on a £73000 two bedroom 1890s semi. Just a couple of years later I would have been priced out of the market

weansu · 14/02/2022 09:05

I would advise anyone who is buying now to future proof, future proof, future proof. Buying in your 30s & want dc, skip the flat stage (unless you are happy to stay there) & get a house near schools that you can extend if needed.

weansu · 14/02/2022 09:03

People are building equity as the prices rise.

But for lots of people this makes it harder to move up the ladder not easier. Unless you bought when very young.

Allelbowsandtoes · 14/02/2022 09:02

@FloBot7

*But why would FTB generally be needing a 3 bed semi? Surely the majority of FTB are young single adults or couples?

Maybe that's some of the problem? People expecting houses larger than "needed"?*

For a lot of them it's to start a family. The alternative is to sell in a couple of years when their one bed flat is too small for a growing baby and then incur SDLT, moving fees, selling and purchasing costs, not to mention the stress. There are also a lot of couples working from home who need somewhere to work.

Exactly this. I'm 33 and bought a one bed flat last year, it was what I could afford (and that was with help from my mum and gran). My partner and I plan to start trying for a baby this year, so at some point will need to either buy a bigger place or move out and rent somewhere bigger while renting out flat....all with a young child (hopefully). Needless to say it's going to be interesting Grin We live in Bristol and house prices are really high here.
Darkstar4855 · 14/02/2022 09:01

People are building equity as the prices rise. Our first house sold for ~£30k more than we paid for it. We’re selling our current house soon and it’s worth probably about £40k more than what we bought it for. Plus 20 years of paying off (and over paying as much as possible) mortgages at relatively low interest rates means we’ve built up a decent amount of equity over the years. However we were lucky and got on the property ladder young.

weansu · 14/02/2022 09:01

It's not good for younger people to have so much income servicing a mortgage/rent.

Plus it's ridiculous that ones wealth these days is now largely determined by whether their own parents owned their home & if they can help. Social mobility is going backwards.

solbunny · 14/02/2022 09:01

@SuitcaseOfWhine

Do you have to use the 'boomers' insult?

At least nowadays the woman's full wage is considered whereas previously, even if the woman earned twi e her husband's wage only half was considered. Also, iif you were a single woman it was next to impossible to get a mortgage.

My boomer mother managed to get a mortgage on her shop floor assistants wage (no partner) and no deposit in the 90's. Getting a mortgage after the 2008 crash is complete different to what it was before then, and that's not including house price inflation beyond wage increases.

There is no doubt that I and DH would have a mortgage now if we were applying in pre-2008 conditions. We have a good household income.

I think what the OP is saying is people of that generation need to just admit they had better conditions for buying instead of beating young people down. I think it is far easier for them to beat young people down than admit they have had it easy, but they shouldn't feel guilty, it was just the market was on their side at the time. There is no shame in that, so I don't understand why people won't admit it.

Exactly this - there seems to be an attitude that's really prevalent where people seem to find it difficult to accept when they had an advantage over other people. I really don't get it. No clue if it's a British thing or a generational thing or just a human thing.
thisplaceisweird · 14/02/2022 09:00

2 of us worked consistently on decent incomes for 7+ years, had an 85k deposit and did a 30% mortgage. We didn't forgo avocado but we never had a big fancy holiday in that time. No financial help from parents.

SpaghettiArmsMurderer · 14/02/2022 09:00

What did it for us was a) earning more than the average household - two educated professionals who both work full time and b) free money from LISAs

weansu · 14/02/2022 08:59

I think what the OP is saying is people of that generation need to just admit they had better conditions for buying instead of beating young people down.

My boss bought in the 90s, interest only mortgage with barely any deposit on a 25k salary. That is not available today.

Goatinthegarden · 14/02/2022 08:57

But why would FTB generally be needing a 3 bed semi? Surely the majority of FTB are young single adults or couples? Maybe that's some of the problem? People expecting houses larger than "needed"?

Most of my friends have been mid-to-late thirties when buying their first homes, by which point, expectations have gone up and they need to house babies and toddlers.

I’m one of four siblings who didn’t get any family money to buy.

DH and I bought our first home six years ago. He was 37 and I was 30. We were fortunate that he was given some large (unexpected) bonuses at work and we got a 1930s semi that we’ve since extended.

One brother has just managed to buy a small 2bed ex-council house at 35 with his wife. One bought a new build, three bed, in the middle of nowhere on a help to buy at 40, also with his wife. My sister is 43, a single mum and unable to buy. They all work full time in professional roles earning more than the UK average salary.

One set of grandparents died in the 1980s leaving very little. My dad died recently, leaving the house and his savings to my mum who will need that to support her and her care as she ages. She could live another thirty years. Our other set of grandparents are still alive in their 90s and have four children, 18 grandchildren and many great grandchildren. I can’t imagine we’ll inherit much at any stage.

SuitcaseOfWhine · 14/02/2022 08:56

Do you have to use the 'boomers' insult?

At least nowadays the woman's full wage is considered whereas previously, even if the woman earned twi e her husband's wage only half was considered. Also, iif you were a single woman it was next to impossible to get a mortgage.

My boomer mother managed to get a mortgage on her shop floor assistants wage (no partner) and no deposit in the 90's. Getting a mortgage after the 2008 crash is complete different to what it was before then, and that's not including house price inflation beyond wage increases.

There is no doubt that I and DH would have a mortgage now if we were applying in pre-2008 conditions. We have a good household income.

I think what the OP is saying is people of that generation need to just admit they had better conditions for buying instead of beating young people down. I think it is far easier for them to beat young people down than admit they have had it easy, but they shouldn't feel guilty, it was just the market was on their side at the time. There is no shame in that, so I don't understand why people won't admit it.

CheeseandWine91 · 14/02/2022 08:53

I live just above North London and was able to buy a new build 2 bed, 2 bath flat for £169k back in 2015 at only 24 as the help to buy just came in. Only needed an £8k deposit which we saved up for by living at home for 2 years after Uni.

Managed to somehow sell the flat last year during the pandemic (when flats really weren’t in demand) for £215k so had good equity in the property, even with paying the help to buy back.

Bought a mid terrace 3 bed in the same area using the deposit plus my dad sadly died in 2020 so we used that inheritance to buy something that we could renovate completely. Without that inheritance we would have either had to buy a house that needed work but we weren’t able to do anything to, or have to move further out to a cheaper area in order to get something that was the same size but didn’t need work. Houses round here have gone through the roof even though it was once considered the cheapest area in the county!

weansu · 14/02/2022 08:53

Quantitive easing devalued wages & inflated assets & that's been the problem with bank policy relying too heavily on it since 08

solbunny · 14/02/2022 08:52

@weansu

It does make me laugh when it's said that young people just need to move to an area with cheaper houses.

Tbf they are doing this hence the growth in UK prices, more FTBs left London to buy last yr than ever before. It just pushes prices up.

Exactly! Smile and yes it's a solution on an individual level - it's how I became a home owner age 23 with no parental help two years ago (not saying that as a badge of honour - they would have absolutely helped if they could). But it's not a solution on a population level which is why the system isn't working.

Also, the only reason me and my husband could move to a cheaper area was because he works from home. If you can't work from home, you can't just up sticks and move anywhere you fancy!

weansu · 14/02/2022 08:50

Because the baby boomer generation are beginning to die? In the next 10-15 years there will be the greatest transfer of wealth in history. Up to £5.5 trillion in the UK alone will transfer from those born between 1945 - 1965 down to younger generations. 2035 is predicted to be the peak year.

I think there will be a wealth tax, they can't push more on income & our nhs & social care costs will increase dramatically due to an ageing population

stuntbubbles · 14/02/2022 08:49

But why would FTB generally be needing a 3 bed semi? Surely the majority of FTB are young single adults or couples?
I was a FTB of a flat when I was 35. Then I sold up and bought with DP, his first buy, and he was 40 and we had a baby by then. We’d be so much better off now if we’d met just a couple of years earlier and bought the house together and skipped the single girl flat – stamp duty, costs, etc. Most people I know now buy a house as the first purchase because they’re all buying in their mid to late 30s and either have kids, are pregnant, or are going to TTC as soon as they get the keys.

SuitcaseOfWhine · 14/02/2022 08:48

Where I live, one guy has bought three flats. Nobody lives in them and they aren't even rentals or holiday lets. Makes me very cross. It's investing for lazy people. This guy is going to be fucked if there is a crash as he's bought them recently when their value is over inflated. I won't shed a tear for him. Grin

I think it's parental help and basically banks lending to people who already have a good sized property portfolio. Weirdly enough, properties are seen as an asset when they are a liability until you pay them off, so those in lots of mortgage debt seem to get more thrown at them. I know someone who has bought a house with the intention of doing it up and making money on it and they've just been told they won't as they spent too much buying the house. It was a shit hole too.

There was an article about Lloyd's bank buying up a lot of property too.

It's a shit state of affairs really. With utilities, leisure and food going up it feels some very rich people are fighting over the scraps of people's wages. Either rent isn't going to get paid, or utility companies won't, or people won't spend in shops and leisure. People will always choose to eat. It's not looking good because something has got to give and landlords and companies are not going to get paid what they are owed.

weansu · 14/02/2022 08:48

It does make me laugh when it's said that young people just need to move to an area with cheaper houses.

Tbf they are doing this hence the growth in UK prices, more FTBs left London to buy last yr than ever before. It just pushes prices up.

weansu · 14/02/2022 08:46

I know lots of people who only could move from a flat to a house during the pandemic because of the stamp duty cut

solbunny · 14/02/2022 08:46

It does make me laugh when it's said that young people just need to move to an area with cheaper houses.

What do you reckon would happen if all FTB followed this advice?

FloBot7 · 14/02/2022 08:45

*But why would FTB generally be needing a 3 bed semi? Surely the majority of FTB are young single adults or couples?

Maybe that's some of the problem? People expecting houses larger than "needed"?*

For a lot of them it's to start a family. The alternative is to sell in a couple of years when their one bed flat is too small for a growing baby and then incur SDLT, moving fees, selling and purchasing costs, not to mention the stress. There are also a lot of couples working from home who need somewhere to work.

weansu · 14/02/2022 08:45

But why would FTB generally be needing a 3 bed semi? Surely the majority of FTB are young single adults or couples?

Probably because they are much older than the past. And moving is prohibitive for many with stamp duty so most people move far less frequently.

stuntbubbles · 14/02/2022 08:44

I live in the south east. For a 3 bed semi you’re looking at upwards of 450k. That’s a lot of money to be a FTB.
Same and it made me laugh upthread when a pp mentioned someone winning £500k so they could skip a few rungs on the housing ladder – once was, half a million on the lottery would have got you a mansion with change for decoration, furnishing, pension pot and an ISA. What it gets you in the SE is laughable – so many cramped, crap, damp and draughty houses for ridiculous sums.