Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?

616 replies

00100001 · 13/02/2022 22:35

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

OP posts:
forinborin · 14/02/2022 10:35

@VelvetChairGirl
And the purpose of me lying about it is....?
I know it as neither of them speaks English well so I helped them to understand some details about real estate process here. And I think you're stereotyping here.

GrendelsGrandma · 14/02/2022 10:32

@GeneLovesJezebel

I see a lot of houses being flipped by builders these days, whereas years ago a newly married couple bought a doer-upper, worked hard on it then sold it for a profit to go towards a forever home.
@GeneLovesJezebel Part of the problem with this is that even a fixer upper takes a long time to save for. It's all very well doing this in your early 20s but most couples I know bought a house then had to get straight on to having babies because they were 30+ and time was not on their side.
forinborin · 14/02/2022 10:31

The bare fact of the matter is that wages have not kept up with increase in property prices and in large parts of the country first time buyers, unless they have significant help have no chance whatsoever in both saving up a deposit and being able to afford and pass affordability checks (which are now MUCH stricter than they were 10 years ago) to get a mortgage.
This is directly opposite to my experience. A couple on £20K each is able to afford a £200K-£250K starter property without any significant pain. Yes, they have to live for four or five years in a houseshare before that in order to put together a deposit, and have quite a frugal life generally.
And no amount of saving a fiver a week on Starbucks is going to changes that.
A fiver in Starbucks a week is £250 / year, and £1.25K over five years even not accounting for any interest.

Woahthehorsey · 14/02/2022 10:29

@weansu

Part of the issue is also that young people seem to want a 3-bed detached as a starter home. A few decades ago, you would buy a flat, then a small home then a bigger home which would mean you would have a deposit each time to get up the ladder rather than start on the top rung.

How many times!!!

The age of a FTB is now 30.

And the ladder doesn't really exist any more.

And that's the problem. Buying a shitty 2 bed terrace or small flat as quickly as you possibly can and then going up the ladder is works better than trying to save for a deposit for a 3 bed house. You'll get further quicker. So the average age of a FTB will go down. I've seen it amongst my friends - those that buy early do better in terms of what house they have by 30.

Those that didn't buy want that end house, the 'forever home'. They turned their noses up at our cheap FTB properties, then have kids in their lovely rentals. It's much harder to save with kids, much harder to live in a do-er upper with kids and to move areas.

SpaghettiArmsMurderer · 14/02/2022 10:27

Higher interest rates in the past are a red herring when it comes to comparing affordability over time. It is much more expensive (like a third more over the life of the mortgage) to own my house now on a 2.99% interest rate than at the 90s price on a 15% interest rate because it’s a percentage of a number which is over 4x bigger!

LakieLady · 14/02/2022 10:26

@catwomando

We've lived for so long hearing about austerity bullshit from this government that we've been brainwashed into thinking we live in a country with no money. We don't. The UK is a rich country with plenty of money sloshing around. At the top. Where it firmly stays and gets bigger.

If you are at the top, finding cash for deposits, fees etc is easily come by. There are a large number of high earners too, who can get stupidly large mortgages to buy these expensive places.

And for those lucky bastards (like me) who are older and started ages ago, it's just incremental spend , so more easily achieved. That said it's getting harder - when we went from flat to house 18 years ago, price difference was c £100k, it's now £400k difference (london, obvs) .

house shortages and prices will stay as they are until the government chooses to stop letting foreign investors to buy what they want and then leave empty , and to put much stronger rent controls and housing quality legislation and enforcement in place. It can be done but they just don't give a shit.

The attitude seems to be 'I'm alright Jack', and that housing is not a basic human right. It is a basic human need and right, and in such a rich county frankly it's a disgrace that we have such poor, expensive housing. We can do better but we keep electing politicians who just don't care about us.

You are sport on, @catwomando .

I also think it's absurd that successive governments have failed to invest in social housing, but are happy to pay (albeit indirectly) the mortgages of BTL landlords via universal credit/housing benefit.

The cost of renting in the UK is one of the reasons people can't save up deposits, and the insecurity of renting is one of the reasons why so many are desperate to buy.

I think if we had affordable rents and secure tenancies, demand for properties to buy might ease a bit.

Wedonttalkabout · 14/02/2022 10:21

We can afford a deposit via saving, and have saved enough over a few years. We can't however get a big enough mortgage for a 2 bed house, and it doesnt matter how little avocado toast we have

The problem is people don't recognise how much things have changed. People even in their mid thirties who struggled and bought 10 years ago struggle to see how much has changed and assume if they could do it others can

In 2011 for example a band 5 nurse earning 21,176 and a minimum wage partner earning about 12k roughly had the buying power of 148.95 thousand.

They could buy the small 2 bed house pictured its gone from 144 to 285. It's a small terrace house in the bad part of town, no parking on street and is a very much ftb house. No garden

Ten years later you would need a household income of 63k for that same house. The couple would now earn 25,665 and 16k and only have a buying power of 187k. Even if they somehow managed to get a mortgage for same small perfect first time buyer house theyd need to save an extra 14,000
If the couple in 2011 saved 20% of their wage they'd have over the deposit in 2.5 years. The couple in 2021 need to save 20% for 3.5 years.

That's including the fact that the minimum wage and nhs wage increase is probably more than other sectors might have see

these threads are always full of "well I did it", and I can't help it's a deliberate push from certain people to encourage the public to think that people who can't are lazy and watch Netflix and go abroad rather than having to fix the housing issue. People who worked hard for their home get insulted because they think people are saying they didn't have to save, so reinforce the same save hard message.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?
PermanentlyTired03 · 14/02/2022 10:20

Most people I know bought their homes with help from inheritance or a wedge from their parents (some released equity- essentially early inheritance). I put my hand up and say that's what we did! Currently our mortgage will be paid off at 60, however if we move to a bigger house, that'll probably change to 65 due to house prices.

VelvetChairGirl · 14/02/2022 10:19

@forinborin

So cash in hand workers. No, self employed, with all taxes duly declared and paid. How would they get a mortgage otherwise.
Ahuh sure they are.

not like construction work is poorly paid anyway.

PatientlyWaiting21 · 14/02/2022 10:18

I didn’t have any help, just worked a full time 9-5 Job topped up with waitressing 3-4 nights / weekends. Still managed to have a life even though was saving.

endofagain · 14/02/2022 10:16

Friend who is an EA has said there is a huge problem with over inflated prices on shared ownership properties when the buyer wants to sell. They have no chance of selling when identical properties in the area are 25% cheaper. I would never advise anybody to go for shared ownership now, although it worked well 15 years ago, the price inflation has got ridiculous now.

SuitcaseOfWhine · 14/02/2022 10:16

WonderingFree

Nobody is going to let Kirstie live that down are they? It was a very, very stupid comment though.

Despite it being clear buying conditions were much more favourable pre-2008 (good point about older gen Xers doing very well too pp). Arguing between generations diverts away from how the government have failed repeatedly to deal with this issue when there was clearly a need to build more houses and stop BTL or holiday let buying. It doesn't matter what different generations say. It is our government that have let us down. Half of these so called 'boomers' who talk this snowflake nonsense on these sites are probably working with the intention to divert people away from the real problem here, which is the housing market being allowed to only benefit a few wealthy people.

I'm glad my parents had the opportunity to buy their homes. I just wish it was the same for all generations. The average worker being able to buy their own home was seen as progress years ago and it's a shame things have gone backwards.

PyongyangKipperbang · 14/02/2022 10:15

There has been a bit of a H2B crisis locally for the same reason. Loads of brand new houses being thrown up, all over priced, all snapped up with H2B and are now in negative/no equity. So the "just sell it and move somewhere cheaper" idea doesnt actually when you still owe ££££ to the bank after selling......

forinborin · 14/02/2022 10:15

So cash in hand workers.
No, self employed, with all taxes duly declared and paid. How would they get a mortgage otherwise.

gingerhills · 14/02/2022 10:15

@nightwakingmoon

I think most buyers are just swapping around within the market tbh. Prices have keen kept artificially inflated for nearly two decades now, and it isn’t sustainable for much longer.
I've been thinking 'This isn't sustainable' since the 1980s. I just can;t fathom how prices keep on rising.

To OP - I think mortgages can be longer now. When I first bought the average mortgage was about 20-25 years. I think these days they are stretched out over 30-40 sometimes.

And yes, if you have a house that inflated in price, you sell and buy at the inflated rates but it was never real money iyswim.

Say you first bought for 100k but sold for 400k. The next house you buy might be 500k, but the increase doesn't feel like £400k more, it feels like £100k more, because the risen value of the first house has been offset into the next one.

nightwakingmoon · 14/02/2022 10:14

I think Healthcare and Social care are being used interchangeably here and at cross purposes.
Healthcare is free
Social care -if you have less than £23500 is paid for by LA.
Otherwise self funded.
A tiny amount with very complex health needs get CHC funding.
The vast majority do not go into care homes.

You’re all missing the point on this. It doesn’t have to be the majority needing social care: these effects happen at the margins (as housing values do too). All you need is a slightly bigger number of a larger demographic needing care and the whole system is overwhelmed.

On social care - no, there are actually a lot of older adults needing social care and care homes: there’s been a huge increase in dementia for one thing as that population live longer. LAs are crumbling under funding needs for care. The funding agreements will not last long and politically, this will need to be revisited very soon. Once the now under-40s become the voting bloc (this shifts within the next 5–10 years), in the upcoming very stretched financial landscape, how much do you think they will be amenable to boomers getting free care from taxation as well as keeping v expensive homes they can’t afford? In any case it won’t work, financially.

Healthcare - we are already seeing free healthcare being eroded. The upcoming NHS burden is huge. Either there will need to be a political agreement for much higher taxation by 2035 to afford it; or there will need to be some contributory costs being paid by the individual. Which option do you think will be the one the U.K. public goes for? Basic rate taxation at over 30 percent (which is what it would take), or contributory costs?

Those posting how “most people don’t need care” really don’t understand the aggregate effects of the total taxation and financial systems. At the same time the welfare bill (almost all spent on the state pension and coming out of general taxation) will rise as well. The aggregate effects will mean there are multiple pinch points on tax revenue and not much scope to bring in more. This will be the uncomfortable reality of her next couple of decades - prices for almost everything will increase, costs to service the expectations we have of pensions, healthcare etc will increase, there will be limited scope for raising more taxation revenue. And things will need to give.

The expectation that a whole generation can have a) a state pension b) free healthcare c) largely free social care d) a massive house price windfall that they get to keep and not liquidate — not all of these will be able to be met. That’s the simple truth.

Especially when the generations who are expected to pay for them via taxation, themselves face increased costs and the prospect of not having many or all of these expectations met themselves.

WindyState · 14/02/2022 10:13

@forinborin

To be honest, I don't recognise these housing horror stories from mumsnet. I am foreign, well integrated into the diaspora. People who don't speak English and do manual jobs for a very low wage are buying quite nice properties after a few years here. I helped so many of them with understanding the process / witnessing papers / re-reading emails from agents and brokers that it is quite a solid statistic at this point. My old cleaner bought a house in London just before the pandemic, with her husband who's a construction worker. All from earned income, not an inheritance windfall.
That's ok then Hmm

The bare fact of the matter is that wages have not kept up with increase in property prices and in large parts of the country first time buyers, unless they have significant help have no chance whatsoever in both saving up a deposit and being able to afford and pass affordability checks (which are now MUCH stricter than they were 10 years ago) to get a mortgage.

And no amount of saving a fiver a week on Starbucks is going to changes that.

VelvetChairGirl · 14/02/2022 10:13

@forinborin

To be honest, I don't recognise these housing horror stories from mumsnet. I am foreign, well integrated into the diaspora. People who don't speak English and do manual jobs for a very low wage are buying quite nice properties after a few years here. I helped so many of them with understanding the process / witnessing papers / re-reading emails from agents and brokers that it is quite a solid statistic at this point. My old cleaner bought a house in London just before the pandemic, with her husband who's a construction worker. All from earned income, not an inheritance windfall.
So cash in hand workers.
blessings2022 · 14/02/2022 10:11

@OmgIThinkILikeYou

*The issue now is that H2B has been used by the government to artificially inflate and prop up the housing/ new build market and people are buying houses they wouldnt be able to get the full mortgage for. Nice until the cost of basic living soars and suddenly those people have to find the money to pay it back. We are talking 100s of £ per month once the repayments kick in*

Then surely you just sell up when approaching 5 years and use the equity as a deposit on a house you can afford? When we got to near the 5 year mark, we had a meeting with mortgage advisor, we could have got a new mortgage to cover the original loan but we wanted to move to a bigger house so decided to go down h2b route again. When we come up to the end, we will probably sell this house then move to an older property. No massive monthly fees but will likely have a nice deposit based on the equity from this house.

I know a couple of people who used help to buy for new build flats, overpriced completely and now cannot sell without a massive loss
weansu · 14/02/2022 10:06

Part of the issue is also that young people seem to want a 3-bed detached as a starter home. A few decades ago, you would buy a flat, then a small home then a bigger home which would mean you would have a deposit each time to get up the ladder rather than start on the top rung.

How many times!!!

The age of a FTB is now 30.

And the ladder doesn't really exist any more.

Whammyyammy · 14/02/2022 10:06

@Georgeskitchen

Just wait until the next property market crash then everyone will be in negative equity like the early 90s Your sincerely, Boomer x
That will not help the average buyer, as lenders will not lend, or have very strict criteria. Then all the 'bargains' thar you think will be available will be bought by investors with cash, and turned into rental stock. Thus quickly recovering the market. I have a friend thst was waiting for a crash, so she could buy a cheap house. She's been waiting and renting for 12 years... and has just watched prices rise, whilst paying someone's mortgage...
WhatATimeToBeAlive · 14/02/2022 10:04

Part of the issue is also that young people seem to want a 3-bed detached as a starter home. A few decades ago, you would buy a flat, then a small home then a bigger home which would mean you would have a deposit each time to get up the ladder rather than start on the top rung.

Mortgages can be spread out over a longer period now rather than the previous 25 years as people will have more employment years due to later retirement.

babyjellyfish · 14/02/2022 10:01

BOMAD, for the most part.

SonicBoomBoom · 14/02/2022 10:01

Many people manage without handouts or living at home rent-free, just by living modestly and saving hard. We did it with no handouts in the last 10 years.

DP and I lived in a studio flat, walking distance to work, for 4 years from 2007, for £500 per month rent, while earning salaries of 19k and 23k and working any overtime that was available. Any holidays were a weekend away. We always tried to feed ourselves for under £7 a day, combined. No cars (which was awkward at times but we managed).

We saved 20k in that time, and then bought a flat for 180k, 10 years ago.

We then progressed in our careers to earn 30-35k or so each, and continued to save as much as we could. Within 5 years we'd saved another 40k, and our flat had increased in value by 15k.

We sold it and bought an (extremely) doer upper house for 300k, a few weeks after DC was born. We've refurbished, then extended it, in the last 5 years, again through savings (plus adding another 80k to the mortgage).

It was all just saving. We got no inheritance or deposit gifts from anyone. Actually, for our first flat, DP's parents paid our £700 (from memory) solicitor fees and my parents bought us a bed and sofa. We could have bought these ourselves, but instead put the extra £1.5k into our deposit (didn't make any difference to the LTV or interest rate).

So it can be done. Our lifestyle wasn't very instagrammable though!

PyongyangKipperbang · 14/02/2022 10:01

Yeah declaring a 13k income is one thing, actually having a 13k income would make all of that impossible so he is on the fiddle somewhere!