Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?

616 replies

00100001 · 13/02/2022 22:35

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

OP posts:
weansu · 14/02/2022 11:23

One of my friends did H2B, they were fully aware that they were buying something overpriced. However the mortgage was cheaper then their rent, obviously more secure & crucially they needed a much smaller deposit.

lapasion · 14/02/2022 11:20

It’s all well and good to say ‘start with a small place’ or ‘snap up a shitty house’ but in our area these get grabbed by property developers. Shitty places especially get snapped up, gutted, and everything painted grey. Then they either become massively expensive private rentals or go on at a much higher price. I have friends who have decent deposits and have been approved for mortgages who literally can’t find even a shitty house to make their own.

CaramacTexan · 14/02/2022 11:18

@Seashor

My son has just bought a house with his girlfriend. 70 thousand deposit. They worked their arses off, didn’t spend on false nails, hair, etc. They lived at home and they didn’t decide to have children and then bleat on about how the ‘Boomers’ had it so easy. They didn’t! They were also prepared to move to a cheaper area.
Seriously good for them, but realistically not many young couples can save this much money in a lifetime, let alone in a small number of years.

The context here is how long did it take them?

If they lived with parents for 5 years whilst being a couple and saving for a house, they would need to save £600 a month EACH .

That's a lot of false nails.

The reality is a normal couple will struggle to save £300 a month.

Lot's do not have the option of living with parents rent free or paying a token amount.

I would say it comes down to how much you earn as couple if you don't get ' extra' help, not how frivolous you are .

Wedonttalkabout · 14/02/2022 11:15

I gave an example of a small ftb house, that's a usual starter home. It's the kind people picture and is the same price as local 2 bed flats. It has no garden etc or parking, bad part of town

It was about 144k ten years ago so couples earning 34 ish k between them could buy it

Now it's 285k so not only would that couple need to save aprox 30k to get deposit and moving costs, you need a house hold income of 63k

The first rung of the housing ladder is now that much higher.

I agree that in hindsight I'd of bought a small home in my earlier 20's, and be now looking at a bigger house.

However not many early 20's have a joint income that high, or that deposit to do so now.

So like me they wait, and are then looking for bigger homes.

weansu · 14/02/2022 11:15

@nightwakingmoon excellent post, I don't know why so many don't see what's coming.

Woahthehorsey · 14/02/2022 11:14

@Baddit

People don't really talk about the impact of the increase in buy to let mortgages and people buying second homes.

There's not been any legislation to curb it - perhaps because a lot of MPs are also private landlords?

Most people can only buy when they inherit. It's like we're going back to a society of lords and serfs who never own property.

But this is a double edged sword. If the government put a curb on buy to let mortgages you decrease the number of rental properties and rents go up (the rental market is very susceptible to supply and demand where as, the buying market is driven more by other factors such as borrowing power, wages, inflation, employment). The government would need to invest more in social housing. There's always going to be a group of people who can't or don't want to buy. Can't- such as bad credit, unemployed, certain disabilities, moves around a lot for work, not been employed sufficiently long, students etc etc. Don't want to: new to an area, don't want the responsibility of home ownership, not planning on staying in the area long, can't find something they want to buy or are in-between purchases etc.

By reducing rentals, you make renting unaffordable to those who will never be able to buy - those reliant on housing benefit etc. So we would need to invest in social housing which comes at a cost as well. The government have chosen to meet the rental need through private investment and in areas where there's lots of benefits recipients, rents generally stay in line with the local housing allowance (see parts of Oldham and Salford for examples).

weansu · 14/02/2022 11:12

I've been thinking 'This isn't sustainable' since the 1980s. I just can;t fathom how prices keep on rising.

where I am in SW London prices haven't changed much since Brexit particularly once you factor in stamp duty.

WindyState · 14/02/2022 11:12

@forinborin

The bare fact of the matter is that wages have not kept up with increase in property prices and in large parts of the country first time buyers, unless they have significant help have no chance whatsoever in both saving up a deposit and being able to afford and pass affordability checks (which are now MUCH stricter than they were 10 years ago) to get a mortgage. This is directly opposite to my experience. A couple on £20K each is able to afford a £200K-£250K starter property without any significant pain. Yes, they have to live for four or five years in a houseshare before that in order to put together a deposit, and have quite a frugal life generally. And no amount of saving a fiver a week on Starbucks is going to changes that. A fiver in Starbucks a week is £250 / year, and £1.25K over five years even not accounting for any interest.
200k won't get you anything in large parts of the country, and for a couple earning 40k between them that is at the utter limit of what a large number of banks will lend - so that's unrealistic for a lot of people.

Plus that's 20k they need to save for a deposit, on top of general living costs, assuming that house prices don't continue to increase in those 4-5 years.

On a monthly take home of less than 3k a month.

So yeah, good luck.

VelvetChairGirl · 14/02/2022 11:09

[quote forinborin]@VelvetChairGirl
And the purpose of me lying about it is....?
I know it as neither of them speaks English well so I helped them to understand some details about real estate process here. And I think you're stereotyping here.[/quote]
I didnt say you were lying, but the self employed cash in hand types can say whatever they like cant they, you dont know how much of their earnings are off the books.

weansu · 14/02/2022 11:08

And that's the problem. Buying a shitty 2 bed terrace or small flat as quickly as you possibly can and then going up the ladder is works better than trying to save for a deposit for a 3 bed house. You'll get further quicker. So the average age of a FTB will go down. I've seen it amongst my friends - those that buy early do better in terms of what house they have by 30.

The problem is the shitty property still needs an hefty deposit that people need time to save for. Of course it's better to buy early but most people aren't in the position too.

weansu · 14/02/2022 11:06

Mortgage multiples used to be 3x main earner plus 1 x 2nd earner, now can get 5 x both earners.

It's not standard to borrow x5

LakieLady · 14/02/2022 11:01

@Baddit

People don't really talk about the impact of the increase in buy to let mortgages and people buying second homes.

There's not been any legislation to curb it - perhaps because a lot of MPs are also private landlords?

Most people can only buy when they inherit. It's like we're going back to a society of lords and serfs who never own property.

And that's if their parents had anything to leave them.

My parents lived in council housing, so left nothing for me and DB save for a few quid in the bank. Same for my late DP and my exH and his siblings, their mum is in council housing.

One friend, whose parents were very comfortably off, inherited very little because his mother had dementia and spent many years in a care home, the cost of which eroded the children's inheritance at an alarming rate.

Woahthehorsey · 14/02/2022 10:53

[quote CharSiu]@Tilltheend99 a house on my very nice road was unoccupied due to a horrible divorce fight. It was empty for 8 years, the husband had removed the entire bathroom and kitchen. It went to auction and sold for 180k to developers for cash, it sold for almost 300k last spring. Just as an actual example regarding your post on developers.[/quote]
But that's because it would be unmortgagable. No kitchen and bathroom means uninhabitable so no mortgage, so it's either left to rot or sold to a cash buyer. Occasionally you can get development loans for such properties but they're not long term, are high cost and difficult to get.

Pr1mr0se · 14/02/2022 10:50

nightwakingmoon - spot on!

Tilltheend99 · 14/02/2022 10:43

@Seashor so it is a choice between owning a house and having children these days?! Sounds really progressive Wink Think you may have lost your own argument there.

But all joking aside, I sincerely hope if they wanted children they will still be able to have them as fertility doesn’t wait around for people to get their finances in order.

Jvg33 · 14/02/2022 10:41

I also had to use the 20% help to buy scheme and you had to be quick to get it paid back before the price value increased. Some of my neighbours haven't paid it back.

Alexalee · 14/02/2022 10:40

Even as a quick crude example if both were earning 30k, their borrowing power has gone from 120k to 300k...

Jvg33 · 14/02/2022 10:39

I bought a gleesons new build a few years ago. They were set at a fixed price range and they were built in a considered not so nice area of a town. Years later the property value has increased and the area is no becoming more desirable. Just luck I suppose.

Gowithme · 14/02/2022 10:39

Our deposit came from my parents when they sold their business and we have saved up so our ds will have a deposit when he buys a place. Our first house cost £90,000 it would now be worth around £300,000 or more (Devon coastal village)

I would like house prices to be slashed across the board and would be happy for our current house to be worth what it was 20 years ago. The rise in house prices has been ridiculous.

CharSiu · 14/02/2022 10:38

@Tilltheend99 a house on my very nice road was unoccupied due to a horrible divorce fight. It was empty for 8 years, the husband had removed the entire bathroom and kitchen. It went to auction and sold for 180k to developers for cash, it sold for almost 300k last spring. Just as an actual example regarding your post on developers.

AngelsWithSilverWings · 14/02/2022 10:38

My boomer parents had tough childhoods and then struggled financially for years. Dad did a low paid manual job plus weekend casual work to make ends meet. Mum did bar work in the evenings and gradually added other jobs as we got older. They are now retired and financially comfortable thanks to mum going to college in her early 30's and getting a decent career going after us kids started secondary school. They got on the housing ladder thanks to the RTB scheme but I remember the worry and the pawning of jewellery to pay bills. They went through the 15% mortgage period too. They have not had it easy by any stretch of the imagination. I'm glad they live in comfort now - they deserve it.

I on the other hand am Gen X and it's been very easy to climb the property ladder even though I wasn't born into wealth and haven't had any financial help from parents. I think perhaps it's my generation who are guilty of not understanding how difficult it is for young people these days. I know not all Gen X have have had an easy ride but most that I know and have grown up with have.

I've no idea how my DC are going to manage it. They will inherit obviously but I'm only 52 so not planning on going any time soon and my parents are only in their 70's and very fit and heathy thankfully. I'm sure nursing home fees will come into play at some point and then anything left will be split between me and my siblings so not much help to my DC even if I pass it straight to them.

Alexalee · 14/02/2022 10:38

Biggest 2 factors by far...
Mortgage multiples used to be 3x main earner plus 1 x 2nd earner, now can get 5 x both earners. Hence same couple can borrow more than double
And low interest rates

Jvg33 · 14/02/2022 10:37

The stamp duty was axed for awhile by the Tories because they were worried about the industry due to covid. This caused house prices to come up. I'm sure they will go back down soon. There was a race for people buy 4 bed detached homes in my area. There seems to be a lot of people around my area who are spending money on extensions etc.

EmpressSuiko · 14/02/2022 10:37

In our experience, everyone who we know who has purchased a home was already a home owner OR they lived at home with parents rent free, and put all their money into saving for a deposit and also had a top up from parents.

We had children young so we and have been stuck renting since our early 20s and we couldn’t stay with parents to save.
Our parents would love to help but they aren’t in the financial position to do so.
All our money goes on ridiculous rental prices and bills so there’s nothing left to put into a savings pot.

INeedNewShoes · 14/02/2022 10:35

Seriously, the lenders must see you coming. Do you know how compound interest works? The longer the term you borrow over, the more the lender makes from you.

Yes but does it matter in terms of this poster's expenditure?

I took out a 32 year mortgage to buy my house. Due to pay off at 65.

My mortgage repayments are £450 pcm. To rent the same house would be £1100 pcm. Yes the banks win by charging plenty of interest but it's still the better course of action financially for me to own my house with a long term mortgage than to rent, surely?

Swipe left for the next trending thread