Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?

616 replies

00100001 · 13/02/2022 22:35

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

OP posts:
BulletTrain · 14/02/2022 11:52

There are bonuses to the value of your house increasing beyond using equity to move. As I mentioned, when we last remortgaged the valuation took us under 60% LTV and we got access to a really low 5 year rate. Some people remortgage, take out a relatively small amount from the equity and add a bedroom, avoiding having to move.

mumwon · 14/02/2022 11:50

when we bought our first house (ex council in cheaper area with issues) you could only get repayment mortgage from housing association not banks & it was before wholesale right to buy council sell off.
if it was a Victorian house you had to have up to 30% deposit & a high deposit for flat conversations too, We had to have savings (over time period to show that we could afford mortgage) in building society. Our mortgage interest went from 10% to 16% during the early days by the by. We were allowed 2 and half times dh salary & half mine - no more than that hence increases (set by estate agents & mortgage providers rose slightly slower - but!!! - conservative government (Thatcher?) opened mortgage providers to Banks etc & because they are more commercially orientated than old fashioned building societies we landed up with lots of different supposedly advantageous (& historically many screwed the people who used them & where shut down because of it - aka new houses who quoted one figure reduced it but the purchaser still got all the amount so 100% mortgage & than the person landed up with negative equity much like help to buy makes people vulnerable to, etc etc etc insurance backed mortgages which promised dividends & landed up in negative ) The updated council house sell off - 80's? -meant houses where purchased for low figures etc)
I primarily blame the banks & government - if you don't/can't pay they took back the house & people still had to pay for the debt & the banks could sell the house. This meant that it didn't really matter whether you could afford the mortgage or not.
Now of course both salaries are taken into account as well

ParsleySageRosemary · 14/02/2022 11:49

That's quite easy if a couple are both in full time employment, and can stay with parent(s) whilst saving.

Ha ha ha. Yeah, everything is easy if you have parents who can and will help. That's the problem. Those of us who don't can just vanish I suppose.

It makes a complete mockery of the idea of working and of capitalism as a whole. If you can't exchange your labour for anything of value, what's the point? And what do we do??

DrSbaitso · 14/02/2022 11:49

Oh, is it false nails and hair (of some unspecified description) now? Not avocados?

Wheresmycustard · 14/02/2022 11:48

This topic bothers me greatly... When I was a child my mum was a sahm parent for my entire childhood only went back to work in her 50's, my dad wasnt a high earner by any stretch but still managed to buy us a decent home. I've just returned to work oldest is 5. Dh earns a good salary, Im part time to balance dh long hours/shift patterns and because childcare is more than my wage so pointless really... But combined is a decent amount... To buy a house in my area were looking at 6.6 x our combined income... And that's for a house that is very dated and needs work. My parents moved away when I was 19 so I was pushed into renting and have forever struggled to get a deposit together. We won't be getting any inheritance ever and with rent in excess of a grand a month it's unlikely we'll ever buy.

Iamthewombat · 14/02/2022 11:47

Hope your son can get back having false nails soon

Hahahaha. And his false hair:

They worked their arses off, didn’t spend on false nails, hair, etc

Kinko · 14/02/2022 11:46

2 incomes, and longer mortgage terms.

I think my parents had a 15yrs mortgage or possibly 20yrs? Its much more common to have a 30 or 35yrs mortgage now. You can even be considered for a 40yr mortgage.

OpheliaThrupps · 14/02/2022 11:46

Personally, I think stamp duty has pushed up prices a lot too and reduced the rate of people moving. It certainly stopped us from moving as often.

I don't know about pushing prices up, but you're totally right about people moving less often. High stamp duty has made the "frictional" costs of moving astronomical. You really don't want to do it any more often than absolutely necessary, because each time you do a significant chunk of equity gets handed over in tax.

I think the main consequence of this is to have abolished the housing "ladder". I don't know why people still use that phrase, it's been irrelevant for at least twenty years. The metaphor of the ladder was that you climbed up, step by step, buying, then selling and buying somewhere sightly bigger, every few years, until you reached the top. If you buy and sell every few years now, you'll never get anywhere because all your money will go in stamp duty!

Iamthewombat · 14/02/2022 11:44

You can see the effect everywhere of housing, particularly mortgages, hoovering up so much disposable income.

Why do we have such a poor choice of high street, and online, clothing stores now compared to 25 years ago? Why are the clothes and shoes we are being sold (generally speaking) such crap quality compared to the 1990s and early 2000s? Why are there so few decent mid-market retailers that haven’t gone bust and been snapped up by BooHoo.com? Because all the money that might have been spent buying nice things by wage earning adults is going into servicing mortgage debt.

Why are so many cars sold on the never never (aka PCP schemes, in which you rent a car you can’t afford but never actually own it)? Because all the money that might have been saved to buy cars outright or with a personal loan is going into servicing mortgage debt.

Why has the government had to default people into occupational pension schemes, that you must opt out of, rather than into? Why do so few people have decent pension provision? Because all the money that might have been saved or invested on a discretionary basis is servicing mortgage debt.

The saddest thing is, I’ve seen several posts on here by people rejoicing that their house has increased in value because they think that they have made a profit. They haven’t. Not unless yours is the only house whose value has increased, or you plan to move into a yurt. You’re actually worse off because when you want to buy a bigger house (that fictional property ladder again), you’re back to square one with a new long term mortgage that you’ll still paying off in your late sixties.

Chewbecca · 14/02/2022 11:40

It is do-able, albeit much harder than it was in the 80s/90s.

My anecdote = DS & DIL. They do not earn high salaries at all, around £55k joint. They returned to parents and curtailed all outgoings to save about £25k then bought a 2 bed place in a cheaper part of town for £265k. We are in Essex, commuter town.

As I say, not as easy as my first purchase (£35k 1 bed flat on single income of £12k, no help), but do-able.

DrSbaitso · 14/02/2022 11:39

We bought our first house ten years ago, partly with savings and largely with inheritance. We COULD have scrimped for years but I'm bloody glad we didn't have to.

BlondeDogLady · 14/02/2022 11:38

To save £70k as a young couple is just massively out of reach for some and it’s disingenuous to pretend it’s easily achieved

You don't need to save that much though. You can get a mortgage with a 5% deposit. So, for a house at £200,000, you need £10,000 deposit. That's quite easy if a couple are both in full time employment, and can stay with parent(s) whilst saving.

PraiseBee · 14/02/2022 11:36

@Seashor

My son has just bought a house with his girlfriend. 70 thousand deposit. They worked their arses off, didn’t spend on false nails, hair, etc. They lived at home and they didn’t decide to have children and then bleat on about how the ‘Boomers’ had it so easy. They didn’t! They were also prepared to move to a cheaper area.
Hope your son can get back having false nails soon
affairsofdragons · 14/02/2022 11:34

@Seashor

My son has just bought a house with his girlfriend. 70 thousand deposit. They worked their arses off, didn’t spend on false nails, hair, etc. They lived at home and they didn’t decide to have children and then bleat on about how the ‘Boomers’ had it so easy. They didn’t! They were also prepared to move to a cheaper area.
Yes, if our children all just give up their false nails when they reach their 20s, everything will be just fine.

Please.

People have to live where they can pursue their careers.
Houses tend to be more expensive in areas with lots of jobs.
Most of us aren't in a position to help our children with large deposits, and living at home only works if they can easily commute to a job from their parent's home.

Supersimkin2 · 14/02/2022 11:33

85 per cent of first-time buyers get cash from family.

I’m in London & don’t know anyone who got a mortgage singlehandedly. Not professionals, no one - two barristers is maybe the only exception cos they might have afforded it without granny dying, who knows.

Jaxhog · 14/02/2022 11:33

It's all changed. As Babyboomers, prices were lower as were expectations and we didn't have stamp duty. Mortgage rates were a lot higher (17+%) though.

House prices have gone up a lot, but we paid a lot more in interest and inflation was much higher too, so people needed the house prices to rise to avoid negative equity. Personally, I think stamp duty has pushed up prices a lot too and reduced the rate of people moving. It certainly stopped us from moving as often. If people move less often, the availability of houses to buy goes down too. Couple that with less house building and greater expectations it's really not surprising that houses prices have gone up so much.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 14/02/2022 11:32

@nightwakingmoon, don’t forget that the buy to let boom, which really took off under Labour, after Gordon Brown diminished people’s faith in pensions (so bricks and mortar seemed a better bet) and was also fuelled by his grossly unfair removal of mortgage interest relief for owner occupiers, while retaining it for landlords.

More recently, IMO the Help to Buy scheme has inflated prices of new builds, while whacking up builders’ bonuses.
When HTB was first introduced, I wrote to my then MP to say that I was afraid it was going to inflate new build prices.

He forwarded it to the then housing minister - Grant Shapps IIRC - who replied that there was ‘no evidence’ that this would happen.
Well of course there bloody wasn’t, when the scheme had yet to start! 🤬

Iamthewombat · 14/02/2022 11:32

@INeedNewShoes

Seriously, the lenders must see you coming. Do you know how compound interest works? The longer the term you borrow over, the more the lender makes from you.

Yes but does it matter in terms of this poster's expenditure?

I took out a 32 year mortgage to buy my house. Due to pay off at 65.

My mortgage repayments are £450 pcm. To rent the same house would be £1100 pcm. Yes the banks win by charging plenty of interest but it's still the better course of action financially for me to own my house with a long term mortgage than to rent, surely?

Yes, it does. She will pay back a shedload more interest, damaging her future wealth.

I see that you are personally invested in the ‘long mortgage’ thing. Your 32 year mortgage might be cheaper than renting at the moment (although I’m not convinced that the monthly differential is as large as you say), but that’s at rock bottom interest rates. What happens when rates go up, which has already begun? The monthly repayments get more expensive, yes, but because you are borrowing over such a long period you will pay loads more for servicing that 40 (or 32) year debt.

Remember those adverts that Carol Vorderman used to front on TV? Home consolidation loans. Carol kindly informed us that homeowners could reduce their monthly repayments on unsecured debt (credit cards, personal loans etc) by consolidating them into a loan secured on their house, alongside the mortgage.

Genius! What could go wrong? Well, what went wrong was that a debt that might have taken 5 years to clear would now take 25 years to clear, and the lender would collect tons more in interest because of the effect of compounding. And, bonus, the lender could take your house if you defaulted because you’d swapped an unsecured debt for a secured debt. But the real advantage to the lender was having you on the hook paying interest for longer.

It’s always better to borrow over a shorter period, and if you’re having to mortgage yourself up to the eyeballs for 40 years to buy a very ordinary house, or to fulfil some fantasy of moving up a non-existent ladder because you have a bit of equity from your first house and are clamouring to take on a new, long term mortgage for an extra bedroom and bifold doors, ask yourself whether you’re buying into an asset bubble.

Ionsion · 14/02/2022 11:31

I think a lot of this is driven by London money I.e people moving from London and other big cities to other areas after the start of lockdown. It’s certainly the case where I live. And quite often if they have elderly parents they will move to the same area too.

Wedonttalkabout · 14/02/2022 11:31

It can be deceptive when you look at right move
A search for flats under 200k near me shows 92 results but by the time you remove the ones you cant mortgage, caravans, auctions, multiple listings for the same property and retirement homes, its actually about 17

ParsleySageRosemary · 14/02/2022 11:30

@Baddit

People don't really talk about the impact of the increase in buy to let mortgages and people buying second homes.

There's not been any legislation to curb it - perhaps because a lot of MPs are also private landlords?

Most people can only buy when they inherit. It's like we're going back to a society of lords and serfs who never own property.

Actually I've been talking about it for years, and everyone I know who rents did too. It's just that no one gave a damn.

It's worth remembering dates. House prices quadrupled in 5 years over the early 2000s, at exactly the same time that buy-to-let suddenly became popular and was encouraged by the government. It only really affected those of us who came from working backgrounds at first: we were just told to shut up and go away by the older generation who were making money hand over fist with no work whatsoever. This was when generational inequality started.

Wages did not increase at all at that time. All we could do was watch as prices went up and up. The only people my age I knew who owned houses in their 20s and 30s were those whose baby boomer parents had bought them and supplied them at cheap or free rent. I had one landlord who must have only paid £25k for the terrace we had to rent at increasing prices; after 10 years he kicked us out and gave the house we had paid for in rent twice over to his daughter. That is how some are still buying.

babyjellyfish · 14/02/2022 11:27

The other thing about telling people to start small is that if it takes them until they are in their 30s to be able to afford a one bed flat, how are they supposed to afford a home big enough for children before they've left it too late to have children?

Kennykenkencat · 14/02/2022 11:26

[quote Tilltheend99]@Seashor so it is a choice between owning a house and having children these days?! Sounds really progressive Wink Think you may have lost your own argument there.

But all joking aside, I sincerely hope if they wanted children they will still be able to have them as fertility doesn’t wait around for people to get their finances in order.[/quote]
I think it has always been the case.

MidnightMeltdown · 14/02/2022 11:26

I think this really depends on where you live. I bought a 3 bed on my own in a very nice area of Yorkshire, without any help from anyone.
Managed to save a deposit while renting.

House prices where I am are above the national average, but still considerably cheaper than the south east. Contrary to popular belief, there are plenty of decently paid jobs up here, and it's only a couple of hours on the train to London. If I'd stayed where I grew up on commuter belt to London, then I would only have been able to afford a 1 bed flat.

I understand that not everyone is able to move, but there are also a lot of people who simply don't want to. That's perfectly fine and reasonable, but personally I think that the sacrifice of never owning a home is too great. Quality of life up here is far better IMO.

Having said all this, I do think that houses will become more unaffordable in the future. The wealth distribution is simply too unequal. Since property values are so high, lots of people are being left with huge sums of money when parents or grandparents die, while others are left with nothing. Buying a home is becoming increasingly dependent on inheritance rather than wages.

Rewis · 14/02/2022 11:25

Me and my bf talked about this yesterday. It's about how much of a sacrifice you're willing to make and personal choices. If property is a priority then move to wherever you can afford. It might mean you'll move far away from everything you know or even aroad and only see your loved ones every few years. It might mean you don't have anything fun that costs money for years. It might mean moving in with parents and hating it. It might mean retraining to a job you'll hate but pays well. Buying a complete sithole and hoping you know people who can work for free. Never having kids. I'm not willing to sacrifice this much therefore I rent cause owning property does not give me enough happiness to forego everything.

Swipe left for the next trending thread