Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder where the money is coming from to buy houses?

616 replies

00100001 · 13/02/2022 22:35

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

OP posts:
meow1989 · 14/02/2022 12:36

We used help to buy in 2014 on a newbuild so needed 11k for a deposit. We also bought a County further out from London where it was cheaper (now you have to go another county out again to get this benefit). We tried to overpay a few hundred a month before ds was born then when our 5 years interest free was up we remortgaged to cover the difference so we only owed the lender and weren't paying interest on the mortgage and the equity loan.

To be honest the house was big enough that we could have stayed there but as it was a town house there was quite a small family living footprint so we moved to an older house, quite a jump in price so had to remortgage over 35 years again but this could be our forever home. We had equity in the newbuild but wanted to secure the best interest rate possible - we were very lucky to have been gifted around 18k from family.

I am so aware of how lucky we are and even 6 months on would already have been priced our of this house even with the family help. It's madness.

WinterOfOurDiscoTent · 14/02/2022 12:33

We lived somewhere tiny pre-children and saved like hell to buy a small terraced house. It's not that great but it's a home and we wanted it to be possible to pay the mortgage on one income or two part time incomes while our DC were little.
Not much point having a massive house if you are never in it because you have to work three jobs to afford it in my opinion. I appreciate others feel differently and that's fine.

Whammyyammy · 14/02/2022 12:29

[quote 00100001]@Seashor
But, can't you see that it wasn't the lack of false nails that got them to the £70k, it's the fact they were living at your house for free/subsidised.

Lets assume your son and gf bring home around £3000 pcm, and and pay £2000+ in rent and bills, and general living costs.
And let's say if your son got false nails and his hair cut once every month. That's, what? £100? And let's even multiply that by 5 to show that he had no luxuries, because they were saving, and the rest of their salaries went on rent, bills, one off costs (MoT etc) etc.
So they're saving £500pcm, that would have taken 140 months to save £70k. That's over 10 years!

However, if they didn't have to pay rent and bills totalling £2k a month, they'd be able to save £2.5k a month. They'd save £70k in 28months (Call it 2.5years)

So saying they didn't have help, and implying that they did it by not having false nails is just utter bollocks.

Unless you're going to drip feed and say it did take them 10+ years, because you were charging market rates etc.[/quote]
£70,000 isn't that much to save for 2 people living rent free at home, on a good to average salary.
£35,000 each at £1,000pm would take 3 years.

icannotbebothered · 14/02/2022 12:27

@MrsSkylerWhite

Lots of “boomers” are in pretty dire straits too, these days: whilst at the same time expected to be bank of mum and dad and Sunnydays residential home for elderly parents, too. It’s not all fun and games and sports cars. Dismissing a group of people as boomer is about as accurate as labelling another group as snowflakes.
There's nothing wrong with admitting that one generation had it easier in some areas than other generations, cheap housing is something that boomers benefitted from. Cheap travel is something millennials benefited from, obviously not ALL people in these generations did
forinborin · 14/02/2022 12:27

[quote 00100001]@Seashor
But, can't you see that it wasn't the lack of false nails that got them to the £70k, it's the fact they were living at your house for free/subsidised.

Lets assume your son and gf bring home around £3000 pcm, and and pay £2000+ in rent and bills, and general living costs.
And let's say if your son got false nails and his hair cut once every month. That's, what? £100? And let's even multiply that by 5 to show that he had no luxuries, because they were saving, and the rest of their salaries went on rent, bills, one off costs (MoT etc) etc.
So they're saving £500pcm, that would have taken 140 months to save £70k. That's over 10 years!

However, if they didn't have to pay rent and bills totalling £2k a month, they'd be able to save £2.5k a month. They'd save £70k in 28months (Call it 2.5years)

So saying they didn't have help, and implying that they did it by not having false nails is just utter bollocks.

Unless you're going to drip feed and say it did take them 10+ years, because you were charging market rates etc.[/quote]
The answer is that they don't pay £2000 / month in rent, but they live in a houseshare for £500/month with bills included.

Boom, 70K saved in 4 years.

icannotbebothered · 14/02/2022 12:24

@Seashor

My son has just bought a house with his girlfriend. 70 thousand deposit. They worked their arses off, didn’t spend on false nails, hair, etc. They lived at home and they didn’t decide to have children and then bleat on about how the ‘Boomers’ had it so easy. They didn’t! They were also prepared to move to a cheaper area.
Do some research.
weansu · 14/02/2022 12:23

I've never known anything but low interest rates, it would be quite nice for my savings to actually increase.

Kennykenkencat · 14/02/2022 12:21

Mortgage interest rates were only that high for a relatively short period. They peaked with BoE base rate in the late 1970s and again in the early 1990s. In between, rates were much lower

Our bank was charging 25% interest (8% above base.) and it didn’t just come down as quickly as the BOE base rate.
Whilst that might not be what they are supposed to do. Our mortgage company were a shambles who had to be threatened with legal action before they begrudgingly reduced the mortgage payments. Friends at the time had a similar experiences with their mortgage companies.

Of course interest rates were a lot lower in between
Anything in single figures would have been amazing. Anything that didn’t begin with a twenty was amazing.

Chewbecca · 14/02/2022 12:18

Living with parents to save money is not quite an equivalent of a cash handout because it is sometimes an option for people who could never afford a cash handout.

RincewindsHat · 14/02/2022 12:16

@Seashor

My son has just bought a house with his girlfriend. 70 thousand deposit. They worked their arses off, didn’t spend on false nails, hair, etc. They lived at home and they didn’t decide to have children and then bleat on about how the ‘Boomers’ had it so easy. They didn’t! They were also prepared to move to a cheaper area.
So they were heavily subbed by their parents because they weren't paying rent and bills, but people who don't have that option are 'bleating'. It's the equivalent of a cash handout worth likely tens of thousands between the two of them.
Kennykenkencat · 14/02/2022 12:10

@00100001

So, if houses used to be (say) 4-5x average annual salary back in the olden days of the boomers.

And now house prices are 10 X average salary... Bit they're still being bought, and people want to buy...

Where is this money coming from?

Are boomer parents artificially inflating house prices by giving huge sums of money by releasing equity etc?

Who is buying the expensive houses??

It was 4-5 times joint salary and of course depended where you lived in the country as it does now.

I think the differences between how easy or hard it is/was to buy a place has changed because of a few reasons.

Firstly I think we need to realise that when looking at average house prices and salaries we need to realise that when starting out most people aren’t on average salaries and didn’t buy average priced properties for their first home.
If that is what you are trying to do today then you are making it very difficult for yourself.

I think you can’t compare todays property buyers with that of someone who was looking to buy in the 70s and 80s

Firstly people tended to live with parents as rental properties were scarce and even if you were forced into private rental it was a case of being lucky if your rental was clean and nice. Most were so horrible that you saved as much as you could to buy anything to get out of the rental.

I think the removal of the first step on the housing ladder when mortgage companies stopped lending on small studio flats means that people stay in rented for longer.

Then providing the multiples added up then you didn’t need a deposit so there was no waiting around for years saving.

Also very few people went to university
It was the exception rather than the norm. So people had been working 5 years when most people today are just leaving university

Most people I know took in a lodger for the first few years to help with mortgage repayments.

The only thing that helps today is the increase in multiples you can borrow but then that could be a negative as well.

My first place I bought with Dh was nearly 12 times my gross salary and nearly 7 times dhs

We did need a very large deposit because the multiples were 1x my salary and 1.5 times Dhs

weansu · 14/02/2022 12:07

@kinko but most people are buying a more expensive house which has increased proportionally by more.

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.ft.com/content/5c49931e-9ddd-3db3-8a67-3fc2bc18f0d2

00100001 · 14/02/2022 12:06

@Seashor
But, can't you see that it wasn't the lack of false nails that got them to the £70k, it's the fact they were living at your house for free/subsidised.

Lets assume your son and gf bring home around £3000 pcm, and and pay £2000+ in rent and bills, and general living costs.
And let's say if your son got false nails and his hair cut once every month. That's, what? £100? And let's even multiply that by 5 to show that he had no luxuries, because they were saving, and the rest of their salaries went on rent, bills, one off costs (MoT etc) etc.
So they're saving £500pcm, that would have taken 140 months to save £70k. That's over 10 years!

However, if they didn't have to pay rent and bills totalling £2k a month, they'd be able to save £2.5k a month. They'd save £70k in 28months (Call it 2.5years)

So saying they didn't have help, and implying that they did it by not having false nails is just utter bollocks.

Unless you're going to drip feed and say it did take them 10+ years, because you were charging market rates etc.

OP posts:
BulletTrain · 14/02/2022 12:05

Yes, I know. I'm a financial adviser. It's just an odd example to use. Most moves are to a larger or smaller house.

Iamthewombat · 14/02/2022 12:05

ITS not IT’S! I hate it when autocorrect introduces misplaced apostrophes.

weansu · 14/02/2022 12:04

Again, there's benefits beyond moving up the ladder!

@Woahthehorsey I'm specifically talking about people who say move up the ladder to make money. Of course if something lowers your LTV than that's good but economically most will still suffer from wage stagnation & increased taxes & receiving "less" for those taxes so what is the overall benefit? My mortgage is lower but I'm going to face a significant increase to my tax soon.

Iamthewombat · 14/02/2022 12:04

As Babyboomers, prices were lower as were expectations and we didn't have stamp duty. Mortgage rates were a lot higher (17+%) though.

Stamp duty land tax, or it’s predecessor, was introduced in the 1950s and applied to houses bought for £30k or more. That wouldn’t have been difficult from the early 1980s onwards.

Mortgage interest rates were only that high for a relatively short period. They peaked with BoE base rate in the late 1970s and again in the early 1990s. In between, rates were much lower.

People buying houses from 1983 until the mid 1990s, when it became essentially worthless, also benefited from MIRAS, mortgage interest relief at source, which got you a deduction on your personal taxes for your mortgage interest. That certainly would have alleviated the pain!

House prices have gone up a lot, but we paid a lot more in interest and inflation was much higher too, so people needed the house prices to rise to avoid negative equity.

Eh? How do you work that one out? Inflation didn’t cause negative equity. Quite the opposite. High inflation tends to inflate away debt, particularly when, as was the case in the 1970s and early 1980s, wage increases broadly kept pace with inflation.

Negative equity is caused when people buy into asset bubbles at the top of the market, using borrowed money, and find that they can’t sell the asset for enough to clear the borrowings. Despite the horror with which it is spoken about, it’s not a disaster. You don’t lose your house because of negative equity. You’re still living in it and paying the mortgage. It’s just that you bought at the wrong time.

Woahthehorsey · 14/02/2022 12:03

@BulletTrain

If you go to buy another house that is £150k then you now have £80k deposit to put down (more than 50%, giving you better interest rates and terms) - you will of course have stamp duty, legal costs, removals etc - but there comes a point where the increase value in your home covers this.

Most people don't move from a £150k house to a £150k house. House 2 would be more likely to cost say £250k if you want a 3 bed from a 2. Unless you move to Sunderland.

But if you remortgage, that's essentially what you are doing, and it benefits you.
DrSbaitso · 14/02/2022 12:01

If you go to buy another house that is £150k then you now have £80k deposit to put down (more than 50%, giving you better interest rates and terms) - you will of course have stamp duty, legal costs, removals etc - but there comes a point where the increase value in your home covers this.

But you're buying a house that's worth the same as the house you're living in now.

I realise you might be moving to change areas and you might get different bang for your buck between cities. But generally, if people move to "climb the ladder", they're moving to a more expensive/valuable property than the one they're living in is worth now. So yes, they get the deposit but they also get a stonking new mortgage on top of it.

BulletTrain · 14/02/2022 12:00

If you go to buy another house that is £150k then you now have £80k deposit to put down (more than 50%, giving you better interest rates and terms) - you will of course have stamp duty, legal costs, removals etc - but there comes a point where the increase value in your home covers this.

Most people don't move from a £150k house to a £150k house. House 2 would be more likely to cost say £250k if you want a 3 bed from a 2. Unless you move to Sunderland.

Woahthehorsey · 14/02/2022 12:00

[quote weansu]@Iamthewombat exactly & yet so many people celebrate that their house has gone up in value 🤦🏻‍♀️[/quote]
Again, there's benefits beyond moving up the ladder!

Kinko · 14/02/2022 11:58

@Iamthewombat

You can see the effect everywhere of housing, particularly mortgages, hoovering up so much disposable income.

Why do we have such a poor choice of high street, and online, clothing stores now compared to 25 years ago? Why are the clothes and shoes we are being sold (generally speaking) such crap quality compared to the 1990s and early 2000s? Why are there so few decent mid-market retailers that haven’t gone bust and been snapped up by BooHoo.com? Because all the money that might have been spent buying nice things by wage earning adults is going into servicing mortgage debt.

Why are so many cars sold on the never never (aka PCP schemes, in which you rent a car you can’t afford but never actually own it)? Because all the money that might have been saved to buy cars outright or with a personal loan is going into servicing mortgage debt.

Why has the government had to default people into occupational pension schemes, that you must opt out of, rather than into? Why do so few people have decent pension provision? Because all the money that might have been saved or invested on a discretionary basis is servicing mortgage debt.

The saddest thing is, I’ve seen several posts on here by people rejoicing that their house has increased in value because they think that they have made a profit. They haven’t. Not unless yours is the only house whose value has increased, or you plan to move into a yurt. You’re actually worse off because when you want to buy a bigger house (that fictional property ladder again), you’re back to square one with a new long term mortgage that you’ll still paying off in your late sixties.

Thats not really true. Unless I'm really stupid but

Using easy numbers:
If you buy a house for £100,000 with a £10k deposit and 5 years later your house is worth £150,000 and let's say you've repaid £20k in mortgage payments. Then you now own £80k worth of asset. But you've only paid in £30k.

If you go to buy another house that is £150k then you now have £80k deposit to put down (more than 50%, giving you better interest rates and terms) - you will of course have stamp duty, legal costs, removals etc - but there comes a point where the increase value in your home covers this.

That's why ppl rejoice!

Or alternatively the increase in value gives them the deposit amount to be able to move up the ladder but keep their mortgage payments around the same and on the same term length.

Least that's how I see it??

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 14/02/2022 11:56

To truely compare costs between different times I think one of the big factors to remember is the drop in interest rates. When I bought my first house in 1988 the average mortgage rate was around 10%, now it is more like 2.5%. So for every £100K borrowed then, you paid back £10K per annum in interest alone, now you can borrow £400K and pay the same amount in interest. It was the amount of interest which worried us then rather than the amount of capital being repaid each month.
I do worry now with signs of inflation creeping up that interest rates might go the same way, house prices could drop if that happens, good news for first time buyers but it means the horrors of negative equity could return with people getting stuck in unsuitable properties with no means of escape due their mortgages being far larger than the properties worth.

weansu · 14/02/2022 11:54

@Iamthewombat exactly & yet so many people celebrate that their house has gone up in value 🤦🏻‍♀️

Woahthehorsey · 14/02/2022 11:52

The saddest thing is, I’ve seen several posts on here by people rejoicing that their house has increased in value because they think that they have made a profit. They haven’t. Not unless yours is the only house whose value has increased, or you plan to move into a yurt.

No. You have made a profit if your house has increased in value MORE than the average increase. So we made a profit on our last house because we added value. Same with this house we are in now - average house prices have risen 12%, ours has risen much more than that because we have added value, more than we have spent on it. We don't intend to sell though, but it does mean when we remortgage we get a better LTV rate.