Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a fair allocation of bedrooms?

217 replies

Wintersbone · 13/02/2022 22:09

We have just moved into our new house. We very purposefully bought a 5 bed so each of the kids DSS (19), DSD (16), DS (12) and DD (7) could each have their own room. Two of the kids bedrooms are slightly larger in area than the other two. I had planned to give the smaller two bedrooms to the stepkids on the premise that they aren't here as much but DSD is quite upset. She ran through the house and declared a bedroom "hers". She's fairly upset at not being given that bedroom and now the younger two are offering to give up theirs which is very sweet but feels wrong. Am I being a cow here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Wintersbone · 18/02/2022 08:11

@TheMeditativeRose She's never mentioned the bathroom at her mums being an issue. Her mum has an ensuite and her brother is at uni so most of the time she has the family bathroom to herself.

OP posts:
LittleGwyneth · 17/02/2022 17:04

Surely it's better to give the kids who are there the least the smaller rooms on the proviso that they get to keep their rooms post leaving school, rather than swapping them around as people get older?

In five years time it would be madness to make your then 13 year old daughter have a smaller room and leave the big en suite to her 21 year old older sister.

TheMeditativeRose · 17/02/2022 16:54

Is it that she shares a bathroom with her brother at her mum’s and doesn’t want to do that again at her dad’s? Perhaps because the experience isn’t that positive.

Jvg33 · 17/02/2022 16:47

I got told which bedroom I was having as a child. And that was it.

Jvg33 · 17/02/2022 16:46

What does your DH think? There his kids.

caringcarer · 17/02/2022 16:21

I'd give DD and DSD the ensuite rooms but make it clear if a guest is staying they will be sleeping in DSD ensuite room. DS and DSS get Jack and Jill bathrooms but never have to give them up for guests.

ancientgran · 17/02/2022 15:50

[quote Wintersbone]@FindmeuptheFarawaytree None of this is 'necessary'. This is about balancing everyone's wants and feelings. I'm not going to tell DH he can't watch tv once DD is in bed because DSD needs to have the other room EOW. Originally I thought I didn't care which bedrooms they each took but on reflection a certain configuration makes more sense. [/quote]
Madness isn't it, your husband not allowed to do what he wants in his own house so his daughter can have the room she wants EOW.

Put her in a cupboard under the stairs like Harry Potter. That'll give MN something to froth about. She could have a jug of water to wash in and a portapotti for her ensuite.

Blondeshavemorefun · 15/02/2022 20:43

@ItsDisneyBitch

I would give the girls an en-suite and the boys the jack and Jill, if the elder boy is at university then it’s like the younger has his own bathroom anyway except during the holidays.
This

Far better two males share a bathroom esp if a lot of the time the youngest son will have to his self

Assume you have bed 5 with en-suite. And possibly another bathroom as well

FindmeuptheFarawaytree · 15/02/2022 19:52

It must feel to 16yo as if her wants and feelings are the only ones being completely ignored. Also, it is possible to watch TV without loud surround sound on, which is what a lot of parents do. I didn't suggest he couldn't watch TV at all, turning it down wouldn't hurt him! Like I said, that's just my view, you've made your decision and that's fine and am sure it will work out in the end. It's not surprising that 16yo is hurt by all this, but I guess she will get over it, either way it's not the end of the world.

Wintersbone · 15/02/2022 19:16

@FindmeuptheFarawaytree None of this is 'necessary'. This is about balancing everyone's wants and feelings. I'm not going to tell DH he can't watch tv once DD is in bed because DSD needs to have the other room EOW. Originally I thought I didn't care which bedrooms they each took but on reflection a certain configuration makes more sense.

OP posts:
FindmeuptheFarawaytree · 15/02/2022 10:36

Or 'poor dad' could just not have surround sound on. It's clearly not necessary in a normal home, most people don't have tv's on loud whilst their children are sleeping! Funny how he only had an opinion when it affected his TV watching. If he had stepped in with some parenting earlier and made sure everyone knew what was happening to begin with there wouldn't be such an issue now.

ancientgran · 15/02/2022 10:29

Poor dad has to sit in silence 7 nights a week so 16 year old can have her own way when she spends time with them. Is he allowed to eat when Madame isn't in residence?

HeddaGarbled · 14/02/2022 23:35

Did you miss the bit about the en suite rooms being noisy from the TV

DH has a surround sound system

There’s a selfish person in this family, for sure.

ancientgran · 14/02/2022 21:43

Sorry I meant the jack and jill rooms being noisier than the en suite rooms.

ancientgran · 14/02/2022 21:43

@FindmeuptheFarawaytree

Sorry but I do think it's a bit mean. I'd give the 16 yo and 12yo the ensuites as they will get most benefit from them for now. 19yo won't be there all that often as at uni so doesn't need the large bedroom and 7yo was more than happy to have the smaller room. From the outside it looks like any excuse not to give bigger room to dsd. When she goes to uni or whatever the understanding will be that dd7 then gets to move to the ensuite room. I think your dh just needs to turn his 'surround sound' down quite frankly if it loud enough to wake anyone. However it is of course your decision, but that's my thoughts on the matter.
Did you miss the bit about the en suite rooms being noisy from the TV downstairs? The 7 year old needs to get to sleep earlier than the 16 or 19 year old so much more sensible for her to have a quieter room.
TheApexOfMyLife · 14/02/2022 13:36

@Wintersbone

Last night DH found he does have an opinion! DD was woken up by the TV because the jack and jill bedrooms are over the lounge and DH has a surround sound system. The ensuite bedrooms are the other end of the house. As we only have DSD EOW she very rarely will overlap with guests unless it's my mother who comes once a year and whom DSD adores. I try to schedule other guests for when DSD isn't with us. Essentially this will leave DSD with a slightly smaller bedroom but a huge bathroom all to herself the vast majority of the time.

I would have preferred a family bathroom to the jack and jill but the layout means it can't be fixed. It doesn't share a wall with the landing.

Well that solves it!

You don't want the 7yo to be woken up regularly by the TV, esp as she is there everyday.

I'm with your dh there.

Wintersbone · 14/02/2022 12:48

There's an awful lot of projection going on here. DSD isn't bratty nor awful. She just isn't. She's a child who has a fixed idea of something she wanted. She's also a stepchild so there will be extra sensitivities to consider. There isn't a single photo of just DH and the younger two anywhere up in the house. All the family photos have us ALL in them. In fact there are far more of my stepkids because frankly I've lost steam with each kid to keep up with the photos!

She has a full set of everything here. All the clothes she likes best migrate to her mums but I bought them for her so that's her choice.

The amount of time she spends here is pertinent in my view. To go with a less convenient set up most of the month seems silly really. Her bedroom will still be a good sized double with space for a big desk and walk-in closet. It's hardly a cupboard!

It's really only a few night a year that the ensuite jack and Jill would have anyone else using it. If she wants I'll offer to have her swap with DD on those nights. But my guess is she won't be fussed once she decorates it how she wants. In the future we could split the jack and jill into two smaller en-suites. It's really quite big. Seems to shame to rip out a nearly new bathroom u til we know if it's a big issue or not.

OP posts:
Shortofspace · 14/02/2022 11:51

Is the Jack and Jill bathroom big enough to divide into two, smaller en-suites?

Monopolyiscrap · 14/02/2022 11:34

@FindmeuptheFarawaytree

Sorry but I do think it's a bit mean. I'd give the 16 yo and 12yo the ensuites as they will get most benefit from them for now. 19yo won't be there all that often as at uni so doesn't need the large bedroom and 7yo was more than happy to have the smaller room. From the outside it looks like any excuse not to give bigger room to dsd. When she goes to uni or whatever the understanding will be that dd7 then gets to move to the ensuite room. I think your dh just needs to turn his 'surround sound' down quite frankly if it loud enough to wake anyone. However it is of course your decision, but that's my thoughts on the matter.
I 100% agree with this. And I see it time and time again on here. People always look for an excuse to give the step kids the smallest rooms in the house. I have never once on MN seen anyone giving any stepchild the largest room. Whether the step kids are young or old, there is always a reason. If they are young, then they do not need a large room as they will be playing mostly in the living room. If they are teenagers, they do not need a large room as they don't have lots of toys to play with. Most mums put their own kids first and what they want ahead of any stepchildren.
Monopolyiscrap · 14/02/2022 11:20

@ivegotasorethroat

Why should she have a bigger room that's left empty the majority of the time because she's with her other parent?

She has a room in another house to keep most of her belongings!

No, she has the smaller room. She doesn't call the shots!

Why should the step kids keep most of their belongings at their mums? Why would they not want access to clothes, music, computer games, etc at their dads as well? Or do you expect them to act like visitors bringing a small bag of clothes for a few days.
FindmeuptheFarawaytree · 14/02/2022 11:10

Sorry but I do think it's a bit mean. I'd give the 16 yo and 12yo the ensuites as they will get most benefit from them for now. 19yo won't be there all that often as at uni so doesn't need the large bedroom and 7yo was more than happy to have the smaller room. From the outside it looks like any excuse not to give bigger room to dsd. When she goes to uni or whatever the understanding will be that dd7 then gets to move to the ensuite room. I think your dh just needs to turn his 'surround sound' down quite frankly if it loud enough to wake anyone. However it is of course your decision, but that's my thoughts on the matter.

MostNamesAreTaken · 14/02/2022 11:05

@Melj1213 presumably the laid back approach only works with young kids or older ones of the same gender? Certainly not with guests.

melj1213 · 14/02/2022 10:56

You need to remember to lock both sides when you go in, and remember to unlock both sides when you go out then relock your side from the outside

Depends on the family norm though - my cousins have a J&J bathroom between their bedrooms and they could never be bothered with the faff of constantly locking/unlocking multiple doors so they just have a system that the bathroom doors are left open (also helps to get fresh air through all 3 rooms if the windows are open in both bedrooms) unless someone is in there, so if the door is closed the you knock before trying the door.

Obviously not everyone would be comfortable with such a laid back approach (and they do occasionally lock the doors if they want to guarantee privacy or if one of them has friends staying over who might also use that bathroom) but it also doesn't have to be overly complicated either.

MostNamesAreTaken · 14/02/2022 10:41

For those that haven't experienced them the issue with Jack and Jill is that they are often less private than a conventional shared bathroom. You need to remember to lock both sides when you go in, and remember to unlock both sides when you go out then relock your side from the outside. I've experienced them in a cheap hotel and it was pretty awkward. The other issue is when both sides go in at the same time. I am sure you get used to them, but I don't think they make good guest rooms, as a disoriented guest is particularly likely to try the wrong door and forget the locking system.

I've only seen them work with bolts (as both sides of the door need to be lockable) and there is a mischievous potential to lock someone in. So not sure they are ideal for young kids, particularly both sides.

Your DH needs to step up to sort this out as sensitively as possible. However reasonable your logic, it's not going to be good optics when you are left to dictate your kids get the best rooms, and the other kids get lesser rooms the other side of the house.

InaccurateDream · 14/02/2022 10:29

Good he has an opinion now. Do what you need to do. If bedrooms are different someone always has the ‘worst’ one and we often have to make decisions based on not much. You can’t even give youngest the smallest and tell them they’ll get the biggest in time if the eldest never leaves!

Fwiw sleep is important. My son didn’t sleep for ten years. We moved house and he had a choice of essentially two box rooms. He ended up in the very smallest room because he felt cosy, could see the door, there was no noise from boiler or bathroom and finally he sleeps… ten years! If a child has trouble sleeping I would always do what’s best to fix that (regardless of room sizes).

Swipe left for the next trending thread