Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MN has it all wrong re proposals?

691 replies

alfayruz · 13/02/2022 20:12

Inspired by a thread the other day, but also a general observation on here, I was thinking ... whenever anyone posts on MN about waiting for a proposal from their DP, you can guarantee hundreds of posts along the lines of ‘just propose to him....’ AIBU to think this is ridiculous because -

  1. Nobody in actual real life does this

  2. Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

  3. Even if you could still muster some kind of sexual attraction towards him, the bar is set at rock bottom before you even start - so why would you expect any initiative or effort from him on any other occasions or general life going forward?

AIBU?

OP posts:
alfayruz · 16/02/2022 07:47

Yes but when I said ‘biology’ in that post, it was specifically in response to the poster before saying biology has nothing whatsoever to do with the way societal expectations have evolved.

That is hardly the same thing as me claiming that biology is responsible for everything! Christ on a bike.

OP posts:
alfayruz · 16/02/2022 07:43

I was more thinking about how and why certain gendered expectations may have evolved through human history in the particular way they have, MangshorJhol.

Of course it’s not the case that your biology means you are a better cook / cleaner whatever.

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 16/02/2022 07:42

You… you know we can go back and read your previous posts, right?

WulyJmpr · 16/02/2022 07:40

A pragmatic mixture

thepeopleversuswork · 16/02/2022 07:37

@alfayruz

Ffs. Someone makes the assertion “gender is purely a social construct, it has nothing to do with biology.’

I say that I believe it’s not as clear cut as that and that SOME (SOME!!!) gendered behaviours will have been somewhat indirectly affected / shaped / engendered by biological differences between men and women (I cited hormone differences and the fact women’s experience of childbirth differs that men’s).

Then - naturally in MN - this is twisted and apparently I am arguing that EVERYHING is down to biology Confused

People then feel the need to go into an explanation that “Social constructs are affected by more than biology.’ Well, no shit Sherlock! Who would have guessed it?

This place is mental.

@alfayruz you said upthread (I quote): "What drives humans? biology."

You can't have it both ways.

If you come onto the internet and basically claim men who don't propose to their partners are soft pantywaists and women who do propose have no sex drive you have to be prepared to be challenged on this regressive bollocks.

SoLoveless2022 · 16/02/2022 07:34

@WulyJmpr

I proposed to my husband when I was 25. We were and still are equal partners in our marriage so it was done in the spirit of that I suppose. I proposed on a Saturday afternoon in the living room of our rental flat as I knew he wouldn't like the 'pressure' of everyone watching if we were in a public place.

It surprises me how feminism goes out the window in society with marriage proposals. A woman should feel she can ask as much as her husband also should have feel he can. Not waiting around like some sort of princess. If you know what you want then seize the day.

@WulyJmpr

Since you brought up feminism:
Did you keep your last name, or maybe he took yours?
Do you have kids?
Who’s name they have?

MangshorJhol · 16/02/2022 07:32

Of course women’s experience of childbirth is different.
But my biology doesn’t make me a better cleaner or cook or washer upper of dishes or EVEN, a better parent.
Men who choose not to be equal partners are choosing not to do so. And there is nothing biological about it.

I breastfed my kids because I could biologically do it. As a consequence in the first six weeks or so DH did absolutely everything else (esp with DS1 who was a Velcro baby).

The gendered roles we choose to play that are NON biological are very much social constructs.

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 07:22

Ffs. Someone makes the assertion “gender is purely a social construct, it has nothing to do with biology.’

I say that I believe it’s not as clear cut as that and that SOME (SOME!!!) gendered behaviours will have been somewhat indirectly affected / shaped / engendered by biological differences between men and women (I cited hormone differences and the fact women’s experience of childbirth differs that men’s).

Then - naturally in MN - this is twisted and apparently I am arguing that EVERYHING is down to biology Confused

People then feel the need to go into an explanation that “Social constructs are affected by more than biology.’ Well, no shit Sherlock! Who would have guessed it?

This place is mental.

OP posts:
MangshorJhol · 16/02/2022 07:08

Also I think what attracts me to DH most is that I am 100% his equal. Of course I carried his babies and birthed them and fed them. This is why it has never occurred to him to NOT wake up at night and help, or not do household tasks, or not be an equal. Frankly I managed to breastfeed because of how much he did in the early weeks. I basically sat around and fed and he did everything else. For instance, when having a small child pushed my career back he had the option of going for a job that would mean mega bucks but never see your family and wouldn’t be so easy for me location wise. He turned it down, (and then later turned down a similar job a few years later for similar reasons) and has done everything possible to help my career flourish AND be an equal parent. He is ridiculously successful but not at the cost of us.

He has flaws (stubborn mule etc) but in the 20 years I have known him he’s never said ever ‘we are going to make X decision as a family because I am a man/you are a woman.’ For instance, he’s on the school PTA (the US version) not me. It wasn’t my job to sort out childcare. We did it together. It isn’t my job alone to remember who needs to be when and where. It isn’t my job alone to make breakfast, lunch and dinner, do the dishwasher, put out clothes, keep the house tidy etc etc.

I find that incredibly sexy.

thepeopleversuswork · 16/02/2022 07:05

I also find the idea of public proposals quite twee and far more performative than two people deciding lovingly to spend the rest of their life together. In fact proposals are entirely performative.

Absolutely. The standard proposal (as featured in Hollywood) is a case study in cringe. It would actually make me think twice about marrying someone I otherwise loved if they did that whole routine.

mellongoose · 16/02/2022 06:59

My DH proposed when we were living together and had a child. In ordering to properly trigger MN, I must inform you that he also asked my dad for permission first. Wink

MangshorJhol · 16/02/2022 06:57

Look DH is far more romantic than I am. I am really not. But we are one of those ‘no proposal’ folks. Knew we wanted to get married at 22. DH was heading to med school and I was off to do my PhD so we decided to get married just before his residency. So we did. We have been together 20 years and I don’t and didn’t find him sexually attractive because he didn’t perform a medieval ritual from another culture (we are Asian anyway).

Our decision wasn’t a performatively feminist one. We couldn’t give a shit about what other people thought and did.

He is incredibly kind, thoughtful, an equal dad and partner. Has made career sacrifices for my career so I didn’t fall behind when I had kids. I still find him incredibly attractive.

I also find the idea of public proposals quite twee and far more performative than two people deciding lovingly to spend the rest of their life together. In fact proposals are entirely performative.

thepeopleversuswork · 16/02/2022 06:48

@JassyRadlett

Where did patriarchy come from if not humans?

Not everything done or created by humans is the result of their innate biology. Our development is also affected by our environment, our experiences, and by the culture and society we exist within - and therefore our behaviours are influenced by much more than the genes we were born with.

@JassyRadlett wins the internet.

Seriously though this has been one of the most effective takedowns of “I want men to be men and women to be women because, er, biology” that I’ve read. I really hope this thread has thread some light on this.

JassyRadlett · 15/02/2022 23:19

Where did patriarchy come from if not humans?

Not everything done or created by humans is the result of their innate biology. Our development is also affected by our environment, our experiences, and by the culture and society we exist within - and therefore our behaviours are influenced by much more than the genes we were born with.

JassyRadlett · 15/02/2022 23:16

But again, we are society. So it’s the same thing.

You keep saying this as if it’s an immutable truth, but there’s not actually much (if any) basis for it.

Who is ‘we’? If it’s biologically-driven, why do societies differ so much by place and time?

And it’s not ‘the same thing’ or the outcomes would be identical. They aren’t.

Society is one of the factors that influence our behaviours, attitudes and beliefs. We are born into a particular societal and cultural context and it influences our development. As individuals and as a group, we influence that construct and it influences us; some of us will have more impact on it than others.

You seem to be totally ignoring the other non-gender based social constructs mentioned - why? Either social constructs are entirely biologically driven, or they’re not.

Women’s attitudes, feelings, beliefs around gender roles are as much driven by men’s reactions to their biology than their biology itself (and that’s ignoring pink/blue, STEM v humanities, whatever.) That’s something that exists outside their individual biology.

I am starting to think though that you are using ‘biology’ to encompass absolutely everything that humans do and the way they experience it - ie if it involves the brain, it’s biological. Which will take us in a very circular way as there is no way for anything to exist outside of biology.

alfayruz · 15/02/2022 23:13

Anyway. Thanks for the thread. I’m off to bed.

OP posts:
SpinsForGin · 15/02/2022 23:12

But again, we are society. So it’s the same thing.
No it isn't

But yes, I agree that “society” (ie us, her and now) is deeply conflicted in the way we view mothers. Look at the threads on here if you need evidence of that! If you SAH you are mocked by other women on here as ‘living off a man’ / or what did that poster call me just now - ‘trad wife.’ (who needs misogynistic men)? If you work, you may well be made to feel guilty about it.
But this isn't due to biology. It's due to how people view the role of women in society. That person mocking SAHMs isn't acting in biological instinct. They're doing that because they view motherhood in a particular way.

So you can’t win. Different women negotiate the fact if childbirth and childcare differently.
And again ( recovery from birth aside) this is due to how we view the role of women in society. Decisions around childcare are not biologically driven. Otherwise we'd all make the same choices.

But biological facts like pregnancy, breastfeeding and the whole shebang do mean that women have all these debates in a way men don’t. And that’s before you get into hormones, post/birth complications, PND.

Nobody will argue with that. Which is why understanding the difference between sex snd gender is important

alfayruz · 15/02/2022 23:12

Where did patriarchy come from if not humans?

Did it descend on us randomly from above?

(that’s not me saying ‘go patriarchy’ by the way - just before I’m accused of being a secret Taliban member).

OP posts:
oblada · 15/02/2022 23:08

DH and I jointly agreed to get married. To be perfectly honest I find the idea that a woman should wait for a proposal from a man to be quite bizarre nowadays. I hope to see more couples do this. It shows equality and generally makes sense.

AlexaShutUp · 15/02/2022 23:06

@alfayruz

Jasey - I’m no anthropologist, but it seems obvious to me that as the child-bearing sex, women since the beginning of time have had to negotiate life differently to men. A lot of ‘social constructs’ such as family structures (whether it’s the nuclear family or plural wives) would have been a double-edged sword of enduring survival and protecting women and their children, but also ensuring paternity. Over time, this morphs into control and all the manifestations of the patriarchy as it plays out in virtually all societies across the globe. Religion is devised (by men) as a way of sublimating and institutionalising it all and the rest is obvious.
You are indeed no anthropologist. You're suggesting that the patriarchy is essentially a natural consequence of our biology, but the evidence suggests that the original hunter gatherer societies were actually much more egalitarian than the agrarian societies that developed subsequently.
alfayruz · 15/02/2022 22:59

‘But my argument is that the reason women have to negotiate the world differently isn't because of the biological differences but is due to how society views women because of these differences.’

But again, we are society. So it’s the same thing.

But yes, I agree that “society” (ie us, her and now) is deeply conflicted in the way we view mothers. Look at the threads on here if you need evidence of that! If you SAH you are mocked by other women on here as ‘living off a man’ / or what did that poster call me just now - ‘trad wife.’ (who needs misogynistic men)? Grin If you work, you may well be made to feel guilty about it. So you can’t win. Different women negotiate the fact if childbirth and childcare differently. But biological facts like pregnancy, breastfeeding and the whole shebang do mean that women have all these debates in a way men don’t. And that’s before you get into hormones, post/birth complications, PND.

OP posts:
IckyPop · 15/02/2022 22:38

@Skeam you got my number Grin

JassyRadlett · 15/02/2022 22:37

Oh don't pretend you weren't being judgemental and sneery about it. Didn't you say the men are feeble and pathetic if they don't propose?

Don’t forget unshaggable.

Luredbyapomegranate · 15/02/2022 22:36

Blimey, OP this has been a wild drip feed. You have A LOT of trad views, I feel like you were trying to soften us up with talk of beaches and solitaires, before you really socked us with the trad wife world. There’s a market for this shit mind you. Start a blog. Maybe combine it with a bit of religious zealotry and a side of tray bakes. 🙃

JassyRadlett · 15/02/2022 22:36

@alfayruz

Jasey - I’m no anthropologist, but it seems obvious to me that as the child-bearing sex, women since the beginning of time have had to negotiate life differently to men. A lot of ‘social constructs’ such as family structures (whether it’s the nuclear family or plural wives) would have been a double-edged sword of enduring survival and protecting women and their children, but also ensuring paternity. Over time, this morphs into control and all the manifestations of the patriarchy as it plays out in virtually all societies across the globe. Religion is devised (by men) as a way of sublimating and institutionalising it all and the rest is obvious.
Yep, there is (as I’ve said) a degree of ‘social reaction to biological imperatives’ in gender roles. But there are other factors at play that undermine the idea that all of these and in particular how we ‘feel’ about them are the direct result of biology.

For example, you cited ‘ensuring paternity’ as a biological imperative, but is it? Is there evidence that it’s innate biology, rather than, say, a response to the environmental factor that there isn’t much food, there’s a fucking sabre tooth cat outside, need to decide who to prioritise, this group looks like a sensible grouping. (And that group will still differ across cultures based on social norms.) I’m not sure there’s any evidence that men have a different biological response to children who aren’t biologically theirs (ie there isn’t a pheromone issue, etc.) It’s the idea of their child that’s the driver, and I think there is a decent argument that it’s more about desire and imperative for power and authority.

There’s much we don’t know. But a couple of good rules of thumb:

  1. When it comes to gender roles, the rapid unwinding of previously supposedly ‘innate’ female roles as soon as women had a way to avoid pregnancy is a signal that many of the roles and norms thrust upon women were not in fact driven by their own biology, and their biological difference from men, but from society’s response to their biological difference from men.
Another way to look at it is by culture - take the contention put forward by some that girls are more innately drawn to humanities, and boys to STEM. If you look at studies and surveys of British children, you’d certainly think that was supported. But those rates vary vastly across countries, and absent a massive biological difference in, for example, Russian girls and British girls, our concepts of what boys and girls are ‘good at’ or ‘are drawn to’ are largely constructed by us and imposed on our children at a young age. (Depressingly consistent is the fact that as more women enter a field, pay rates decline.)
  1. There are plenty of social constructs that aren’t gender based and where it is incredibly difficult to apply a biologically-driven lens to some of the constructs we’ve invented. Numerous people have mentioned race; there are others. The idea of adulthood, for example, is an example of a social construct that has shifted considerably (for both men and women) over time. Again, there is a biological component (sexual maturity) involved but it’s not the sole or even the determining factor in different concepts of adulthood across societies and over time.