Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MN has it all wrong re proposals?

691 replies

alfayruz · 13/02/2022 20:12

Inspired by a thread the other day, but also a general observation on here, I was thinking ... whenever anyone posts on MN about waiting for a proposal from their DP, you can guarantee hundreds of posts along the lines of ‘just propose to him....’ AIBU to think this is ridiculous because -

  1. Nobody in actual real life does this

  2. Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

  3. Even if you could still muster some kind of sexual attraction towards him, the bar is set at rock bottom before you even start - so why would you expect any initiative or effort from him on any other occasions or general life going forward?

AIBU?

OP posts:
SpinsForGin · 16/02/2022 11:10

Once again and for the final time - no I don’t think ‘everything is due to biology.’ confused. I just don’t think you can totally ignore it either.

Nobody is ignoring biology. You, however, are placing far too much importance on biology and too little importance on societal influences. If you actually research the history and origins of the patriarchy you will see that it developed out of particular societal structures. While biology might be used to explain the division of labour in early society, patriarchy as we know it today was a social construction and one that actually has no place in modern society.
There is no biological need for men to hold the power....

If women didn’t give birth and breastfeed babies, it’s patently obvious that the concept of ‘gender’ would have evolved differently through history.

I'm not sure I fully agree with this. The oppression of women is not just about childbirth and breastfeeding. There is so much more to it that that.

I don’t know why that’s such a shocking concept for some people. If you’re going to fight the patriarchy, there no point being in denial about why we are where we are.

I'm not in denial. It's my job to understand this!

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 11:04

I don’t mean you personally, MangshorJhol! I’m not talking about individuals in the here and now. I’m talking about women’s traditional gender role as caregivers which has evolved historically and has generally been in evidence in all societies globally, to a greater or lesser degree. It stems from the fact that they are the ones who give birth and breastfeed. In times gone by, they would have been more ‘housebound’ as a result and then other ‘gender expectations’ get piled on - housework, cooking and whatever.

If women didn’t give birth or breastfeed - let’s pretend for the sake of argument babies were delivered by the postman to both parents ready to go - then the gendered expectations on women in relation to the domestic sphere might well have developed differently.

OP posts:
MangshorJhol · 16/02/2022 10:58

Finally those same 20-30 year olds doing the bulk of the housework are also agonising that their partners they live with more often than not are not proposing to them with a shiny ring. So they are waiting and hoping while cooking and cleaning and trying to be the perfect girlfriend and wishing for that special day.
I don’t blame the women. I blame society that even in 2022 thinks that this is how young women (mostly sans kids) should value themselves.

MangshorJhol · 16/02/2022 10:54

As someone WELL past the birth and breastfeeding stage, I am amazed by the 50 year olds on MN who do everything for their husbands and their kids who are not small babies while trying to hold down part time jobs (because childcare is always the woman’s problem). And carrying all the invisible load of remembering World Book Day and birthday parties and all the rest.

What any of that has to do with my boobs and vagina I don’t know. Society (broadly) has taken a brief period in a woman’s life when she is tied down and vulnerable to condemn her to the domestic sphere and have very low expectations of men in that regard. So MANY 20-30 year olds without kids on MN who do the bulk of the housework. WHY?!

MangshorJhol · 16/02/2022 10:51

But giving birth and breastfeeding is a very small fraction of my life.

That doesn’t explain why I wasn’t encouraged to study science as a 10 year old. Or why I got groped on a bus in my teens. Or wolf whistled. Or why people expect my husband to ‘babysit’ our kids and are amazed that he does more.

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 10:46

Today 08:31 SpinsForGin

Despite cultural differences between societies, now and through history, the vast majority of societies are essentially patriarchal at the core. It just manifests in different ways and to different degrees. It is unfortunate, but not a coincidence.

And you think this is due to biology?

Then what hope is there? Why bother fighting for equality if, due to biology, patriarchy will win?

Once again and for the final time - no I don’t think ‘everything is due to biology.’ Confused. I just don’t think you can totally ignore it either.

If women didn’t give birth and breastfeed babies, it’s patently obvious that the concept of ‘gender’ would have evolved differently through history.

I don’t know why that’s such a shocking concept for some people. If you’re going to fight the patriarchy, there no point being in denial about why we are where we are.

OP posts:
oblada · 16/02/2022 09:29

@JassyRadlett

I dont particularly like double barreled name as it just makes thing a bit difficult (nothing wrong with it i am just not keen).

Your preference is obviously absolutely fine, but I just want to challenge this myth that double-barrelled names make things difficult. More than ten years in, I’m a different nationality from my kids as well, and the number of difficulties we’ve had is zero, I’m happy to report.

That's good for you. For me it is too faffy. But maybe because my kids name are already pretty long (different culture) so it wouldn't seem fair to also give them a double barrel surname. And I can't say my name and my husband's (different national and both not British) would sound good together.
oblada · 16/02/2022 09:26

[quote CupOfNiceTea]@oblada

Alright, and since you are then in a pretty traditional marriage, you then should understand that some women do want to be proposed to and that doesn’t make them stuck in the 1950’s or whatever.[/quote]
Why is my marriage traditional? Because i changed my name? That's a bit simplistic. My maiden name was my father's name. Why should i prefer it to my husband's father?

Funny story on this - it's my husbands father who actually started the family name thing in his family as it is not culturally common to have family name where he is from . So my surname is literally my father in law's name. It started with him. He was a fantastic man. My father's name is my father's name but also his father and father before him etc.
My father in law passed away the day of our wedding sadly so in a way i am honouring his memory.

None of this makes my marriage traditional.
I know some women want to be proposed. Good on them. Do I understand that urge? Not really. Do i respect it? Yes of course it's their choice entirely (well, influenced by our society of course).

CupOfNiceTea · 16/02/2022 09:08

@oblada

Alright, and since you are then in a pretty traditional marriage, you then should understand that some women do want to be proposed to and that doesn’t make them stuck in the 1950’s or whatever.

SnakeLinguine · 16/02/2022 09:07

@JassyRadlett

I dont particularly like double barreled name as it just makes thing a bit difficult (nothing wrong with it i am just not keen).

Your preference is obviously absolutely fine, but I just want to challenge this myth that double-barrelled names make things difficult. More than ten years in, I’m a different nationality from my kids as well, and the number of difficulties we’ve had is zero, I’m happy to report.

DH, DS and I have never had any issues either, with him having both our names, and both parents travelling a lot individually with him. And while DS has a five-syllable surname (both our names), and his name would indubitably sound better if he had one or other of our surnames individually, I think it would be ridiculous to put aesthetic considerations over all else.

Like those Mumsnetters who claim they've always loathed their 'maiden names' and were thrilled to change to their DH's gorgeous surnames on marriage. DH's surname is nicer than mine, but I would have retained mine even if it were Smellie/Longbottom/D'eath.

Qwill · 16/02/2022 08:49

I think this is one of best threads I have read for a long time. It’s a shame the OP keeps flitting and backtracking, and won’t address some of the points that people have made. But the ‘against’ arguments have been calm, logical, we’ll researched, thought provoking and rational. Very ‘unmumsnet’, despite what the OP is trying to make out. It’s interesting how people react when their world view is challenged. There are so many posters on her that have given real world examples of why they disagree (I also don’t know anyone that had, or even wanted, a surprise proposal, it was just a logical step for both of them), yet we are still told ‘most women want a surprise proposal, gifts, etc., and most want a man to also act in this certain way’. It’s such a shame these gender stereotypes are still pushed and do no favours in the sex vs gender debate, except make those who don’t conform feel worthless and less of a man/woman.

MopHeaded · 16/02/2022 08:42

I don’t know what I can contribute 500 posts in, but I think the way me and DH decided to get married was pretty good. We had a conversation. I said ‘I think we should get married’ and he said ‘I agree’ and then we talked about it and set a date and planned the wedding together.

I don’t really understand making massive life decisions by hanging about waiting for a bloke to decide he’s picked you.

JassyRadlett · 16/02/2022 08:39

I dont particularly like double barreled name as it just makes thing a bit difficult (nothing wrong with it i am just not keen).

Your preference is obviously absolutely fine, but I just want to challenge this myth that double-barrelled names make things difficult. More than ten years in, I’m a different nationality from my kids as well, and the number of difficulties we’ve had is zero, I’m happy to report.

JassyRadlett · 16/02/2022 08:37

@alfayruz

Yes but when I said ‘biology’ in that post, it was specifically in response to the poster before saying biology has nothing whatsoever to do with the way societal expectations have evolved.

That is hardly the same thing as me claiming that biology is responsible for everything! Christ on a bike.

Yeah, that poster didn’t say that either.

But great. We’re all on the same page as gender as a social construct that is not innately biological. That means women are not necessarily biologically, or innately, more suitable or drawn to certain roles/preferences as was the contention waaaay back upthread when we started down this rabbit hole.

Societal conditioning plays a very significant role that is quite apart from innate female genetics.

SpinsForGin · 16/02/2022 08:31

Despite cultural differences between societies, now and through history, the vast majority of societies are essentially patriarchal at the core. It just manifests in different ways and to different degrees. It is unfortunate, but not a coincidence.

And you think this is due to biology?

Then what hope is there? Why bother fighting for equality if, due to biology, patriarchy will win?

oblada · 16/02/2022 08:30

@CupOfNiceTea

So all these modern women who aren’t passive willows or whatever, all also kept they’re last name and of cource children also has the woman’s last name? They must have surely, why would they want rigid gendered stereotypes? Loose their name, why, because the have a vagina?
We chose to change my surname and give the kids my husbands name. what is key though is that we could have decided to do it differently. Personally i don't mind the whole patriarchal name because I recognise men didn't give birth and it makes sense to me that they will take longer to adjust to the realities of being a parent and feeling that child belongs to them as they do not go through the physical process. So in that respect i don't mind giving the kids his name and helping that process along. I didn't feel like I needed to give my kids my father's name over their own father's so that worked for us. And for me it is was just easier for the family unit to have the same name. Again personal preference. I dont particularly like double barreled name as it just makes thing a bit difficult (nothing wrong with it i am just not keen). My kids already have long-ish first and middle names so that was enough for us.
cheekyasfish · 16/02/2022 08:28

I know somebody who booked a venue, chose a ring )prob paid for it too), organised invitations then arranged a night out and instructed him to
Propose

They got married. Take control ladies

MangshorJhol · 16/02/2022 08:25

I will point out that as I said the kids have my last name as a middle name, my last name is ALSO patriarchal. It’s my dad’s last name not my mother’s. Weirdly and coincidentally my mother’s maiden name and DH’s last name is the same. (We are not white British).

In my work place I don’t actually know a single woman (admittedly I am in a academic department) who changed her last name. There are a couple of older women with double barrelled names. In my social circle it is certainly far more unusual to change your last name than it is not.

SnakeLinguine · 16/02/2022 08:22

@SoLoveless2022, I’m not the poster you asked, but as another person who got married after a conversation, no, I never considered changing my name, which I think is a ridiculous, reactionary idea, yes, we have a child, and he has both our surnames. (As do about half his class, judging by his class list.)

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 08:20

Yes I agree that sex and gender are different things. Where we differ (and will have to agree to disagree), is that historically, I don’t believe gender and sex have always necessarily been fundamentally discrete entities.

Despite cultural differences between societies, now and through history, the vast majority of societies are essentially patriarchal at the core. It just manifests in different ways and to different degrees. It is unfortunate, but not a coincidence.

That’s not me saying it should be this way. I’m just saying what I see.

OP posts:
CupOfNiceTea · 16/02/2022 08:15

So all these modern women who aren’t passive willows or whatever, all also kept they’re last name and of cource children also has the woman’s last name?
They must have surely, why would they want rigid gendered stereotypes?
Loose their name, why, because the have a vagina?

SpinsForGin · 16/02/2022 08:05

@alfayruz

Ffs. Someone makes the assertion “gender is purely a social construct, it has nothing to do with biology.’

I say that I believe it’s not as clear cut as that and that SOME (SOME!!!) gendered behaviours will have been somewhat indirectly affected / shaped / engendered by biological differences between men and women (I cited hormone differences and the fact women’s experience of childbirth differs that men’s).

Then - naturally in MN - this is twisted and apparently I am arguing that EVERYHING is down to biology Confused

People then feel the need to go into an explanation that “Social constructs are affected by more than biology.’ Well, no shit Sherlock! Who would have guessed it?

This place is mental.

Your arguments yesterday did read as though you believed everything was down to biology......🤷🏼‍♀️

However, gender is a social construct. It is sociological as opposed to biological. The characteristics associated with a specific gender vary between societies and cultures and change over time which makes it difficult to say it's down to biology.

That isn't ignoring the biological sex differences between men and women but sex and gender are two different things.

AlexaShutUp · 16/02/2022 08:03

@GrendelsGrandma

Eh? DH and I didn't really do any kind of proposal, we got together, spoke about whether to have kids, then once we decided we wanted them, we discussed whether marriage was sensible.

Plenty of romance in other areas of our relationship but marriage is about as sexy as taking out insurance for me!

The whole romance sweep you off your feet thing is daft. Marriage is a legal arrangement about the allocation of property. And you get to have a party if you want.

Perhaps people's perceptions of marriage are at the heart of the proposal thing?

Those who are focused primarily on the wedding might see a grand proposal as an essential element of the whole performance.

Those who are focused primarily on the marriage as a legal agreement between two people might be more likely to just sit down and have a pragmatic discussion about it.

GrendelsGrandma · 16/02/2022 07:59

Eh? DH and I didn't really do any kind of proposal, we got together, spoke about whether to have kids, then once we decided we wanted them, we discussed whether marriage was sensible.

Plenty of romance in other areas of our relationship but marriage is about as sexy as taking out insurance for me!

The whole romance sweep you off your feet thing is daft. Marriage is a legal arrangement about the allocation of property. And you get to have a party if you want.

MangshorJhol · 16/02/2022 07:56

Also didn’t take my husband’s last name.
He didn’t take mine either.

I have a VERY hard to pronounce name AND last name. My last name is hard for people of my cultural background to pronounce let alone others. So their names have my surname as a ‘middle’ name. DH’s surname is very easy to pronounce. My life would be much much easier if I had changed my last name! Then I would have just an unpronounceable first name…

Swipe left for the next trending thread