Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MN has it all wrong re proposals?

691 replies

alfayruz · 13/02/2022 20:12

Inspired by a thread the other day, but also a general observation on here, I was thinking ... whenever anyone posts on MN about waiting for a proposal from their DP, you can guarantee hundreds of posts along the lines of ‘just propose to him....’ AIBU to think this is ridiculous because -

  1. Nobody in actual real life does this

  2. Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

  3. Even if you could still muster some kind of sexual attraction towards him, the bar is set at rock bottom before you even start - so why would you expect any initiative or effort from him on any other occasions or general life going forward?

AIBU?

OP posts:
youvegottenminuteslynn · 16/02/2022 17:16

My other daughter, same house, same socialisation, could take or leave the sparkly princess stuff. She was more into animals from the off

You're doing that weird thing again where you're making the same point as me but presenting it defensively as if you disagree...

I've specifically said that some people will naturally have preferences that simply happen to tally with gender stereotypes and that others won't.

The fact some people tally with gender stereotypes doesn't mean that those stereotypes are due to them having either a vagina or penis, it's down to individual preferences.

It just happens that on top of individual preferences, some kids (not your daughter) will also be influenced by societal expectations to conform to gender stereotypes too. Which then means there are usually a larger number of girls 'into' pink and sparkly than not up to a certain age, because the group includes those who would have been into it anyway plus those who if they were born on a desert island that happened to have no gender stereotypes would have been meh about it but were born in a place where they see particular gender stereotypes aka pink = girly.

Your daughter didn't gravitate towards pink and sparkly because she happened to be born with a vagina. Your other daughter is proof that that isn't what happens.

You're literally making the same point as me but dressing it up as an opposing opinion for a reason I can't get my head around.

She has always been stereotypically feminine but it’s hardly held her back in life.

Again with the odd defensiveness, nobody has said your daughter liking pink will hold her back in life.

You sound so keen to argue!

cuno · 16/02/2022 17:16

@alfayruz

Why do you keep going on about race? If you want a response, at least try keeping it vaguely relevant. You don’t sound with it.
I'm not the only poster who asked you about race. You were claiming all social constructs including patriarchy is down to biology, so naturally people asked about race and you carefully ignored that besides "what's that got to do with male and female biology". You're the one that's been jumping from one bizarre tangent to another, but I'm the one not keeping things vaguely relevant? And I'm far more with it than anyone who believes a girl can be born with an innate interest in pink, sparkles and princesses and boys can be born with an innate interest in karate and rugby. I felt so exasperated by the stupidity of it all! And please remember the things you have said about men and women on here who don't adhere to your idea of a traditional proposal. But you clutch your pearls at someone calling you an idiot. Do you prescribe to #BeKind only when it suits you?
SpinsForGin · 16/02/2022 17:08

@alfayruz

“But it's not just about TV!! Literally the way people speak to baby girls is different to how they speak to baby boys.”

Oh sure. But why was my other daughter not like that though? Same parents. Same environment.

Because were not saying that individual preferences don't exist. Of course they do .....

But your example actually argues against biology being the main determining factor because if that were the case, wouldn't you daughters have the exact same interests?

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 17:04

“But it's not just about TV!! Literally the way people speak to baby girls is different to how they speak to baby boys.”

Oh sure. But why was my other daughter not like that though? Same parents. Same environment.

OP posts:
SpinsForGin · 16/02/2022 17:02

@alfayruz

Spins - I know what you’re saying. I understand. But with this daughter it was quite marked and, as I say, she didn’t have that stuff in the house and they don’t watch TV at age 1!
But it's not just about TV!! Literally the way people speak to baby girls is different to how they speak to baby boys.
SpinsForGin · 16/02/2022 17:02

@alfayruz

Spins - I know what you’re saying. I understand. But with this daughter it was quite marked and, as I say, she didn’t have that stuff in the house and they don’t watch TV at age 1!
But it's not just about TV!! Literally the way people speak to baby girls is different to how they speak to baby boys.
alfayruz · 16/02/2022 17:00

Why do you keep going on about race? If you want a response, at least try keeping it vaguely relevant. You don’t sound with it.

OP posts:
alfayruz · 16/02/2022 16:57

Spins - I know what you’re saying. I understand. But with this daughter it was quite marked and, as I say, she didn’t have that stuff in the house and they don’t watch TV at age 1!

OP posts:
SpinsForGin · 16/02/2022 16:55

I'd highly recommend reading 'The Gendered Brain' and 'Invisible Women' if you want further insight into the impact of societal expectations and stereotypes.

cuno · 16/02/2022 16:54

Rich coming from the woman who started a thread to bash people. Hmm
I've added plenty constructive but you are very selective with what you respond to. Never quite answered the question about race, for example.

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 16:52

You have nothing constructive to add to this thread cuno and you just sound horrible.

OP posts:
cuno · 16/02/2022 16:49

And don't be dramatic, I called you an idiot not a cunt.

SpinsForGin · 16/02/2022 16:48

@alfayruz

Ok, so we have 4 children. 2 girls and 2 boys.

The elder girl was obsessed with princesses, fairies, ballet and anything sparky (particularly shoes) since she could express a preference. I didn’t have that stuff in the house. We’d be in the shopping mall and she’d toddle off into the shoe shop for pink sparkly shoes. Wouldn’t wear trousers. It’s too simplistic to say that was gender expectations and socialisation at the age of one. She has always been stereotypically feminine but it’s hardly held her back in life.

My other daughter, same house, same socialisation, could take or leave the sparkly princess stuff. She was more into animals from the off.

With the boys, the elder one would occupy himself with pretty much anything. He prefers solo activities like karate.

The younger one was something else and if he doesn’t have a lot of physical activity, he’s too much. As a baby, the way he played was totally different as everything he used to bang together snd every game was a battle. I took him to a psychologist once but she just said he’s fine. He did calm down fortunately. He’s into rugby and football and he needs that kind of contact sport to cope. In this way, he is like his dad, I think.

So they are 4 very different children. The very stereotypically ‘girly’ daughter literally ‘came out’ like that as far as I’m concerned. So no, I don’t believe gendered behaviour are always and only down to socialisation. The evidence is here in this house! Some people naturally conform to gender types than others. It’s just who they are as individuals.

It's also far too simplistic to say 'they just came out that way'. You have 4 individuals who are are a product of their genetic make up with a heavy dose of socialisation thrown in there. Of course they will display individual preferences but you are kidding yourself if you think it's just 'Nature'.

Children are literally bombarded with messages about what it means to be a girl or a boy from the second they are born. You can't avoid it no matter how hard you try. Even the way people treat boys and girls and the language they use when talking about them is gendered - often in a subconscious level.

You might make a huge effort , as we did, to avoid this in our house but if they are interacting with the wider world these messages are unavoidable.

These messages tell us how society expects us to behave and that in turn has an impact on EVERYTHING. My particular specialism is career development..... from a very young age we can see societal expectations in relation to gender influencing career and education choices.

cuno · 16/02/2022 16:47

Is it unladylike to swear?

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 16:46

cuno - nobody else is swearing on here. Did you notice that?

OP posts:
cuno · 16/02/2022 16:45

Well it was such a tremendously idiotic thing to say. Again, what do you expect?

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 16:45

Oh I see we’ve now moved onto names...,

To Jassy’s question - ‘when does a woman get to call a name her own?’ I think about it like this -

A distinction needs to be made between ‘owning’ and ‘origin.’

In terms of ‘origin,’ your name will be equally patriarchal whether you took it from your dad (by default, no choice at birth), or your husband (choice on marriage). If your name came from your mother, then you do not have a patriarchal name.

But in terms of ‘owning’ a name, of course any name you go by is YOUR name. It has to be. Make one up, take your husband’s, stay with the one you inherited from your father (or mother) - your name is what you go by.

OP posts:
cuno · 16/02/2022 16:41

Tbh you have really shown your attitudes on here about gender roles and stereotypes, so it's unsurprising your children picked them up from you.

cuno · 16/02/2022 16:39

Oh my god, you are a fucking idiot if you think your daughter was born into pink, sparkles and princesses. What a bizarre post! Confused

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 16:34

Ok, so we have 4 children. 2 girls and 2 boys.

The elder girl was obsessed with princesses, fairies, ballet and anything sparky (particularly shoes) since she could express a preference. I didn’t have that stuff in the house. We’d be in the shopping mall and she’d toddle off into the shoe shop for pink sparkly shoes. Wouldn’t wear trousers. It’s too simplistic to say that was gender expectations and socialisation at the age of one. She has always been stereotypically feminine but it’s hardly held her back in life.

My other daughter, same house, same socialisation, could take or leave the sparkly princess stuff. She was more into animals from the off.

With the boys, the elder one would occupy himself with pretty much anything. He prefers solo activities like karate.

The younger one was something else and if he doesn’t have a lot of physical activity, he’s too much. As a baby, the way he played was totally different as everything he used to bang together snd every game was a battle. I took him to a psychologist once but she just said he’s fine. He did calm down fortunately. He’s into rugby and football and he needs that kind of contact sport to cope. In this way, he is like his dad, I think.

So they are 4 very different children. The very stereotypically ‘girly’ daughter literally ‘came out’ like that as far as I’m concerned. So no, I don’t believe gendered behaviour are always and only down to socialisation. The evidence is here in this house! Some people naturally conform to gender types than others. It’s just who they are as individuals.

OP posts:
oblada · 16/02/2022 16:29

@MarieIVanArkleStinks

I have absolutely no issue with women deciding to keep 'their' name.

Then why the scare quotes? It is theirs.

It's a matter of perception. I see my maiden name as my father's name and my husband's name as mine actually. Everyone will have a different perception. The quotes were just stylistic, not meant to direct that a particular perception was more valid than another.
SnakeLinguine · 16/02/2022 16:26

@MarieIVanArkleStinks

I have absolutely no issue with women deciding to keep 'their' name.

Then why the scare quotes? It is theirs.

Oh, of course it’s really their father’s name, though, curiously, the people who make this point with a ‘gotcha!’ air on here never feel their DH’s name is really their FIL’s.
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/02/2022 16:18

I have absolutely no issue with women deciding to keep 'their' name.

Then why the scare quotes? It is theirs.

cuno · 16/02/2022 16:16

That wasn't meant to say sexually unfuckable, just unfuckable!

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/02/2022 16:15

But I’m serious: when does a woman get to say ‘this is my name?

I share your frustration and suspect we would both respond to that question: Me. Now. I’m frequently addressed as Mrs Hisname when I’m Mrs no one and have my own name, but wishing this were so doesn’t make it the case. My family name isn’t on loan to me any more than my brother’s is. It was bestowed upon me from birth and it denotes my blood ties, my connections, my history and my roots, for better or worse (and yes, it was often worse). But it’s mine.

I laugh particularly at two objections to this: one that it’s a choice between your father’s or father-in-law’s name so you’re shackled to the patriarchy regardless. Untrue. Your father-in-law’s name signifies a childhood, history and formative years that isn’t yours. Why would I shelve a name I’ve used for life to take on an alternative history.

The other is the bizarre objection ‘I’m still me, a name has nothing to do with identity!’ Of course it does. How else is a person identified if not by their name? It’s fundamental to you, even if you don’t particularly like it. Otherwise why do people guard it so jealously and get pissed off when someone misspells it or gets it wrong? By that logic, you could address me as Engelbert Humperdinck and wouldn’t turn a hair.

Incidentally, men are never the ones who try to put me back in my box for not relinquishing my own identity because I’ve chosen to commit to one partner for life.