Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MN has it all wrong re proposals?

691 replies

alfayruz · 13/02/2022 20:12

Inspired by a thread the other day, but also a general observation on here, I was thinking ... whenever anyone posts on MN about waiting for a proposal from their DP, you can guarantee hundreds of posts along the lines of ‘just propose to him....’ AIBU to think this is ridiculous because -

  1. Nobody in actual real life does this

  2. Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

  3. Even if you could still muster some kind of sexual attraction towards him, the bar is set at rock bottom before you even start - so why would you expect any initiative or effort from him on any other occasions or general life going forward?

AIBU?

OP posts:
cuno · 16/02/2022 21:25

*what AIBU is

cuno · 16/02/2022 21:25

And tbh you're the one who doesn't seem to understand what AIBU. You've basically been told you're unreasonable and yet here you are still clutching at straws to defend yourself.

cuno · 16/02/2022 21:24

I didn't call you the taliban! Oh my god. Are you for real???
And yeah, keep lying about what I have and haven't grasped if it makes you feel better. But I have said a lot on here, seems that you failed to grasp what I've said if that's all you seem to understand from what I said.

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 21:17

This is AIBU. You state an opinion or view and ask AIBU? That’s the whole point.

Don’t call me a liar. It’s not my fault you’re unable to grasp anything more than ‘But you said biology.’ ‘You are the Taliban.’ “I call you an idiot, not a c*.’

I don’t even know why I’m bothering.

OP posts:
Shuffletime · 16/02/2022 21:13

@alfayruz

Yes I totally agree scottishnames. We have relatives who had arranged marriages in the previous generation and even some of DH’s cousins on our generation have had marriages that if not arranged, were kind of orchestrated (the men still has to propose though). These are doctors, lawyers etc. This is within a broadly Islamic cultural context.

So many of your family have had these discussions about marriage, whether arranged or orchestrated (which is just the conversation with a cup of tea only includes other family members, not just the couple themselves) and you still can't see it?

SpinsForGin · 16/02/2022 21:11

But yes, my daughter was very drawn to stereotypically feminine things as soon as she could express interest in anything. I don’t think it’s because of her biology! I was actually asking what people think caused that? Because although I don’t deny socialisation would have been a large part of it, I still don’t think that’s the whole story.

But this isn't what you said.

cuno · 16/02/2022 21:09

But you have lied multiple times on this thread about things you have said and not said. I am not the only one who has pointed this out.
And you started this thread to bash women (and men) that don't conform to what you idea of a perfect proposal is.
You are incredibly defensive over everything people are saying.
And yet you get on your high horse about respectful, nuanced debate.
😂

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 21:04

Are you capable of respectful, nuanced debate in any aspect of life cuno?

I doubt it. Goodbye.

OP posts:
cuno · 16/02/2022 21:01

The one missing the point here is you OP.

cuno · 16/02/2022 21:01

I'm only rude and obnoxious because the truth hurts. 🤷‍♀️
I am right though.

tigger1001 · 16/02/2022 21:00

Pink is just a colour. Is it possible she just likes it as a colour?

Interestingly it's only since since the 1940/1950's that pink has been considered a "girls" colour and previously pink was seen as a masculine colour. Shows the power of advertising.

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 20:58

Yes she did come out like that, pretty much.

But it wasn’t because if biology.

Did I say that?

Rude, obnoxious and wrong again, cuno. You have missed the point since you came on.

OP posts:
cuno · 16/02/2022 20:55

You can't explain it because you can't keep up with your own web of lies!

cuno · 16/02/2022 20:55

Was it not you who said the exact following earlier:
The very stereotypically ‘girly’ daughter literally ‘came out’ like that as far as I’m concerned. So no, I don’t believe gendered behaviour are always and only down to socialisation. The evidence is here in this house! Some people naturally conform to gender types than others.

Stop insulting our intelligence by lying about things that we can see with our own eyes.

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 20:44

I don’t think her liking pink is biological. I’m getting exhausted with this now.,

I used the word ‘biology’ in a spin-off discussion. I stated that the biological fact that women are the childbearing sex will have had an impact on how the social construct of gender has evolved in the ways it has - over time and across cultures in multifarious complex ways.

Can you please try and understand that this is not the same thing as saying ‘girls like pink because biology.’ ‘Men propose because biology.’ I’m getting very tired of being asked to justify something I never even argued!

But yes, my daughter was very drawn to stereotypically feminine things as soon as she could express interest in anything. I don’t think it’s because of her biology! I was actually asking what people think caused that? Because although I don’t deny socialisation would have been a large part of it, I still don’t think that’s the whole story.

I can’t explain all this again.

OP posts:
Qwill · 16/02/2022 20:22

I still don’t understand how the OP thinks her daughter liking the colour pink is biological and therefore proves her confused notions of gender and biology? She could like any colour, but the gender stereotypes we have makes pink a ‘girl’ colour. So in essence you are fitting the stereotype to your child’s preference. It’s like saying my daughter likes the colour black, so biologically she must be a goth.

SpinsForGin · 16/02/2022 20:20

Yes, socialisation will affect anyone, but it’s impossible to quantify the extent of this. You can’t second-guess yourself on everything. So you might as well just be honest about how you feel and get on with it.

But there is lots of research on this topic. Those of us who teach and research this aren't just pulling these ideas out of thin air.

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 20:06

Yes I totally agree scottishnames. We have relatives who had arranged marriages in the previous generation and even some of DH’s cousins on our generation have had marriages that if not arranged, were kind of orchestrated (the men still has to propose though). These are doctors, lawyers etc. This is within a broadly Islamic cultural context.

OP posts:
scottishnames · 16/02/2022 19:56

Sorry - but from an historical perspective, this whole debate does not really tie in with reality for the past 2000 years and more.

For most of that time - WHATEVER biology said - marriages were arranged by parents or agreed among couples - some very different from what we'd expect today - to benefit family fortunes/connections, or as a matter of convenience or sheer survival. Or - as in witty but cynical Jane Austen - as a matter of social and/or financial advancement.

Proposals based on sexual attractiveness were simply not the thing for many - maybe most - couples. That's really rather the point. Marriage and romantic love/sexual attraction were not co-terminous. That difference between the two is quite probably how the concept of 'romantic love' was created, by poets/songwriters/other literary folk in the Middle Ages, with 'courtly' suitors sighing after their (already married) would-be lovers. It was 'rediscovered' by late Georgian/Victorian novelists etc, and publicised by the wedding industry in the 20th cent. But for a great many people, it was never their real-life experience, any more than glossy adverts or Instragam scenes are 'real' today.

As other posters have said, among poor/ordinary people, men did promise marriage as a way of getting into bed with women they fancied. But even in the Middle Ages, people knew not to take such promises seriously. Public shaming and punishment for 'immorality' were quite damaging; 'shotgun marriages' were definitely a thing. It's been shown (case studies, SW England) that in over one-third of 'poor' rural peoples' marriages, the bride was pregnant. Being pressuried into a marriage to save face/escape punishment is not very "romantic" either.

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 19:55

I wasn’t talking about the proposing thing in and of itself. Sorry I should have made that clear. Of course its ridiculously simplistic to talk about ‘biology’ in relation to a specific act such as proposing. That wouldn’t be how I would respond to what I think you’re getting at. I would say that people don’t choose who are what they are attracted to - behaviours, physical aspects or whatever. Sexuality is innate. Yes, socialisation will affect anyone, but it’s impossible to quantify the extent of this. You can’t second-guess yourself on everything. So you might as well just be honest about how you feel and get on with it.

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 16/02/2022 19:32

Our responses to a specific, fairly recently manufactured social construct are biological? It’s a massively implausible argument.

We all feel how we feel. Just because our feelings are deep doesn’t mean they’re driven by biology. It’s such an odd contention. Why don’t you think the impact of socialisation on our feelings is somehow less than the impact of biology on those feelings?

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 19:19

I feel how I feel Jassy. You don’t choose who or what you’re attracted to. You will of course tell me that it’s affected by socialisation (and I certainly wouldn’t disagree with that), but I still think there are some innate drives that run deeper than socialisation. That is where we differ, I guess. But that’s ok. I have lived a life. I know myself and that’s it really. You can draw you own conclusions.

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 16/02/2022 19:11

(I’ll admit that it took me a while to realise that some of your statements were based on a fundamental misunderstanding of Spins’ post. I think we’re all a lot closer to consensus than it seemed at the lowest points of the thread.)

JassyRadlett · 16/02/2022 19:09

Jassy - you keep giving these really obvious, rigid explanations ad infinitum without actually understanding what it is I’m saying. It’s like you’ve assumed a position for me and are using it to argue with yourself.

I do understand what you’re saying, I think the difference is that I also understand what other posters are saying, and therefore I can see how you’re misrepresenting them.

Its that fundamental misunderstanding that has taken us down this bizarre and wonderful rabbit hole.

But anyway: men who are proposed to are unshaggable, eh? I think we all now agree that the (bizarre) lack of attraction is based on socialisation rather than biology? Please?

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 19:03

Jassy - you keep giving these really obvious, rigid explanations ad infinitum without actually understanding what it is I’m saying. It’s like you’ve assumed a position for me and are using it to argue with yourself.

OP posts: