Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MN has it all wrong re proposals?

691 replies

alfayruz · 13/02/2022 20:12

Inspired by a thread the other day, but also a general observation on here, I was thinking ... whenever anyone posts on MN about waiting for a proposal from their DP, you can guarantee hundreds of posts along the lines of ‘just propose to him....’ AIBU to think this is ridiculous because -

  1. Nobody in actual real life does this

  2. Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

  3. Even if you could still muster some kind of sexual attraction towards him, the bar is set at rock bottom before you even start - so why would you expect any initiative or effort from him on any other occasions or general life going forward?

AIBU?

OP posts:
HelloFrostyMorning · 14/02/2022 00:18

DH never proposed to me - and I used to feel a wee bit sad about that. But I don't now, because I think a classic movie-type-proposal rarely happens.....

I know 3 couples right now, who got engaged in the past 6 months, and all 3 women claim their man 'proposed.' I don't believe a word of it. I know all 3 men and they would NOT have proposed. Especially as 2 of them have not been keen on the idea of marriage -ever... I genuinely believe men getting down on one knee - and proposing -rarely happens now.

Me and DH met in 1983, and moved in together in 1985, and married in 1988.

In 1987, he said 'you wanna get engaged?' I said 'yeah OK then!' All my friends and cousins and neighbours were engaged or married already, so I was chuffed he asked. It wasn't really the 'done thing' in my (working class) social circle to ask a man.

Then about a year later, (early 1988,) I said 'when shall we get married then?' He said 'whenever you want to... Just book wherever you want, and let me know when it is.'

Sounds batshit now, but that is how it was, and he never asked for my hand in marriage from my dad (yuk) and my dad didn't care.

I don't believe most men 'propose' these days, and it's a thing from rom-coms mostly.

I find the whole 'going down on bended knee' thing so fucking cringey now... Who DOES that?

OllyBJolly · 14/02/2022 00:17

@Campfirewood

95% of marriages have started with the man proposing. All graduates, all professionals, all fairly assertive capable woman.
Do you have scientific evidence of that, @Campfirewood? I very much doubt it - especially as cross-sectional as you quote!
LuckySnips · 13/02/2022 23:57

Nothing against the man proposing - that's what happened with me too. Just was sooner than I expected, but both were fairly certain we were going to end up getting married!

Anyone remember Jerry Springer talking about proposals? He wisely said that a proposal shouldn't be a surprise to either party.

Campfirewood · 13/02/2022 23:55

@LuckySnips I agree there was little commandeering but I was quite surprised (in a good way) by my proposal as were a few of my friends.
None of us desperately waiting out of pathetically clinging on to old school man, all professional assertive feminists.
We didn’t take umbrage or get mad.

LuckySnips · 13/02/2022 23:48

@Campfirewood

95% of marriages have started with the man proposing. All graduates, all professionals, all fairly assertive capable woman.
Love the idea that's how a marriage works. Man pops up, proposes, and the women just have to go along with it Grin

(kidding obvs - just pointing out that maybe the start of the marriage isn't actually the man asking, it's the relationship forming and developing to the extent that both parties actively consider spending the rest of their lives with each other...)

lightisnotwhite · 13/02/2022 23:46

@AlexaShutUp of course women should say if they want to be married. But so should men.
And if a man says he wants to marry you then he needs to actually do it. No proposal required from either party You can just do it.

Campfirewood · 13/02/2022 23:46

95% of marriages have started with the man proposing. All graduates, all professionals, all fairly assertive capable woman.

lightisnotwhite · 13/02/2022 23:42

@Gynaesaur Well yes.
Unfortunately women tend to be the ones most hurt in the sexual, cohabitation, children situations.

Take having children. I mean why would any man not think he should offer the woman he’d impregnated the legal and financial benefits of marriage? She’s got to do the life/ body changing 9 months risking her health. She’s more than likely got to have some time out of her career even if it’s just a few weeks. Even if she turned his proposal down for whatever reason. Why would a man not ask?

AlexaShutUp · 13/02/2022 23:34

It would have 100% killed my attraction to DH if he had subscribed to the view that a woman should patiently wait for a man to do her the honour of asking them to marry him instead of just saying what she wants.

Indeed, I would only have married someone with a more egalitarian approach to relationships. The kind of person who is capable of mature conversations where both people communicate openly and honestly about what is important to them.

I find men who buy into the old sexist traditions so offputting.

Gynaesaur · 13/02/2022 23:25

No but men haven’t changed that much. They will quite happily live with you, have sex with you and have kids with you. Often without the “grown up discussion”. Often just wine. Committing to something that gives you more should you split up is less readily given. Certainly less than any of those other scenarios.

There are various legal and financial benefits to marriage that aren't apparent with sex, cohabitation or having children. To my knowledge, none of them are dependent on the man being the one to propose.

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 13/02/2022 23:22

I do sometimes wonder if I'm 'womaning' wrong because I just have no patience at all for trying to guess and influence DH into doing things.

We got together when I was 16, we'd had loads of conversations about our future and what we wanted in life before we go married, but getting married was very much a chat one day about how we'd been together a while and would be wanting kids soonish, so should probably get married soon, yeah we both said. Neither of us wanted a wedding really, we wanted a marriage, so we went online and booked a holiday to Vegas and spent 30 minutes on the chapel website picking options from drop down menus.

No proposals involved, don't have an engagement ring or a wedding ring for that matter. I got a cheapie ring for the service because I had to have something and he used one that he already had.

Seems to work for us, we've been together 22 years so far, married 16.

lightisnotwhite · 13/02/2022 23:13

@ChocolateButtonsOfShame

Gosh. I proposed to mine. I asked because I love him and he's a brilliant partner. I don't doubt his commitment just because I was the one to propose. We're getting married in a couple of months. He's going to take my name. Our son already has my name, so we'll all be the same 🙂

My brother is also marrying this year, his fiancé proposed too.

Great. Why didn’t he propose to you out of interest?
YesILikeItToo · 13/02/2022 23:10

Well, having proposed myself, I’d say 1 is untrue, 2 is a matter of personal preference, but 3 might be food for thought.

TheSmallClangerWhistlesAgain · 13/02/2022 23:04

Most couples I know had a conversation about their future, which ended with the man proposing in a semi-traditional way with a ring or token of some sort. Normally this took place at home or somewhere familiar. DH and I did it the same way, in bed one night, and DH gave me one of his own rings.

Unless you are my brother, who apparently took all his clothes off before getting down on one knee behind a bathroom door, waiting for SIL to exit.

housemaus · 13/02/2022 22:41

@alfayruz

Inspired by a thread the other day, but also a general observation on here, I was thinking ... whenever anyone posts on MN about waiting for a proposal from their DP, you can guarantee hundreds of posts along the lines of ‘just propose to him....’ AIBU to think this is ridiculous because -
  1. Nobody in actual real life does this

  2. Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

  3. Even if you could still muster some kind of sexual attraction towards him, the bar is set at rock bottom before you even start - so why would you expect any initiative or effort from him on any other occasions or general life going forward?

AIBU?

  1. Yes they do? I know several people who've done this.
  1. To you maybe - but that suggests a pretty strong attachment to traditional gender roles where the man leads the way in your life and you just accept the 'initiative and effort' from him, without making any of your own. That's not for everyone.

Personally, I don't think that's especially sexually attractive and therefore would have had no issue proposing to DH. As it is, we're one of those apparently annoying couples who just agreed to get married... weirdly, DH manages to show plenty of effort and initiative in our relationship, so thankfully we've managed to struggle along despite the lack of formal, asking-for-my-hand-in-marriage Wink

Porcupineintherough · 13/02/2022 22:34

Erm women do propose and the rest of your post is too stupid to bother with.

ChocolateButtonsOfShame · 13/02/2022 22:29

Gosh. I proposed to mine. I asked because I love him and he's a brilliant partner. I don't doubt his commitment just because I was the one to propose. We're getting married in a couple of months. He's going to take my name. Our son already has my name, so we'll all be the same 🙂

My brother is also marrying this year, his fiancé proposed too.

lightisnotwhite · 13/02/2022 22:26

@Ifailed

is this the 1950s?
No but men haven’t changed that much. They will quite happily live with you, have sex with you and have kids with you. Often without the “grown up discussion”. Often just wine. Committing to something that gives you more should you split up is less readily given. Certainly less than any of those other scenarios.
BobMortimersTrout · 13/02/2022 22:18

@alfayruz

Inspired by a thread the other day, but also a general observation on here, I was thinking ... whenever anyone posts on MN about waiting for a proposal from their DP, you can guarantee hundreds of posts along the lines of ‘just propose to him....’ AIBU to think this is ridiculous because -
  1. Nobody in actual real life does this

  2. Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

  3. Even if you could still muster some kind of sexual attraction towards him, the bar is set at rock bottom before you even start - so why would you expect any initiative or effort from him on any other occasions or general life going forward?

AIBU?

🤣 I proposed to my husband. Why on Earth would it be a turn off?!?
CaptainCallisto · 13/02/2022 22:18

DH and had discussed it in general terms, and knew it was something we both wanted. He had planned to propose on our holiday, but I somewhat scuppered his plans. He was so obviously nervous and hiding something the night before we went away that I thought he was planning to break up with me. I was stressed, tired, and hormonal and got really upset; he was stressed, tired, and completely confused. Our proposal kind of went: "For fuck's sake, woman, I've bought a ring!" "Oh" "Now can we get some sleep?" "Yes, sorry".

I'm actually really glad it happened that way - it felt really natural and like he really just wanted to be with me. There was nothing performative about it. For some people the big proposal would be exactly what they wanted, but having already established that we wanted to get married, it would have felt a bit fake. DH always says he's glad he didn't have to do it!

DelurkingAJ · 13/02/2022 22:15

This is up there with ‘you can’t have sex with a man until the 14th date’ type rule. Bonkers in my view…and DH did propose but only after we’d had a conversation where I’d said ‘if this isn’t going end in marriage fairly soon I’m out’ or words to that effect. He said afterwards that he’d just assumed we’d get married sometime and simply hadn’t done the maths I had about the time from proposal to wedding (much overseas family who would want to be there) to children and therefore the possible need to get a wiggle on!

All this shows is that we’re all different. I once dated a chap who bought me flowers when we’d been going out for a month for our ‘anniversary’. I was utterly nonplussed, he thought I’d be furious if he hadn’t. I’m clearly not a romantic.

hugr · 13/02/2022 22:14

I think it's more that a poster will complain that they are waiting. If you want to be proposed to, sadly you have to wait. If you want to get married, ask your partner.

gingerhills · 13/02/2022 22:11

I was planning on proposing to DH. After a few months it was clear he was the one. The following year was leap year and I thought, feck it, I'll propose on 29th Feb. But he beat me to it by several months.

CatherinedeBourgh · 13/02/2022 22:10

We just talked about it. When we both agreed that yes, we would get married, he said kwell when, shall we set a date?’, we discussed our diaries for a bit and agreed.

I guess he could then have gone out and bought an engagement ring and proposed, but I didn’t want aring and it would have felt a bit silly.

Thewindwhispers · 13/02/2022 22:10

Yanbu. I think it’s a bit silly where the couple have discussed marriage and agree they want to marry but both are waiting for the man to do some elaborate proposal ceremony. That imo is ott and weird.

But, I (and most people) live in a culture where it’s traditional that the man propose. So when you’re in love, and have been living together for a couple of years, and you’ve discussed wanting to start a family soon, yet the man says nothing about marriage, and the months pass and it gets awkward… In that situation it is not at all romantic for the woman to ‘propose’. By choosing not to, and missing his cue, the man has already made a kind of statement. If he wanted to be married, he’d have asked.

It’s like saying “if someone doesn’t invite you to go with them, just go alone and see them there!” It isn’t the same…

Swipe left for the next trending thread