Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MN has it all wrong re proposals?

691 replies

alfayruz · 13/02/2022 20:12

Inspired by a thread the other day, but also a general observation on here, I was thinking ... whenever anyone posts on MN about waiting for a proposal from their DP, you can guarantee hundreds of posts along the lines of ‘just propose to him....’ AIBU to think this is ridiculous because -

  1. Nobody in actual real life does this

  2. Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

  3. Even if you could still muster some kind of sexual attraction towards him, the bar is set at rock bottom before you even start - so why would you expect any initiative or effort from him on any other occasions or general life going forward?

AIBU?

OP posts:
AlexaShutUp · 14/02/2022 10:08

@alfayruz

‘Do you ever take him out for dinner?’

Well I’ve organised a few surprise things on various birthdays etc over the years, if that’s what you mean?

I don't really know what I mean, because in my relationship, my dh and I just go out for dinner. Neither of us "takes" the other and I am not really sure what is meant by it if I'm honest.
PeeAche · 14/02/2022 10:06

In the course of an ordinary conversation, my now-husband asked me if I'd ever consider marrying him. I said "of course!" 😍

6 months later, he cooked me lobster and proposed with a vintage Tiffany's engagement ring.

I said yes, we ate lobster and made sweet love on the floor in the sitting room.

Later on, someone on Mumsnet said that my ring was a waste of money and I'd never be able to sell it for its full amount when he inevitably leaves me.

Honestly, I don't even know why I still hang out with you guys! 😅

alfayruz · 14/02/2022 10:04

‘Do you ever take him out for dinner?’

Well I’ve organised a few surprise things on various birthdays etc over the years, if that’s what you mean?

OP posts:
alfayruz · 14/02/2022 10:02

No I don’t get him anything for Valentines because I know him and he genuinely doesn’t want ‘stuff’ for the sake of it. He just likes to go out for dinner and have a ‘date night’ if you can call it that.

OP posts:
AlexaShutUp · 14/02/2022 10:00

@alfayruz

I’m not bothered about Valentines by the way as it’s just commercial hype. But it’s nice to get flowers anytime. He’s taking me out tonight for dinner somewhere and he’s booked that. Why not?
Do you ever take him out for dinner?
AlexaShutUp · 14/02/2022 09:59

@alfayruz

You can have equality in a relationship and romance though. The two are not mutually exclusive! Why would anyone think they can’t?
Of course you can have both. I'm not saying that you can't. I'm just saying that romance is poor compensation for equality if you don't have both.

The vision of relationships that you're presenting seems to be all about romance without much emphasis on equality. Personally, I think it's possible to have romance without falling back into the tired old gender stereotypes perpetuated by the patriarchy.

Do you think it cannot be romantic if a woman proposes to a man?

SmellinOfTroy · 14/02/2022 09:58

Did you not get a gift for your husband/partner?

Mine bought me something I would like, and I bought him something he would like..... nothing patriarchal

I dont think that Cartier got the memo about men not being allowed diamond rings either,
www.cartier.com/en-gb/jewellery/collection-jewellery/rings

alfayruz · 14/02/2022 09:58

I’m not bothered about Valentines by the way as it’s just commercial hype. But it’s nice to get flowers anytime. He’s taking me out tonight for dinner somewhere and he’s booked that. Why not?

OP posts:
SarahJessicaPorker · 14/02/2022 09:57

I didn't do a big proposal like get down on one knee etc to my dh, but I did tell him there was no way I'd stay with him if we weren't getting engaged. He'd asked me to move to another country with him as he had a brilliant career opportunity. We were pretty young 24/25 or so and he honestly didn't appreciate why this would be an enormous risk for me to leave my career and family behind and trail after him to another country. I said not unless we're engaged, so we got engaged. Trotted off together to the jewellers and bought a beautiful ring that day, he even spoke to my dad before we did it, which was a bit traditionalist for me, but my dad liked it Hmm.

We're very happily married, 11 years now, with two dcs. I've not had to drag him through life. He's done really well in his career and I'm about to start retraining as a teacher, which has been my dream for ages.

Tbh, the couple we are, I'd have been more weirded out and turned off by a big, fancy proposal from either of us than I was by having a pretty sensible conversation about it. We are romantic in a different way and it works for us. I don't give a shiny shit if someone online or irl doesn't find our engagement cutesie enough for their standards.

Our wedding was pretty no nonsense as well and I looked fucking fantastic in my secondhand dress from ebay Grin. People irl were a bit judgey about me doing that, but again, meh

alfayruz · 14/02/2022 09:52

You can have equality in a relationship and romance though. The two are not mutually exclusive! Why would anyone think they can’t?

OP posts:
NoWordForFluffy · 14/02/2022 09:51

DH and I clearly have a relationship which is totally the opposite of the OP's:

I proposed;
DH gave up work to be a SAHD when the kids were young;
I earn about 3.5x the amount he does; and
Neither of us does Valentine's!

Neither of us are very traditional. 😁

alfayruz · 14/02/2022 09:49

Well obviously if women on here are saying they proposed to their DH - I hold my hands up and who am I to argue with their lived experience.

I have never met or heard of anyone doing this in real life though. And I don’t live in some sort of bubble - I live in London.

Nor have I ever known a friend express anxiety that she was ‘waiting around on tenterhooks’ for her DP to propose. The only thing resembling that I can think of, is one friend who came back from the Caribbean and told me she felt a bit weird because she thought her DP might have proposed while over there. But then he proposed the next week or something anyway, so no big deal.

OP posts:
AlexaShutUp · 14/02/2022 09:47

@alfayruz

Alexa, I think, in relationships, people ‘take the lead’ in different ways. Your husband proposing to you is hardly a reason to feel diminished as a woman. My husband gave me a diamond ring when he proposed - well, I could hardly give him a diamond ring could I? He’s just given me flowers this morning. Is the fact men tend to give women flowers or gifts today and not the other way round patriarchal as well? It’s ok to have differences and celebrate that and not worry about such things.
No, I would not be diminished as a woman if a man proposed to me, but do you think a man would be diminished if it happened the other way round? I wouldn't be interested in a man who felt like that personally.

If gifts are only given in one direction on Valentines day, I find that a bit weird. Most modern couples I know either give stuff to each other or don't bother at all because they think the whole thing is just commercial. For me, flowers and chocolates every now and then wouldn't really make up for treating me as a second class citizen the rest of the time, which is what I often observe. These rituals are a weird way of placating women while keeping them in their place.

Clearly, some women are quite happy to stay in their place and "not worry about such things". However, some of us don't feel that flowers and romance instead of equality is a particularly good bargain.

Drunkpanda · 14/02/2022 09:41

OP have you even accepted yet that your first point was wrong, as many woman have been the ones to propose?
I enjoyed planning my proposal to dh. No loss of attraction there! Maybe I just like to be in control of the big stuff in my life.

Lesperance · 14/02/2022 09:40

OP you obviously go for a certain type of alpha male, and that's fine. We're not all the same, and clearly some women propose to men, so you are wrong on that point.
Feeling a little sorry for your husband though, why don't you get him gifts? I don't think it's a "fact" at all that men get women gifts today and not the other way around.
And the 1950s thing, you know what they say, if the cap fits...

SmellinOfTroy · 14/02/2022 09:37

but its not attention from your partner, its so you can instagram how wonderful he is, and how he got doves to fly out at the exact moment you said yes, and how he magically knew what ring you wanted and size (because you had prepped your friends in advance) and how it was a huge surprise that you were expecting

Personally? I dont like it as its all about control. The film Bride Wars shows it quite well I think, Liv is desperate to be proposed to, and he knows and he waits and waits and all the time she's going crazy.

NoWordForFluffy · 14/02/2022 09:36

@alfayruz

I really don’t think you need to take everything so literally as ‘patriarchal shot’ though, Alexa. Some traditions persist because women like things like that. They expect a certain level of behaviour in a man. Otherwise, it’s like sucking all the joy and romance out of life? I’m not saying a proposal has to be a big social media - orientated affair. Not at all. That kind of thing didn’t even exist in the same way when my husband proposed. It’s nothing to do with anyone else.
Women are not an homogeneous mass. What 'women' like depends on the individual woman. Clearly you're quite fixed on rigid gender stereotypes. Others aren't.
alfayruz · 14/02/2022 09:35

Alexa, I think, in relationships, people ‘take the lead’ in different ways. Your husband proposing to you is hardly a reason to feel diminished as a woman. My husband gave me a diamond ring when he proposed - well, I could hardly give him a diamond ring could I? He’s just given me flowers this morning. Is the fact men tend to give women flowers or gifts today and not the other way round patriarchal as well? It’s ok to have differences and celebrate that and not worry about such things.

OP posts:
AmbushedByCake1 · 14/02/2022 09:34

My sister proposed to her now husband. So it definitely happens in the real world op.

Pyri · 14/02/2022 09:32

@ForTheLoveOfSleep

The fanfare around being proposed to is actually quite pathetic. 90% of people know its going to happen and even choose their own ring. So what's the point? Attention clearly.
What’s wrong with some attention from your partner?

The reverse snobbery on MN around proposals is tiring. You’re not better people with stronger relationships for deciding to get married and then no proposal.

steppemum · 14/02/2022 09:32

I do think all the suspense about will he/won't he propse is ridiculous.

If you don't know that you want to spend the rest of your lives together, you shouldn't discover that atthe moment he (or she) asks you to marry them.

dh and I knew we were at that point, and at the same time, having reached that point, he then chose a nice moment to propose, knowing full well that I would say yes.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 14/02/2022 09:31

The fanfare around being proposed to is actually quite pathetic. 90% of people know its going to happen and even choose their own ring. So what's the point? Attention clearly.

AlexaShutUp · 14/02/2022 09:28

@alfayruz

Yes but my point is, MN is different to what I observe in real life.

I am mid 40s. I don’t know anyone who hasn’t had a marriage proposal of some sort. I don’t know anyone who has been offended about being given an engagement ring. Confused

I do wonder if MN threads are ‘confirmation bias’ in a way because it’s only people that are ‘against’ something (in this case proposals) or have objections that bother to post?

But that says more about the social circles that you move in than society as a whole. There are lots of real women here telling you that their experience is different. Why do you doubt them?
SmellinOfTroy · 14/02/2022 09:27

and men like to tell us we should like it, and then we should keep it

Do you like the tradition of the wife stopping work when she gets married? or has a baby, afterall thats tradition

SmellinOfTroy · 14/02/2022 09:27

@alfayruz

I really don’t think you need to take everything so literally as ‘patriarchal shot’ though, Alexa. Some traditions persist because women like things like that. They expect a certain level of behaviour in a man. Otherwise, it’s like sucking all the joy and romance out of life? I’m not saying a proposal has to be a big social media - orientated affair. Not at all. That kind of thing didn’t even exist in the same way when my husband proposed. It’s nothing to do with anyone else.
Some traditions persist because SOME women like things like that.
Swipe left for the next trending thread