Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MN has it all wrong re proposals?

691 replies

alfayruz · 13/02/2022 20:12

Inspired by a thread the other day, but also a general observation on here, I was thinking ... whenever anyone posts on MN about waiting for a proposal from their DP, you can guarantee hundreds of posts along the lines of ‘just propose to him....’ AIBU to think this is ridiculous because -

  1. Nobody in actual real life does this

  2. Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

  3. Even if you could still muster some kind of sexual attraction towards him, the bar is set at rock bottom before you even start - so why would you expect any initiative or effort from him on any other occasions or general life going forward?

AIBU?

OP posts:
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/02/2022 16:05

@MarieIVanArkleStinks

Does this equate with never telling our partners what we actually want, but reserving the right to get all pissed off and flounce/mete out the silent treatment when we don't get it?

Unless people expect their partners to be mind-readers they need to tell them what they want. This singular inability to communicate something so basic really isn't a good foundation for a marriage. As for 'waiting' for a proposal, no thanks. There are other things going on in life.

^This
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 14/02/2022 16:03

@alfayruz

Inspired by a thread the other day, but also a general observation on here, I was thinking ... whenever anyone posts on MN about waiting for a proposal from their DP, you can guarantee hundreds of posts along the lines of ‘just propose to him....’ AIBU to think this is ridiculous because -
  1. Nobody in actual real life does this

  2. Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

  3. Even if you could still muster some kind of sexual attraction towards him, the bar is set at rock bottom before you even start - so why would you expect any initiative or effort from him on any other occasions or general life going forward?

AIBU?

YABVU. You are stuck in a 1950s mindset but expecting 2020s benefits.
TheFlyHalfsMum · 14/02/2022 16:00

Performative feminism, now I really have heard it 🤦🏻‍♀️ Hardly, it was a chat on the sofa on a Friday night…no one was watching…

CoalCraft · 14/02/2022 15:58

I know a woman who proposed to her now-husband in the most traditional way imaginable, but for the sexes. She rang his mother for her "blessing", took him out for a lovely meal, got down on one knee and presented him with an engagement watch.

Good for her! Why the hell should women be expected to wait around for when they already know they want to get married?

As for me and DH, neither of us proposed. I turned and said to him one day "do you think we should get married at some point?" and he said "yeah, how about summer [year]", then we went together to get engagement gifts for each other. I'd have hated a public proposal, to not get to choose my own ring, and to be forever waiting - what a waste of time.

As for your points 2) and 3), OP, sorry but I don't relate at all. It seems like you think men and women have fundamentally different roles in relationships and for me that's just archaic. My DH is my equal partner and my attraction towards him isn't based on old-fashioned ideals about what... Chivalry? We make decisions together.

TheFlyHalfsMum · 14/02/2022 15:50

Me and DH, as a pair of equal adults who could see ourselves in a long term relationship, agreed to get married. There was no proposal. I remember someone at the time giggling and saying I’d done myself out of a “romantic proposal” with my feminism…🤦🏻‍♀️ I simply can’t fathom why anyone in this day an age would sit for a proposal, it’s madness.

DrSbaitso · 14/02/2022 15:47

@alfayruz

I think guessing or having a strong suspicion is fine. Probably most women do. That’s very different to “let’s go to x place. I’ll stand here and say this script. You stand there and look amazed. Make sure it’s filmed at the right angle....”
I know this is MN, so everyone knows a load of people who obviously got their proposal staged by Steven Spielberg so they could be Instagram perfect, but in real life, I don't think it usually goes that way. They may take some photos to mark the occasion.
alfayruz · 14/02/2022 15:44

I think guessing or having a strong suspicion is fine. Probably most women do. That’s very different to “let’s go to x place. I’ll stand here and say this script. You stand there and look amazed. Make sure it’s filmed at the right angle....”

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 14/02/2022 15:38

@alfayruz

No, I mean it’s a bit weird to go somewhere with both of you knowing you’re going to get engaged. Very staged. Probably it was for Instagram or something? Everything seems to be for Instagram these days.
Is it?

My brother and his girlfriend went to Paris. She sort of guessed he was going to propose; they'd made it clear they were in each others' plans. They had a happy moment and then phoned us to tell us. It was nice. Nobody in the family thought it was weird at all. Staged for whom? The life partner he loved? Why is it so hard to believe that he did it because he wanted to, and she enjoyed it? Why the assumption that they were trying to impress anyone?

It was also long before Instagram. Facebook was barely a thing. I'm sure they'd still be married if he'd lived.

nokidshere · 14/02/2022 15:25

DH didn't propose to me nor I him. We lived together and had discussed being married occasionally. The only thing set in stone was that I wanted to be married before having children.

In 1987 we booked a holiday to Portugal and I suggested we could turn it into a honeymoon so that's what we did.

I ended up not getting pregnant till 21yrs later so we could have taken more time with hindsight.

aloris · 14/02/2022 15:22

I like a hybrid approach. I think that at some point during dating, the couple should be having discussions about whether they would be a good match for each other for marriage. Do they have similar ideas about having children, raising children, religion, fidelity, etc. If one member of the couple wants to be in a marriage within, say, a couple of years, while the other is happy to keep dating indefinitely, then the one who is looking for marriage can then know that they are not in a suitable match and can exit, and move on to finding a better match. If they are both interested in marriage, then, by discussing it, they can know that they are a possible good match for each other and can then explore that more completely. If neither is interested in marriage and they want to just keep dating, then that's fine too.

Every couple can make their own decisions. Personally I do not think I would propose to a man, but if we were dating seriously and he seemed to be taking "too long" then I don't know if I would try to put pressure on him. I would be worried that being pressured into proposing would signal he was not really that interested in marrying me. But I also wouldn't feel obligated to stay in the relationship while he took his sweet time and enjoyed my attention and care. I would probably move on, i.e. break up and look for someone else.

I feel that many of the threads on this board indicate that sleeping with a man, without the financial protection of marriage, can place a woman in a very difficult position if she becomes pregnant while they are unmarried. This seems to have happened even to women who were in long term relationships with men who said they were totally committed to the relationship. Where the man showed his true (stingy, or selfish) colors after children arrived, or the couple were together for many years without marriage and then the relationship broke down and the woman was left with no legal right to the home or savings because they were unmarried. So, personally, I would not want a relationship to go on so long that I "ended up" having children with the man, but without the financial protections of marriage.

BeyondMyWits · 14/02/2022 15:12

One year in, I said I'd want to be married before having kids. He said "will you marry me"... done.

alfayruz · 14/02/2022 15:08

No, I mean it’s a bit weird to go somewhere with both of you knowing you’re going to get engaged. Very staged. Probably it was for Instagram or something? Everything seems to be for Instagram these days.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 14/02/2022 14:58

It's weird to phone your friends and family to tell them you're engaged?

alfayruz · 14/02/2022 14:57

“. they told everybody that they were going to New York to get engaged and then when it happened they spent the whole day phoning people telling them they were engaged.... “

Yeah, that’s weird. Couldn’t be doing with that.

OP posts:
icannotbebothered · 14/02/2022 14:55

@LawnFever

Oh and I find it utterly ridiculous when couples get as far as buying a ring together but insist on ‘a proposal’ - years ago someone I worked with did that and I virtually laughed at her in surprise at the ridiculousness of the situation Grin
Some people do go waaay over board, my sisters friends got engaged, they went to New York specifically to get engaged.. they told everybody that they were going to New York to get engaged and then when it happened they spent the whole day phoning people telling them they were engaged....

No shock that they are now in an unhappy marriage

icannotbebothered · 14/02/2022 14:50

@alfayruz

Also, anyone who receives an engagement ring is deemed materialistic and ‘all about the bling.’ More than once, I have seen engagement rings described as ‘markers of chattel.’ Grin

According to MN, you are supposed to ‘sit him down at the table’ apparently. Like a business meeting.

Lmao this is so true, and if he hasn't proposed within 3 years, he's never going to apparently
Qwill · 14/02/2022 14:31

I think maybe those couples that are open to either side proposing (or a joint thing) are obviously compatible, and those who have a strong preference for a certain sex proposing are also compatible. Makes sense really. My husband and I split every 50/50 (childcare, housework, mental load, paid employment, etc.) and that works well for us, so it seemed obvious marriage discussions would also be in that vein too. Doesn’t work for everyone, but we are happy and it’s a good job we found each other!

RagzRebooted · 14/02/2022 14:25

I proposed to DH (on the leap year day!), but we already had 2 children and had discussed marriage. I made a huge banner and hung it at the end of the garden!

alfayruz · 14/02/2022 14:23

‘have you ever thought maybe the man like to be proposed to for a change?’

Well I suppose some men must do (going by this thread) but my DH would have been Hmm about it. I do think, still today, most men are not exactly expecting that.

OP posts:
SarahJessicaPorker · 14/02/2022 14:22

After we were engaged / getting married I have friend who wanted her boyfriend to propose. She was orchestrating it madly behind the scenes - she'd booked the registry office / the reception venue / dress shopped etc ALL without him and before speaking to him. I told her I didn't think it was the best way to go but she carried on. They did get married and are still married several years later!

That is clearly bonkers. Arranging a wedding behind your partner's back is insane, whatever the gender. Is your friend Gaston from Beauty and the Beast by any chance 😂😂?

I don't think any normal person would suggest doing any of that. It isn't a binary choice between "surprise proposal by the man" or "unhinged, wedding mad woman booking the registry office without discussing it with her boyfriend beforehand"

Qwill · 14/02/2022 14:10

All of my friends (make and female) all talked about getting married before they actually did, therefore there was no surprise proposal. I also know a couple of women who proposed to men (shock horror!!). I think it would set alarm bells with me personally if a man proposed out of the blue, I would think we had communication issues. I think people get annoyed on here that some women seem to be more about the proposal than the actual marriage. If you want to get married then have a conversation about it, not drop hints, be passive aggressive, etc. I can’t see the problem with the woman proposing - have you ever thought maybe the man like to be proposed to for a change?

UniBallEye · 14/02/2022 13:58

These threads turn up with some regularity on MN and I am always intrigued by them.

I come from a fairly traditional family, parents married young and are still together 50+ years later.

I had zero desire to get married or settle down or have kids at all. Until I met my now husband.

He was from a family where there had been a very acrimonious breakup and had no interest in marriage having seen how wrong it could go.

We met in our very late 20's / early 30's and were immediately inseparable. We both knew it was totally different to previous relationships and we just loved being together.

I moved 300km to be with him less than 6mths after we started seeing each other and I had no concerns about doing it at all. In the early stages we spoke about our upbringings and how neither of us had wanted to get married. We'd both been in long term relationaships before and had not been in the least bit tempted by the thought even though our respective partners did want it.

Over the course of our first year together we just grew closer and closer and then I got a job that required me to be 300km away 4 days a week and we really missed each other. I think things began to change then and we stopped feeling so casual to focusing more on not wanting to let each other go.

Good friends of ours got married and we saw how happy they were to do so and I think we began edging towards it more at that stage. We had some lovely chats on holidays in Paris directly after that wedding and we realised that we were both thinking along the same lines. we had both done a u-turn really.

When we got home (and we did not consider ourselves engaged whatsoever at that point, the conversations had been more generalised) and I went back to work long distance, we felt the separation more keenly.

A couple of weeks later I came home one friday and he proposed. I was not expecting it at all. He had a beautiful ring made by a jeweller whose work I really admired (but sort of imagined I'd never have one of his rings). It was private and intimate and it meant to world to both of us. We were married in less than 9 months later.

We are married 20+ years now and I have never once felt diminished by him having proposed and I still love the ring. I am looking at it right now and it still makes me smile. Our wedding day was one of the happiest days of my life (only topped by the arrival of dc) and we are very very happy together.

After we were engaged / getting married I have friend who wanted her boyfriend to propose. She was orchestrating it madly behind the scenes - she'd booked the registry office / the reception venue / dress shopped etc ALL without him and before speaking to him. I told her I didn't think it was the best way to go but she carried on. They did get married and are still married several years later!

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 14/02/2022 13:34

@Bonheurdupasse

YANBU. It’s performative “feminism” for show.
Rot. If anything's 'performative' and showy it's OTT 'proposals' and identikit 'traditional' weddings that probably cost more than the house.
SmellyWellyWoo · 14/02/2022 13:31

No proposal. No rings. Just a joint discussion. DP and I had a civil partnership. I have never wanted to be a wife- I have wanted us to have exactly the same title and role. So it's a turn off when men don't conform to gender roles? Like when he does cooking and cleaning and more than half of the childcare? I suppose that's a turn off too,

Shuffletime · 14/02/2022 13:25
  1. yes they do

  2. I would be much more attracted to a man who isn't insecure to feel "emasculated" by a female proposing that some macho twat.

  3. see point 2. The bar has been raised from macho twat to decent human being who values his partner as am equal.

(Obviously there are plenty of men who propose who are also decent human beings too, this is just in response to the OPs misogyny)

Swipe left for the next trending thread