Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MN has it all wrong re proposals?

691 replies

alfayruz · 13/02/2022 20:12

Inspired by a thread the other day, but also a general observation on here, I was thinking ... whenever anyone posts on MN about waiting for a proposal from their DP, you can guarantee hundreds of posts along the lines of ‘just propose to him....’ AIBU to think this is ridiculous because -

  1. Nobody in actual real life does this

  2. Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

  3. Even if you could still muster some kind of sexual attraction towards him, the bar is set at rock bottom before you even start - so why would you expect any initiative or effort from him on any other occasions or general life going forward?

AIBU?

OP posts:
tigger1001 · 17/02/2022 10:25

There has been more twists in opinion than on a corkscrew. Op I don't think you know what your own points are anymore as you have flip flopped so much

alfayruz · 17/02/2022 10:20

cuno - Biological means er, biological. Things like having a uterus, being the childbearing sex. Like I explained about ten times now.

Biology hardly determines whether you like pink, fgs? How can it?

Hormones are biological and these can influence how people feel about themselves, innate preferences etc, I guess. But I don’t think hormones are that relevant to a baby. Maybe more relevant to me in the peri-menopause, but it’s hard to say.

I would call it innate preferences - or personality, if you like. My two girls had different innate preferences, but have been socialised the same. They still have very different personalities, despite similar socialisation. So not everything is socialisation and it’s too simplistic to say it is.

But they both have the same biology!

OP posts:
SnakeLinguine · 17/02/2022 10:20

@alfayruz

“Preferences!!!! You like things because of your preference! Your daughter likes pink sparkly things. Society has deemed those things ‘girlie’. If you honestly believe that she popped out liking pink then it’s to do with her preference”

Yes Thankyou! I totally agree.

The problem I have is when posters try to tell people that certain preferences can only be the result of socialisation.

Well, there’s nothing innately ‘feminine’ about liking pink, which was regarded as a masculine colour because of its closeness to ‘warlike’ red until well into the 20thc, while blue was regarded as the ‘prettier’ and ‘more delicate’ colour, hence suitable for girls and young women:

edition.cnn.com/2018/01/12/health/colorscope-pink-boy-girl-gender/index.html

So pink being ‘girlie’ is a fairly recent social story.

SpinsForGin · 17/02/2022 10:14

The problem I have is when posters try to tell people that certain preferences can only be the result of socialisation.

But literally nobody said that .........

What we said was they play a HUGE part which you chose to interpret a particular way because you just want an argument.

alfayruz · 17/02/2022 10:08

“Preferences!!!! You like things because of your preference! Your daughter likes pink sparkly things. Society has deemed those things ‘girlie’. If you honestly believe that she popped out liking pink then it’s to do with her preference”

Yes Thankyou! I totally agree.

The problem I have is when posters try to tell people that certain preferences can only be the result of socialisation.

OP posts:
cuno · 17/02/2022 09:01

By saying someone came out that way, it does absolutely suggest it is biological. You haven't explained how your daughter innately aligns with female stereotypes. You say it's not socialisation, then it has to be biological, no? Unless you accept she didn't "come out like that", then you are absolutely suggesting it is biological whether you use that word or not. But she just happens to match gender stereotypes across the board, which you say she just came out that way. She didn't come out like that at all. Remember it's nature vs nurture... so what is this third thing you allude to that is neither of those things yet still innate and you can't explain it? Is it something woo?

Sorry but no matter how deep your feelings run about being a SAHM being so innate to you, it is largely down to socialisation. Do you not understand how socialisation can make you feel so deeply about these things? Socialisation isn't something that just makes you do things without being fussed about it, it permeates everything we think and do and absolutely affects us all on a deep emotional level and drives us towards certain life choices. I'm not sure why you think being a SAHM is the exception to this, unless you are suggesting there is a biological element to it?

Qwill · 17/02/2022 08:50

It’s also odd that you think all men who don’t propose are passive (and therefore unattractive). You get all that from one lifetime event (that doesn’t happen in everyone’s lifetime), when loads of people on here are saying they all discussed it first with their partner, so pretty much the opposite of passive. By your logic, all women that don’t propose are therefore passive?

SnakeLinguine · 17/02/2022 08:50

@alfayruz

‘men are pathetic, feeble, unfuckable and whatever else for not proposing, and that all women (or 99% of women) want men to do the proposing.’

Again, your words not mine cuno and I wouldn’t have quite put it like that, but yes, you are at least not misinterpreting my sentiment here so we’re not talking through cross wires.

I would not be attracted to a man who couldn’t even bring himself to propose no, because more passive men are not my thing.

Yes I can see how people sort of end up having a conversation about marriage and that’s it. To be perfectly honest, I have never come across this in real life but plenty of people are talking about it on here so I live and learn.

Call me old-fashioned (and no doubt you’ll call me a lot worse than that), but to me, it does seem kind of ungentlemanly for a man to put his girlfriend in a situation where she feels she has to propose to him! That would be the turn-off, for me.

But if people are telling me they feel proposing is taking control, then I accept that and you do you.

So you’re turned n by your own self-chosen lack of agency, while deploring what you term ‘passivity’ in men? Do your entrenched ideas about gender not include the possibility that it’s ‘unladylike’ to put your boyfriend in a situation where he feels he has to propose to you? Or no, because female passivity is ‘normal’?
Qwill · 17/02/2022 08:45

Preferences!!!! You like things because of your preference! Your daughter likes pink sparkly things. Society has deemed those things ‘girlie’. If you honestly believe that she popped out liking pink then it’s to do with her preference and you have made the connection they are ‘girlie’ because society has deemed them so. If she liked pink and blue equally then you wouldn’t make this pattern. As for wanting to be a SAHM, I honestly don’t know what that has to do with anything, unless you think that preference is more ‘feminine’? Surely that was your preference based on a myriad of other factors?

WalkingOnTheCracks · 17/02/2022 08:19

Again...

1) Nobody in actual real life does this

Yes they do.

2) Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

Why?

HelloDulling · 17/02/2022 07:14

Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

Whereas remaining completely passive and having no agency over your own future gets you really hot to trot?

alfayruz · 17/02/2022 07:11

Sure.

OP posts:
hugr · 17/02/2022 07:10

That would be the turn-off, for me.

Isn't that the crucial thing though? It's for you, not everyone else?

alfayruz · 17/02/2022 06:58

‘men are pathetic, feeble, unfuckable and whatever else for not proposing, and that all women (or 99% of women) want men to do the proposing.’

Again, your words not mine cuno and I wouldn’t have quite put it like that, but yes, you are at least not misinterpreting my sentiment here so we’re not talking through cross wires.

I would not be attracted to a man who couldn’t even bring himself to propose no, because more passive men are not my thing.

Yes I can see how people sort of end up having a conversation about marriage and that’s it. To be perfectly honest, I have never come across this in real life but plenty of people are talking about it on here so I live and learn.

Call me old-fashioned (and no doubt you’ll call me a lot worse than that), but to me, it does seem kind of ungentlemanly for a man to put his girlfriend in a situation where she feels she has to propose to him! That would be the turn-off, for me.

But if people are telling me they feel proposing is taking control, then I accept that and you do you.

OP posts:
alfayruz · 17/02/2022 06:39

cuno
“Biological, innate, born this way, come out like that, people generally use these terms interchangeably.”

NO.

Saying I believe my daughter “came out that way” or had certain innate traits from a very early age, is in no way the same thing as claiming these traits are biologically-determined!

If something is biologically-determined, then I would be saying the same traits apply to all females!

If I was arguing that, why would I be telling you in the very next paragraph, my other daughter was not like this?

Why would I then go on to say that one of my sons showed characteristics that were what people might call more stereotypically masculine more so than than the other one?

This is insane. I did not use the word biology. You and others are having this reading something that is not there and was not intended.

Do I need to explain it again? When I talked about ‘biology’ earlier in the thread, it was in the context of women being the childbearing sex and how this has likely impacted societal structures, specifically notions of gender through history.

How many times do I have to say this?

I don’t think my daughter’s very feminine traits are biological. That goes without saying. In mentioning my observations if my own very different children, my point was, I don’t think the traits are entirely down to socialisation.

If it was all about socialisation and nothing else, my younger daughter would have been the same, surely?

I believe some traits are innate, basically. It’s not all about socialisation.

I also went on to describe my own feelings about wanting to be a SAHM. Of course I accept that will have been affected by socialisation but again, it also felt as if it ran deeper than that for me. It still does.

So I was asking - are people telling me my daughter is only stereotypically feminine because of socialisation? And am I only the way I am because of socialisation? Is this the argument? Because this rigidity does irk me to be honest, and I find it slightly patronising.

PLEASE DON’T NOW COME BACK AND SAY “OH SO YOU THINK WANTING TO BE A SAHM IS BIOLOGICAL DO YOU?”

It’s doing my head in.

OP posts:
JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 16/02/2022 23:41

YABU and a bit of a dick.

Of course women propose to men! Why the hell shouldn't they? And why should it be a turn off?

Don't be ridiculous 🙄

Qwill · 16/02/2022 23:25

“ But yes, my daughter was very drawn to stereotypically feminine things as soon as she could express interest in anything. I don’t think it’s because of her biology! I was actually asking what people think caused that? Because although I don’t deny socialisation would have been a large part of it, I still don’t think that’s the whole story”

You really want to know what made your daughter like the colour pink? Same reason I like the colour orange. It’s a preference based on pleasure from visual stimulation.

Recent stereotypes of gender colours are a social concept. If you daughter liked the colour yellow, trucks, sparkly wands, princesses, racing cars, and there were no gender stereotypes then you wouldn’t see a pattern. You are looking for a pattern because of social stereotypes, otherwise they would just be things, colours, attitudes, and preferences that all individuals have.

cuno · 16/02/2022 23:02

Interesting that you think everyone happens to be misinterpreting everything you say...
And your "explanations" to clear up the "misinterpretations" don't actually explain very much at all.
If someone being born a certain way you didn't mean it's biological, what then? What else are you implying? The debate is nature vs nurture and you clearly said it's not nurture in the example given. Hmm
Biological, innate, born this way, come out like that, people generally use these terms interchangeably.

No reason to lie? Really? All I'm seeing is mental gymnastics in a desperate attempt to justify that men are pathetic, feeble, unfuckable and whatever else for not proposing, and that all women (or 99% of women) want men to do the proposing, and apparently no-one in real life sits down and makes a mutual decision without any proposal at all.

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 22:41

I am exhausted with this now. I have not ‘backtracked’ at all. I’ve just tried to explain that you are misinterpreting me and then, when you see the difference, you interpret that as backtracking!

I have no reason to lie about what I meant or didn’t mean. I can kind of see why you interpreted that post as you did. But I’ve explained repeatedly now what I meant. It is what it is. I can’t say anymore. There is nothing to be gained through going on and on in circles about misunderstanding.

OP posts:
SpinsForGin · 16/02/2022 22:13

@alfayruz

I did not use the word biology in that paragraph, Spins. There is no mention of biology. I said she ‘came out like that.’ Because she did basically. What I said was “ I don’t believe gendered behaviour are always and only down to socialisation.‘ This statement is NOT the same thing as the statement ‘my child’s gendered behaviour is down to her biology.’ Surely you can see that.

I was trying to discuss what I observed about my daughter as an example of something that cannot be purely ‘socialisation.’ I was actually asking what it could be - why are children born the way they are? I did not state anything about biology because I was not thinking that. You assumed I meant something I genuinely didn’t.

But can't you see why we came to that conclusion? You might not have meant it but it's his it came across. We had been discussing biology and socialisation and when people use the phrases you did, they are typically referring to biology.

If that's not what you meant then it's still not clear what point you were actually making!!

To be honest, it felt like this was your 'gotcha' moment. Your proof that you were right and we were wrong. Then the discussion didn't go quite as you expected so you've back tracked (again) and are now claiming that's not what you meant at all and it's all our fault for making assumptions and not understanding you.

Obviously you'll never admit to that but it's how it's coming across.

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 21:58

I did not use the word biology in that paragraph, Spins. There is no mention of biology. I said she ‘came out like that.’ Because she did basically. What I said was “ I don’t believe gendered behaviour are always and only down to socialisation.‘ This statement is NOT the same thing as the statement ‘my child’s gendered behaviour is down to her biology.’ Surely you can see that.

I was trying to discuss what I observed about my daughter as an example of something that cannot be purely ‘socialisation.’ I was actually asking what it could be - why are children born the way they are? I did not state anything about biology because I was not thinking that. You assumed I meant something I genuinely didn’t.

OP posts:
SpinsForGin · 16/02/2022 21:44

@alfayruz

Spins - it’s is not what I was arguing but you and Jassy launched into the whole ‘it’s not about female biology, it’s how men have responded to female biology.’ So I was having to respond to that discourse from you and Jassy (even though it didn’t feel relevant to the point about my daughter). I didn’t talk about my kids to imply they are the way they are because ‘biology.’ I was saying I didn’t think they were like that because of socialisation and nothing else. You assumed that meant I was arguing it was biology, but I hadn’t meant that. I was asking what it could be - because if not socialisation, then what?

So much misunderstanding on this thread.

The very stereotypically ‘girly’ daughter literally ‘came out’ like that as far as I’m concerned. So no, I don’t believe gendered behaviour are always and only down to socialisation. The evidence is here in this house! Some people naturally conform to gender types than others.

If you were referring to biology in this paragraph what did you mean? Surely you must read this back and realise why we came to that conclusion, especially given the conversation had been about biology vs socialisation.

I mean, I'm struggling to understand what else you could possibly mean when you use the phrase 'came out like that'? If you weren't referring to biology what did you mean?

The only think you've actually been consistent with on this thread is the constant contradictions!! It's very difficult to have any kind of discussion when someone constantly backtracks.

Anyway, you are entitled to your opinion. I don't agree with much of what you've said and I suspect you'll continue to disagree with me on principle anyway! But enjoy the rest of your evening.

cuno · 16/02/2022 21:43

This is what I said:
If you're trying to give credence to men proposing being the done thing because social constructs are the natural order of things influenced by biology (according to you), then you are automatically giving credence to all the horrible awful things that happens to women at the hands of men because of the same social constructs. You don't get to cherrypick which ways are okay for women and men to not be on equal footing because you think those ways are lovely, and ignore all the awful shit that is sneaking through the back door along with it.

Then you said:
Yes society determines social constructs.

And what is society composed of?

Humans.

And what drives humans?

Biology.

After that I said:
Honestly sounds like the dumb shit the taliban would argue.

I wasn't calling you the taliban. I was saying how the taliban can argue this biology bullshit to justify the way they treat women. Once you start using it to justify the little acts of sexism you consider to be all well and good, it can be taken to extremes i.e. taliban. Obviously you are not the taliban, but can't you see how the same argument can be used in a sinister way??? It's dangerous to give those arguments any legitimacy.

alfayruz · 16/02/2022 21:36

Yesterday 21:27 cuno

Honestly sounds like the dumb shit the taliban would argue.

OP posts:
alfayruz · 16/02/2022 21:32

Spins - it’s is not what I was arguing but you and Jassy launched into the whole ‘it’s not about female biology, it’s how men have responded to female biology.’ So I was having to respond to that discourse from you and Jassy (even though it didn’t feel relevant to the point about my daughter). I didn’t talk about my kids to imply they are the way they are because ‘biology.’ I was saying I didn’t think they were like that because of socialisation and nothing else. You assumed that meant I was arguing it was biology, but I hadn’t meant that. I was asking what it could be - because if not socialisation, then what?

So much misunderstanding on this thread.

OP posts: