Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MN has it all wrong re proposals?

691 replies

alfayruz · 13/02/2022 20:12

Inspired by a thread the other day, but also a general observation on here, I was thinking ... whenever anyone posts on MN about waiting for a proposal from their DP, you can guarantee hundreds of posts along the lines of ‘just propose to him....’ AIBU to think this is ridiculous because -

  1. Nobody in actual real life does this

  2. Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

  3. Even if you could still muster some kind of sexual attraction towards him, the bar is set at rock bottom before you even start - so why would you expect any initiative or effort from him on any other occasions or general life going forward?

AIBU?

OP posts:
ThAtSnOtMynAm · 14/02/2022 20:19

@SpinsForGin

And most adults don't need the Disney view of romance. A mutual decision to get married is sensible but can also be romantic.

Ours was a full on whirlwind romance .... we were married, pregnant and had bought a house within a year. All mutual decisions but romantic all the same.

That's lovely to hear. I quit like the Disney view of life. Outdated or not. Everyone is different.
SpinsForGin · 14/02/2022 20:16

And most adults don't need the Disney view of romance. A mutual decision to get married is sensible but can also be romantic.

Ours was a full on whirlwind romance .... we were married, pregnant and had bought a house within a year. All mutual decisions but romantic all the same.

SpinsForGin · 14/02/2022 20:13

@ThAtSnOtMynAm

Spins for Gin - why? ... Because in my view it takes a man longer to decide he wants to get married than a woman, so if a woman's proposing I would think the man really wasn't bothered about it. Mutual decisions are different, not incredibly romantic but different. My view so don't attack me like the last one 🤣🤣
I think you might need to address your sexist views! I'm not going to attack you but your views are a little outdated ....🤷🏼‍♀️
Confusedtraveler · 14/02/2022 20:11

none of my friends - and almost all of us have been married for decades - expected to wait around for a romantic proposal from a man. Nor did our parents or grandparents. Instead, like adults, like equals, we discusssed getting married.

not the experience from my grand-mother time at all.

Confusedtraveler · 14/02/2022 20:09

@LionGiraffeMonkey

Do people still ask the bride’s father before proposing? Or do we accept that women aren’t the property of their father these days?
yes, people still do.

People (the man) have also be known to ask the mother who was a widow.

Unless they offer half a dozen cows or a flock of sheep in exchange for their acceptance, pretty sure it has nothing to do with being someone's property 😂

my dad would have been delighted to take a good bottle of scotch as a bribe I am sure

ThAtSnOtMynAm · 14/02/2022 20:08

Spins for Gin - why? ... Because in my view it takes a man longer to decide he wants to get married than a woman, so if a woman's proposing I would think the man really wasn't bothered about it. Mutual decisions are different, not incredibly romantic but different. My view so don't attack me like the last one 🤣🤣

scottishnames · 14/02/2022 20:08

Look, once and for all, big 'performance' proposals are not 'traditional', They are a modern Hollywood/marketing /social medoia invention. Of course people should enjoy them if that's what they would like, but please don't imagine that it's an old or traditional way to behave.

Proposals from man to woman sort of hovered around in literature from the 19th cent, but have grown out of all proportion in my lifetime. I'm not that old, but none of my friends - and almost all of us have been married for decades - expected to wait around for a romantic proposal from a man. Nor did our parents or grandparents. Instead, like adults, like equals, we discusssed getting married.

Medieval people believed that the birds began to sing - and maybe paired off - on 14 Feb (which, because of calendar change, would have been a diffrent day than 14 Feb today). But that's all that can be definitely proved. Chaucer (14th cent) linked birds pairing off with human ditto, but quite what he meant, historians disagree.

Hollywood so often gets things wrong. Romantic marriage was not a thing until a relatively short time ago. Sure, people loved each other or got to love each other, but all this hearts and flowers stuff is modern invention. Love might happen, but it was by no means always linked to marriage. Hence the plots of so many, many, many early stories and poems.

In the further distant past, marriage was usually arranged by parents, or - among poor/ordinary people - was as much a matter of convenience or even sheer survival as love. And maybe one-third of the time it was forced to take place by the Church and/or social convention because the bride was pregnant.

Namenic · 14/02/2022 20:06

Hehe - we decided to get married quite soon after going out. I’m from another culture and family expected DH to ask permission. So the next year was spent with DH getting to know my family/culture and then asking my dad. We picked rings together - and I’m glad we did because when trying on rings, I found I liked ones I hadn’t expected to like. The proposal wasn’t a surprise, but DH planned a day out and it was lovely. I do find waiting a bit weird- I guess I like certainty.

LionGiraffeMonkey · 14/02/2022 19:59

Do people still ask the bride’s father before proposing? Or do we accept that women aren’t the property of their father these days?

SpinsForGin · 14/02/2022 19:58

@ThAtSnOtMynAm

Whenever I see a women propose it really makes me think "oh god she's desperate" completely agree with OP
Why?
SpinsForGin · 14/02/2022 19:56

If my DH had asked my dad for his permission/blessing I would have lost a lot of respect for him.

I'm an adult and make my own decisions. My dad doesn't get a say!

HelloFrostyMorning · 14/02/2022 19:44

@alfayruz

Alexa - He just spoke to my dad to be on the safe side as he didn’t know him and so didn’t want to risk any offence. We would have got married anyway.
Wait, what? Your husband-to-be doesn't know your dad? Confused

Why? Have they never met?

JassyRadlett · 14/02/2022 19:39

It's not mind game, it's not getting taken for granted, and start the relationship on a good base., and carry on the same.

Yep. Still don’t understand why that doesn’t cut both ways.

But as I say, on an emotional level I can’t really understand the desire for or attraction of unequal roles in a relationship or different expectations being put on each partner based on their sex - so setting up those very different expectations otherwise you feel ‘taken for granted’ does feel a bit like mind games to me.

RedRobin100 · 14/02/2022 19:36

YANBU

alfayruz · 14/02/2022 19:32

Alexa - He just spoke to my dad to be on the safe side as he didn’t know him and so didn’t want to risk any offence. We would have got married anyway.

OP posts:
HelloFrostyMorning · 14/02/2022 19:27

hellofrostymorning

What I find odd, is when women sneer, and turn their nose up at a woman who has got a card/flowers/a gift from their husband for Valentine's Day, with the predictable, catty, shitty line 'I don't need shit like that. I want a man who loves and respects me and treats me well all year round, not just Valentine's Day!' As if the man buying the gifts/card/flowers shows fuck all interest any other time of the year.

It's such a stupid obnoxious comment, and always comes exclusively from women who get fuck all off their man for Valentine's Day, and they are bitter and jealous.

@SpinsForGin

There's been a lot of this today ...... it's so depressing and predictable...

I know right. So pathetic. Trying to tell everyone how much you just HATE Valentine's day and it's a waste of money, and just for 'sad sacks,' and it's all so naff, and obviously all the men who get a card and flowers for their wife/girlfriend are hideous to them for the other 364 days of the year.

Just bore off. No-one gives a flying tit about your opinion, so keep your negative remarks to yourself. Your jealous is strong, and green doesn't suit you. Wink

And as the saying goes........ 'methinks the lady doth protest too much.....'

AlexaShutUp · 14/02/2022 19:25

@HelloFrostyMorning

I know it's 2022 and not the 1950s (yawn... ) but I do find a woman proposing to a man very odd.

Yep I really do.

Also, I don't know one single married couple in real life, where the woman proposed. I find it a bit cringe to be honest.

So depressing that there are still attitudes like this out there. The idea that a woman exercising agency over her own life is "a bit cringe"...words fail me.
Confusedtraveler · 14/02/2022 19:24

@JassyRadlett

I really can’t understand why it’s a ‘turn off’ but I don’t really understand (at all emotional level) quite a lot about ‘traditional’ relationship dynamics where women want to be chased and would never ask a man out, want to play all sorts of mind games, etc.
It's not mind game, it's not getting taken for granted, and start the relationship on a good base., and carry on the same.
NotImpossible · 14/02/2022 19:24

And no, I don't mean a man proposing is controlling so please don't misinterpret/twist that!

AlexaShutUp · 14/02/2022 19:23

FWIW, OP, I don't think there is anything cringeworthy or controlling about your DH's proposal. It sounds lovely and it was obviously very special for you.

To be clear, I don't see any issue with a man proposing. My issue is more with the notion that that's the only right and normal way to do it. I don't like the expectation that this role will fall to the man when the conversation could just as appropriately be initiated by the woman.

I would have taken issue with DH if he had asked for my dad's blessing though. That would have been a deal breaker for me. Perhaps I would have forgiven him if he had at least made a point of asking my mum as well, but even then...I am a grown adult and I make my own decisions. What would he have done if your dad had said that he didn't give his blessing?

JassyRadlett · 14/02/2022 19:22

I really can’t understand why it’s a ‘turn off’ but I don’t really understand (at all emotional level) quite a lot about ‘traditional’ relationship dynamics where women want to be chased and would never ask a man out, want to play all sorts of mind games, etc.

NotImpossible · 14/02/2022 19:20

@alfayruz

Inspired by a thread the other day, but also a general observation on here, I was thinking ... whenever anyone posts on MN about waiting for a proposal from their DP, you can guarantee hundreds of posts along the lines of ‘just propose to him....’ AIBU to think this is ridiculous because -
  1. Nobody in actual real life does this

  2. Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

  3. Even if you could still muster some kind of sexual attraction towards him, the bar is set at rock bottom before you even start - so why would you expect any initiative or effort from him on any other occasions or general life going forward?

AIBU?

I mean, my opinion of a woman who sits around passively waiting for someone else to take control of her life when she knows what she wants but isn't bepenised enough to do it would drop drastically, so I could understand this being a turn off to a man... Unless he's the sort of man who wants control and not equality I suppose.
Throckmorton · 14/02/2022 19:20

@HelloFrostyMorning

I know it's 2022 and not the 1950s (yawn... ) but I do find a woman proposing to a man very odd.

Yep I really do.

Also, I don't know one single married couple in real life, where the woman proposed. I find it a bit cringe to be honest.

Why cringe? Fair enough if you don't personally want it, but why would you judge others for doing things differently? Do you not see its quite pantonising and sexist to look down on women who do things differently from you?
HelloFrostyMorning · 14/02/2022 19:19

@lumpofcomfort

I posted my surprise on the thread. I'm not married and have never had a proposal but every single couple I know that married there was a proposal involved and 99% of the time the man proposed to the woman. On MN nobody has a proposal, they just sat down one night and agreed they would get married then went back to watching Netflix or whatever.

I think the mumsnet type thing is the norm tbh. I genuinely believe that most men don't go down on bended knee, with a ring in a box in their hand, stretched out towards their woman.

I don't think the man even gets the ring actually (in most cases,) and I believe that the couple DO decide together to get married, and go and pick the engagement ring together. But she almost ALWAYS goes on to facebook/twitter/instagram, with pics of the ring, saying 'he proposed to me!' We all know that never happened. And as I said, I have NEVER known a woman propose to a man.

Confusedtraveler · 14/02/2022 19:18

If he can't be bothered to make an effort for the proposal, not point bothering at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread