Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think MN has it all wrong re proposals?

691 replies

alfayruz · 13/02/2022 20:12

Inspired by a thread the other day, but also a general observation on here, I was thinking ... whenever anyone posts on MN about waiting for a proposal from their DP, you can guarantee hundreds of posts along the lines of ‘just propose to him....’ AIBU to think this is ridiculous because -

  1. Nobody in actual real life does this

  2. Having to propose to a man would be a massive turn off anyway so what is the point?

  3. Even if you could still muster some kind of sexual attraction towards him, the bar is set at rock bottom before you even start - so why would you expect any initiative or effort from him on any other occasions or general life going forward?

AIBU?

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 15/02/2022 21:13

I guess I mean that most women want to marry a man who proposes to them of their own free will and not because they were cornered into it.

I’d switch that up a bit. Most women want to marry a man who wants to marry them of his own free will and not because he was cornered into it.

I think that is true for most women, sadly I don’t think it happens for at least a proportion of women.

The proposal feels like an added extra. It’s clearly more important for some people than for others, and people find the wonder in the moment in different ways (mine was the fact he’d got there first, sneaky. But it was fairly low key.)

For others, the ‘wonderment’ of a single (often quite staged) moment doesn’t even come close to the deeper sense of wonder at having the sort of connection to another human that makes you want to contemplate a commitment to life together.

Some need or want frills, some don’t. Both are ok and neither is less special or less wonderful. The men who propose are no less or more than the men who are proposed to, or decide jointly with their future wives. It’s the absurdity of the OP in suggesting otherwise that’s kept this one going.

alfayruz · 15/02/2022 21:12

No it’s nothing to do with money.

For socio-economic context - I don’t know anyone whose husband didn’t propose to her. Most of my social circle met the DH at uni or shortly after when the gender-pay gap hadn’t really set in. I met DH a bit later, but he hadn’t made his money then. The women are just as educated as the men and they certainly didn’t ‘need’ marriage.m for financial reasons. They just like men with certain behaviours and manners really. That’s all it is.

OP posts:
DontWantTheRivalry · 15/02/2022 21:05

Nobody is saying it isn't lovely. We're just saying not everyone wants that. Surely that's not difficult to understand? I love telling the story of how me and DH got married. Just because it didn't involve a surprise proposal doesn't mean it's any less valid (or romantic) than those that did start that way.

Of course I understand that. My partner proposed to me in our living room and I loved it. The surprise element of it was what made it so romantic, not the surroundings.

I guess I mean that most women want to marry a man who proposes to them of their own free will and not because they were cornered into it.

A sit down discussion at the about the practicalities of marriage and the financial and legal benefits just doesn’t have the same sense of wonderment about it - in my opinion anyway.

But like I said, I know everyone is different. And ok, maybe not every woman wants the exhilaration of a surprise proposal but I imagine the majority of woman would.

AlexaShutUp · 15/02/2022 21:01

I wonder if there is a socioeconomic thing going on here, rather than a biological one?

There seems to be a deeply ingrained assumption on this thread that women will want marriage while most men will need to be cajoled into it...except the "good" ones who somehow manage to do it without being told. I find this really curious.

Obviously, there is still a gender pay gap in our society and many women are still financially dependent on men. So there is a financial benefit in marriage for those women while the men pay a financial penalty.

And if that's the set up, I guess maybe it is reasonable for the man to propose because he is the one who stands to lose the most and therefore has to really want to get married in order to make it worthwhile? Whereas it's seen as a no brainer that the woman will want to get married as it's obviously in her economic interest.

Perhaps those of us who are arguing for a less gendered approach to relationships are the ones who are economically in a stronger position? So we stand to gain much less from marriage financially, if at all? (In my case, not at all - quite the opposite, actually).

Consequently, we don't feel the need for any grand gestures from the man to "prove" that they really want to marry us because the cost of marriage to them is no greater than it is to us.

Perhaps the very fact that financially independent women don't need to get married changes the way they approach the subject?

Just a theory.

alfayruz · 15/02/2022 20:59

So why does gender exist then?

OP posts:
SpinsForGin · 15/02/2022 20:56

I would argue that biology does influence gender in some ways (for some people more then others, it’s true). But you can’t just write off the impact of different hormones or physicality and how these differences can manifest in terms of human behaviour or sexuality.
These are sex based differences. Nobody is 'writing them off' because they are important BUT they are completely separate to the social construct of gender.

‘Social constructs’ are generally just a reflection of this or an attempt to control / sublimate human drives. You can see gender as repressive because in ms t ways it is, but it persists because it’s also a form of human expression.

Gender isn't about biology.
You need to understand the difference between sex and gender.

Skeam · 15/02/2022 20:48

@alfayruz

I would argue that biology does influence gender in some ways (for some people more then others, it’s true). But you can’t just write off the impact of different hormones or physicality and how these differences can manifest in terms of human behaviour or sexuality. ‘Social constructs’ are generally just a reflection of this or an attempt to control / sublimate human drives. You can see gender as repressive because in ms t ways it is, but it persists because it’s also a form of human expression.
OP, you seem very, very confused about the meanings of many of the main nouns in this post.
alfayruz · 15/02/2022 20:44

I would argue that biology does influence gender in some ways (for some people more then others, it’s true). But you can’t just write off the impact of different hormones or physicality and how these differences can manifest in terms of human behaviour or sexuality. ‘Social constructs’ are generally just a reflection of this or an attempt to control / sublimate human drives. You can see gender as repressive because in ms t ways it is, but it persists because it’s also a form of human expression.

OP posts:
SpinsForGin · 15/02/2022 20:39

@DontWantTheRivalry

What we're talking about here are adult conversations between two people. Men can still initiate a conversation about marriage that doesn't involve the big, surprise proposal.

Which is something a lot of women would be disappointed.

My experience of newly engaged women, of which I’ve met many, is that they enjoy gushing over ‘how’ he proposed….and that’s not surprising as generally “so how did he propose?” is usually one of the first question women are asked Grin

I love the gushing and the happiness and excitement newly engaged women have about their proposals. I think it’s lovely.

Nobody is saying it isn't lovely. We're just saying not everyone wants that. Surely that's not difficult to understand?

I love telling the story of how me and DH got married. Just because it didn't involve a surprise proposal doesn't mean it's any less valid (or romantic) than those that did start that way.

DontWantTheRivalry · 15/02/2022 20:33

What we're talking about here are adult conversations between two people. Men can still initiate a conversation about marriage that doesn't involve the big, surprise proposal.

Which is something a lot of women would be disappointed.

My experience of newly engaged women, of which I’ve met many, is that they enjoy gushing over ‘how’ he proposed….and that’s not surprising as generally “so how did he propose?” is usually one of the first question women are asked Grin

I love the gushing and the happiness and excitement newly engaged women have about their proposals. I think it’s lovely.

SpinsForGin · 15/02/2022 20:26

I think deep down every woman wants a romantic proposal from a man who chose to do it off his own back and not because he’s somehow cornered into doing it.

Nope. I did not want DH to do that.

Why is there an assumption that it's women driving the conversations about marriage? Like men are being dragged into it without agency.

What we're talking about here are adult conversations between two people. Men can still initiate a conversation about marriage that doesn't involve the big, surprise proposal.

NoWordForFluffy · 15/02/2022 20:21

I think deep down every woman wants a romantic proposal from a man who chose to do it off his own back and not because he’s somehow cornered into doing it.

Now that is total and utter nonsense!

DontWantTheRivalry · 15/02/2022 20:17

Me and my boyfriend always used to joke about getting married, laughing about how our married life would be, joking about the £10’000 diamond ring I’d like etc and we could always laugh about it because we were both on the same page and we knew we’d end up married.

When he actually did propose though it came as a complete surprise because we’d never actually talked seriously about marriage so the proposal out of the blue was so romantic.

I think deep down every woman wants a romantic proposal from a man who chose to do it off his own back and not because he’s somehow cornered into doing it.

I can see though why it is advised for women to bring it up in a business like manner when she feels that she and her partner are on completely different pages and not wanting the same things.

However, I can totally see why some women wouldn’t want to do this or propose themselves because it goes against what their dream proposal would look like.

SpinsForGin · 15/02/2022 20:11

@alfayruz

To the poster above, I didn’t say the tradition of men proposing was biological Hmm. Obviously that’s cultural. When I was talking about biological differences, it was with respect to childbirth, breastfeeding, attachment and the emotional / physical / psychological impacts of having children.

I believe there are fundamental differences here for men and women which obvious ramifications in the personal and public spheres. To pretend otherwise is to do women a disservice. Just because some women seem threatened by the idea if any biological differences between men and women whatsoever, doesn’t give them the right to tell me or other women how we should feel. You can relate to your husband in a totally ‘gender free’ way if that’s how you feel and that’s absolutely fine. But plenty of women and men feel differently and that’s also fine.

I think you are misunderstanding what people are saying. Yes, there are biological differences between men and women but those biological differences do not influence how we behave in relation to our gender. Gender is a social construct. To ignore that is to do a huge disservice to women.

Choosing to be a SAHM is not a biological decision.
Choosing how you split childcare or housework is not a biological decision.
Your husband taking on the responsibility of the family finances is not driven by biology.
These are driven by societal expectations, gender stereotypes and personal preferences.

If you choose to structure your family along more traditional lines then that is your choice. But it's not a decision that is driven by biology.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 15/02/2022 20:09

You can relate to your husband in a totally ‘gender free’ way if that’s how you feel and that’s absolutely fine. But plenty of women and men feel differently and that’s also fine.

That's essentially what everyone has been saying to you the whole time OP, that couples should do what works for them (rather than defaulting to gender stereotypes based on penis vs vagina with no consideration of alternatives that may work better or be fairer) and that in doing so they may live up to traditional stereotypes or they may choose to not to.

You're agreeing with people in essence, you just seem to be determined to keep arguing!

alfayruz · 15/02/2022 20:01

I have not said anyone is ‘pathetic’ or ‘desperate.’ I don’t think I’ve used the word ‘cringe’ either. If someone has said that, it wasn’t me.

OP posts:
alfayruz · 15/02/2022 19:59

To the poster above, I didn’t say the tradition of men proposing was biological Hmm. Obviously that’s cultural. When I was talking about biological differences, it was with respect to childbirth, breastfeeding, attachment and the emotional / physical / psychological impacts of having children.

I believe there are fundamental differences here for men and women which obvious ramifications in the personal and public spheres. To pretend otherwise is to do women a disservice. Just because some women seem threatened by the idea if any biological differences between men and women whatsoever, doesn’t give them the right to tell me or other women how we should feel. You can relate to your husband in a totally ‘gender free’ way if that’s how you feel and that’s absolutely fine. But plenty of women and men feel differently and that’s also fine.

OP posts:
user1469770863 · 15/02/2022 19:45

Old Gimmer here, I proposed to my now husband in 1970. We're still together ... Golden wedding next year ...

Throckmorton · 15/02/2022 19:40

Nor are we "pathetic", "cringe", or "desperate" for doing things differently from you alfayruz

Qwill · 15/02/2022 19:14

[“I am a woman
I feel like this.
Therefore all women feel like this. “

That’s exactly what you’re saying though Alexa. Can’t you see that? You’re saying that because you don’t feel a certain way, no women can do.]

No that’s exactly the opposite of what Alexa is saying and the vast majority of people on here. What we are saying is that not every woman feels like you do, and it doesn’t make us any less valid as women for feeling the way we do.

LiveFromNewYork · 15/02/2022 19:10

To me either you both know you are on that course in which case there's no element of surprise even if one is fashioned somehow - it's ultimately play acting. Not that there's anything particularly wrong if you like that sort of thing and don't mind the 'submissive' role. Or you don't know where you're headed and a proposal seems an oddly old fashioned way to find things out, and is particularly weird when the woman has to wait around or set an ultimatum for one. Sometimes I think proposals are along the same fantasy lines as a big wedding with white dress, you want to tick it off but can easily lose sight of the meaning.

But marriage isn't for me in the first place.

AlexaShutUp · 15/02/2022 19:09

@GoldenOmber

Maybe some of these men are also waiting for a sign that the women actively want to marry them as well?

I’m thinking of the ones who are like “well we’ve talked about it, and he said he’d want to be the one to propose, so I waited, but then he didn’t, and then I got pregnant, so he said we should put it on the back burner for a while, and then we went through a rough patch and after that he kept asking what my ring size was, but he didn’t, and then we went on holiday to Paris and he kept dropping hints that I should expect something special for our anniversary dinner but then he handed me a Now 47 CD, and I got upset, and then he said he was waiting for the right moment and if I kept asking about it it would ruin it, so I waited, and…”

Ah, OK. Well, tbh, in that scenario they might as well just cut their losses and leave instead of waiting for anything!

If they have already talked about marriage, I don't personally understand why either of them then needs to be "the one to propose" at that point. Surely a proposal is redundant because a discussion has already been had, and they each know where the other one stands on the issue already? So isn't it simply a question of setting the date at that point?

GoldenOmber · 15/02/2022 19:02

Maybe some of these men are also waiting for a sign that the women actively want to marry them as well?

I’m thinking of the ones who are like “well we’ve talked about it, and he said he’d want to be the one to propose, so I waited, but then he didn’t, and then I got pregnant, so he said we should put it on the back burner for a while, and then we went through a rough patch and after that he kept asking what my ring size was, but he didn’t, and then we went on holiday to Paris and he kept dropping hints that I should expect something special for our anniversary dinner but then he handed me a Now 47 CD, and I got upset, and then he said he was waiting for the right moment and if I kept asking about it it would ruin it, so I waited, and…”

AlexaShutUp · 15/02/2022 18:58

@GoldenOmber

Yeah, but, many of the women posting on here who are waiting for a proposal, want the man to propose because it’s a sign he really actively wants to marry them. It’s not really about who asks first so much as it’s about what that asking means.

Have seen more than one post with a ‘DP’ who clearly doesn’t really want to get married despite two kids and a joint mortgage and a partner who desperately wants to, and it’s clear she doesn’t just want to see him kneeling with a ring for its own sake, she wants getting married to be something he wants enough to do that. (rather than something he passively ambles along with so she doesn’t leave.)

Maybe some of these men are also waiting for a sign that the women actively want to marry them as well? On that basis, they could both end up waiting indefinitely...
GoldenOmber · 15/02/2022 18:56

Yeah, but, many of the women posting on here who are waiting for a proposal, want the man to propose because it’s a sign he really actively wants to marry them. It’s not really about who asks first so much as it’s about what that asking means.

Have seen more than one post with a ‘DP’ who clearly doesn’t really want to get married despite two kids and a joint mortgage and a partner who desperately wants to, and it’s clear she doesn’t just want to see him kneeling with a ring for its own sake, she wants getting married to be something he wants enough to do that. (rather than something he passively ambles along with so she doesn’t leave.)

Swipe left for the next trending thread