Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if your older relatives don’t ‘get’ that you work?

258 replies

Knityourownyoghurt · 13/02/2022 18:21

My dad is in his 60s, has been retired for 10 years & before that was his own boss. However he seems to have totally forgotten what full time work is like. He phones mid afternoon on weekdays expecting a chat and doesn’t ‘get’ that I don’t have half an hour to natter.

MIL, who worked sporadically but never full time and not for many years after having children, offered to look after DD one day a week as she thinks full time nursery is ‘too much for little ones’. When we explained she would have to 100% commit to that day, she seemed confused, and said if something popped up and she couldn’t have DD we would just have to take the day off Hmm

Is this a ‘thing’ or just my relatives?!

OP posts:
Maireas · 14/02/2022 08:13

@trilbydoll

My mum was a teacher. For the first 15 years of my career she really struggled to get her head round the fact I worked all year round and didn't get school holidays off. Or that it being school holidays didn't meant everyone else shut down and work was really quiet.
How odd. I've been a teacher for about 38 years and have never had that attitude, nor come across another teacher that has! That's why we get dental/hairdresser/medical/beauty appointments in the holidays - other people are at work. Your mum is definitely alone in her thinking!
EricScrantona · 14/02/2022 08:06

It's a thing but not necessarily age related. After I had DC, I was invited to a mummy group. They met one day a week and asked me to join, I said I work so won't be able to make it. First it took a while to grasp that I work not only ever day but every week. Then once it was half term... they couldn't believe I worked half term too. Not being a teacher, I'm not sure why they thought I would automatically have the time off!

My gran gets it as she worked but thinks DH is failing because I have to... it's not that, I want to.

My mum started her own business and was annoyed that everyone piled around thinking that working from home meant she was always available. When everyone started wfh for covid, she was always bloody ringing me doing what they had done to her but over the phone.

My dad has always worked from home but work is a strong term. He does no where near his contracted hours but gets everything done and it's a niche area but he's always on YouTube or something. He once met me where I live for lunch as he was passing. I told him I only have one hour lunch but love to meet. When I said I have to go after 50 mins in order to get back he thought I was too "corporate" and should just have a few hours off. Couldn't understand why this wasn't acceptable.

WonderWomansBoobs · 14/02/2022 07:31

My name is a bit like this. She rang me at 10am the other day because she wasn't well (she sometimes stiffens up on a morning and can't get out of bed) but I was at work(not allowed phone). Rang her when I was finished and asked if she'd rang my cousin (who can have her phone) but she said "no,I don't want to disturb her" ffs. I know she's got a higher ranking job than me, but she'd be more than willing to help her.

dizzygirl1 · 14/02/2022 07:23

Yep so so bad my dad isn't even retired yet. But because I wfh, I apparently can call them, do my housework, cook 3 coursemeals and just be available at any point...
Nope I'm working from home, I'm on calls ALL day, lucky if I can make a drink /go to the loo, let alone a lunch break so I have zero time. Also because I'm a woman in an office based role, I obviously just sit there typing away some very important man's notes 🤬🤬🤬

MaryBeardsShoes · 14/02/2022 07:20

Not just older relations. My younger brother will text on a morning asking if I want to go to soft play with my nephew right then. 🤣 Like yes mate I just sit around waiting for you to text.

CoverYourselfInChocolateGlory · 14/02/2022 07:11

Yes!!!! I've had this quite a few times. Currently living with DF and working from home and he frequently thinks he can pop in for a chat or complains he doesn't see much of me. Yes Dad, because I've got a job. It also mildly annoys me that he goes on about me 'working so hard'. Don't get me wrong - I do work quite hard, but it's just a full time job. I rarely work evenings or weekends. I start at 9. It's really not over the top.

middleager · 14/02/2022 00:05

During lockdown when we were both wfh with increased work and kids homeschooling, in laws would call by unannounced for "a cuppa" in the middle of the day. MIL always worked a few hours a week and retired at 60. FIL worked in a factory, clocked on and off and never took work home. It really was a different way of working.

My dad would call in the day, but he's a bit better now. He has even been known to turn up at the office "for lunch" in the past! He was made redundant at 60. When I was a child, he was home just after 5 and I really envy those hours kept. There was not all the involvement with school either in the 70s and 80s. Now, working parents have so much school admin and school events.

When I started work in the 1990s, it was less pressured, no email, long lunches. It's so full on now, plus social media is part of my working world and this comes with stress, along with a work mobile and out of hours calls.

Miserablecat · 13/02/2022 23:28

Me and DH have our own business. MIL commented recently that she thought it was great how I supported Mr miserablecat with his work. I'm pretty sure the assumption was that I was there to make the odd cup of tea and admire what he was doing, not that it actually takes 2 of us working full time for the business to function.
She's always saying it would be nicer if I was home more.
She gave up work in her mid 20s to have children and never went back, so working outside the house was a fairly long time ago for her.

Monopolyiscrap · 13/02/2022 22:52

@Kite22 I have been at work for nearly 40 years now. I am working class though. And spending one day at the weekend visiting grandparents was very common. Some families still do this even if they both work full time.
I am NOT saying you or anyone else should do this. But it is about different ideas of how families should interact and priorities for how you spend your time.
I have friends who work full time and spend most weekends going to family and family events, often Saturday and Sunday. I wouldn't do this, but they just see this as being a close family.

Kite22 · 13/02/2022 22:47

I think this is about family life-changing rather than work. My parents worked full-time and had 3 kids, but visited my gran every single week. This used to be common.

For you maybe. We saw our Grandparents about 3 times a year.

We are all different and it is difficult to generalise.

The fact I can now work at home gives me a freedom and autonomy I couldn't have dreamt of 20 years ago.
I've only been at work 40 years, but have never worked anywhere that involved "going for long boozy lunches". I don't recognise @Octomore 's experience at all.

Which, once again, brings us back to all being different.

eurochick · 13/02/2022 22:42

My parents respect the working week but don't get how time poor we are. My mum didn't return to work after having me and my dad had his own business so could pop out in a quiet five minutes to pick something up for a diy project or go to the bank or whatever - things we only have time to do at the weekends. And sometimes one of us ends up working then too. They also had a lot of help from my grandparents who would baby sit. We've never had any babysitting from them. They turn up to visit and remark that the gutters need clearing or the weeds are coming up. I once pointed out that when I was growing up out of their 2x7 days in the week as a couple, there were 5 out of 14 spent at work. We spend 10-11 at work, and commute (my dad worked locally). They seemed quite offended when I pointed out this difference.

Monopolyiscrap · 13/02/2022 22:37

@Cluelessasacucumber I worked in the council in the eighties. In my team we worked hard. With Tory cuts there was not enough of us. But things were less formal. So you could easily call people and ask them for favours and get it if it was for a good project. We borrowed equipment from events for our outreach work, because my manager was married to a manager in events.

Cluelessasacucumber · 13/02/2022 22:32

@Octomore I agree, I think demands have changed. I work with volunteers, many whom are retired and although they definitely understand working hours they really dont seem to understand how pressurised those hours are, or the costs and formalities involved. They cant grasp that I wont have time to dedicate to their pet projects for example, or that I cant just call up a mate at the council and sort something out rather than book a meeting a month in advance... I think when they were at work things were more relaxed and a lot just got agreed on a handshake over lunch. Not the same now.

cakewitch · 13/02/2022 22:18

Yep.. my father still believes I work for 'pin money' he cannot actually believe that its necessary for two incomes to run a home these days.

Monopolyiscrap · 13/02/2022 22:17

Average working hours in UK are 16750 a year.

clockify.me/working-hours

Personally, I worked much harder hours when younger in the 80's and 90's. And have a much easier time now. But I think it depends on your type of job. DP has the opposite experience in terms of the amount of paperwork, but is expected to work with less people per day than in the past.

MindyStClaire · 13/02/2022 22:15

Yup. We have this with PIL. Before covid, it was whether I wore a uniform because "the girls in the bank do", and whether DH gives me much housekeeping. I was in a profession in finance.

During the first lockdown we were both WFH full-time, looking after two year old and I was heavily pregnant - were we enjoying our break?

These days DH is back in the office roughly once a week. Every Sunday they ask "are you working at all this week?". Drives him insane.

They have a very stereotypical public sector view of work being 9-5 and not a minute more - things like no one covering our work if we're on holidays are completely alien. They were flabbergasted when I had to nip away and do an hour on a Sunday recently.

My mum who gave up work years before she had DC is the one who fully gets it. MIL worked til her 60s, albeit part-time, and FIL still works at 78 in his own business. It's bizarre and infuriating in equal measure.

bumblingbovine49 · 13/02/2022 22:03

This happened to my parents once they had been retired a few years . They worked for 50,+ years each so it wasn't that they had never worked. I think as they got older they just forgot what having a job was like . A bit like me having forgotten what having s baby / toddler is like now I am in my 50s Grin

My parents died in their late 80s/ early 90d and retired at (60 ) my mother) and 65 ( my father) so were retired for 25+ years. Long enough to forget the specifics of their working lives

Octomore · 13/02/2022 22:02

[quote Monopolyiscrap]@Octomore All the data shows hours worked have fallen over the last seventy years.[/quote]
Ok, well that doesn't tally with my experience in office based 'professional' jobs over the last +20 years (I've worked in both public and private sector).

In my experience, workdays used to involve a lot less activity than they do now. Many workplaces used to have a culture where going for a long boozy lunch a few days a week was the norm - that's not how it is now.

My experience is that expectations of employees have shifted hugely since the late 90s. It used to be rare to get requests to turn around sizable pieces of work extremely quickly at short notice, now it's almost a weekly occurrence.

AcrossthePond55 · 13/02/2022 22:01

Nope.

My mum and dad (born 1921 and 1914 respectively) always understood what working full time meant. Same for DH's parents (1926/1922). And now that we're retired we get that our adult DC work full time. Although with WFH and the types of jobs DS1 and DiL have, they now have more free hours during the day than we ever did. But we still don't bother them during the day. And we remember that DS2 works a late shift so we don't call him in the mornings.

I do think that part of it for my and DH's mothers was that they both worked before we were born as well as returning to work in our teen years. I can see where a person who has either never worked outside the home or hasn't for 20+ years might forget about 'working hours' or the restrictions working puts on one's flexibility.

FlyingPandas · 13/02/2022 21:57

I agree it's about selfish / self-absorbed attitudes, rather than age.

My DP retired nearly 25 years ago (DF is 84, DM a few years younger) but they wouldn't dream of just randomly calling/popping in or disrespecting working hours. They both seem to remember well enough what the stress of a working week was like, as does MIL, who is similar. We speak regularly and send regular text messages through the week but they would only make an urgent call if it was a genuine emergency i.e. something medical or a car accident or something.

We are obviously very lucky but I wonder whether part of the problem is with retired people who just don't have enough in their lives to keep them occupied. My DP and inlaws all belong to various clubs and societies and are always off out doing this that and the other, they wouldn't have time to keep calling us/popping in for cups of tea etc.

Monopolyiscrap · 13/02/2022 21:56

@Octomore All the data shows hours worked have fallen over the last seventy years.

LadyCatStark · 13/02/2022 21:52

My parents still work but PILs are like this. They’re nearly 70 and we’re lucky to retire at 60 as did DH’s auntie and uncle at a similar time. DH’s sister hasn’t worked in years and when his grandparents were alive, they were obviously long retired. DH has a small family and therefore DH and I are the only ones in the whole family that work. The rest of them can do all sorts of lovely things during weekday days and they’ll organise important events but say they understand we can’t come because we’re working which I guess they think is understanding but it would be more inclusive of us to organise things when we’re not working!

Realitea · 13/02/2022 21:45

Yep. My dad calls me every single day. Always at times when I’m busy. He knows I work, knows I have to get my dd from school at 3. He rarely has anything to really say as he’s retired and has admitted he’s bored. It’s usually while he waits for his partner to come out of the supermarket so I’m being used to kill time. If I don’t answer he will keep calling, then call my Dh who is also working. I feel mean but it’s really quite annoying. I wouldn’t mind if he called me in the evening after dinner time but he’s usually in bed by 7!

Octomore · 13/02/2022 21:44

I think also, what "full time work" involves has changed a lot in the last 20-30 years. I think this is a big part of why some retired people don't 'get' the pressures that many workers are under in 2022.

  • People use to live closer to work in average, so they'd get home fairly soon after finishing work.
  • In most professions, people used to finish roughly on time (or even early). Now, it's rare for someone in a 'professional' role to be able to walk out the door at 5pm on the dot. 10-12 hr days are fairly normal in many workplaces.
  • Work is much more fast paced now, and a hell of a lot more gets squeezed into the working day. This is driven by lots of factors, including the instant communication that emails deliver. (Back in the day, people would dictate memos and letters.) Overall productivity may not have gone up (I'm not sure), but the 'busywork' of reading and dealing with hundreds of emails a day definitely has.

So someone who works full time in a professional role in 2022 will probably work longer hours than the equivalent worker in 1990, have a longer commute, and be expected to cram much more activity into their hours, making them more tired at the end of the day. And then they still have the normal life admin to sort out - cooking dinner etc.

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 13/02/2022 21:36

@Whattochoosenow

Yes my parents seem genuinely surprised I have to work between Christmas and New Year. We have the same surprised conversation every year.
Same with my PILs. Every year they express shock, sadness, and disbelief that my workplace expects me in on the days between Boxing Day and New Year's Day.

This is even more laughable when you know that I work in a hospital, so actually just getting the bank holidays off is a very good deal indeed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread