Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Katherine Ryan reckons her eight month old is toilet trained

220 replies

WheelieBinPrincess · 13/02/2022 15:31

Now, if I held my baby over the loo for a couple of hours for want of something better to do on a rainy Sunday, I reckon eventually he’d use it. I could then clap and proclaim I had started toilet training Hmm

AIBU to think she’s off her rocker? Apparently, putting your baby in a nappy means you are teaching them to always go in a nappy.

I know she has a nanny to deal with all this as well, who Im sure rolls her eyes at the proclamation that her baby is fully potty trained at 8mo.

Reminds me of a friend of mine who claimed her newborn learnt to use a hand signal for hunger from day 2 or 3 so she didn’t need to cry. She was apparently fluent in baby sign from two months old.

OP posts:
WheelieBinPrincess · 13/02/2022 16:27

Ok so she’s able to use less nappies, and that’s great because we know they just pile up rotting in landfills, which is awful, and cloth or reusable ones are an expensive outlay and not very practical and have to sit around festering between washes.

That’s not the same as your baby being trained to know when to go to the toilet or communicate it though, is it.

OP posts:
Plasmodesmata · 13/02/2022 16:26

I did this. For poo not wee though. Once they could sit up I'd sit them on a potty when changing nappy, and they would then poo in the potty. Saved on dealing with poo in washables - they did still wear them to catch wee until about 19 months (I remember this, because first one was out of nappies in the day by the time the second was born).
My mum did the same with me (she was hand washing terry nappies which tends to focus the mind a bit) and my granny did the same with my mum.
Waiting until they are 3 has definitely coincided with greater access to washing machines and disposable nappies.
So it's not a new thing. More of an old thing.

mummymei · 13/02/2022 16:25

Exactly @Beamur

I was potty trained at 11 months, but it wasn't that unusual back in the 70s.

Terry nappies meant babies quickly felt uncomfortable if wet, meant babies became much more aware of the discomfort of a wet nappy. Disposables really don't help our children to know.

As I could walk at 11 months, when I needed a wee, I just sat on the potty. There was a potty in every room. I remember my aunt potty training my cousin the same way at around the age of 1. Once they could walk they could potty train. Probably helped by the fact both my cousins and I were summer born, so to start off with, just walked around naked to facilitate easy potty access.

veevee04 · 13/02/2022 16:25

I think this could be true when I went to China people put their babies over grids to wee. I have no idea how they could tell but it seemed to work!!

OfstedOffred · 13/02/2022 16:24

This is 100% the norm in loads of parts of the world. It's time consuming but her choice, I dont see why we have to judge her for doing something millions of mothers do and have done for millennia.

Nappies are gross and bad for the environment (washable use a lot of energy to wash) so have no objection to her promoting this

formalineadeline · 13/02/2022 16:22

@WheelieBinPrincess

This is nothing to do with what they do in other parts of the world, through necessity or differing cultural practices, totally different and not my point at all.

No I don’t believe she has potty trained her eight month old baby, at least not in the way she thinks.

I actually think what is done in the rest of the world is entirely relevant. Your starting point here was that this is impossible and weird because it is outside your experiences and expectations as a western person.

That's just arrogant. The way we do things in the West isn't automatically superior and it's certainly not the only way.

WheelieBinPrincess · 13/02/2022 16:22

Sorry @13yearslater I missed the joke!
Grin

OP posts:
Pembertonrd · 13/02/2022 16:22

@lucillelarusso

Why do so many MNers accuse people with very normal experiences of lying? Just because they have different customs? I did this, both fully trained by 1, no accidents and no issues caused. I was very poor and hated the washable nappies drying everywhere, it was hell being in a 1 bed damp back to back so I put the work it and it wasn't hard at all. People are different, stop mocking those of us from other cultures who don't accept the British way is the only way.
What happens with dc who bed wet ? That’s a maturity thing so how would this method work in those cases?
mowglika · 13/02/2022 16:22

When people say things like ‘my grandmother trained all of hers by 1’ what does that mean? was the child in normal underwear and taking themselves to the toilet at age 1, or was the parent still doing a routine
of holding them over a toilet or terry cloth after lunch, after naps etc? Because the two are very different things.

Beamur · 13/02/2022 16:20

My Mum claimed I was potty trained by 1. I think she would just put me on the potty quite often when it was likely i would need a wee! After a nap/feed etc. Plus terry nappies were not as dry to wear as modern disposables. So I wonder if kids did become aware of wetness younger. It meant less nappies were used but it's not the same as expecting a child to be able to understand the need to go to the toilet. I think it's less common in the UK than it used to be - I think my Mum was far from unusual in her approach.

Pembertonrd · 13/02/2022 16:20

@13yearslater

My son knew 26 capital cities by the age of 2 including Chisinau and Baku. What on earth was I thinking.
Grin
WheelieBinPrincess · 13/02/2022 16:19

@13yearslater

My son knew 26 capital cities by the age of 2 including Chisinau and Baku. What on earth was I thinking.
What’s that got to do with the price of fish Confused
OP posts:
HotChoc10 · 13/02/2022 16:19

Is anyone going to explain what elimination communication is then?

LorelaiDeservedBetter · 13/02/2022 16:19

You don't know about the practise because you don't know what happens in other countries or cultures (or happened in the UK historically). That's entirely the point. You thought you could sneer at KR but by doing so you're sneering at a practise that is common in other cultures.
There's a real parochial paternalism about that attitude ... and that's without even touching on your claim that people would be washing cloth nappies or would need a toilet or potty nearby.

13yearslater · 13/02/2022 16:18

My son knew 26 capital cities by the age of 2 including Chisinau and Baku. What on earth was I thinking.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 13/02/2022 16:16

My mother start training us from 6 weeks.

To be fair, that number of children, it was probably an essential survival mechanism.

lucillelarusso · 13/02/2022 16:15

Why do so many MNers accuse people with very normal experiences of lying? Just because they have different customs?
I did this, both fully trained by 1, no accidents and no issues caused.
I was very poor and hated the washable nappies drying everywhere, it was hell being in a 1 bed damp back to back so I put the work it and it wasn't hard at all.
People are different, stop mocking those of us from other cultures who don't accept the British way is the only way.

WheelieBinPrincess · 13/02/2022 16:12

This is nothing to do with what they do in other parts of the world, through necessity or differing cultural practices, totally different and not my point at all.

No I don’t believe she has potty trained her eight month old baby, at least not in the way she thinks.

OP posts:
SisterAgatha · 13/02/2022 16:11

*She would lay a Terry nappy on the floor and hold baby over it, so no toilet or potty used in all instances.

There are no differences in the behaviour of the children here. Just in the actions of the parent by holding them over something. The child has not learned to use the potty or the Terry Towel or anything except empty their bladder. The behaviour of the parent is facilitating all of this.

Id call the parent trained, not the child. Grin

Whitefire · 13/02/2022 16:11

It is not potty training as such, it is wee and poo catching. There are hormonal and physical development involved with continence.

Somethingsnappy · 13/02/2022 16:10

The elimination method, whilst perfectly valid, is not potty training in the sense that most people in the UK know it. A very young baby could probably (!) not know they needed the toilet, communicate this, hold it in long enough to find a toilet, and then pull down their own clothes and sit on the toilet independently, all of which is usually how a potty trained child is recognised in the UK.

Ivegottagoforaliedown · 13/02/2022 16:10

I heard about this! Watching this thread as I'm intrigued to hear views

BearOfEasttown · 13/02/2022 16:10

@Totalwasteofpaper

My grandma had 9!!!! And did this.

All her children were toilet trained by 1 Shock
I will prob be too lazy Blush

Is that what she told you? That ALL 9 of her children were potty trained by the age of 1?

And you believed her?!

JuliaSways · 13/02/2022 16:08

@WheelieBinPrincess

You’d have to always be in reach of a toilet or potty I presume which just sounds totally impractical for most people, unless her baby never really leaves the house.
My grandma did it with all her children (5) including twins. She told me about it when I was pg with my first. She would lay a Terry nappy on the floor and hold baby over it, so no toilet or potty used in all instances.

It wasn't for me and it made my grandma laugh when I later told her it was called Elimination Conditioning, she thought it was daft as it is an age old way to do things and was just how it was done in rural Hampshire in the 40s and 50s.

BearOfEasttown · 13/02/2022 16:07

@Shehasadiamondinthesky

I know a few people who did that very successfully, my DS wasn't bad he was 2.5 and then dry at night at 3. He was a heavy sleeper so had the odd nightime accident. I worked full time but the childminder was on board with it. Better than going to school in nappies.
That's not 8 months though is it?
Swipe left for the next trending thread