Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Katherine Ryan reckons her eight month old is toilet trained

220 replies

WheelieBinPrincess · 13/02/2022 15:31

Now, if I held my baby over the loo for a couple of hours for want of something better to do on a rainy Sunday, I reckon eventually he’d use it. I could then clap and proclaim I had started toilet training Hmm

AIBU to think she’s off her rocker? Apparently, putting your baby in a nappy means you are teaching them to always go in a nappy.

I know she has a nanny to deal with all this as well, who Im sure rolls her eyes at the proclamation that her baby is fully potty trained at 8mo.

Reminds me of a friend of mine who claimed her newborn learnt to use a hand signal for hunger from day 2 or 3 so she didn’t need to cry. She was apparently fluent in baby sign from two months old.

OP posts:
Wedonttalkabout · 14/02/2022 22:47

@HollowTalk

In short it's about picking up on cues that babys need to toilet and using that opportunity to place them on a potty/toilet often earlier then when a child could verbalise this or take themselves. For some people it's about knowing when the baby is likely to go eg. After meals, others it's about recognising a poo face, others build a routine themselves

It's far more common in other countries

HollowTalk · 14/02/2022 22:31

Does anyone else want to know what elimination communication means but is too scared to ask?

Luredbyapomegranate · 14/02/2022 22:20

@TheWayTheLightFalls

It’s a thing in other parts of the world, as PP said. My husband was raised in the USSR. Nurseries wouldn’t take kids who weren’t toilet trained. MIL needed to work. DH and his bro were trained by 12 months, she says.
I think potty training has got later in the West through the last century hasn’t it? Now it can be really quite late, in the 70s/80s you’d expect kids to be trained by 2, I’ve been told in the 30s/40s it was more like a year or 18 months.
BoredZelda · 14/02/2022 21:56

I knew someone would say something snarky about that. I have zero issue with paid childcare- I’m a nanny myself (on maternity leave) I’m simply saying she would probably not be able to do what she’s claiming if it was just on her.

Presumably, if you knew someone would say something which you would perceive as snarky, you thought about not making it about the fact she has nannies. But given you are apparently one, it’s clearly a chip you have on your shoulder about work you do with parents take credit for.

thirdfiddle · 14/02/2022 07:19

He did wear nappies whch he sometimes weed in but never did a poo in them
Ah yes, agree, that sort of not quite EC we did with childminder too, DD was similarly not pooing in nappies by the time she went at 1. I just meant not the no-nappy watch for cues aspect.

Chichimcgee · 13/02/2022 23:47

I have a brother who was potty trained at 9 months old. He HATED nappies, hated feeling wet or dirty and basically potty trained himself because of that. Another brother was around 6 and wet the bed until 16.
Everyone is different and I personally can’t bring myself to be bothered how old anyone’s kid is when they do something. I call it a great day if me and ds survive it to be honest without this competitiveness!

PinkPinkPinkGreen · 13/02/2022 23:42

Read the article and it seems fair enough. Mine isn’t potty trained at 18 months but different strokes for different folks.

Wanderingowl · 13/02/2022 23:39

My DS literally did one poo in a nappy after he turned 6.5 months, two weeks after I introduced the potty to him. It was when he was 9 months old and we'd gone to stay with a terminally ill family member and I believe it was because he was feeling my distress. Even when he was nearly one and we all got a norovirus infection, he did every single poo in the potty. He realised very, very, very quickly that he didn't have to soil himself and refused to. It actually took me a little longer to fully accept what he was doing when he communicated his need to use the potty to me, as it was mind-boggling that it was really what was happening but it was. It took him longer to learn not to pee in the nappy but in the spring after his first birthday, I stopped putting nappies on him and it only took wetting his clothes a couple of times for him to decide he didn't want to. By 15 months he wasn't even wetting at night.

Quite a few of my friends did the same with their children after seeing my DS and they all had pretty much the same results. In fact one of my friends introduced the potty at a few days old and her baby almost never pooed in his nappy past 2.5 months.

Bizawit · 13/02/2022 23:10

YABU. It’s called elimination communication. I’ve done it with both my DC. It is so much more hygienic than nappies, more comfortable for babies, helps with soothing/ burping, and they are fully toilet trained (out of nappies completely) much earlier without all the toilet “training” fuss. I don’t know why more people don’t do it!

0blio · 13/02/2022 23:04

My mother did it with me. Not having disposable nappies or a washing machine or dryer and not going out to work meant she had the motivation to do it. I also apparently gave very clear signs when I needed to go Smile
She said I was reliably out of nappies at 9 months of age.

Kermitsolvestheclimate · 13/02/2022 22:41

"I wouldn't ask a nursery to do EC though anyway. They don't have time to pay the amount of attention required." We did and the nursery were really happy to do it as it wasn;t any extra effort, it was less effort. I didn;t insist they did it, I just asked if they would be happy to try and they did and said they prefered it! DS was 12 months when he went to nursery. He did wear nappies whch he sometimes weed in but never did a poo in them as by then he did all his poos in the loo on his Bumbo toilet seat (which sort of held him in place without needing to be held). When they changed all the babies nappies after naps or before lunch or whenever, they would just sit him on his potty seat, no problem. Easier and more pleasent for them than changing his shitty nappies.

thirdfiddle · 13/02/2022 19:21

@Footsanitiser

"Training" a baby suggests you are teaching them something or that they will learn to do x y or z. From what I've seen in the very young babies at least the baby doesn't change their behaviour, the parent changes theirs, in response to learning what the babies signals are.
Mine did change her behaviour, she learned to empty bladder/bowel on cue if she had anything to do. I think she learned to wait longer too, or at least wasn't trained /out/ of the wait for open air instinct so gaps naturally widened.

It's not potty training in the undress self and climb on toilet sense. It is in the don't mess your nappy sense.

PeakyBlender · 13/02/2022 19:14

Also to the person asking, they pay to be in papers like the Daily mail and the sun, on the sidebar. Lottie Moss and Rizzo etc do the same too, the articles are paid for by their PR people to generate interest (I used to be in charge of these at a newspaper)

Katherine is on tour at the moment and it's not sold out so these articles help, although this particular one isn't paid for by her PR team, it's just an interesting POV

PeakyBlender · 13/02/2022 19:09

I was more shocked by her face. She looks nothing like herself at all.

Pumperthepumper · 13/02/2022 18:54

@MajorCarolDanvers

I had to google who she is as I'd never heard of her.

Of course her child is not actually potty trained. But announcing it to the world gets her some media coverage which in turn will boost her profile and enable her career.

She doesn’t need it. Most people have heard of Katherine Ryan.
Unmumsymofo · 13/02/2022 18:51

EC is awsome for the environment and frankly my washing basket as we cloth nappy but it’s been a part time journey for us and at 18m we are not potty trained! Though I am going to start when the weather is warmer and I think it will be an advantage. Nappies take like hundreds of years to degrade and huge amounts of resources to make so for us that was the motivation. Genuine respect to cultures still practicing EC!

MajorCarolDanvers · 13/02/2022 18:42

I had to google who she is as I'd never heard of her.

Of course her child is not actually potty trained. But announcing it to the world gets her some media coverage which in turn will boost her profile and enable her career.

Taswama · 13/02/2022 18:41

@toomuchlaundry

How does this work for night time dryness, which is down to hormones?

DS was quite happy lying in his own poo after soiling his nappy when he was bed, he certainly didn’t have a problem of soiling his own bed.

Think modern disposable nappies do delay potty training, because many babies probably hate having a wet bum, and they don’t get that sensation with disposables.

We didn’t rush into potty training with DS, partly because we had a reasonably long commute to his nursery, so wanted him to be able to be able to hold on and not immediately go for a wee once he needed the loo. I assume EC isn’t much use when you are driving at 70mph with nowhere to pull over!

We used to put dc in a nappy for car journeys. We once drove 3 hours to see ILs. We took him to the toilet as soon as we got there and the nappy was bone dry.
Footsanitiser · 13/02/2022 18:39

"Training" a baby suggests you are teaching them something or that they will learn to do x y or z. From what I've seen in the very young babies at least the baby doesn't change their behaviour, the parent changes theirs, in response to learning what the babies signals are.

Pr1mr0se · 13/02/2022 18:35

"Toilet trained" surely means being able to go to the toilet successfully without needing a nappy, or prompting or a hovering adult. A baby cannot do this, this is mummy bragging.

BuffyTheBuffetSlayer · 13/02/2022 18:34

I did this with 2 of my DC starting at 6 weeks old. Not full on EC, never looked for cues, never hovered them over the potty for hours either Confused After every feed or clothes change I'd put them on the potty for 5 to 10 minutes which is all it took.

By around 8 weeks, as they got used to it, they were doing their business almost straight away then I'd put a nappy on them. When they were crawling they'd crawl to the potty themselves and do the toilet and by 1yo they were in proper underwear.

It never stopped me taking them out, or visiting other people.

Only reason I did it was because it was something that took very little effort on my part and had great results.

Mischance · 13/02/2022 18:28

When my baby sister arrived I was 9. My Mum used to hold her over the pot after every feed, just for a few minutes, making sure the pot touched her skin so she could feel it. Inevitably there was often a bit of follow-through after a feed and lots of offerings were caught in the pot. I do not know how far this could actually be regarded as training, or how long-lived the results were, but I have a lot of sympathy with her as she had terry nappies to deal with and no washing machine!

Fizbosshoes · 13/02/2022 18:26

Neither of my DC were reliably dry at night until they were 7. Both were potty trained (in the conventional way - it took about 8 days iirc) when they were 2. (DS was nearly 3)
But the health visitor and Dr told me they could not be "trained " to be dry at night.

FlyingPandas · 13/02/2022 18:23

@WheelieBinPrincess

She has at least one full time nanny so it would be interesting to know how much dangling over a potty or cleaning up a carpet of wee she’s undertaking herself in order to make these claims.
As other PP have said, she used the same method with her daughter who is now 12, and based on various interviews and social media comments etc she was parenting on her own and very much struggling financially from when Violet was tiny.

I don’t doubt she has a stack of help now and she’s very obviously very wealthy from her Insta posts -beautiful house, dripping in designer gear, frankly, good on her if that’s what she wants - but she has previously used the same method with a baby, way before she was famous and wealthy, which does slightly add to her credibility here.

Footsanitiser · 13/02/2022 18:23

IMHO, not using nappies full time and training a baby are 2 separate things.
From what I've read it's more about parents reading expressions or recognising signs that a baby is about to wee or poo. Or realising there is a pattern to their bowel or bladder movements. I noticed DS did a wee immediately after having a bath when he was about 1, and started sitting him on the potty. I didn't train him to do anything, I just realised I could save a nappy or in a few cases a wet carpet if I sat him on the potty at that point.

In the case of a very young baby (months) I'm sure they are completely unaware that they are making a face/doing something different with their hand etc. It's the parent that is actively observing and recognising the sign and then making the effort to catch the wee or poo in something other than a nappy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread