Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I too old to be a midwife

81 replies

goodnightgrumble · 13/02/2022 15:23

So I am 47 (only just) and a primary school teacher. I would like to retrain to be a midwife but. It sure if I will be considered too old. I will need biology or an access before I start so I will be 51 when I qualify! My current degree is primary Ed with English so not relevant at all.

My children are older now (I have 5) and I feel that I am in a position to finally retrain! What do you think? I am not bothered to be in classes with younger ones but would like some real honest opinions from midwives or mature students.
Funding not a problem as I funded my degree first time round.

OP posts:
Ironingoutthecreases · 13/02/2022 19:43

If you do apply OP, I would focus on your transferable skills from teaching (safeguarding etc), rather than being a mother. The ratio of applicants (who meet the entry criteria) to places is around 28:1.

goodnightgrumble · 13/02/2022 19:30

@titchy

Giving birth five times between the ages of 23 and 40 would also make me more experienced than a midwife who has trained at 21!

You were at the business end for none of your births. How arrogant.

I was been defensive not arrogant as the previous poster said I would be inexperienced! Maybe I worded it wrong but I meant that I would be just as experienced as any other midwife. have the emotional and physical experience of giving birth. I myself, found more of a connection with midwives who had experienced birth themselves. Of course the midwives who haven't given birth were incredible but I found it more comfortable to be with someone who understood. My experience will not be the same for everyone. Some won't give a shit!
OP posts:
goodnightgrumble · 13/02/2022 19:22

@lulubelle6

I don't think the OP was saying she was more experienced than a 22 year old she was saying that at least she would have an understanding of actually going through labour rather than someone 22 that hasn't experienced it! To be honest I'd rather have OP knowing exactly what I'm going through and can understand the pain and fear compared to someone who hasn't!! People are so quick to jump on an issue! Go for it OP it sounds amazing.
This! Thankyou!
OP posts:
goodnightgrumble · 13/02/2022 19:21

I apologise! I did not mean it to sound demeaning to younger midwives. Just the comment about you will be ready for retirement wound me up!
I meant to get across that I would be trained like any other person that has done the training!

OP posts:
Kitkat151 · 13/02/2022 19:08

[quote Simonesignoret]**@alfreddo87* as a 'senior nurse' (like every nurse on MN Hmm) surely you don't do nights ? From my experience the higher up the management ladder the less* the stress and physical/emotional challenges. Just endless meetings and delegating.[/quote]
Band 6 would be classed as ‘senior’....so a junior sister would definately still be on a rota for nights.....someone needs to be in charge of a ward

Simonesignoret · 13/02/2022 19:02

@alfreddo87 as a 'senior nurse' (like every nurse on MN Hmm) surely you don't do nights ? From my experience the higher up the management ladder the less the stress and physical/emotional challenges. Just endless meetings and delegating.

Kitkat151 · 13/02/2022 18:52

@CovidCorvid I think many non nurses/midwifes would be shocked at how time is spent completing documentation..... around 70% in my nursing role I would say

CovidCorvid · 13/02/2022 18:50

@pancakes22

Finding this thread interesting as was also considering retraining but in 40s rather than 50s. For those saying 50s is too old, would you say the same for 40s in terms of coping with the mental/physical demands? To those comments re the hard work and sinking ship etc would you think this also applies as a maternity support worker rather than a midwife? OP have you thought of being a maternity assistant rather than a midwife?
Pros and cons. I think MSW get to spend more time providing care to women especially postnatally. But not as much autonomy, don’t get as involved in antenatal care or labour. But less paperwork. So I can see there could be good job satisfaction from that point. Midwives seem to spend more time on documentation than caring for women at times!
Ironingoutthecreases · 13/02/2022 18:40

A maternity assistant has the benefit of providing hands on care, particularly on postnatal ward, without the professional responsibility. It is still a route into midwifery, though many Trusts no longer offer secondment (where you are paid to train for your degree) and you’ll have a good grasp of the realities of NHS practice. In time I think we’ll see more band 4 posts in a similar way that’s happening with nursing. That could be a good option.

pancakes22 · 13/02/2022 18:14

Finding this thread interesting as was also considering retraining but in 40s rather than 50s. For those saying 50s is too old, would you say the same for 40s in terms of coping with the mental/physical demands? To those comments re the hard work and sinking ship etc would you think this also applies as a maternity support worker rather than a midwife? OP have you thought of being a maternity assistant rather than a midwife?

missingeu · 13/02/2022 18:01

Go for it, I retrained as a nurse mid 40s, best thing ever.
It'll be hard but worth it if its something you want to do.

Good luck.

TottersBlankly · 13/02/2022 17:58

I’m only sad that you preferred AIBU to the actual Mature Study and Retraining board …

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/mature_students

Sad
Thewindwhispers · 13/02/2022 17:55

Talk to some midwives about it. I hear it’s a job that’s very physically demanding especially hard on the knees, but what so I know 😬

Grapewrath · 13/02/2022 17:46

And please don’t assume that giving birth makes you experienced as a midwife. It’s like saying driving a car qualifies you as a mechanic.

TheyTookTheCrownButItsAllRight · 13/02/2022 17:46

I don't see why not.

My mum retrained as a nurse in her mid 40s. Late 50s now, and has been a registered nurse for almost 10 years. Go for it.

CovidCorvid · 13/02/2022 17:46

@lulubelle6

I don't think the OP was saying she was more experienced than a 22 year old she was saying that at least she would have an understanding of actually going through labour rather than someone 22 that hasn't experienced it! To be honest I'd rather have OP knowing exactly what I'm going through and can understand the pain and fear compared to someone who hasn't!! People are so quick to jump on an issue! Go for it OP it sounds amazing.
Even that is a dangerous attitude. I’d had a baby before I trained as a midwife but I would never have dared to presume that meant I understood what someone else is going through. People have their own very individual experiences.

Rather than assuming what someone is going through is the same I went through, and putting my own feelings and values on their experience I’d prefer to talk to them and listen to them and reflect on what they’re telling me.

A decent student will learn how to do that over their training. Some of the best midwives I know don’t have children.

Plus you can’t experience every complication and type of birth even with 5 kids!

Grapewrath · 13/02/2022 17:45

You’re not too old.. however you need to be very energetic and physically fit. Most midwives go into it hoping to support and empower women and discover the reality is actually exhausting and gruelling. Id volunteer up on the wards before you commit

titchy · 13/02/2022 17:44

Giving birth five times between the ages of 23 and 40 would also make me more experienced than a midwife who has trained at 21!

You were at the business end for none of your births. How arrogant.

alfreddo87 · 13/02/2022 17:44

Hhmmmm I'm in two minds about what to say.

On the one hand I would advise against joining the NHS, especially as a nurse or midwife, as it's an absolutely draining job sometimes (I'm a senior nurse not midwife) nights and 12 hour shifts im keen to get away from now in my mid 30s as been in the job since I was 18. Also the lowest rung of a band 5 is a really shit salary.

On the other hand if you are really passionate about it then go for it, I had a lovely colleague who trained as a nurse in her late 40s after many years as an auxiliary nurse. She qualified at 50 and is still working now at 60 however she does outpatients clinics and vaccinations so avoids the shite shifts.

Also don't pay attention to the posters saying that having had 5 children won't give you an advantage in the job, of course it will! I'm on my third pregnancy and of all the midwives I've encountered, the more experienced ones with children of their own always stand out from the crowd.

Good luck whatever you decide to do. It's a hard job but if you enjoy it then it's worth it.

USaYwHatNow · 13/02/2022 17:40

Yeah sorry, I was with you 100% until you said you'd be more experienced having had children than a 21 year old childless midwife.

Im a childless midwife with 7 years post qualification experience on top of my three years of training?

As you've had all those babies, could you manage a shoulder dystocia? PPH? Cannulate a woman as she seizing during an eclamptic fit? Errrm no probably not, so please drop that attitude or you'll piss a lot of people off

Ironingoutthecreases · 13/02/2022 17:40

The real learning curve is upon qualifying when you hold your own registration and that is at risk each and every shift. It’s a huge adjustment to working under your supervisors PIN.

Contemporary practice is incredibly demanding OP As for your own birth experiences benefitting you, I’d completely disagree as it can affect your ability to be compassionate to others. Don’t bring that baggage with you.

Kitkat151 · 13/02/2022 17:40

@lulubelle6

I don't think the OP was saying she was more experienced than a 22 year old she was saying that at least she would have an understanding of actually going through labour rather than someone 22 that hasn't experienced it! To be honest I'd rather have OP knowing exactly what I'm going through and can understand the pain and fear compared to someone who hasn't!! People are so quick to jump on an issue! Go for it OP it sounds amazing.
‘Giving birth 5 times would make me more experienced than a midwife who trained at 21’ ....lthose are OPs words🙄
Blinkingheckythump · 13/02/2022 17:40

@Iwonder08

Don't do it. The last thing poor women need in this country is yet another inexperienced midwife. By the time you are fully qualified and gain some experience in the field you will be nearing retirement age
What an absolutely stupid post. Regardless of the age of the mw every single person becoming a mw has the same training /experience when they start the role
lulubelle6 · 13/02/2022 17:37

I don't think the OP was saying she was more experienced than a 22 year old she was saying that at least she would have an understanding of actually going through labour rather than someone 22 that hasn't experienced it!
To be honest I'd rather have OP knowing exactly what I'm going through and can understand the pain and fear compared to someone who hasn't!! People are so quick to jump on an issue!
Go for it OP it sounds amazing.

Miranda14 · 13/02/2022 17:35

It might be worthwhile to try some bank shifts as a health care assistant on a midwifery ward before you commit. Then you will see the reality !!