Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think This Is Going To Hurt is awful to women?

390 replies

justanoldhack · 13/02/2022 13:39

Watching the show and can't help but shake a really uncomfortable feeling that its writer just...really doesn't like women.

I get that doctors are super overstretched, so tired, giving the job everything at the expense of their personal lives. I also get that it's a 'comedy' and not real, although it is based on his true life experiences.

But the way the women are portrayed as silly, a nuisance, stupid, battleaxes, or simply a vessel that 'covers his pubes in blood'... feels so off. These are women at one of the most vulnerable moments in their lives, but they're just props, the butt of the jokes. I can't shake the feeling that Adam Kay really, really doesn't like women. Definitely does not respect them.

Thanks goodness, I guess, that he's not longer practicing medicine. And not surprised either to learn that when he was younger he wrote 'comedy' songs about babies with Down's Syndrome and women from the North.

OP posts:
AnnaMagnani · 13/02/2022 19:50

I lived on site - a diet that consists solely of sausages and chips is not a healthy diet and has left me with lifelong obesity. However we did support each other as fellow juniors which has now been lost.

A life of moving every 6 months isn't appealing so while I did genuinely want to do my specialty, the fact I wouldn't have to do nights or weekends was definitely part of the appeal.

And along the way I failed to have the relationship or the kids. So you could says that was another sacrifice for medicine.

By the time I was able to have a chance to date - as a consultant - it was basically too late for kids. And I didn't want to have children I didn't see. So that was that.

It's a career that it is still highly misogynistic to it's staff and has a long way to go.

Franca123 · 13/02/2022 19:46

I don't know anything about the book or the author but I'm really enjoying the TV series. They're not celebrating the protagonist or his behaviour at all. It's clear he's a broken, damaged man whose fucking up.

Cbtb · 13/02/2022 19:39

@AutomaticMoon

Things have got better with shift length in the last 20 years

The reason for not enough students are complex:

  1. The government doesn't want to pay for more medical students
  2. There are not enough hospital spaces for students - patients don’t want students especially in obs and Gynae - there was a recent thread on here where the consensus seemed to be that medical students shouldn’t have obs and Gynae experience and it should be post grad only
  3. Qualified doctors are so busy with work they can’t spare the time to train more students (catch 22 this, train less = more work in the long run)
  4. The medical unions have lobbied hard for Medical school places to be capped at the number of foundation programme jobs (this isn’t the unions not wanting more doctors so they earn more as it’s often portrayed but that so all uk medical school grads can get a pre-reg foundation year job as in most counties this year would be part of medical school. It’s only after this year you become fully registered with the GMC and can seek other employment. Medical unions would support an increase in medical school places as long as foundation places are also increased otherwise you don’t get more “proper” doctors for your increased money.

Other than foundation there are shortages right across the medical fields. Hours are in theory limited but we are volun-told to opt out of the WTD. You might be down to work a 12 hour shift but when the next slot is vacant you end up staying because there is no one to hand over to.

The reduction in working hours has meant we now do “full shift”. These rotate between days, nights and lates. Hospitals want the most work they can squeeze from each dr so instead of designing rota patterns that go from days to lates to nights and then time off you get insane shifts that switch from day to night and back again without rests. You end up permanently jet lagged. You feel like you do in that newborn stage when you are just so bone tired everything’s hazy.

Some tiny specialities like psychiatry and neurosurgery are just so short staffed that there are simply not enough qualified doctors in these areas to staff the On calls without people being on for 72hrs at a time.

Junior doctors are not allocated admin time- so you are scheduled to see patients from 8-6 in a normal day but that does not include time to write letters to patients and check notes and audit your practice or have meetings with your mentors or clinical meetings about department improvements etc or teach students. All that is done in your own time before or after work or on your days off.

You are also advised by the royal colleges in order to pass the exams for the next stage of training you should be putting in 2hrs study per day after work (what i should be doing now) as junior doctor jobs are all about keeping the service afloat - there is no time for training.

Back in the “good ol’ days hours may have been longer but doctors could live on site and get meals provided etx. They were generally male and single without kids. If they did get married the salary would support a wife who could run the home for them. Now we move hospital every 4-6months and are told that 1.5hr commutes each way are to be expected and we cook and clean and look after our kids like everyone else.

maddening · 13/02/2022 19:29

www.theguardian.com/society/2022/jan/04/women-more-likely-die-operation-male-surgeon-study

Also this, it is misogyny, and similar to racism in that black patients have better outcomes from black doctors and nurses.

AnneElliott · 13/02/2022 19:12

I haven't watched it but I thought the adverts for it were misogynistic so I probably won't end up watching the series.

I do get that gallows humour is a coping mechanism - but no way would any other public servant get away with comments and such that have been detailed on this thread. Do we think the cops at Charing X were fine to use the language they did because they were no doubt overworked/underfunded/ traumatised? No of course not. Even though it appears to have been a private what's app group not available to the public.

I do think we deify the NHS in this country and that contributes to the entitlement that some (mainly male) medics develop.

And I do think a programme with another protected minority as the main butt of the jokes wouldn't be aired on the BBC. Something similar about ethnic minorities would just not be made.

AutomaticMoon · 13/02/2022 19:09

I don’t understand why doctors have to not sleep and do 46547 hour shifts, since many many people want to be doctors and there are limits on how many are allowed to qualify in this country. I know of a british lady who had to go study medicine in Romania even though she had the required grades, there weren’t enough ‘spaces’ to study. Isn’t this a false economy, to have less doctors to save money? A lot of how the nhs seems to function is false economy.

AutomaticMoon · 13/02/2022 18:55

There’s a report from Baroness Cumberlege about women’s treatment: First Do No Harm

There’s a great study on pubmed, the history of Hysteria (through the ages)

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3480686/

Women And Hysteria In The History Of Mental Health

AutomaticMoon · 13/02/2022 18:52

I think it’s inhumane, the training for doctors and how many end up treating women and every patient, pretty much. Of course that this kind of chronic sleep deprivation and trauma exposure is harmful and will affect how they work and how much empathy they have left for patients. I’m not excusing it because my life is in tatters in big part due to not being listened to or diagnosed properly or treated. I treat myself for the last decade and have to buy expensive illegal antibiotics and sleeping pills to just survive.

groeggmeg · 13/02/2022 18:52

I really don’t understand this view. I’ve read the book and I’ve seen the series and I jeep seeing this opinion and I didn’t get that from it at all.

I honestly believe you been a dark sense of humour to work in that role, it helps you from being too affected by what you see day in day out. A man that didn’t care wouldn’t be so affected by a case where he made the wrong decision as much as he is with the pre eclamptic 25 weeker. The older lady with the Vuval cancer he cares for and goes that extra mile to ensure she’s comfortable, there was no misogyny in my eyes just a dark sense of humour that helps him get through the day.

AutomaticMoon · 13/02/2022 18:47

If anyone hasn’t read his book, there’s a free pdf online of it.

AnnaMagnani · 13/02/2022 18:47

Thanks @Cbtb

My mum was a nurse, I'd been an HCA, I didn't think I was THAT sheltered.

But actually I was an 18 year old from a naice all girls selective school. In my first job I was sent to see a man who had shoved his daughter's care bear toy up his arse. He spent his time telling me his wife didn't understand him.

Nowadays that would be seen as Safeguarding. In 1999, it was seen as a funny anecdote, nobody thought about his daughter, and certainly nobody thought about me, the 23 yr old female the team set up to go and clerk the guy with a child's toy up his arse.

All of us junior doctors were going through multiple traumas, every shift - once we sat down and worked out when we had last had some positive feedback. For some of us it had been over a year.

It's a miracle any of us stayed in the job at all.

twominutesmore · 13/02/2022 18:44

I disagree that he takes human suffering and turns it into entertainment. He shows great concern for the older, rather cantankerous woman who is lonely without any visitors and there are no laughs levelled at the woman in an abusive relationship for example.

Yes, he pokes fun at the patient who wants to eat her placenta and the woman who, when asked how many weeks she is, calculates her own age in weeks. But the big stories are there too, to show us what medical professionals have to deal with, the weight of it all.

And he doesn't shy away from criticising himself either. He is a dick to Shruti but she proves to be wonderful.

Yeahthat · 13/02/2022 18:44

@AnnaMagnani

A very interesting and enlightening perspective. Thanks for sharing.

Cbtb · 13/02/2022 18:44

@XingMing that would be one way to cope, yet this is a thread mainly full of people saying medical professionals need to be empathetic compassionate people who connect with patients on a personal level.

What we want from healthcare professionals is not possible for the majority in the present system.

LittleBearPad · 13/02/2022 18:43

[quote coffeepopcorn]Do complain to the BBC about the unacceptable offensive misogyny in this programme. I have. They need to know that women are not impressed by this.

www.bbc.co.uk/contact/complaints/make-a-complaint/[/quote]
Speak for yourself. I’ve really enjoyed it. It shows how broke maternity care was and is in the NHS

bozzabollix · 13/02/2022 18:33

I don’t see the misogyny in it. If he had been an A&E doctor there would have been plenty of comic material featuring both sexes (especially certain foreign objects in certain orifices, mainly men). It’s really made me see what crushing responsibility medics have and the relentless nature of it.

Haven’t read the book so can’t comment on that.

Didiplanthis · 13/02/2022 18:29

I HATE his books and wouldn't watch it. I am a medic and loathe that ANYONE uses other people's suffering for 'entertainment' ... the fact we are privvy to these moments... is many things.. scary, difficult,frustrating bizarre... but funny... not really... not for them , not for us.

Cbtb · 13/02/2022 18:24

Annamagaini has said it much better than me.

You have no idea at 18 what you are signing up for and then you see precious little as a student - especially a male one. The at around 23 your given a pager (yup still a pager) and told you are responsible for the lives of 200 odd sick people overnight in the hospital. You have no idea really what to do and you see so many terrible things you can’t care about them all as you want to or you would break. I did around 2 years total on obs wards and NEVER saw a normal birth - no one calls doctors to the ones there not needed and no one lets student in.

There are some amazing superhuman medical professionals who can be compassionate and not burn out but they are the minority. Ideally only these people would be doctors and nurses but I doubt there are anywhere near enough for the burden of disease we have so somehow we need to figure out a way for normal people to go through this trauma and either not end up so traumatised they quit or so burnt out they become and arsehole

ichifanny · 13/02/2022 18:22

It’s actually very acurate , misogynism in health care is alive and kicking . Explains why woman have awful experiences while in hospital . I work in healthcare btw .

espressomartiniweeny · 13/02/2022 18:20

I also read the book, didn't know it was being made into a series and won't be watching it.

I also felt whilst reading it that he just didn't like women. Liked being seen as the saviour though.

XingMing · 13/02/2022 18:20

@Cbtb, I suspect that being successful as a doctor or nurse or any medical profession involves the ability to distance every patient. That surely is why doctors are not allowed to treat members of their own family? For professional sanity, it is really important not to become over-involved. Emotion has to be eliminated as much as possible. Medicine is an intellectual discipline and practice.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 13/02/2022 18:14

@Ionlydomassiveones

I’ve no doubt about the misogyny within the NHS - ‘cervix havers’ being a perfect example. But I don’t find Adam Kay’s book misogynistic and I think people miss the point. I can’t imagine an obstetric doctor that wouldn’t reduce each case into the actual body parts they’re dealing with. How could it not with the sheer volume of blood, guts and bodies they’re dealing with? It’s incredibly naive that under that amount of pressure, every women would have precious, individualised personal care. He describes it almost like battlefield conditions. I would’ve had no problem to have Adam Kay as my doctor - he came across as dedicated, skilled and humane.
Used to work for a Consultant Obs/Gynae with a special interest in Gynae Oncology. He terrified SHOs.. But he also tried to save every single individual woman. Not because it was a cancerous womb of ovaries that needed to be beaten, but because he didn't want any of them to die as his mother did when he was 19.

It destroyed him in the end. But not before he did save thousands of women, every one of which felt that he knew and cared for them personally - which in all likelihood, he did.

cansu · 13/02/2022 18:13

yeahthat
I can see that you can't accept we have a different opinion on this. I do not think that it is good that people are so overworked and stressed out that they do have compassion fatigue. I also don't think that every time Adam Kay interacted with a woman he was nasty and uncaring. I think this interpretation lacks an understanding that these are snippets of someone's work life with a cynical humour applied. It is interesting that you don't seem able to recognise that in many of these snippets he describes some of the situations with compassion. Anyway, I think wishing that I am treated poorly by the emergency services in the future is a bit unpleasant on your part. Dare I suggest that if you dislike the series that you maybe don't watch it!

RosesAndHellebores · 13/02/2022 18:09

@Blossomtoes so was death shortly thereafter four generation ago. People have been dying naturally since the beginning of time. Why help them when they are in acute pain?

AnnaMagnani · 13/02/2022 18:09

He comes across to me as exactly like the people (male and female) who wrote Rag Week content at Med School in the 90s.

As posters have said above, AK has acknowledged that selection for med school at the time was basically 1. Are you academic 2. Have you excelled at music or some other hobby. No thought at all as to whether you were actually going to be good at the job.

There were loads of students in my year realising the only reason they had wanted to do medicine was their parents were doctors, and now they were in, WTF were they going to do.

Female students were a minority, it was the era of the ladette so no-one was going to be pointing out misogyny anyway, and the thing to do for many was to fit in with the hard drinking culture of the boys. Or keep your head down, study and move on.

Then you started the job and were made so busy and so tired that you wondered why they had recruited you for being Grade 8 at playing the flute as you hadn't had time to even look at a fucking flute for years, have no social life and only eat sleep study and work any way.

Medicine keeps trying to change but over and over the next generation of junior doctors is still demoralized and the themes are the same.