Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think This Is Going To Hurt is awful to women?

390 replies

justanoldhack · 13/02/2022 13:39

Watching the show and can't help but shake a really uncomfortable feeling that its writer just...really doesn't like women.

I get that doctors are super overstretched, so tired, giving the job everything at the expense of their personal lives. I also get that it's a 'comedy' and not real, although it is based on his true life experiences.

But the way the women are portrayed as silly, a nuisance, stupid, battleaxes, or simply a vessel that 'covers his pubes in blood'... feels so off. These are women at one of the most vulnerable moments in their lives, but they're just props, the butt of the jokes. I can't shake the feeling that Adam Kay really, really doesn't like women. Definitely does not respect them.

Thanks goodness, I guess, that he's not longer practicing medicine. And not surprised either to learn that when he was younger he wrote 'comedy' songs about babies with Down's Syndrome and women from the North.

OP posts:
Thymeout · 18/02/2022 20:25

@alexdgr8 I think pps are getting confused about 'Poem' by Simon Armitage, Poet Laureate, and the lyrics of Northern Birds which Kay and Biswas wrote when they were students, inspired by Tom Lehrer. TL was a Harvard Maths professor with a sideline in writing new lyrics to different types of traditional popular songs.

Pp quoted the Armitage poem because the series brought it to mind. It was in the GCSE Anthology 20 odd years ago. Used to generate some vg class discussion. I'd guess a fair few of my pupils had witnessed DV. Are you saying that it's misogynist of S.A. to have written it?

I don't know the context of Northern Birds. For all I know, based on Tom Lehrer's comedy style, they were satirising the sort of rah rah public school halfwits who'd be obnoxious enough to come out with those opinions. Similarly, the trisomy song isn't mocking the Down's syndrome baby but the sort of woman who no doubt turned up at his clinic thinking she could put off having babies till she'd pursued her career or had her fill of a child-free life. Kay and Biswas were 19? 20? Clumsy and insensitive and, yes, enjoying the shock value, like Ben Elton, or Ricky Gervase, but not really a hanging offence.

Like the series, this whole subject is a lot more nuanced than ' man criticises woman = misogynist. Won't watch it.'

I heard the GP on LBC. He represents GPs on the GMC. He mentioned the AK series and said it should be thought of as a documentary because he recognised it as an attack on those who've let the NHS get in such a horrific state that there's a serious problem in recruiting and retaining GPs. My copy of the paperback ends with an open letter to Jeremy Hunt.

Please don't put people off watching it. It's an important message. They can make up their own minds.

whataboutbob · 18/02/2022 17:50

Doctors are Olympic champions at complaining about their working conditions. Maybe Adam Kay just didn’t have enough of a vocation to cut it and didn’t really want to be a doctor but mummy and daddy pushed him into it? As Shakespeare wrote “No profit grows where is no pleasure ta'en: In brief, sir, study what you most affect”.
That “poem” is beyond the pale. It shows hatred and contempt of women, poor people, northerners all in one fell swoop.

alexdgr8 · 18/02/2022 17:39

so if someone is actually trying, intending to offend as many people as possible, then we should not be offended by it, because he was so clever as to have succeeded in that ? ??
i must be very old.

it still does not commend it to me.

alexdgr8 · 18/02/2022 17:32

just heard i think it was a GP on LBC saying this tv show is so realistic, he views it as almost a documentary.
was talking about the lack of doctors; he said no wonder, the conditions are dire, as this portrays.
not sure what to make of that.

alexdgr8 · 18/02/2022 17:30

@Theluggage15

That’s a fucking awful poem. And once punched his wife in the face but he loved his mum!
yes, i wonder how a woman would have written such a poem. might be a bit different maybe. he's trying to make a point about not generalising, nobody's perfect etc, but, but...
sociallydistained · 18/02/2022 17:25

I read this during the first lockdown. I felt iffy about it but haven't thought about it really but since Ive just had my first baby, I really hate it and what he said about women now!

DrSbaitso · 18/02/2022 17:21

@anEnglishTERFinBerlin

For anyone wondering whether Adam Kay is a misogynist irl, here's a song he wrote with his "comedy" partner Suman Biswas about northern women.

"This is a national service announcement for all men
If you go to Bolton
If you go to Manchester
Or crewe
Newcastle, or Scarborough
York, or Scunthorp, Bradford, Barnsley too
Or Grimsby
Listen up to what we have to say
Northern birds are lazy ugly whores who smell of burgers
So don't have too much to drink
Or you might fuck one
And end up getting aids
There's nothing fun
To be found off the M1
Northern birds are lower class
Slags who take it up the arse
They're in the sack
After one cider and black
But they're fucking awful rides
and your dick won't touch the sides
Da-da-da-da-da-da
Da-da-da-da
Northern Birds
Da-da-da-da-da
If you really have to
Go up north then follow our advice
Fight away the women
Or you'll find yourself with Pubic lice
And herpes
Your much better staying in the South
Northern Birds
Are desperate ugly hippos dressed in Burberry
With a peanut for a brain
And an accent that makes you want to die
Now you've been warned
They're all physically deformed
Northern birds
Are all obese
And they're riddled with disease
Try to escape
Northern sex is worse than rape
Stay down south and mark my words
Stear well clear of northern birds
Northern birds
Northern birds"

Seems like a lovely chap with absolutely no issues regarding women.

Wasn't that a parody of West End Girls by the Pet Shop Boys?
Toanewstart23 · 18/02/2022 16:55

Absolutely she didn’t

Blossomtoes · 18/02/2022 16:54

You haven’t watched the TV series, have you @anEnglishTERFinBerlin?

Toanewstart23 · 18/02/2022 16:53

It was a complete piss take!

anEnglishTERFinBerlin · 18/02/2022 16:52

@widdlindiddlin Thanks for your insightful analysis. I had no idea it was an "offend as many people as you can pisstake"! I thought it was a completely serious attempt at art Hmm
And it's to the tune of More Than Words? Well that changes literally nothing everything!

Personally I don't think it's a coincidence that a man who wrote a song mocking and dehumanising women also wrote a bestselling book that mocked and dehumanised women, leading to a TV series in which women in intensely vulnerable situations are repeatedly made the butt of jokes.

But that's just me.

WiddlinDiddlin · 18/02/2022 15:33

To be absolutely clear and in context.. that song is to the tune of 'More Than Words'...

It is clearly a 'offend as many people as you can' pisstake, written by students. It isn't particularly clever, but nor is it grade A evidence that Kay is an evil misogynist (I mean... none of that can be his personal experience now can it)...

Or is it fair to judge EVERYONE on the planet, based on what they thought was funny when they were in their early 20's.

The fact they (because Kay did not write that on his own!) wrote some pretty crude offensive songs back then really doesn't prove this TV show is full of misogyny.

I know I've changed a smidgen since then, there were things I said and did I certainly wouldn't do now. Shall I decide not to write a book now, because I said something really fucking offensive in 2004? Because I know I definitely did.

anEnglishTERFinBerlin · 18/02/2022 14:27

For anyone wondering whether Adam Kay is a misogynist irl, here's a song he wrote with his "comedy" partner Suman Biswas about northern women.

"This is a national service announcement for all men
If you go to Bolton
If you go to Manchester
Or crewe
Newcastle, or Scarborough
York, or Scunthorp, Bradford, Barnsley too
Or Grimsby
Listen up to what we have to say
Northern birds are lazy ugly whores who smell of burgers
So don't have too much to drink
Or you might fuck one
And end up getting aids
There's nothing fun
To be found off the M1
Northern birds are lower class
Slags who take it up the arse
They're in the sack
After one cider and black
But they're fucking awful rides
and your dick won't touch the sides
Da-da-da-da-da-da
Da-da-da-da
Northern Birds
Da-da-da-da-da
If you really have to
Go up north then follow our advice
Fight away the women
Or you'll find yourself with Pubic lice
And herpes
Your much better staying in the South
Northern Birds
Are desperate ugly hippos dressed in Burberry
With a peanut for a brain
And an accent that makes you want to die
Now you've been warned
They're all physically deformed
Northern birds
Are all obese
And they're riddled with disease
Try to escape
Northern sex is worse than rape
Stay down south and mark my words
Stear well clear of northern birds
Northern birds
Northern birds"

Seems like a lovely chap with absolutely no issues regarding women.

Chimchiminie · 18/02/2022 13:37

@DePfeffoff

Yes, that's why Kay is being given a few pass to make cheap jokes about how stupid he finds women

But he doesn't do that. He's writing about people. Some people do stupid things - women aren't immune to that.

Exactly this

I think it’s fair to examine things carefully, as let’s face it, there’s plenty of low-level / normalised misogyny about, but I just can’t see any evidence that this was an example if it

DePfeffoff · 18/02/2022 13:30

Yes, that's why Kay is being given a few pass to make cheap jokes about how stupid he finds women

But he doesn't do that. He's writing about people. Some people do stupid things - women aren't immune to that.

Toanewstart23 · 18/02/2022 13:12

Just read magazine interview with Kay and the actor

Not a whiff of misogyny. Not even a whiff

borntobequiet · 18/02/2022 09:14

I read the book a while ago and enjoyed it, but it was only after seeing the TV series I realised what an excoriating confessional it was from a man who had come to the realisation he was actually an unkind, entitled, selfish prick rather than a selfless medical hero. Yes there were clues as to part of the reason for that - Harriet Walter was very good as his mother - but Ben Whishaw portrayed Kay brilliantly. The TV series brought maturity and humanity to a story that had originally been sarcastically flippant in the way of many black humour medical memoirs. The script, direction and the rest of the cast were also excellent. It wasn’t misogynistic at all.

AnnaMagnani · 17/02/2022 14:52

The sewing up tattoos badly was an urban myth going round doctor's messes in the early 2000s around the time dolphin tattoos became trendy.

No way did he, or anyone else actually do it, but it definitely got talked about a lot as it was the first time young women had had tattoos in any number.

Lottapianos · 17/02/2022 14:15

'I think anybody dealing with members of the public is entitled to let off a bit a steam, and take the piss out of the ridiculous ones a bit'

Completely agree. In fact I think it's essential in order to stay sane

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/02/2022 14:12

I am curious as to how many people swearing blind it is 'misogyny writ large' have actually watched the whole thing and/or read the book recently.

I was in two minds, I don't really LIKE Adam all that much and the first episode.. mm.

But I am glad I stuck with it...

Do people REALLY believe he sewed up someones tattoo as badly as that - I don't, for a second. Thats one of those things you wish you had done because someone was a vile person, but didn't actually do.

Books and, even more so, TV series like this are full of this sort of thing - they have to be because a book full of 'I wish I'd had my revenge on this vile person but I'd have lost my job if I did' don't sell.

Nor do tv series that are just 'woe is me/this is grim' and no shocking or funny stuff (not at the moment anyway and certainly not set in the NHS).

So.. its all aimed at women - well yes, theres not a lot of blokes giving birth, obs and gynae tends to be pretty heavy on women.

I think theres a lot of folk who missed the point, wilfully, and a lot determined to hate it becuase he wrote some unpleasant lyrics as a student a long time ago - presumably as students, you lot were all absolute SAINTS.

Rhythmisadancer · 17/02/2022 12:47

I think anybody dealing with members of the public is entitled to let off a bit a steam, and take the piss out of the ridiculous ones a bit. Of course it would be unprofessional to do it openly.
Read the book years ago, and I think he says somewhere, that the reason he actually liked working in obs and gynae was that your patients are generally fairly young and healthy, and a lot of the time you can actually help with the problem / issue they came in with, and send them home with a positive outcome. That seemed to be a fairly good motivation to me.

Blossomtoes · 17/02/2022 12:27

@VestaTilley

YANBU. Misogyny writ large. I won’t watch it.
Presumably because you don’t want to be proved wrong. It’s as far from misogyny as you can get. It must be miserable to have such a closed mind.
RemoteControlledChaos · 17/02/2022 10:09

Tbf I don’t suppose my midwife was delighted when I shat on her scrubs

gingerhills · 17/02/2022 09:41

I actively would want him as my doctor
Ok, so he’s not going to stroke my hair
But he’s going to do his best for my baby and me. And that’s my focus

As long as he's not too busy texting his boyfriend or takes a dislike to you and sews you up in a way that amuses him but clearly will give you long term problems (dolphin woman. Yes she was horrible but that doesn't mean he has the right to mangle her flesh for fun.)

VestaTilley · 17/02/2022 09:39

YANBU. Misogyny writ large. I won’t watch it.