Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think This Is Going To Hurt is awful to women?

390 replies

justanoldhack · 13/02/2022 13:39

Watching the show and can't help but shake a really uncomfortable feeling that its writer just...really doesn't like women.

I get that doctors are super overstretched, so tired, giving the job everything at the expense of their personal lives. I also get that it's a 'comedy' and not real, although it is based on his true life experiences.

But the way the women are portrayed as silly, a nuisance, stupid, battleaxes, or simply a vessel that 'covers his pubes in blood'... feels so off. These are women at one of the most vulnerable moments in their lives, but they're just props, the butt of the jokes. I can't shake the feeling that Adam Kay really, really doesn't like women. Definitely does not respect them.

Thanks goodness, I guess, that he's not longer practicing medicine. And not surprised either to learn that when he was younger he wrote 'comedy' songs about babies with Down's Syndrome and women from the North.

OP posts:
Toanewstart23 · 19/02/2022 17:11

@Blossomtoes

It’s another one I suspect

Toanewstart23 · 19/02/2022 17:11

@airbalonz

Sorry was on about the actual Adam Kay rather than the tv version
The TV version is very close adaptation of book

Have you read the book?

Blossomtoes · 19/02/2022 16:16

@airbalonz

Sorry was on about the actual Adam Kay rather than the tv version
The TV adaptation is based on the book.
airbalonz · 19/02/2022 15:41

Sorry was on about the actual Adam Kay rather than the tv version

Toanewstart23 · 19/02/2022 15:36

* guess it’s hardly surprising a posh privileged bloke doesn’t really care about this, it’s nothing new shrug*

And now conveniently ignoring the female doctors in the programme

Ionlydomassiveones · 19/02/2022 15:31

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

DrSbaitso · 19/02/2022 15:18

[quote Thymeout]@airbalonz

Interesting interview in the Guardian online today with Margaret Atwood.

She seems to see the current obsession with misogyny as a sort of cult.

'People are very ready to tell the writer that a bad person he or she is because he or she has not produced the sort of book or essays the preacher feels he or she should have produced.'

Does the cap fit?[/quote]
The quoted paragraph doesn't imply at all that she thinks there is a current obsession with misogyny or that it is a cult.

What did Atwood say that gives you that impression?

airbalonz · 19/02/2022 15:08

Instead of seeing everything from the rosy tinted world of whale music, gentle massage and a Four Seasons Hotel

??
No I’m viewing it from the world where at least a fifth of women treated by Kay have experienced rape or sexual assault, where the women with a ‘plan’ or wanting their boundaries respected are often carrying trauma, where a third of mothers have trauma from childbirth which most of the time is not caused by them being ‘selfish’ but the way they were treated, where rational intelligent women are routinely not listened to and dismissed and don’t have their pain taken seriously, where informed consent is routinely not a thing in maternity care (see the Montgomery case, the ruling goes completely against Kay’s views on maternity care)

Bu I guess it’s hardly surprising a posh privileged bloke doesn’t really care about this, it’s nothing new shrug

Ionlydomassiveones · 19/02/2022 14:55

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Thymeout · 19/02/2022 14:31

what not that

Thymeout · 19/02/2022 14:29

@airbalonz

Interesting interview in the Guardian online today with Margaret Atwood.

She seems to see the current obsession with misogyny as a sort of cult.

'People are very ready to tell the writer that a bad person he or she is because he or she has not produced the sort of book or essays the preacher feels he or she should have produced.'

Does the cap fit?

velvet24 · 19/02/2022 14:08

I didnt pick up on anything towards women, he was working in a obs and gyne ward!!
I don't believe any doctor though would speak to patients that way or the way some of the others do?

Blossomtoes · 19/02/2022 14:06

[quote Toanewstart23]@airbalonz

I think a lot of the female patients are portrayed as ‘idiotic’ as obviously Kay has full control of the characters and how all the anecdotes go.

Conveniently forgetting the laughably inept male doctor, who faints and comes across as totally thick
The male father who makes stupid unfunny jokes
The senior consultant who comes across as an uncaring twat

The domestic abusing father[/quote]
And the drunken idiot who pisses in the corner of the delivery room.

Toanewstart23 · 19/02/2022 13:57

@airbalonz

I think a lot of the female patients are portrayed as ‘idiotic’ as obviously Kay has full control of the characters and how all the anecdotes go.

Conveniently forgetting the laughably inept male doctor, who faints and comes across as totally thick
The male father who makes stupid unfunny jokes
The senior consultant who comes across as an uncaring twat

The domestic abusing father

airbalonz · 19/02/2022 13:48

I think a lot of the female patients are portrayed as ‘idiotic’ as obviously Kay has full control of the characters and how all the anecdotes go.

So of course we are not going to see examples of all the rational and intelligent women who are routinely not listened to and dismissed by doctors. Of course he is not going to address or acknowledge that issue. Instead he flips the situation where the ‘not listened to’ woman is clearly ‘crazy’ and he becomes the victim.

In the same way there is zero acknowledgment of the large proportion of women who have been raped or suffered sexual assault before walking into the hospital and are often the ones who seek to have some control. Instead the women who want choice or control are portrayed as selfish and idiotic and divas. He writes that talking through treatment options with patients for informed consent is silly and a waste of time, and that it’s better to give them one option and have them ‘trust him’ to do with what he knows is best.

Chimchiminie · 19/02/2022 13:46

I don’t think you understand how misogynistic cultures work. It isn’t because of people shouting the words l HATE WOMEN - it’s the subtle things we accept, popular culture, literature, everyday sexism that we don’t question because it’s not so overtly sexist. But it weaves into our narrative and out every day, and all of it is damaging

How condescending 😂 That’s right, anyone who has a difference of opinion simply doesn’t understand, they’re just a little bit basic, that’s all.

The fact is, there is not definitive evidence in the book of misogyny (or at least no one has presented any yet that I’ve seen - and I read the book when it first came out). Clearly there is some stuff in there - stories about patients etc. - that lead some people to question whether the author is misogynistic. But it’s speculative. Had he worked in male genito-urinary ward, presumably his anecdotes about patients wouldn’t have featured many women at all. Perhaps we’d be discussing whether he is a misandrist (and perhaps not, because misandry is not an issue this society suffers with in the same way as misogyny).

Fair enough if you believe the way patients are portrayed to be motivated by misogyny, that’s your opinion, you’re entitled to it. But pretty lame to write off anyone who does not hold the same opinion as uneducated and lacking any concept of the insidious ways systemic cultures work.

ButtercupOfFlorin · 19/02/2022 13:25

You don’t sympathise with someone who self harms due to deep rooted misogyny in our culture that says genitalia has to be perfect?

Pardon me if I don’t take posts from you seriously then, I don’t engage with woman haters

Blossomtoes · 19/02/2022 13:20

Yes, I would actually. She was attempting to make her vulva look like those she’d seen in porn. Frankly I have very little sympathy. But you’ve made up your closed mind and won’t be shifted so it’s pointless wasting words on you.

ButtercupOfFlorin · 19/02/2022 13:11

@Blossomtoes oh so we ARE horrified by racism but not misogyny Hmm

I wouldn’t call someone who self harms and has MH issues an idiot, no. Would you?

Try harder

Blossomtoes · 19/02/2022 12:48

Also which women in his books were idiots please?

Well there was the racist one who threw sharps at him - going to defend her? Or the one who decided to trim her own labia - is that a sensible thing to do?

ButtercupOfFlorin · 19/02/2022 12:09

@Ionlydomassiveones have you read the book?

I’m amazed people miss the misogyny in it.

I’ll ask you this - is it ok if he was racist and talking about ‘idiot black people’?

Also which women in his books were idiots please? It just seemed to me they were women having babies and wanting the best experience possible.

There are genuinely heinous things going on in society right now that are grossly misogynistic - this book is not one of them

I don’t think you understand how misogynistic cultures work. It isn’t because of people shouting the words l HATE WOMEN - it’s the subtle things we accept, popular culture, literature, everyday sexism that we don’t question because it’s not so overtly sexist. But it weaves into our narrative and out every day, and all of it is damaging.

Ionlydomassiveones · 19/02/2022 11:57

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

ButtercupOfFlorin · 19/02/2022 11:44

It actually disturbs me how people (including women) will excuse such blatant and damaging misogyny.

“He’s only telling the truth”
“He doesn’t hate women, he hates PEOPLE who just happen to be women”
“He was just a student having a laugh”
“NHS workers have dark humour donchknow” my sister is an A&E nurse and she would NEVER be as vile as Adam Kay is.

If he was being racist, there wouldn’t be these excuses, so why is it always OK to be hateful towards women and we just have to put up with it and laugh along?

C8H10N4O2 · 19/02/2022 11:39

Theres SO many more levels to it than 'its misogyny writ large' and 'adam kay is a cunt'.

There may be but that doesn't mean that it isn't misogynistic or that Adam Kay can't be a cunt. Cardiac Arrest it isn't, much as it tries to emulate it. (and yes I've listened to his interviews both before the book and the tv series, listened to the adaptations of the book, read the book and watched the two episodes broadcast of the tv series - I still think he is a misogynistic arsehole).

WiddlinDiddlin · 18/02/2022 21:20

[quote anEnglishTERFinBerlin]@widdlindiddlin Thanks for your insightful analysis. I had no idea it was an "offend as many people as you can pisstake"! I thought it was a completely serious attempt at art Hmm
And it's to the tune of More Than Words? Well that changes literally nothing everything!

Personally I don't think it's a coincidence that a man who wrote a song mocking and dehumanising women also wrote a bestselling book that mocked and dehumanised women, leading to a TV series in which women in intensely vulnerable situations are repeatedly made the butt of jokes.

But that's just me.[/quote]
Oh you do like to pick apart other peoples words and mock them, but no one else is apparently permitted to do same with people whose opinions and ideas they disagree with are they?

I pointed out its to a tune, words to fit 'northern birds' scans the same as 'more than words'. Lots of people have got the wrong end of the stick confusing parody song writing with poetry.

20 years ago I wrote a disgusting parody of Dolly Parton's '9 to 5', but that doesn't mean I can't do my job well today, nor does it mean I am the same person I was then.

Evidently you've always been exactly as you are now eh.

I don't think the book did mock and dehumanise women, it mocked some, disagreed with some, painted a grim picture of some... men and women alike.

Ditto the show - was the drunken happy twat pissing in the corner NOT a mockery of a certain type of bloke? Or the bullish, bullying twat of a consultant?

Both consultants in fact were bullies in the TV series, one was nicer to Shruti than the other but they were both pretty awful people - but thats ok because they mostly bullied Adam?

Adams mother is cold, hard, rude and disinterested, but thats ok because she's a woman right?

Even poor Shruti, pressured from her parents, her exams, Adam, patients, consultants... found herself bullying the person below her, being harsh on patients, leaving the guy who asked for a date hanging around for hours...

I highly doubt you've watched it though.

Theres SO many more levels to it than 'its misogyny writ large' and 'adam kay is a cunt'.