Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think This Is Going To Hurt is awful to women?

390 replies

justanoldhack · 13/02/2022 13:39

Watching the show and can't help but shake a really uncomfortable feeling that its writer just...really doesn't like women.

I get that doctors are super overstretched, so tired, giving the job everything at the expense of their personal lives. I also get that it's a 'comedy' and not real, although it is based on his true life experiences.

But the way the women are portrayed as silly, a nuisance, stupid, battleaxes, or simply a vessel that 'covers his pubes in blood'... feels so off. These are women at one of the most vulnerable moments in their lives, but they're just props, the butt of the jokes. I can't shake the feeling that Adam Kay really, really doesn't like women. Definitely does not respect them.

Thanks goodness, I guess, that he's not longer practicing medicine. And not surprised either to learn that when he was younger he wrote 'comedy' songs about babies with Down's Syndrome and women from the North.

OP posts:
Goooglebox · 13/02/2022 16:33

Doctors do what they need to do to emotionally survive it. Walk a mile in the shoes then you can talk

No. Standards of behaviour apply to everyone. It's not acceptable to be a prat because you're tired or overworked. Many labouring women ml are just as tired and overworked. They're expected to treat professionals with respect and courtesy in response for clinical excellence and professional respect/empathic treatment.

Goooglebox · 13/02/2022 16:30

I found the book unpleasant in this way also. He has a total indifference to pain and I'm not sure he would find his empathy after a good wash and sleep.

It's a pity this is acceptable.

straighttalker · 13/02/2022 16:28

And I have to disagree with the previous poster.
It is unfortunately very realistic.
I liked the amateur transplant songs, so perhaps that says something about my attraction to dark humour.
The NHS song was gold. www.dailymotion.com/video/x3ov698
Replacing Tony Blair with all the subsequent Tories, the NHS just got worse!

raffegiraffe · 13/02/2022 16:28

Ridiculous. This is what it's like! Childbirth is difficult and dangerous. This isn't spoken about enough because people don't want to acknowledge it. Watch the episode about the private hospital. Doctors do what they need to do to emotionally survive it. Walk a mile in the shoes then you can talk

grumpytoddler1 · 13/02/2022 16:27

He was interviewed by James O'Brien a while ago and I thought he came across well. He was saying that the only entry criteria for medicine are academic, and how ridiculous that is. People go into medicine because, like him, their parents did, and there is no testing for whether these people are going to actually be able to cope with the job. He fully admits he couldn't cope with it.

I also think he has written himself as an awful person in the TV show, much more so than in the book. So he is well aware of how flawed he is. I didn't necessarily think he was misogynistic, or uncaring, although I do now understand why the jokes would make people think that. I actually think the fact that he struggled so much after losing a patient that he had to quit the profession altogether shows he did care - a lot.

littlelollypop · 13/02/2022 16:27

Some of the jokes in the book are grim. One anecdote was a woman anxious about opening her bowels during delivery and the loss of dignity. The ‘punchline’ was that she’d eaten a huge curry the night before so the end result was even worse🙄

It’s far easier to make those types of jokes when you’re not frightened, humiliated person half-dressed in front of strangers.

straighttalker · 13/02/2022 16:24

You're not being unreasonable not to like a TV programme. But it's not misogynistic because there's no evidence that he's behaving this way because the patients are women. So YABU for being precious.

I think it's brilliant, funny and incisive. Unfortunately realistic - though, thank goodness that many disasters - and awful patients - are usually spread out over years rather encountered in a short space of time!

caoraich · 13/02/2022 16:18

I'm a doctor, I thought the book was horrible although a little more nuanced. I suspect he was trying to illustrate compassion fatigue but actually I think he is just a misogynist who is better off out of medicine.

I started training around the time his book was published and I recognise very little of what he describes. The way junior doctors, along with many other healthcare professionals, are treated at times is grim. But I didn't witness the kinds of awful attitudes to patients that he writes about.

I found most of the songs by the amateur transplants pretty unpleasant too.

Tippexy · 13/02/2022 16:17

*full of

Tippexy · 13/02/2022 16:17

The book is well known for being for of misogynistic rubbish - there have been a few threads about it on here over time.

Gowithme · 13/02/2022 16:13

The NHS is not interested in individuals, it's a numbers game.

Faevern · 13/02/2022 16:12

AFAIK Suman Biswas who sang those songs with AK is a practising anaesthetist in the NHS.

WouldBeGood · 13/02/2022 16:11

I’m really glad you posted this.

I loathed the book fir these reasons.

He seems wholly unsuited to be a doctor, with his contempt for patients and surprise at the hours as a junior doctor. Horrible.

Toanewstart23 · 13/02/2022 16:08

@M1212

Things have changed a lot since the European working time directive was introduced in about 2008. There seems to be no reference to that at all in this TV show set in 2006. This should be pointed out to the public. Junior doctors shouldn't be working those horrendous 108 hour working weeks anymore. I can remember starting my weekend on call Sat at 8am and not sitting down until 5pm the following Monday in my surgical discipline. All this having been in work Mon to Fri 8-5.30pm and working one of those weekday overnights on call too. It was punishing, but same as babdoc, I'd like to think I was polite and respectful to patients despite falling down the hospital stairs with tiredness several times !
Exactly

The new breed of junior doctors have a very very very different life! Set hours and they absolutely do clock off on time!

Toanewstart23 · 13/02/2022 16:06

I thought it was superb

Not my experience of being a gynae patient in the slightest though.

But brilliant tv and absolutely no cause for offence as far as I can tell

M1212 · 13/02/2022 16:03

Things have changed a lot since the European working time directive was introduced in about 2008. There seems to be no reference to that at all in this TV show set in 2006. This should be pointed out to the public. Junior doctors shouldn't be working those horrendous 108 hour working weeks anymore.
I can remember starting my weekend on call Sat at 8am and not sitting down until 5pm the following Monday in my surgical discipline. All this having been in work Mon to Fri 8-5.30pm and working one of those weekday overnights on call too. It was punishing, but same as babdoc, I'd like to think I was polite and respectful to patients despite falling down the hospital stairs with tiredness several times !

twominutesmore · 13/02/2022 16:03

I didn't feel that it was misogynistic. By the nature of his job, his 'customers' are women and so of course he is going to talk about his experiences and poke fun at them. If he worked in the fracture clinic he'd be taking the piss out of equal numbers of men and women. If he worked in a care home, he'd be telling stories aimed at the elderly. He's changed names to preserve anonymity but if you doubt that nhs staff come into contact with people just like those portrayed I think you're being a bit naive.

A lot of people are talking about this very positively. I think it's only on mn that people are overlooking that he worked a 12 hour shift after a night in his car, did two 12 hour shifts back to back, saved a woman's life by refusing to send her home and so on. All of that dedication, which shows how he cares about his patients in every way that matters, is sidelined because he takes the piss out of a thick woman who thinks her baby weighs two stone.

greyinganddecaying · 13/02/2022 16:02

@Babdoc

I’m a retired doctor, and the majority of my colleagues were nothing like this. Kay is just a particularly unpleasant misogynist shit. Even the narcissistic consultant surgeons I worked with, who could be complete knobs to colleagues, were always unfailingly courteous and kindly to their patients, who revered them. Anyone prepared to give Kay the benefit of the doubt should listen to the lyrics of his “comic” song “Your baby has trisomy”, to the tune of My baby just cares for me. It includes the lines “A bit of a Mong, your baby Your baby has trisom, it’s what he will die from” If he was still a doctor, I’d be phoning the GMC.
That is horrendous.
Whattochoosenow · 13/02/2022 16:01

We went to see him live. It started off funny but wasn’t at the end.
He came across as a one trick pony. He’s left medicine but is earning off the back of his experiences there. There’s only so many times you can tell the same story

veevee04 · 13/02/2022 15:59

I actually really enjoyed it and I've given birth. I am a HCP when I have birth I wasn't and I felt ignored and scared. I kind of get it now when you have seen a 1000 births you become hardened to it, I'm hardened to a lot of things in my work now which when I first started it really affected me. I'm professional and I care but when I leave a shift I forget about what's happened I don't dwell on it. If I did dwell I would have a break down. I think the medics were all suffering from compassion fatigue and burnout.

Rua13 · 13/02/2022 15:58

I'm reading this book at the moment and I didn't think he was that much of a misogynist just the circumstances he was working under.The woman who he asked how many weeks are you and answered I'm 32 so must be a thousand weeks has to be a made up story.

BestKnitterInScotland · 13/02/2022 15:58

I read the book and thought exactly the same. Repulsed by women, their bodies and childbirth. "Brats and twats" sums it all up.

Blossomtoes · 13/02/2022 15:58

@justanoldhack

There does seem to be something seriously wrong with a system that encourages medics to dehumanise women to that extent, and also be proud enough about it to write about it (and make a shitload of money out of it, too)
You do know he left the NHS because he felt it was impossible to provide the care he wanted to? He’s far from proud of it.
Tanith · 13/02/2022 15:57

It's been done before: TLC with Reece Shearsmith and Alexander Armstrong.

Never really took off here, but I understand it was a real hit in Germany.

Babdoc · 13/02/2022 15:55

I qualified as a doctor in 1980, and worked those same gruelling 100 hour weeks as Kay did. And unlike him, I stayed for 36 years.
I can honestly say that, however knackered I was after a 72 hour continuous shift, I have never treated a patient with the casual contempt and disregard evident in Kay’s book.
My colleagues and I would share gallows humour in the doctors’ mess, but never in front of patients. We did our best even when exhausted to be supportive to patients, especially frightened mothers in painful labour, or emergency cases needing theatre.
I think Kay was wholly unsuited to a medical career - he more or less admits this, saying it was just expected he would follow the family into it. However intellectually bright he may have been, he lacked empathy, and was horrifically misogynist.

Swipe left for the next trending thread