Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find DH's inability to answer a question infuriating?

57 replies

AllTheUsernamesLeftAreShit · 13/02/2022 12:32

For example, today is my lie in and DH often takes toddler DS to the park or duck pond on a Sunday afternoon. Today it is lashing it down, leading to this conversation:

Me "The local museum is opening on a Sunday for half term. Shall we take DS as the weather's awful?"

DH "I hadn't thought about it"

Ten minute break for thinking

Me "So, do you fancy the museum"

DH "I really haven't thought about it"

Me "Well, is it something you need to think about? I thought it was something you'd either fancy or not without pondering for a period of time."

DH - complete silence for several minutes

Me "Well, it closes at 4 so we'll have to get up and out straight after DS's nap. Would you like to go?"

DH "I really haven't thought about it yet"

I'm working on the assumption we're not going and buggering off on my own, but why can't he just say yes or no?!

OP posts:
LawnFever · 13/02/2022 13:33

OP did you want to go to the museum?

I’d have just said, ok we’re leaving at x if you want to come.

@AnotherMansCause that sounds infuriating! Can’t you just say I’m having x if you don’t want that sort yourself out? I’m irritated just thinking about it!

Skiptheheartsandflowers · 13/02/2022 13:31

Stop phrasing it as a question. Just say it. 'Let's go to the museum today after DS's nap'. Then he'll actually have to use his big boy words and disagree if he doesn't want to.

@AnotherMansCause I would stop meal planning with him at all and leave him to sort himself out. He sounds infuriating.

TheApexOfMyLife · 13/02/2022 13:30

Yep it’s a way to get out of going out to said museum and have an afternoon for himself.

I’d tell him that you are going out ON YOUR OWN.

Sally872 · 13/02/2022 13:27

Next time just say "let's take ds to the museum" take all the pressure of thinking about it away for him. Hmm

AnotherMansCause · 13/02/2022 13:26

Have you taken my DH? (You can keep him - he's a terror for doing this.)

Me - "What do you want for tea?" Him - "I don't know".
At supermarket, later. Me - "What do you want for tea?"
Him - "I don't know".
Me - "Well I'm going to have X"
Him - "That sounds nice"
Me - " Do you want the same?"
Him - "No"
Me - "What do you want? Spicy? Chicken/beef/pork? Soup? Pasta? Pizza? Something cold that you don't have to cook, or I'll cook it if you want?"
Him - "Don't know"
30 minutes pass. He wanders, vetoes everything. Explodes at me if I dare to suggest anything specific or point out something he's had & enjoyed previously. Frequently we visit another supermarket & repeat the process.
Me - "Any idea what you want yet?"
Him - "No. I'll probably have a sandwich. I think there's bread at home."

Every. Bloody. Time.

I've tried meal planning. I've tried making lists of meals he likes & getting him to just pick one. I'm not even allowed in the kitchen while he's preparing food. One time he accused me of being controlling & manipulative by trying to make him eat certain foods, so now I've officially given up. I refuse to get involved. It wouldn't be so galling if I didn't have to meticulously plan my meals ahead due to numerous & extremely limiting food intolerances. He can literally eat anything but he refuses to make any decisions & it's such a massive issue. Ironically I'm the least troublesome person in the house, food-wise & there are dozens of foods I can't have.

It's not just food, BTW. He's just as indecisive about pretty much any other bloody thing. Drives me absolutely bananas.

frogsbreath · 13/02/2022 13:25

My DH does this, as well as, "could do" and "might do" and "maybe yeah".

Just fucking answer. I hate it even more when he does it to ds because "could do" is a no to me but a yes to him.

Gizacluethen · 13/02/2022 13:25

Omfg yes! "Do you want to go for a carvery today?" "Well we need to let me mum down." " What? About what so do you want to go?" silence turns out what he actually meant was "yes that would be lovely my darling wife, could we invite my parents aswell to soften the blow because we need to tell them they won't be looking after DS tomorrow." Took me about an hour of mind games to get to that 🤨

RightOnTheEdge · 13/02/2022 13:24

YANBU OP! My god that sounds absolutely maddening!

Bunce1 · 13/02/2022 13:21

I’d go out on my own then. No kids and no husband.

“I’ve thought about it and made my decision, see you later Aristotle”

MatildaTheCat · 13/02/2022 13:18

@AllTheUsernamesLeftAreShit

I have tried all these things! About six months ago we had a blazing row about this when he said he wanted to think about it to work out what the right answer was (i.e. what I want him to say), he just couldn't accept that the right answer was his opinion. So therefore "I can't be arsed" or "no" is the right answer.

Just a complete logic breakdown. But however much I know I need to just carry on and make my own plans, it still drives me utterly batshit.

It’s pretty obvious in this example that you DO want to go to the museum- you’d hardly have suggested it if you loathed the idea.

If he is always like this I’d suggest that after the first ‘I don’t know I haven’t thought about it’ you say, ‘ok, I’m going to ask you again in ten minutes so please can you think now?’ After that I’d be putting the toddlers coat on and going without him.

billy1966 · 13/02/2022 13:16

@WallaceinAnderland

Do it back to him.

What's for dinner - I haven't really thought about it.

This.

He sounds dim.

ApolloandDaphne · 13/02/2022 13:13

I do this. It means I think I would like to go but that means summoning up the energy to get lunch, sort out what we need to take, book tickets, drive there and park etc. if I am not quite in the zone yet then I will be non committal until I am ready. Often my DH will just say we are doing it and somehow I find i am ready and out the door without having to think too much! I suspect I just want someone to decide for me sometimes because I get fed up deciding stuff all the time.

Losingmyeverything · 13/02/2022 13:09

Just as bad as my partner who answers a question with a question drives me mad. Indecisive.

Me: do you want sugar in your tea?

Him: what we having?

Me: tea do you want sugar?

Him: what are you having?

Argh!! Just tell me .

KylieKoKo · 13/02/2022 13:05

I would have just said. I am taking ds to the museum. I'll leave after he wakes from his nap. You are welcome to join us and then just got on with the plan.

DaveGrohl · 13/02/2022 13:01

It is a sign of a narcissist - as they can gain power by keeping you guessing. Obviously just one feature in a whole list - does he display other narcissistic behaviours?

RNBrie · 13/02/2022 12:58

Is this not just a tactic so you take DC on your own and he gets the afternoon off to sit around in his pants and scratch his arse?

Do you ever get time alone to sit around and scratch your arse? If not, I'd be replying with something like "I'll take that as a no... So I'm going to pop to the shops/gym/whatever and leave dc here with you if that's ok?"

Or just change your whole approach and tell him what you'd like to do - "its miserable outside, after dc's nap, lets get going to the museum. We need to be out of the door by 2pm as it closes at 4pm".

My DH struggles to answer questions too, but in a different way...
me: Will you be home for dinner tonight?
him: Ah, well, I have that project due in tomorrow...
me: ok, its fine if you need to work late, but will you be home for dinner tonight?

He answers the question he thinks I am asking, not the question I am actually answering. Drives me potty.

AllTheUsernamesLeftAreShit · 13/02/2022 12:57

I have tried all these things! About six months ago we had a blazing row about this when he said he wanted to think about it to work out what the right answer was (i.e. what I want him to say), he just couldn't accept that the right answer was his opinion. So therefore "I can't be arsed" or "no" is the right answer.

Just a complete logic breakdown. But however much I know I need to just carry on and make my own plans, it still drives me utterly batshit.

OP posts:
JurgensCakeBabyJesus · 13/02/2022 12:51

DH asked me if I wanted to take ds to the local aquarium today for similar reasons, I did not, we've been a million times before (annual pass), I'm tired, don't feel well and have almost no voice at the moment. So I just said I don't feel well enough to go out but you take him if you like, he said yes I will, do you want anything while we're out? He then made a packed lunch for DS while I went back to bed, picked up a few things we needed in town and they are now at the aquarium.
If he doesn't want to go he just needs to say that.

MsChatterbox · 13/02/2022 12:49

I would assume he doesn't want to but doesn't want to say no. In which case I would reassure "it's fine if you say no. I need to know to plan my day". If he still wants to "think" then let him know what time you're leaving and if he wants to come he can. Some people need longer to get their head around last minute plans.

WallaceinAnderland · 13/02/2022 12:46

Do it back to him.

What's for dinner - I haven't really thought about it.

PragmaticWench · 13/02/2022 12:45

I'd reply that you've given him plenty of time to think, you're going with DC anyway and it's entirely up to him if he joins you or not.

Then go.

CrystalCoco · 13/02/2022 12:43

Me "So, do you fancy the museum"

DH "I really haven't thought about it"

Me "Ok so can you think about it now then and give me an answer please, I want to organise my day"

and stand/sit there looking at him waiting for the answer

I think he doesn't want to look like the bad guy and give you a flat out "no" but no is indeed what he's trying to say?

This style of (non)communication would drive me nuts!

Oblomov22 · 13/02/2022 12:42

Why haven't you had the conversation? Did you know that you say : "I really haven't thought about it", quite a lot?
I find it quite irritating, especially when I actually need a definitive yes or no answer. Could you try not to?

Blinkingheckythump · 13/02/2022 12:41

God I'd just say well think about it then! How frustrating

Lovemydoggie · 13/02/2022 12:40

My husband never answers a question directly...talk about long winded replies!