Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DMum constantly asking me if I know people I obviously do know...

135 replies

Lockheart · 13/02/2022 11:58

[Light-hearted]

I will caveat this by saying that I do love my mother dearly but she drives me round the absolute bend with this. Any time we talk:

Her: "I was chatting to Anne, you know Anne from next door?"

Me (thinking): Yes, I know Anne, I only lived next door to her for 15 years too and she only babysat us many many times.

Mum: "Do you remember Betty, from Closest town?"

Me (thinking): Yes, I know Betty, she's only been your best friend and like a second mother to me for as long as I can remember and I saw her daughter last Tuesday as you well know.

Meeting someone on the street with her: "Oh Lockheart you know Sue from down the road." Yes of course I bloody know her, she's only lived there 20 years and we saw her last fecking week. She came over for coffee! We were both there!!.

Mum: "Did you know Cathy has a new car? You know, Cathy your cousin?" YES I KNOW WHO MY FUCKING COUSIN IS FOR CHRISTS SAKE

The above examples have unique names in our social circles. We don't know a million people all called Linda, for example, where differentiation might be justified Grin That I could understand.

Just why?? I'm honestly awaiting the phone call which goes "Hello love, it's your mother, you know, the one who birthed and raised you".

My only theory is that either she has the memory of a goldfish or she thinks that I do Grin

Please tell me other people's mother's do this and it's not a torture she's dreamed up just got me?

OP posts:
BulletTrain · 13/02/2022 14:33

MiL does this. "My aunt in Hong Kong said x". Just call her Jill, MiL. I have been hearing tales of Jill since 2003.

annonymousse · 13/02/2022 14:32

My mum does this but usually with people I don't know. She will try and persuade me for ages that I did know them and then tell me they've died. So now when she asked do I remember susan from 20 years ago I just ask why? Has she died?

AcrossthePond55 · 13/02/2022 14:32

God bless all those mums. It's lovely to look back on those little 'absurdities', even if it was frustrating at the time. With my mum (she died a year ago) it was the inability to give a concise answer to a simple question.

Example:

"Mum, what did the doctor tell you today?"

"Well, it was very interesting, let me tell you. I got up this morning at 7, it was such a beautiful morning. I went to the cupboard and realized I was out of cereal! So I had to have toast. Did you see XX on the Today show?"

"Mum, ok, but what did the doctor say?"

"I'm telling you what he said! Anyway, after my walk I decided to wear my blue dress to the doctor's. But I had to wash it and I noticed there was a little rip along the seam. So I....."

"Mum! The doctor!"

"Heavens! No need to be so short with me! I decided to have lunch before I went but the tuna had gone off so I had........"

And on and on and on, only after I had a full recounting of all events leading up to the doctor's appointment would I finally hear "And he said it was just another age spot, nothing to worry about" or "He thinks it might be serious and wants to do more tests".

God, I loved that woman. Mum was a joy and an adventure. I miss her so much.

teateaandcoffee · 13/02/2022 14:29

Definitely not just you OP! Grin

I get this all the time.
The most recent one, I think I put a stop to it. I had gone to primary school with a girl, grew up on same road but was a little older.
A few years ago she started a small business, which locally you would see her work out and about. So inevitably I heard all about that, and where she was living now, etc.
Recently my Mum started a bat shit conversation about her, that she had broken up with her partner and was now going off the rails a little bit, second hand news from her friend kind of thing.
I just asked ‘Oh dear, when was the last time you saw her Mum?’
Mum had to admit she hadn’t met her in over 30 years (since I left school).
I don’t understand why people get so involved in peoples lives who they don’t actually know. Gives me the creeps thinking some busy body knows about ongoings in my life just cus most of women where I’m from are terrible gossips!!!!

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 13/02/2022 14:28

@Lockheart - is she possibly making sure you know which Anne/Betty/Sue/Cathy she’s referring to? Ie. Cathy your cousin, not Cathy her friend from the book club or Cathy who used to be her boss?

Though even if that is what she’s doing, I can understand why it’s so frustrating, when it happens every time!

tkwal · 13/02/2022 14:25

She has accepted that you are an adult who may have other people by similar names in your life. She may also be used to explaining who people are to others who don't have shared experiences with her. I have an elderly Aunt who does this because she's a social butterfly who is out and about with various groups and is fortunate enough to live between two families of very considerate neighbours

ImInStealthMode · 13/02/2022 14:25

I get the opposite, many tales about the lives of neighbours, people from the local pub, very distant relatives that I don't know.

'Oh my second cousin twice removed Shirley's daughter is having another baby, and Dave, with the grey hair, from 5 doors down has got a new car. Tina from behind the bar has started her own business selling scentsy stuff, isn't that great?' (ConfusedHmm)

I don't care! I don't know these people!! And stop buying bloody wax melts and perpetuating the MLM problem! Hmm

thecatsthecats · 13/02/2022 14:24

I get this. At a certain point, they decided that I did not, in fact, grow up in the house they live in and need telling about the neighbours and the house itself and the local area as if I'm a visitor.

But at least they don't talk about the route I took to get there. No matter how often I answer "Oh, I just follow the sat nav" to ILs, they ask. My husband talked about what route we were going to take the other day, and I pointed out if he was going to start on that behaviour then divorce was imminent.

Cafog · 13/02/2022 14:20

My DM used to do the opposite..."I was chatting to Mart today and she was telling me....." Now DM had lots of Marys in her life, her sister, her next door neighbour, her best friend , her colleague and lots of other acquaintances. Without fail I'd have to stop her and ask her which Mary for context. She always presumed I'd know which one she was talking about, it drove me mad. Not such an issue any more as the Marys have petered out.

contrary13 · 13/02/2022 14:19

Not my mother, but my ex-FIL. My ex and I went to school with each other from the age of 11 to 18 - our friends were all mutual ones essentially. When collecting our youngest for contact, ex-FIL would attempt to make awkward small talk:

Ex-FIL: "Oh, [ex] went to [friend A]'s wedding last weekend, did you ever meet them when you were together?!"
Me: "Yes. I was also at the wedding. [Friend A] is our son's godfather and even though it was my weekend with the children, we were all there... oh, and I introduced [friend A] to [ex] seeing as I've known [friend A] for my entire life!"

There have been a few times when I have, perhaps rather bluntly, reminded ex-FIL that he, too, has known me since I was 12 years old!!! I'm now 45, and very grateful that my 17-year-old is the youngest and more than capable of sorting out when/if he sees them (he tends not to) because they literally make my brain hurt.

On the other hand, my Dad goes into unnecessary detail about total strangers ("oh, I was talking to Bob and... what's his wife's name... I can't think...") where I end up pointing out that if it's not relevant to the story, and it never is, I don't need to know. My children and I joke (affectionately) about how he can recall what he ate for breakfast on May 14th, 1964... but that's about it (I'm his only daughter, and he can never recall my name, birthday, age, likes, and/or dislikes... it is, what it is).

EmmaH2022 · 13/02/2022 14:18

@Slumcat

My mum does the opposite and its always about the folk at slimming world, I don’t go to slimming world nor do I know any of them, I still know : Jan’s grandson Frankie (he’s the same age as your youngest well 2 years older) has a stigmatism

Linda who’s lovely, although at first I wasn’t keen, her husband John has taking early retirement he’s going to power hose drives to make a bit extra, he’ll need to careful though what with his pancreas

And so on and so forth for Margaret, Frank, Lisa, Debbie. I just smile and nod politely but inside I’m kicking doors of hinges

This is infectious because I'm wondering if there's a pancreatic condition that can be affected by power hosing 😂
TimBoothseyes · 13/02/2022 14:15

My Mum used to drive me mad with conversations which usually went like this

Mum " You remember Doris*
who we lived next door to when you were younger?"

Me " Um no I don't"

Mum " Yes you do, small woman, wore glasses"

me " no can't place her"

Mum " oh you MUST remember her, she wore a flowery apron like your grans"

And so on and so on. In my head I would be screaming "no mum I don't fucking remember someone who lived next door to a house we moved from 40 odd years ago!!"

Turned out Doris had moved.

*not really called Doris.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 13/02/2022 14:14

My mum has a neighbour called Linda. She doesn't know anyone else called Linda. But it's always Linda-Next-Door. Never just Linda!

Stories about people you don't know or give a fuck about, are the absolute worst yes I get this too. I did finally break one day and say I was bored with hearing about the same neighbours I'd never met over and over again. She was offended but she got over it and talks about them - just not quite as much.

Slumcat · 13/02/2022 14:13

My mum does the opposite and its always about the folk at slimming world, I don’t go to slimming world nor do I know any of them, I still know :
Jan’s grandson Frankie (he’s the same age as your youngest well 2 years older) has a stigmatism

Linda who’s lovely, although at first I wasn’t keen, her husband John has taking early retirement he’s going to power hose drives to make a bit extra, he’ll need to careful though what with his pancreas

And so on and so forth for Margaret, Frank, Lisa, Debbie. I just smile and nod politely but inside I’m kicking doors of hinges

JayniSummers · 13/02/2022 14:12

Sorry crossed post the exact story , my dad does exactly this !!!

EmmaH2022 · 13/02/2022 14:12

Smudge Flowers

JayniSummers · 13/02/2022 14:10

My dear father will get VERY ANNOYED when I can't recall folk. Last time it was the barmaid of his local ( not mine) of a pub he went to over 30 years ago ...and when I don't recall her he will say things like " she was married to that builder had a limp ?.... had to have her cat put down when it was poisoned ?daughter was a lesbian ? YOU DO KNOW HER .... found it easier to just say yes now when he asked as usually the punchline and the only reason he's brought her up is " she's dead now"

LoopyDream · 13/02/2022 14:08

My MIL is the opposite. She just starts chatting about Linda or Shawn or Poppy like I’m best friends with them. She will tell me an entire story with NO context - for example she works with Shawn but she won’t tell me that the story takes place at work. I’ve learned to nod, smile and ‘hmmm’ at the right places

Justilou1 · 13/02/2022 14:06

My mil has remarried and has totally thrown herself into her DH’s family. (They can have her…) On the rare occasions she rings to speak to my kids or my DH, she yacks on and on about people we’ve never met, and also does the “You know Natalie, who lives in …. with X & X, well her boyfriend’s brother just got a job at the local supermarke. Well…. His mum was telling me about the surgery she had on her knee and it was just like the time when Brent - you know Brent who is Darryl’s BIL? Well…..” That wouldn’t be so bad if she hadn’t also adopted their openly racist, homophobic, xenophobic and right-wing opinions as well…..

SmudgeButt · 13/02/2022 14:00

Sadly I've got the conversation going in the other direction.

"Mum, Pat called. You know, Pat Fisher?"
"Who?"
"Pat Fisher! You know, you used to play bridge every week."
"No, I don't remember her!"
"Yes, you know. We used to go on holiday for a week every summer when we were kids as all the Fisher kids were the same age. We'd rent those cottages next to each other at that lake!"
"No I have no idea what you are talking about. We never holidayed by a lake. When did we stay in a cottage??"

Substitute any topic of conversation or any close personal friend from the last 90 years and the answer is always "No, no idea."

PonyPatter44 · 13/02/2022 13:56

Um, I am this person. I forget sometimes that not everyone knows all the people I know. This is especially true for my poor DP. We have only been together 3.5 years, and while he has met quite a lot of my friends and relatives, there are still lots he doesn't know, which leads to interesting conversations.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 13/02/2022 13:54

@Squeekyturtle

My MIL does this but only ever talks about 'important' people and always adds a vital detail about how rich they are or how big a house they have or what an important job they have eg do you know Janet's daughter the doctor with the mansion and 16 horses.

Yes I do know Janet's daughter and she is an insufferable twat !

Hyacinth Bucket! The sister with ‘room for a pony’.
SockFluffInTheBath · 13/02/2022 13:51

Don't get me started on the 'Guess Who's Dead?' Challenge (mum, there are 7.5bn people in the world, we could be here for a while).

PMSL Grin I had this last week- one of my cousins had died but since we counted I have 54 first cousins you really need to narrow it down…

EmmaH2022 · 13/02/2022 13:45

Fifty - lol so hard at "Probably not (the Boer war".

EmmaH2022 · 13/02/2022 13:44

Angelina yes, that's my parents till I explained that I didn't have enough spoons to cope with their Post Office story.

To make it fair, they get/got cross with me for being amazed sometimes when they know a certain song e.g. in the pub, Will Young "Jealousy" came on and they said "ooh, we like him" and I was honestly surprised they knew him.

That song must be 15 years old now, I think it's fairly safe to assume mum never watches music videos now...