Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel excluded from a 'mums night out'

81 replies

Poppins2016 · 12/02/2022 23:59

I'm a member of a group of relatively new friends and we keep in touch through a WhatsApp chat (as well as in person).

We all agreed that we'd like to go for a 'mums night out' sometime soon (we usually see each other with children in tow). There aren't many of us and we've been able to agree on a date easily in the past.

A couple of dates were suggested. The majority said they could make date 1. I said I couldn't, so asked whether date 2 would work.

Lady A said she couldn't make date 2.

Someone else suggested an activity on date 3, which everyone (including me) expressed interest in.

Lady A (not the person who actually suggested the night out, in case it's relevant) responded to say that we should 'go for date 1 this time as she'd already booked it' (without confirming anything first or checking to see whether I minded missing out...).

This feels like a 'big deal' to me, but I suspect there's an element of PND/PNA clouding my judgement... I admit I burst into tears when I read that I was the only person who would be excluded from the group meet up. The friendship group is quite new and I haven't said anything because I don't want to become known as oversensitive/overreacting/'that' person... I joined the group as making/maintaining new friends and a social network is important to me at the moment, even though I find it difficult (from an anxiety point of view).

So I suppose I'm wondering how people without clouded judgement might view this.

AIBU to think that a group meet up should be held on a mutually convenient date for all the people who want to go?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
notanothertakeaway · 13/02/2022 18:51

@Poppins2016

Thanks, everyone. I appreciate all of the different perspectives and it's really helped me to get a grip!

To those who have said I'm being oversensitive... I know (and it's partly because I have PND/PNA and my hormones still seem to be all over the place 5 months after giving birth). That's why I've posted here rather than make a fool of myself on the WhatsApp group! I've maintained a completely breezy, relaxed approach in the group as I know that doing anything else would be counter productive.

Well done OP. MN can be a good way to get impartial advice from strangers with no skin in the game
autienotnaughty · 13/02/2022 17:11

I would be upset too and completely agree if everyone was free on the third date then obviously that's the one to go for. I would definitely say "looks like I'm missing out this time have a great time and I'll look forward to next one. " or similar so people are aware as not everyone alway read messages properly so people may have missed the fact you couldn't make that date. My dh and I have a friendship group of five couples and there seems to be this unwritten rule that we all have to go it's a bit of a nightmare tbh because we probably try to arrange meet ups every couple month and at least 50% end up not happening due to scheduling clashes. So my preference would be go with the majority date. The issue is there was a date you could all attend. Friend A sounds abit ruthless. Also don't know if this is a new babies mums group but I found with those groups people would start to drop out once they went back to work/kids started school. I would recommend cultivating individual friendships within group as well. My first dd our mums group disbanded after about three years, some totally dropped contact, a few stayed friends in smaller groups but I wasn't included so I basically lost all my friends. It was a shock, with ds I made friends with three mums from the group and we are still close 7 years on. The rest of the group are more like acquaintances now.

carltonscroop · 13/02/2022 16:57

@MajorCarolDanvers

It's pretty difficult to get a date that suits everyone and sometimes you miss out.
But they had a date that suited everyone!

And one of the group took it upon themselves to arrange instead on a different date, excluding OP and only OP

Poppins2016 · 13/02/2022 16:20

Thanks, everyone. I appreciate all of the different perspectives and it's really helped me to get a grip!

To those who have said I'm being oversensitive... I know (and it's partly because I have PND/PNA and my hormones still seem to be all over the place 5 months after giving birth). That's why I've posted here rather than make a fool of myself on the WhatsApp group! I've maintained a completely breezy, relaxed approach in the group as I know that doing anything else would be counter productive.

OP posts:
LawnFever · 13/02/2022 13:36

@BobbinHood

In my friendship group if we waited for the date everyone was available, we’d never see each other.

When was date 3? If date 1 was Thursday, date 2 was Friday and date 3 was Saturday then it would be reasonable to wait for Saturday.

But if date 3 is in another month, it’s not unreasonable to go for the first one. Something else would happen by the time you get to date 3 meaning someone else couldn’t come and by the “everyone must be able to attend” logic you’d then have to look for another date…and so on and so on into eternity.

Totally agree, I’ve got a few groups of friends and have to accept it’s too complicated to always wait until everyone can do a date.

We tend to go with the majority and put another date in too, or it’d go on for months.

MajorCarolDanvers · 13/02/2022 12:17

It's pretty difficult to get a date that suits everyone and sometimes you miss out.

chiickenandchiips · 13/02/2022 12:14

@LimeSegment

With my groups of friends we keep going until we find a date that suits everyone

The problem is that could be months away. Why not have two (or more) meet ups in that time. OK if it's a group of old friends that meets once a year, but that's not OPs situation.

As I said, someone tends to bow out before it gets to that point if it's them causing the difficulty. Generally we can find a time that suits everyone within the next month or two and we always plan ahead and not last minute.

We wouldn't pick a date that excluded one person when there was another date everyone could do, on the say so of one selfish person.

LimeSegment · 13/02/2022 11:59

With my groups of friends we keep going until we find a date that suits everyone

The problem is that could be months away. Why not have two (or more) meet ups in that time. OK if it's a group of old friends that meets once a year, but that's not OPs situation.

Dillydollydingdong · 13/02/2022 11:49

We try hard to accommodate everyone but at the end of the day, if one or two people can't make it, we arrange a date that suits the majority., Otherwise we'd never do anything. Nothing personal I'm sure, OP.

chiickenandchiips · 13/02/2022 11:39

With my groups of friends we keep going until we find a date that suits everyone, unless anybody bows out and says they genuinely don't mind missing out that time if it is getting really and it's them causing the difficulty making dates everyone else can.

Toanewstart23 · 13/02/2022 11:38

You’ve found dates in the past
This is the first time it’s happened
And this is your reaction?

LyndaLaHughes · 13/02/2022 11:36

Actually I think this woman is being vile. She wasn't even the organiser and booked something that suited her without everyone responding yet?
I would I say back- can we not do date 3 please as everyone is available on that date so as not to exclude anyone.

watchtheglitterdustswirl · 13/02/2022 11:33

It depends how many people there are, in all honesty.

I organised an end of term meal with our mums group. 16 of us. It was a total pain in the arse and in the end we went with the date that 12 of us could make.

No one was deliberately excluded but I went with what the majority could do.

If it's under 5 people it's easier I think but then I have a group of long standing friends also that is 5 and it's even a nightmare trying to get a date we can all do, we have to do it at least six weeks in advance! Everyone is busy.

In this occasion you can make it. Unless it happens again and again I wouldn't worry about it or take it personally.

Toanewstart23 · 13/02/2022 11:33

@chantico

Well there was a date where everyone could go. But the one where only the OP cannot go was chosen instead.

Poor show. It's hurtful

But you don't have any choice than to suck it up and put as happy a face on it as you can.

There wasn’t Date 3 “everyone expressed interest in” ie no one confirmed either way
Stanleyville · 13/02/2022 11:30

How far apart are date 1 and 3? Can the group do both?

chantico · 13/02/2022 11:19

Well there was a date where everyone could go. But the one where only the OP cannot go was chosen instead.

Poor show. It's hurtful

But you don't have any choice than to suck it up and put as happy a face on it as you can.

LimeSegment · 13/02/2022 11:16

Yanbu to be privately a little annoyed, but I do see A's position. I'm often the organiser for a group of friends, not because I love doing so but because no one else usually does. If we can agree a date that most can come (a big if), I usually end up calling the restaurant or whatever 3-4 times to change the date, numbers, special requests, etc etc. It can be annoying.

I've realised the best way is to basically say "here's the plan, who's in?".

Don't forget, the person organising the meet up is putting themselves out there, the stress that maybe no one will be interested or the meet up will be a flop.

Send a message out in a few weeks organising something else.

Howshouldibehave · 13/02/2022 10:09

I think that’s really rude of her and other people will have noticed!

I’d reply-‘Oh what a shame, I thought everyone could make date 3?! As I said, I can’t do date X, so won’t be able to make this one-sorry.’

Chestofdraws · 13/02/2022 10:07

I think maybe the fact you cried because you couldn’t go is a sign of your overall mood right now. It’s not deliberate, it’s not an exclusion, please try to reframe it. It’s just you can’t make the preferred date, that’s all.

Cam2020 · 13/02/2022 10:01

Another time, it'll be someone else that can't make it. You could waste several months waiting for a date that everyone can make. In that time, several meet ups could have taken place with whoever was available.

I'm sure it wasn't a deliberate snub.

stuntbubbles · 13/02/2022 09:53

It’s often the case that 1 or 2 people can’t make it and people go with a majority as another time will come along.
But Date 1 only OP couldn’t make; date 2 only Lady A couldn’t make – so the dates were equal, one person missing out on each. Yet OP didn’t quickly book something for date 2 and announce that they were going forward with it to Lady A’s exclusion. And it sounds as though everyone could do date 3.

LazySaturday · 13/02/2022 09:15

I completely get why this would upset you. It would have been nice if Lady A had tried harder to include everybody. However, this wasn't personal in any way, she was clearly invested in this specific date/location and didn't want to change.
Next time be proactive with the organising, that way you can make sure you're at the centre of things.

BobbinHood · 13/02/2022 09:12

In my friendship group if we waited for the date everyone was available, we’d never see each other.

When was date 3? If date 1 was Thursday, date 2 was Friday and date 3 was Saturday then it would be reasonable to wait for Saturday.

But if date 3 is in another month, it’s not unreasonable to go for the first one. Something else would happen by the time you get to date 3 meaning someone else couldn’t come and by the “everyone must be able to attend” logic you’d then have to look for another date…and so on and so on into eternity.

Sharrowgirl · 13/02/2022 09:07

@Fellrunner85

I’m chief organiser in my group and I would never do what Lady A has done here. We find a date everyone can do, however long it takes

All friendship groups are different. My friends and I could never include everyone as we're too busy. If we waited until every single person was free then we would literally never meet up. One or two people can't make it each time - that's normal and that's ok. What isn't normal is if those people then cry over it. It's not personal.

To be fair, I’m thinking of a particular group that is five of us. Agree that a group of 20 school mums would be different, you’d just pick a date the most could do. But I don’t think that’s happened here, it sounds more like six people than twenty?
Fellrunner85 · 13/02/2022 09:03

I’m chief organiser in my group and I would never do what Lady A has done here. We find a date everyone can do, however long it takes

All friendship groups are different. My friends and I could never include everyone as we're too busy. If we waited until every single person was free then we would literally never meet up. One or two people can't make it each time - that's normal and that's ok. What isn't normal is if those people then cry over it. It's not personal.