Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not want my DH at my birthday party

133 replies

ParisLondonTokyoSlough · 12/02/2022 22:59

It's my birthday coming up - just a standard one (not a milestone). I just want a girls night and don't want my husband there or any of their husbands/partners. After being stuck in a man/boy house all this pandemic, I only like the company of my female friends and family members to be honest. Hanging out socially with my husband feels like a chore and changes the dynamic of all-female gatherings. And I want to actually have a fun birthday this year (after not celebrating the past 3 years (including my 30th) due to being in labour on my 30th and covid the past 2 years.

Would this be weird? Would you think it's strange if you were invited to a friends birthday and her husband wasn't there and she said no (male) partners allowed?

YABU - yes it's weird, your DH should be there and husbands should be welcome
YANBU - no it's completely fine, men are boring

OP posts:
Anonymous48 · 13/02/2022 15:27

You are not being unreasonable for wanting a night out with the girls. We all need that from time to time. But if you'd rather do that then go out with your husband for your birthday, then I think that's an issue.

Georgeskitchen · 13/02/2022 15:22

You want a girls night out for your birthday. You are absolutely NOT being unreasonable!!

girafferafferaffe · 13/02/2022 15:01

I was ready to come on here and say how awful it was that you didn't want to do anything with your husband for your birthday but I absolutely see why now. He sounds like a terrible person to be around. I would definitely do a girls night out. But also look in to counselling with him. I do believe that (if they want to and put in the work) people can change. But reading about his personality I don't hold out much hope..

babyjellyfish · 13/02/2022 14:54

YANBU but I would want to celebrate separately with my husband.

It's my birthday soon and my husband and I are taking the day off work and going out for lunch.

I want to go out for drinks with my friends as well but they are all women, and even if we got a babysitter so my husband could come out too, none of my friends' partners would come because they'd all be at home with their kids.

CleansUpButWouldPreferNotTo · 13/02/2022 14:53

if he was so awful then how come he has so many friends, and is the kind of person who knows everyone and everybody knows?

because they don't have to live with him. A few hours here and there is fun, 24/7 with him is not.

AnotherEmma · 13/02/2022 14:51

"Also the thing is he has loads of male (and a couple of female) friends, and they all love him and joke about his temper issues lovingly. So that also confuses me - if he was so awful then how come he has so many friends, and is the kind of person who knows everyone and everybody knows?"

They don't have to live with him, do they?!

Some reading for you:

www.healthline.com/health/signs-of-mental-abuse

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/relationships/2268977-The-Abuser-Profiles

www.hiddenhurt.co.uk/abusers.html

ParisLondonTokyoSlough · 13/02/2022 14:42

@AnotherEmma thanks so much for taking the time to respond. If my friend was telling me all that I probably would tell them life is too short. But I guess I've never seen him as abusive because I'm a strong-willed person so I do always let him know whenever I think he's crossed a line. My mum kept sending me links to the freedom programme last year and I told her to stop as I'm not in an abusive relationship but maybe I should look into it. I'm also remembering that he has completely lost his shit at a couple of my female family members on two separate occasions (shouting and swearing at them) - I've told him if it happens again then we're over and he hasn't done it since. None of it every seems serious enough on its own to break up a family over.

Also the thing is he has loads of male (and a couple of female) friends, and they all love him and joke about his temper issues lovingly. So that also confuses me - if he was so awful then how come he has so many friends, and is the kind of person who knows everyone and everybody knows?

OP posts:
AnotherEmma · 13/02/2022 14:14

OP, I've read through all your posts but not all the replies.

I think you should get this thread moved to Relationships or start a new thread there, with a summary of the main issues and not just the birthday question. I think many people are just going to respond to the birthday question without reading all your posts and considering the other issues in the relationship. In a healthy relationship, it would be strange not to want to celebrate your birthday with your spouse. In this relationship, which is not at all healthy, it's completely understandable that you don't want to.

I think it's great that you've decided to get counselling for yourself and hopefully it will help you to work out how you feel about your husband and what (if anything) you want to do.

Can I suggest that you read through all these comments, imagining that your sister or friend has written them about her husband - what would you think?

he's quite a negative person in terms of outlook and I'm someone who is naturally positive but my mood is very affected by the people around me. So being locked in a home together with him for extended periods over the past 2 years was quite draining. I find that these days I only laugh and feel like the old happy me when he's not there.

my husband moans and drags his feet about anything remotely "girly" that I used to enjoy (such as shopping, romcoms, doing my hair/makeup to get ready etc)

A date night with him would probably consist of him ranting about politics how the country's going to shit. I'd rather not.

He's a half glass empty kind of person (e.g. if I want us to go on a day out anywhere as a family he'll insist it's too hard, the kids will play up, there'll be too much traffic etc. and then when we're there he'll be wanting to go home early). He also can have a short fuse and can be a bit shouty when he's stressed (whereas I am more laid back) - ultimately harmless but it means home life is not exactly relaxing.

we never laugh together anymore - I don't find him funny or fun.

I don't really go out that much. But when I have done we have had some arguments over him checking up on me all the time.

I actually went out with just one of my sisters for my birthday a few years ago and he was so moody about it the next day that it wasn't worth it.

he also dominates the conversation so he really does change the dynamics of a gathering (think speaking 90% of the time).

If he loses his temper, does something wrong, or life/accidents happen, he'll always blame me or the kids.

When our other son was admitted back into hospital for malnutrition as a 2 day old newborn, his first reaction was to tell me it was my fault for choosing to breastfeed.

there were a couple of red flags while we were dating that I ignored (such as DH accusing me of wanting to cheat on him with a colleague at a work event because I'd invited said colleague to head elsewhere for drinks with a group of us, and another time getting angry and shouting at me in front of his friends at a wedding, which they told him off for).

He sounds negative, critical, controlling and rude. Abuse can be more subtle than physical aggression or verbal name-calling. I think he is abusive. Either way, he is not making you happy - quite the opposite, in fact. Think very carefully about what you want your life to be like, and what you want to teach your sons about relationships and how they should treat women. You don't want to end up like your MIL, with your sons behaving like your DH is.

Thatsplentyjack · 13/02/2022 13:54

I think it depends. Big birthday party....weird not to invite your friends partners, and your husband. Just a few friends who are women having a night out/in....not weird.

movinghelprequired · 13/02/2022 13:50

My DH and I usually do a nice dinner together for birthdays and then an "own friends" big night out too. So I'll have a nice meal (or takeaway) with DH on my actual birthday and then I'll have a girls' night to celebrate with my friends (no DPs/DHs) as they'll all be home with the DC. Sometimes I have several nights with no DH to celebrate with different groups of mates.

I've never once considered it strange to do this! Even pre-DC we did similar for non-milestone BDays.

So I think this should be totally fine OP. But it sounds like your DH's reaction is strange. Bordering on worrying.

My DH even had his 40th without me! I had small DC and he wanted to do activities that didn't appeal (expensive meat meal and gaming!) I didn't think it was a snub at all that I wasn't invited.

KatyRebecca84 · 13/02/2022 13:44

Not weird at all that you want a girls night, what is weird is that you don’t like socialising with your husband!

Monr0e · 13/02/2022 13:23

The constant messaging while you are out absolutely is controlling. You say if you responded he wouldn't get so worried. Worried about what? You are a grown woman, out with people you know presumably in a public place. What exactly is it he is worried about? And if you answer once does he message again, and again.

Its a tactic to keep you under control, stop you enjoying yourself while you are out, stop you wanting to go out in the future.

DH and I rarely message each other if we are out, unless it's to check roughly what time to expect them home or to let each other know we might be later than expected.

CreepyDibillo · 13/02/2022 13:13

@Aquamarine1029

Hanging out socially with my husband feels like a chore

This doesn't bode well at all.

I totally agree. Absolutely nothing wrong with a girls night out, even for your birthday, but to say you don't enjoy socialising with your husband is definitely not the norm.
ParisLondonTokyoSlough · 13/02/2022 12:41

@AngelinaFibres that does concern me that the pattern will continue and he'll pass on he same traits to our sons (especially since they don't really see the "fun" me much anymore).

As for the constant messaging when you do go out = controlling.

See I never saw it like that - I always seen it like he can't control/help himself from messaging. He says that if I responded to his messages he wouldn't get so worried.

If he loses his temper, does something wrong, or life/accidents happen, he'll always blame me or the kids. So he once quite dangerously gave our the wrong medication dose (triple the amount needed), but apparently was it our son's fault because our son distracted him by chattering away to DH while he administered the medication. When our other son was admitted back into hospital for malnutrition as a 2 day old newborn, his first reaction was to tell me it was my fault for choosing to breastfeed.

Thinking about it, there were a couple of red flags while we were dating that I ignored (such as DH accusing me of wanting to cheat on him with a colleague at a work event because I'd invited said colleague to head elsewhere for drinks with a group of us, and another time getting angry and shouting at me in front of his friends at a wedding, which they told him off for).

Does he ever comment on his dads behaviour, could he be made to see that's he's behaving the same way?

I think he realises that some of his dad's behaviour isn't ideal (sexist and racist/xenophobic comments) but excuses it as getting old. However the negativity and moaning, shouting and poor anger management - DH doesn't really see it. In fact, he idolises his parents and when our children are playing up, often reminisces fondly on the fact that his dad would have knocked sense into him. Sometimes he threatens to smack our DS5 and always tells me we're too "soft" on the boys (which is not true - compared to gentle parenting methods, I'm very strict and working on chilling out the discipline a bit).

That said he's not all bad - I feel like I've focused on the negatives - and I'm certainly not perfect. I zone him out most of the time now. I don't accept his offers to watch stuff together anymore (he always fast forwards through the "boring" bits of series we're watching together so I prefer to watch them alone now). I decline when he asks if I want to grab lunch with him. Generally, I actively avoid one-on-one time with him. Like I said upthread he's very hand-on with the boys and takes them on long muddy walks, plays lots with them in the garden- the boys really do love their father, even with his short fuse, as he does engage well with them and is fun with them if they're doing a physical activity.

I think I will book some counselling for myself to work through my feelings as I don't want to keep living like this.

OP posts:
ChateauxNeufDePoop · 13/02/2022 11:57

@daisychain01

If you don't like your husband's company at all, then the birthday do is just a red herring. You sound like you have marriage problems, you should be thinking about that rather than asking if it's unreasonable to go out with your friends without him.

It doesn't need to be either/or, but the drip feed is you don't want him at all, so there's your answer.

Yup. Enjoy a birthday with your friends, you'd not be unreasonable to want that whatever the state of your marriage but you obviously have a separate issue (no pun intended) that you need to address sooner rather than later in that your marriage doesn't make you happy.
balzamico · 13/02/2022 11:12

You have every right to go out with your friends without interruption.
However there's clearly more going on than one evening.
Does he ever comment on his dads behaviour, could he be made to see that's he's behaving the same way?
If he can then maybe counselling would help.

The biggie for me would be that you are bringing up two boys who you don't want to grow up with the same miserable outlook - if you separate at least they'd have happy, laughing you at least 50% of the time

CrinklyCraggy · 13/02/2022 11:02

A birthday night out, perfectly reasonable and normal to go with your friends. An actual party, I think it would be odd if partners weren't included.

I'm not sure why, but I'd expect something family/partner based on the day and friends at the weekend.

It is a worry that you don't want to be around DH though.

Monr0e · 13/02/2022 10:55

OP, he sounds awful. How old are your children? Do you go on holidays? Days out? Does he ruin them all? You talk about things maybe being better when they are older but they deserve happiness (as do you) right now
This is their childhood. And he sounds like he is sucking all the fun and light out of all of your days.

As for the constant messaging when you do go out = controlling.

I'd be laying it on the line. He is making you unhappy, he is chipping away at your love and like for him and ultimately your marriage. And ask him what is he willing to do about it.

You get one life, don't spend it waiting years to get better, when all the signs are there that it won't.

AngelinaFibres · 13/02/2022 10:45

I put the problems in my first marriage down to having small children, no sleep, difficult pregnancies, PND . I had a group of friends and when we got together they mostly had a good old moan about their husbands so I thought everyone had a marriage as grey and devoid of jollity as me. .I tried to talk to my mum but her attitude was that you got married and you stayed married so she just batted away anything I said and changed the subject. She wasn't in a happy marriage so I guess she thought I should share her pain. I became very ground down by it but everyone else looked knackered and a bit saggy so I thought that was how it was supposed to be after you had had children.Your comment about not laughing anymore took me back to how it was. He didn't ever want to go to social events . People would invite us and I would be desperate to go. I knew I had to come up with a legitimate reason why we couldn't go as I wouldn't be allowed to go on my own and he wouldn't want to go. The time that I decided to out my foot down and insist that we go he behaved like your husband and dominated the event with his fabulous knowledge. After a while he got drunk and fell asleep in the corner. The invitations dried up after that and I became even more isolated and lost. It was years ago. I had no job, tiny children and nowhere to go. I would still be there now I expect if he hadn't had an affair and left me. You don't have to be married to a man who makes you so miserable. There are other ways to live. You say your boys are picking up his traits. My boys love shopping and girly films and chatting over coffee as much as they love beer and rugby. My second husband was brought up by a man who sounds very much like your husband. We married when he was in his 40s .He said it had taken life with his late wife to make him realise that joy was allowed, that shopping didn't make you effeminate, 'a poofter' as his dad would say. Doing things that bring joy and treating your partner as an equal was allowed and watching rom coms made that person happy and was therefore very much worth doing. Your boys will absorb all they see around them. A childhood without laughter in a house affects you for life.

Lightupmynorthernsky · 13/02/2022 10:34

Go out with your friends. And at a different time go out with just DH or with other couples. Don’t lose your own identity just because you’re in a relationship, if you want a girls night out have one. No need to compromise on everything. It wouldn’t occur to me to include DP in plans for a night out with friends. I’d say ‘just letting you know I’m out on X night’, he’d say the same to me. Otherwise I’d say ‘we’re going out with/do you fancy going out with X on X night’.

There may be wiser issues within your relationship you may choose to address. Wanting a night out with your mates isn’t one of them.

peboh · 13/02/2022 10:13

I'd be upset if my dh didn't want to celebrate his birthday with me. Wether it's a milestone or not. However we like each other's company! You don't seem to like your husband, so I think your relationship is dead in the water.

AngelinaFibres · 13/02/2022 10:11

I said up thread that you should go for counselling. Reading all your posts Op, I still think you should go, either with him, or for yourself, but as a way of separating amicably. It is not unusual for female friends not to warm to a husband in the group , but the fact that his own friends are pulling him up on the way he behaves is very telling. Men rarely get involved in other couples relationships. He is a mood hoover, a fun sponge, a misery. My SIL is the same. I dread family meet ups. She will suck the joy out of the planning of an event and then suck the tiny crumbs of joy that remain when you actually get together. If she went to Mardi gras within 5 minutes they would all have packed up and gone off to phone the Samaritans. Her husband left her years ago. He came back and now they simply exist in a sexless, joyless journey towards death. They are 75. You are young. Take some time to think if this is really the life you want.

DonnyBurrito · 13/02/2022 10:07

@5128gap Nail on the head. Thank you for spelling this out.

endingintiers · 13/02/2022 10:03

@Bananarama21

Interesting the similar was posted about the same thing other day about a man wanting to celebrate with his friends and not partner and he was called worse than shit on here. Talk about double standards!
The other post was the OH going away over Easter weekend for 3 nights for a milestone birthda, leaving the poster to look after the kids. This is one night out for a non-milestone birthday. I don't think it's the same at all.

To answer your question I usually go out with my girlfriends without partners for our birthdays. But then we also spend time with our family and partners as well. So it's not the one man-free night out but the fact you don't want to spend any time with your partner which is the issue

roarfeckingroarr · 13/02/2022 09:56

Change the phrasing.

Don't call it your birthday party, call it a girls night for your birthday. Then do something with your husband / family too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread