Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you feel if your child as beneficiary of his pension instead of you?

187 replies

insuretothecore · 12/02/2022 22:19

stay at home mum for nearly a decade now while having children, earning potential has decreased, no pension contributions in this time while DH is putting money into a private pension on top of what is required. Not a lot, but obviously it builds over a lifetime.
He has put our children down to receive the money if he dies.
I have stayed at home and been mother and wife, my qualifications are now obsolete its been that long since I've been in the game, and it looks like DH thinks I should be left with nothing if he dies.
I have never felt so worthless. we aren't married either.

Yabu - children should be beneficiary
Yanbu - partner should be beneficiary

OP posts:
fallfallfall · 13/02/2022 00:19

@insuretothecore, not sure if you're doing it on purpose or if mentally it is what you want but he is NOT you're DH.
he is your dear partner and the legal difference is significant when it comes to finances.
so i read that your doing the best you know how based on your lived experience.
you have multiple posters telling you that the first step in securing your future is to marry.

then other's giving you more detailed advice and you're saying no way.
change is hard but would you want your daughter to be in such a position with the very real potential of being homeless with hardly any income in her older years?
it's a good thing your asking and the potential if you seek financial advice could be life changing for you in 5 years.

caringcarer · 13/02/2022 00:17

@insuretothecore, I know plenty of families where both parents work with 1 or 2 children in full time child care. My dd went back to work after 10 months and her D's had to go to full time nursery. Childcare is very expensive but too much time out of your career is more expensive in the long run. She waited to have a second child until her first child was getting his free hours at preschool. After second DC she went back in to my work after 8 months. It is normal to go back to work after having a baby.

noirchatsdeux · 13/02/2022 00:15

Makes me sad that a woman of nearly 30 has the same views as my mother...who is 80...

She was a stay at home mother, she felt my father 'owed' her financial support for her whole life because she'd had children. Backfired massively on her when he left her for OW when I was 21 (he'd waited until my younger brother turned 18 so he wouldn't have to pay child support).

They were married, but had only owned the house for 3 years so hardly any equity. No pensions, savings, insurance...nothing. House had to be sold and the equity was split. My mother ended up with a lump sum of £10K, after a 23 year marriage.

She now lives in the Australian equivalent of a tiny housing association flat on a state pension.

If you aren't going to get married you need to get a job asap.

Starseeking · 13/02/2022 00:13

Your situation actually doesn't work well for your living family. If your DP died, your living family is you and your DC.

If you are not married, or named on the house deeds or life insurance, your house would have to be sold to settle the mortgage balance, and you would have no income other than any state benefits you could claim to live on.

You are in an extremely vulnerable position OP, I wouldn't waste your time on here thinking up smart responses to those who've given you robust advice. I'd be absorbing the most useful and helpful comments, and focussing on sorting this out pdq.

Riv · 13/02/2022 00:12

I don’t want to add to the doom and gloom. You are doing what you believed best for your family, but you, like so many of us women, have difficulties thinking about yourself .
Hopefully you now realise: if you are married and something awful happens (eg you split up or one of you dies) everything you have built up together (savings, house, pension etc regardless of who’s name they are in) is split, or inherited by the surviving spouse.
If you are not married, and one of you died without a will, each partner is only entitled to what is already theirs and in their name- eg half the house IF both names are on the mortgage and half of the joint accounts for example. The other half goes to his direct relatives in a specific order (kids, parents, siblings, blood related aunts and uncles, cousins NOTHING is automatically left to the unmarried partner ) It’s the same if you split up - if you are unmarried he has to pay towards his children but you get nothing you don’t already own in your own name.
It’s quite a shock and it’s tough. Marriage is a legal contract that gives both parties rights over each other’s property, it is a lot more than a piece of paper. You need a lot of other legal documents to get those benefits if you don’t want to go down the marriage route.

AlexaShutUp · 13/02/2022 00:08

I understand, OP. It's easy for other people to judge if they are surrounded by people who are making better financial decisions, and there are things that therefore seem like basic common sense. But we are all influenced by our environments and if everyone you know was making similar choices, it's easy to see why you might not have thought about doing things differently.

I do think you've made some errors of judgement that have put you in a tricky position now, but you can take steps now to improve the situation. Life insurance is a good plan. And so is finding a job of some sort. It doesn't matter if you haven't had much experience, you can still start to build it up now. And please just get married. Try to make your dp understand how vulnerable the current situation makes you. If he is decent, he will take steps to protect you. If he is not, then all the more reason for needing to protect yourself.

steff13 · 13/02/2022 00:07

Cut out my wink face emoji that indicatedjoke that's not very nice, or clever as there is a written record of the infact joke.

You can't copy am emoji when you copy on here. And it really isn't something to be joking about anyway. You're in a very precarious position.

nellly · 13/02/2022 00:03

Now that you know you have no protection what about just getting married down the registry office, don't even need to tell
Anyone!
It does sound like your boyfriend hasn't really thought about you in any sort of
Way if something bad happens. I don't think that means he thinks your worthless at all it's probably just not crossed his mind. But now you know and youve thought about it you'd be daft not to put some plans in place! Especially if you plan not to have a career and do cleaning part time because you'll just never earn as much as him.

insuretothecore · 12/02/2022 23:59

@steff13

Sorry it works well for our living family. The zombies hate it.

No it works for your partner and your children are probably unaffected either way. It doesn't work for you. I wouldn't be so snarky if I was in that position.

Cut out my wink face emoji that indicated joke that's not very nice, or clever as there is a written record of the infact joke.
OP posts:
princesspopppy · 12/02/2022 23:56

If he won't marry you take out life insurance on him so you can at least afford to buy your house out right.

insuretothecore · 12/02/2022 23:53

@AlexaShutUp

I don't know anyone with children who has both parents working before school age. childcare costs too much for it to even be an option.

OK, so it sounds like you are living in a deprived community where everyone is on a low wage. Maybe you are also surrounded by others who are in a similarly precarious position to your own, and that you do not therefore fully appreciate the risks that you are exposing yourself to. They are significant and you have no protection at the moment. Please consider either finding a job or getting married sooner - you can do the paperwork and then have a proper celebration later.

nail on the head here. don't know anyone who knows this stuff and the only people I know who have a house is council so no deposit needed. Also marriage comes at about 30-40 when (ironically) you are financially secure! you just do what you know don't you?

and to the poster who said contradicting myself. I was on track to getting a good job that I was j terested In , fell pregnant decided to post pone and keep baby. Me and dh moved in and we talked about it decided we wanted more children and thought we would have them close together so they an grow up together, be close and if not going to be working for 4 years until reception what's one more? but it took longer and bee 2 more and then we had surprise so now ots looking like 13 years. I had a very short stint in the middle before surprise baby but even before that happened I had to quit because DH couldn't be there to look after them, no family help and the local nurseries have minimum days and it costs more than I could have earned part time, plus travel costs, extra hours for travelling to and from. It would have cost us more and we were renting, saving for a house and it wasn't worth it. in the end it took us 8 years to get enough as house prices keep going up and its a race to save
we wouldn't have done it if we were losing money so I'm confident we made the right decision. BUT still financially dependent on DH and have a very lived working history and experience. a big gap and children which deter employers. don't care what you say its true
I already know I'm up shit creek if DH left me or died but him not even realising or thinking about that DESPITE ME TELLING HIM! just was the cherry on top

OP posts:
princesspopppy · 12/02/2022 23:53

My DH is leaving his pension to our children, they will benefit for longer than me. That said I will naturally inherit his half of our house plus there's significant cash set aside.

On its own the pension thing isn't bad but being a SAHM unmarried is. Personally I'd be looking at having a low key wedding.

Shutupandcry · 12/02/2022 23:50

Mumsnet is a great resource. I don't know anyone with children who has both parents working before school age. childcare costs too much for it to even be an option

Literally every other parent I know works in some capacity whether part time or full time surely that’s the norm now? The only SAHMs I know are v wealthy. Childcare might cost 400 x 2 a month but your wage will far outstrip that?

RedToothBrush · 12/02/2022 23:45

both names on the mortgage. But still what if the mortgage isn't paid and he's gone? would I lose the house if I don't work orost likely work part time because of the children.

as previous poster said - you need life insurance on him.

CayrolBaaaskin · 12/02/2022 23:45

@insuretothecore - are you suggesting I said you were “scum” as obviously I didn’t. This is mumsnet. Most mums work. It’s not impossible, and if you’re financially struggling, it’s probably a good idea.

UnderTheSea20k · 12/02/2022 23:45

I actually have no words, how anybody could treat their entire life with so little forethought or consideration. Why do you consider yourself to be so worthless that you can live with zero potential or security, relying on somebody’s good moods for a roof over your head? He meets someone hot at work—you’d basically be homeless unemployed without a dime to your name and an old age of poverty. Yet you seem almost proud of this situation???

MichelleScarn · 12/02/2022 23:44

you are right I am scum nope that's not what @CayrolBaaaskin said. You're the one being sarky!

Kite22 · 12/02/2022 23:44

He is working 60+ hours a week plus commute plus staying away whenever he is needed. So it's not really possible, I couldn't even manage 1 day

When our dc were little, dh and I were both working 60 hours a week. I'm not sure why you can't manage one day Confused

I don't know anyone with children who has both parents working before school age.

Odd. I don't know anyone who didn't go back to work. Even if it was PT work.

I don't understand how you can have decided to make a choice to be a SAHP without discussing everything financial. Quite frankly, I don't know why you would decide to become a parent at all without having all these discussions about how you will manage.

Why will you still be paying the mortgage if he were to die suddenly ? Did you not take out insurance when you bought the house ? ('You' being both of you, as a couple ?)

dh = dear husband
dp = dear partner
In a thread like this, yes, it does make a difference.

prsphne · 12/02/2022 23:43

But what if you die first? What have you put in place? You’re a SAHM as someone needs to look after the kids and childcare doesn’t make financial sense, so how would it make sense if you died. Is there an insurance payout that would cover childcare costs or mortgage costs if he had to stop working?

You both need to sit down and ensure there is adequate protection for the other if either one of you died. It’s not fair to say he didn’t think of you if you haven’t thought of him either. You are in the more precarious position so it matters more for you, but it does cut both ways.

CayrolBaaaskin · 12/02/2022 23:42

Op you have very old fashioned and imo sexist ideas. No reason women can’t and shouldn’t work. I know very few who don’t.

AlexaShutUp · 12/02/2022 23:42

I'm guessing that you were very young when you had your first dc, OP? You have put yourself into quite a vulnerable situation but it isn't too late to change it. A change of mindset is probably the first thing that you need. You can't rely on anyone else to look after you, you need to plan for yourself. Just in case.

insuretothecore · 12/02/2022 23:41

@CayrolBaaaskin

I worked full time in a demanding job from when dd2 was 9 months. I became a single parent and still work full time. Having kids is not the reason you haven’t worked for 10 years.

I also left my pension to my kids not my ex even when we were together. I wanted them to have it.

you are right I am scum
OP posts:
steff13 · 12/02/2022 23:41

Sorry it works well for our living family. The zombies hate it.

No it works for your partner and your children are probably unaffected either way. It doesn't work for you. I wouldn't be so snarky if I was in that position.

Aquamarine1029 · 12/02/2022 23:40

You act as though you have no agency in your own life. You've make poor choices that have put you in this shit position, now you have to make choices to get yourself out of it. One thing is for certain, this man is never, ever going to marry you. You've known this all along yet allowed yourself to get here.

insuretothecore · 12/02/2022 23:39

@steff13

Our situation works well for our family BUT if he died or if he left me ( I couldn't even dream of it because I'm financially dependent and have children to comsider - luckily I don't want to he is the love of my life) well if have been done for.

The fact that you would be in financial trouble if he died or left you means that your situation does NOT work well for your family.

Sorry it works well for our living family. The zombies hate it 😉
OP posts: