Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you feel if your child as beneficiary of his pension instead of you?

187 replies

insuretothecore · 12/02/2022 22:19

stay at home mum for nearly a decade now while having children, earning potential has decreased, no pension contributions in this time while DH is putting money into a private pension on top of what is required. Not a lot, but obviously it builds over a lifetime.
He has put our children down to receive the money if he dies.
I have stayed at home and been mother and wife, my qualifications are now obsolete its been that long since I've been in the game, and it looks like DH thinks I should be left with nothing if he dies.
I have never felt so worthless. we aren't married either.

Yabu - children should be beneficiary
Yanbu - partner should be beneficiary

OP posts:
LaChanticleer · 13/02/2022 06:30

You are very financially vulnerable. If you split, you would have no automatic right to anything that doesn’t have your name on it.

So try to get back to work. Or have a discussion about your partner paying into a pension for you. Or life insurance.

But you need to plan for getting towards some financial independence.

HotToddyColdSauvignon · 13/02/2022 06:30

Stop calling him your DH

He is not your DH. He is your DP
Huge massive legal difference. Short answer: get married. Book a Wednesday morning off in 5 weeks or whenever the registry office has their next available opening and get bloody married.

Butchyrestingface · 13/02/2022 06:19

I suppose life just happens and you don't think about these things until you do and then you go 'uh oh I suppose I'll be in the shit' or worse he dies and you're actually in the shit.

So if YOU haven’t thought about these things, why do you think HE should have? You clearly haven’t given any thought to how a bloke who works 60+ hours a week is going to cope with 3 kids and no family support in the event that you die.

How would he continue working and pay the mortgage? And yet HE’S the one who only sees you as a “vessel” for his children when you have both sleepwalked into this situation and your relentless description of him as your “DH” suggests you intend to continue doing so.

I’d get married in a registry office as a matter of urgency just to improve your legal/financial status. Surely a church wedding can come later? Smile

Krakenchorus · 13/02/2022 05:44

"Our situation works well for our family"

The situation works very, very poorly for you, OP. That statement only works if you don't count. And you don't seem to.

Your dp makes plans for the future as if you do not exist. You feel financially vulnerable (you are) and highly anxious about how you'll ever work again. You are happy to clean houses (nought wrong with that, but you mentioned another career path) over putting yourself first, retraining and finding work that will give you a career.

There is no substitute for work. Not even marriage (which would also be a Very Good Idea). No substitute for you sitting down tomorrow and making a plan for your working future. Then, with the support of your dp and children, putting it into action.

What job would you like to go for? What training or education is needed? How will that be paid for? What childcare will be necessary?

You are so very worth the time and money and effort, OP. And it will benefit your family.

hellcatspangle · 13/02/2022 05:43

Why don't you have life insurance linked to the mortgage? I thought it was a pre requisite when two people were buying a house, to safeguard against one of them dying and making the other homeless.

Anniegetyourgun76 · 13/02/2022 05:41

I never really thought about it before as we were renting a tiny flat, saving for a house to get out of the vicious cycle of paying more to a landlord that can kick you out. cost you more etc
only now we have gotten to our goal and now have life Insurance and hpuse insurance and stuff.

Darling if you're not married and your name isn't on the deeds all you've done is moved from a house where the landlord can kick you out at any time to a house your partner can kick you out of anytime. You need real advice you are in a really vulnerable position.

lonelydad2021 · 13/02/2022 05:32

There is a lot of help for childcare 30 hours free, 85% of childcare, tax free childcare, etc. Even if you work and get even mondy wise, you will be building your career and pension.

RedWingBoots · 13/02/2022 05:31

OP posters aren't being rude to you they are telling you to wake up and that you can make choices in your life.

Even if you marry him there are no guarantees that you will stay married for the rest of your life, he won't get so ill so he can't work, or one of you will not die early.

So you need to sit down with him and tell he cannot just go galavanting around the country working a 60 hour week like a childless single person without considering that you need to work as well. That way you are all, as in your family, are financially protected if anything happens to him.

TealSapphire · 13/02/2022 05:15

Do you want more for yourself OP? Not just material things, but more interaction with others, more fulfilment?

My DH left me - and our four kids - two years ago and in many ways life just went on. Yes, the emotional side took a toll, but I'm certainly not in the shit. If you would be, then I would take steps now to get more independence.

Also, everyone has to factor in travel time and costs when working. That is not unique to you. It's not easy at times working with young kids, but in most cases it can be done.

TheKeatingFive · 13/02/2022 05:15

OP you've been naive, but as you're still young you have time to get yourself in a better position

Someone posted this upthread, it's a good list of thing ms you should be doing to help yourself.

Ensuring money is being paid into a private pension in your name.
Better still getting a job and/or qualifications.
Getting life insurance on him.
Making sure you own half the house legally.
Getting married.

Make an action plan and execute it. If I were you I'd prioritise getting back to the jobs market. You're making yourself vulnerable relying on him like this.

bonetiredwithtwins · 13/02/2022 05:04

My pensions are left to our children

But my DH isn't a SAHP but he does earn significantly less than me

I don't get posts like these honestly- presumably it was a joint decision for you to stay off work. You could have said no I want to go back to work and build a career and use childcare - but you didn't - you have benefited by not working and being at home with your children but are now not happy about it 🤷🏻‍♀️

Childcare costs more than my DH income but we made the choice for him to continue working

AnnaK163 · 13/02/2022 05:02

You are right to be upset OP.
If he is dead set against marriage, what about a civil partnership? That would be some legal protection for you if he died.
What worries me is if he left you - you would end up homeless with the little ones, with no work or money either.
Definitely he needs life insurance so you are protected if he dies.
I live in an area where there are loads of young couples with kids who aren';t married and they call themselves "common law" wife as if that is some kind of status in law - it isn't - in the eyes of the law your relationship does not exist. A lot of women don't know this until something bad happens. Good luck

BootsScootsAndToots · 13/02/2022 04:54

@MichelleScarn

In fact why are you thinking about your partner dying? He's not yet 30, no health Issue?
You win the silliest comment of the thread 🏆
DropYourSword · 13/02/2022 04:38

Two things stand out here. If you were childhood sweethearts and he's around 30 then you must be around the same age. So you have 30+ more years earning potential.

Secondly, when me and DP wrote our will we went together to get it done. It wouldn't have occurred to me to do it separately - then we both knew exactly what the plan was. It sounds like a communication issue here.

AlDanvers · 13/02/2022 04:30

Tbh I am thinking there's a chance this isn't real 'I suppose it was the trend for marriage being a piece of paper'. Really? You are aware it was just a trend but planned your life on it anyway?

You live in a deprived area, he doesn't earn that much but managed to get a mortgage with both of your names on? So it must be a cheap area? When one person isn't working, mortgage application usually classea that person as a dependent. So he would have had an extra dependent to factor in.

So either he earns fairly well or it's a cheap area. I live in a similar area. Plenty of the mothers work when their kids go to school.

You are chose to be a sahm and choosing to remain so. You are choosing to be out of the work place. If he is on a low wage you, wont earn much you will get help towards breakfast clubs.

You sounds fairly young (around 30) so have time to build your pension. Being a sahm benefitted him. But it also benefitted you. Its choice you made and our choices have consequences. Whatever we choose.

You need to get back into work. Quite frankly if he isn't paid well, his pension won't be enough, if he died to keep you comfortable, pay the mortgage off etc

He needs life insurance, to pay the mortgage off, if he died. The more urgent situation would be if he left you. You wouldn't get to stay in the home for as long as you want or pay for yiu in anyway. You need your own income.

Which is why, in general, lots of women work.

Stop planning your life on what other people do or say and secure your own financial security.

Nowayoutonlydown · 13/02/2022 04:22

There's a huge amount to unpack here OP. It does seem like both you and your DP have been quite foolhardy financially.

Having child benefit means you get NI contributions toward your pension.

There should be insurance alongside your mortgage which should stipulate that the mortgage is paid off if one of you dies- you should check that.

What about life insurance? It doesn't seem like something either of you have considered. He needs to get it for you too. Not only so you can be financially protected but so he can be if you die too. Life insurance would mean having money to support yourself potentially, but for him it would mean that things like childcare would be covered.
It doesn't cost a huge amount, I took some out several years ago, and coverage works out at about £4000 a month. I think we're paying £60 a month. It's worth the peace of mind.

Please, if you can figure out how to work from home, evenings or weekends. Even if it is only 1/2 shifts per week. You need to have some financial stability. I'm off work at the moment because of Pregnancy related health issues, we've discussed our finances for when the baby arrives. Myself and DH earn penny for penny the same so one of us working didn't necessarily mean it had to be me (except for breastfeeding!) But DH is cutting his pension down in order to pay into mine whilst I'm off work because its unfair otherwise given that I'm at home so he doesn't have to be, given that our working hours would make childcare nigh on impossible. He wouldn't take advantage of the situation where it seems your partner hasn't even given it any thought.

bedheadedzombie · 13/02/2022 03:46

You need to stop being sarcastic about well meaned replies you don't like and start organising your life.

silentpool · 13/02/2022 03:36

OP, you are being very defensive. You can help yourself here by:

Ensuring money is being paid into a private pension in your name.
Better still getting a job and/or qualifications.
Getting life insurance on him.
Making sure you own half the house legally.
Getting married.

My husband left me when I was in my mid 40's. It happens and my standard of living is lower now - I'm rebuilding my career. But he didn't get to walk away - my marriage certificate got me a court ordered settlement.

People are trying to warn you. We see so many women like you on here and you need to know that you do not have to live as if you have no control over your life.

echt · 13/02/2022 03:20

I'm in Australia, where things are slightly different, but may have implications about your husband's private pension.

When my DH died, his occupational pension contacted me about NoK, etc. and nominated beneficiaries and children, their age, etc. The pension company made the decision about the split of the pension. They judged 100% to me. This is the point: they could have overridden my DH's intentions had they so judged.

It's worth checking out your OH's pension scheme to see if this applies.
Although a lot of stuff on pensions is online now, there'll be hard copies somewhere of original documents.

Meanwhile, good advice here about getting married/a job, etc.

While I loved my DH dearly, as I he did me, getting married was significantly about making money matters, particularly pensions, easier.

Goooglebox · 13/02/2022 02:32

I'd be hurt by this too. You would need that money in later life.

Rainbowqueeen · 13/02/2022 02:30

Yes OP that would make me feel crap.

I hope it spurs you into action. In your shoes I would start looking for work immediately. CAB might be a good place to start to look at your options. Or a recruitment agency. You have mentioned cleaning. Would care work interest you - there are usually lots of jobs available. I’d try to start earning asap but come up with a longer term plan.

Is getting married an option? I’d discuss it with my partner and if he agrees, get it booked. No fuss, just get it done.

It’s great that you have realised things need to change while you are relatively young. So get to work on changing them. And 💐💐. You are not worthless.

fallfallfall · 13/02/2022 01:42

not to mention as quickly as he changed the beneficiary he could change it back....so naïve.

mummykel16 · 13/02/2022 00:46

@insuretothecore

stay at home mum for nearly a decade now while having children, earning potential has decreased, no pension contributions in this time while DH is putting money into a private pension on top of what is required. Not a lot, but obviously it builds over a lifetime. He has put our children down to receive the money if he dies. I have stayed at home and been mother and wife, my qualifications are now obsolete its been that long since I've been in the game, and it looks like DH thinks I should be left with nothing if he dies. I have never felt so worthless. we aren't married either.

Yabu - children should be beneficiary
Yanbu - partner should be beneficiary

Yabu because your dp could well be equally as clueless as you about the risks to your future if something happened to him, he could be relying on the common law wife myth.
youvegottenminuteslynn · 13/02/2022 00:43

It is the way it has always been done the man works and the women work when the childbearing and rearing is over

And this tradition was always in tandem with the tradition of marriage.

He's chosen the bits that allow him to have free childcare, a partner, someone to take care of her home and have sex with but not the bits that mean he has to share any assets of finances if you split up.

LittleBearPad · 13/02/2022 00:22

Get married. You are in a really precarious situation.
Then train to do something, then get a job.