Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you feel if your child as beneficiary of his pension instead of you?

187 replies

insuretothecore · 12/02/2022 22:19

stay at home mum for nearly a decade now while having children, earning potential has decreased, no pension contributions in this time while DH is putting money into a private pension on top of what is required. Not a lot, but obviously it builds over a lifetime.
He has put our children down to receive the money if he dies.
I have stayed at home and been mother and wife, my qualifications are now obsolete its been that long since I've been in the game, and it looks like DH thinks I should be left with nothing if he dies.
I have never felt so worthless. we aren't married either.

Yabu - children should be beneficiary
Yanbu - partner should be beneficiary

OP posts:
timewillhealabrokenheart · 13/02/2022 09:02

OP I'm considerably older than you; almost pension age, but was in a similar position 40 years ago. Living together, but fell pregnant and didn't want to get married. OH had good job, wanted me to be a SAHM (much more common then), which I was quite happy to do, but after a while I suggested getting married. He was fine with that, but if I hadn't mentioned it, I think he would've carried on living together. We married and had another child. Still married 40 years later, but I look back and shudder to think how vulnerable I was if something happened to him before we married.
DH was SE and worked 7 days a week in the early days. He couldn't have done that without me being at home looking after the DC's. We moved house many times over the years, trading up to bigger houses. I worked my butt off turning a dump into a home, that was my working contribution. However my pension has suffered; something I hadn't really thought about when younger, but I'm redressing now.

It may be difficult for you atm, if children are still young, but once in school you can do private cleaning, which pays well, register with HMRC as self employed and you can pay Class 2 NIC's if your profit is over £6500 per year.

Oh and speak to DP about getting married. A small registry office wedding won't be expensive.

dottydodah · 13/02/2022 08:58

TBH If hes only in his 30s, then hopefully he will be around for a while yet! I think its the very least of your worries ATM! God forbid if you broke up in the future ,then you would not have a claim on his estate at all! Maybe talk about getting married when you can .Also maybe look for a PT job either now or when DC start school? Nurseries /play groups /TA posts are all family friendly .I worked as a Nursery School Teacher ,Term times only .This worked out well .Also have a PP from my earlier Career in a bank . It would be wise to look at your future now TBH.Its unlikely that you will be happy being a SAHM for ever surely!

Aposterhasnoname · 13/02/2022 08:52

But still what if the mortgage isn't paid and he's gone?

Firstly, surely you have life insurance that will pay off the mortgage if he died? I thought it was a condition of getting a mortgage, but maybe not. If you don’t have it, get it now.

Secondly, not all jobs are 9-5 Monday- Friday, I worked evenings and weekend when DD was young.

MichelleScarn · 13/02/2022 08:23

*04:54BootsScootsAndToots

MichelleScarn

In fact why are you thinking about your partner dying? He's not yet 30, no health Issue?

You win the silliest comment of the thread🏆*

Oh gosh I am honoured! 🥰🤩

TheChild · 13/02/2022 08:21

@Darbs76

It’s funny OP says she doesn’t know anyone who works who has children pre school age but I have the opposite - I don’t know anyone who gave up their job completely. There’s a lot of funded hours too now age 3, my friends DD goes 3 full days that she doesn’t pay for as she gets 30yrs free.
Same here, I don't know any families with one SAHP while the other works. Most families I know are a mix of both parents working full time or one full time and one part time.

My DD gets her 30 hours free childcare in a school nursery so is at nursery 9 till 3:30 every weekday with no extra costs to pay. There are plenty of options out there for assistence with childcare that can be mixed with evening/weekend/home working.

Darbs76 · 13/02/2022 08:14

It’s funny OP says she doesn’t know anyone who works who has children pre school age but I have the opposite - I don’t know anyone who gave up their job completely. There’s a lot of funded hours too now age 3, my friends DD goes 3 full days that she doesn’t pay for as she gets 30yrs free.

notanothertakeaway · 13/02/2022 08:13

If you live in Scotland, then you might have some rights post-separation as a cohabitee

But I agree with PP that you are in a precarious financial position

There's a huge shortage of carers across the UK, so you might be able to pick up work quite easily, even if only evenings / weekends

Threads like this frighten me. There's a time and place for marriage v cohabitation, and I'm not saying that one is always better than the other, but I see so many threads on here where people have little understanding of the consequences of their decisions

Darbs76 · 13/02/2022 07:57

Many women work and pay for childcare out of the family pot. It’s not just about earning money to pay for stuff but keeping a career going, paying into a pension and being financially independent. There’s no way I’d have considered giving my career up, then have to start again when they started school. So many women are in this position, unmarried and oblivious to the fact their partner could walk away and they’d be entitled to nothing.

CovidCorvid · 13/02/2022 07:50

When my Dd was little we lost money on paying out childcare. So yes we were worse off every month with me working. But I still did it because I knew it was temporary and I needed to build my career and ultimate earning potential up. Taking time out wouldn’t have helped with that. Now Dd is 20yo and I earn nearly as much as dh.

CovidCorvid · 13/02/2022 07:47

When a man in such a situation says he doesn’t want to get married it makes me very suspicious. The main benefit to not being married for him is to protect his assets in the event of a split. He is prioritising protecting his assets over protecting his family. I know you say he’s nkw agreed to get married but don’t let him drag his feet on this.

Also you say you can’t get a job now because of costs of childcare, etc. Remember the childcare doesnt just fall on you to pay, he should pay at least half. I get if things are tight maybe it’s not very affordable but please look again once the kids start school. Before school and after school childcare will cost less than full time.

I’m old enough for my kids to be grown now and have seen enough mums at my stage of life be really shatter by separation and even divorce when they’ve not been working for twenty years. It’s very hard to get a job at that point.

TheChild · 13/02/2022 07:45

I pushed out TWO babies, I still had a job before pregnancy, during and after pregnancy. Do you not live in a country that has maternity leave?!

And your earlier post when you said why would people wait years before having another baby and then have to leave work again, people wait years BECAUSE they don't want to be in your financial situation where paying for 2 young children to attend full time childcare costs more than their wage. They wait so they can afford another set of childcare costs when the first child is in school.

I have sympathy for your situation and your DP should have put you down as beneficiary for his pension, but you don't exactly sound like you're willing to put the things in place to protect yourself. In fact, you sound like you're just making excuses.

BatshitCrazyWoman · 13/02/2022 07:33

@lonelydad2021

There is a lot of help for childcare 30 hours free, 85% of childcare, tax free childcare, etc. Even if you work and get even mondy wise, you will be building your career and pension.
Didn't see this! Much better than 30 years ago!!
BatshitCrazyWoman · 13/02/2022 07:32

OP, for every mortgage I've ever had, I've always been strongly encouraged to get decreasing term life insurance. When I was married, it was for both of us, so if one of us died, the mortgage was paid off. Do you have this - I would find out.

Childcare where I live, full time, is £1400 a month, and the hours aren't great for someone who commutes into central London. But possibly part time work and a childminder would be better - could you look into that? Childcare costs took all my salary for ages, it was shit. That was back in the day, when childcare vouchers or any financial help towards childcare didn't exist. Other posters might know more about the situation now.

Mayvis · 13/02/2022 07:21

You’ve been a SAHM for ten years but not even 30 yet. Your qualifications aren’t obsolete but the lack of work experience for most of your adult life will probably hold you back if you need to job search.

iRun2eatCake · 13/02/2022 07:15

Also - are you actually on the deeds of the house.

There is a difference between being on the mortgage and being liable to pay it .... and being on the deeds and actually owning the home

rurallibralady87 · 13/02/2022 07:14

Are you renting or owners OP? You talk about mortgage and then mention rent?

iRun2eatCake · 13/02/2022 07:11

How old are yourr DC now?

If they are at school, there are jobs available for school hours.... not many but places like warehouses do 4hr contracts, weekend work, lunchtime supervisor in school etc

BABAHOTEL · 13/02/2022 07:11

I'd be more concerned about him leaving than dying to be honest. You'd be in shit street then if you've got no employable skills.

Also you're on one hand being "traditional ", but then you're not married, which is odd!

OfstedOffred · 13/02/2022 07:09

Also it's not a requirement for a man to have a SAHM at home to be promoted/do well at work. My DH has managed it just fine while I've worked and developed my career.

OfstedOffred · 13/02/2022 07:07

I don't know anyone with children who has both parents working before school age. childcare costs too much for it to even be an option.

It's a reflection on your community. I by contrast don't know any families with a SAHM. We've all only had maternity leaves of between 6-12m and continued working between and after kids. The "two in nursery" years often cost more than the lower earning parent bring in but it only lasts a year or two before free hours/school make a massive difference.

How old are you OP? Remember women of our generation will work until we are probably 68, if you early thirties you probably have 35+ years of work ahead of you so its absolutely worth getting on and starting your career.

Soontobe60 · 13/02/2022 07:06

The very first thing you can do is to get life insurance up to the value of the mortgage for BOTH of you. If he dies, you can’t pay the mortgage. If you die he will have to pay childcare so also needs to be able to pay off the mortgage.

twominutesmore · 13/02/2022 06:58

I think you are getting a bit of a hard time, op.

It is usual for pensions to be left to long-term partners - unless the relationship looks very precarious, which doesn't seem to be the case for you. Entirely normal for assets to be left to the surviving partner, and then to the children when that parent passes.

So yes I would be hurt if I'd facilitated his career and raised four of his children only to learn that he had made no provision for me in the event of his death.

Did you ask him why? I hope he doesn't feel that your relationship won't last, or feel resentful of your sahm status.

Having said that, pp are right that you have walked yourself into this situation. It is a terrible idea to have children and buy a house without getting married. I don't think you can complain too much about a lack of career as you decided to have a baby before establishing a career, and then chose to have three more at intervals that saw you out of work for a decade. Although many talk about being a sahm as a sacrifice I presume you also rather enjoyed not working for ten years, had the luxury of being at home with your little ones every day and so on. I know many people who would have loved to do it but couldn't. So it is not just sacrifice.

I guess the thing to do now is work towards putting things right - he has changed his pension so next is you getting a job, marriage and wills.

CurtainTroubles · 13/02/2022 06:50

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

QforCucumber · 13/02/2022 06:49

it is the way it has always been done the man works and the women work when the childbearing and rearing is over

Not for a long time. Dh and I both work ft have 2 kids aged 5 and 1 - the gap because childcare for 2 is unaffordable. Not one person in my group of friends or colleagues wives have been SAHP, tbf it hasn’t been the norm for many years. I’m 35 and growing up most of my friends parents also worked.

MintJulia · 13/02/2022 06:44

OP, if you've been a sahm for a decade, I assume your dcs are at school.

You need either to marry or to get yourself a job. Or both. Claiming you can't work is absurd. I'm a single mum and have worked full time all the way through. There is always something you can do, more so now so many jobs offer home-based work.

Your situation is your CHOICE. You have very sensible concerns, so sit down with your DP (who is not your husband), discuss the issue and make the necessary changes.