Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you feel if your child as beneficiary of his pension instead of you?

187 replies

insuretothecore · 12/02/2022 22:19

stay at home mum for nearly a decade now while having children, earning potential has decreased, no pension contributions in this time while DH is putting money into a private pension on top of what is required. Not a lot, but obviously it builds over a lifetime.
He has put our children down to receive the money if he dies.
I have stayed at home and been mother and wife, my qualifications are now obsolete its been that long since I've been in the game, and it looks like DH thinks I should be left with nothing if he dies.
I have never felt so worthless. we aren't married either.

Yabu - children should be beneficiary
Yanbu - partner should be beneficiary

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 13/02/2022 10:41

OP, you are probably make it more of it than it was when he put the children's name. In all likelihood, he was told that putting children names down was the norm and he just did whilst being rushed.

You shouldn't have to justify your family choices. If it works for you, that's all that matters. However, you are making it as if you had no choice in it and therefore it's all about the sacrifices you've made.

It isn't. You chose to have a child before gaining any work experience or further qualifications and then went on to have two more children soon after. These were choice that has put you in a potential vulnerable position. However, hopefully, your relationship is secure and you'll be fine. It's along way before you reach retirement age so entry of time to get these qualifications and get decently paid jobs.

mindutopia · 13/02/2022 10:37

How old are your youngest children? If nursery age, I suspect you would be eligible for funded hours (if not 2 year funding, then 3 year funding), plus tax free childcare (which you can use until children are 12 for wraparound care and holiday club).

Our youngest is in nursery 4 full days a week 9-5 and school age one in school 8:30-4 with after school club (which is free). So it means I work nearly full time hours and it only costs us £200 a month. Even if after school club is not an option there is so much you can do from home. I used to do transcription when my eldest was a baby. I could fit it in the hours I had, including weekends and evenings after bedtime, and could easily make £800 a month in a few hours a day with no childcare costs. Dh has someone he pays to do admin work (answering emails, shipping orders, etc) 3 days a week school hours and she makes £1000 a month.

There are lots of options, you just have to seek them out and also see childcare as a long term investment. After our first, the money I earned was basically cancelled out by the added childcare costs. By the time we had our second, I was making 3x more so the time invested meant it was so much easier for us to afford childcare.

CecilyP · 13/02/2022 10:37

In fact why are you thinking about your partner dying? He's not yet 30, no health Issue?

Because that’s what you have to do when you fill in a work nomination or you make a will. OP I’m wondering if he just took this attitude when completing the form. Just thought it couldn’t happen for another 30 years instead of thinking it could happen tomorrow.

HomeHomeInTheRange · 13/02/2022 10:22

@CrinklyCraggy

The pension and the death benefit are separate things. Dependant children (as well as a spouse/named partner) would usually be entitled to a pension until they're of age anyway. The trustees are unlikely to pay a pension income to the children after 18/end of FT education regardless of who he names as beneficiary.

I have DH's death benefit and an income from his pension. I feel that the income is "mine" because that was effectively saved from joint income and would have been joint income in retirement had he lived. I have to admit though, I do feel the lump sum death benefit really belongs to DC.

It depends what kind of pension it is.

The OP’s DP might have a private pension scheme.

caringcarer · 13/02/2022 10:16

I would feel hurt.

CrinklyCraggy · 13/02/2022 10:08

The pension and the death benefit are separate things. Dependant children (as well as a spouse/named partner) would usually be entitled to a pension until they're of age anyway. The trustees are unlikely to pay a pension income to the children after 18/end of FT education regardless of who he names as beneficiary.

I have DH's death benefit and an income from his pension. I feel that the income is "mine" because that was effectively saved from joint income and would have been joint income in retirement had he lived. I have to admit though, I do feel the lump sum death benefit really belongs to DC.

HomeHomeInTheRange · 13/02/2022 10:03

OP: are you named as a joint owner of the house?

You are in an incredibly vulnerable position. You have given up your earned income and pension contributions and if the house is in his name you have absolutely no claim on it if you split or if he dies without having left it to you in a Will.

The named beneficiary of a pension can be changed by a click.
Wills can be changed.
If you split up you will get not one penny of anything not in your name.

My advice is:
Get married.

If he will not marry, as fast as possible refresh your qualifications and get a job. Earn money, any money, build a pension. Do not undertake childcare of his kids that enables him to earn and build his own assets on which you have no claim!

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 13/02/2022 10:03

There are a lot of strong opinions on this thread.

Ultimately OP you have made decisions which mean that in the event your partner leaves you for any reason you will be financially in a very difficult position.

You need to have some open and direct conversations with your DP about how to bring more parity to the financial situation so that if he leaves, gets I'll and can't work or dies you are not left destitute.

If your children are now all in school then you can work, that would give you more security, you may not want to work, you may find that things like after school clubs need to reduce to allow for it but life is like that.

I worked full time from when DD was 9 months old, DH also works full time. We're in a slightly different situation in that I am the higher earner, with more than 4 times his income, so if we split I would be the one paying support to DH, not the other way round.

Marriage is sensible, it can be as simple as going to the registry office, it doesn't need to be a huge shindig.

If not a marriage then you need to ensure you have clear wills that define what will happen with any assets including pensions, and you need to have complete transparency and access to joint funds. You also need to check your Government Gateway account to make sure your NiI contributions are up to date so you get your state pension when it's due, and it would benefit you to have a private pension too which your DH should be willing to set up.

MrsSkylerWhite · 13/02/2022 10:01

If you’re not married, you’re not his spouse.
Is he considering that you may have a new partner and he wants to be sure the kids are secure?

FinallyHere · 13/02/2022 09:59

it just feels like I gave up everything for the family and I'm not even considered to be looked after financially if he dies before me.

For anyone else reading this and thinking 'it would never happen to me' , please, if you are going to give up your work/career to be a stay at home parent and be financially dependent on someone, get married first.

If he 'doesn't believe in marriage or doesn't want to get married in those circumstances, choose someone else.

End of public service broadcast.

Lazypuppy · 13/02/2022 09:57

You need to get married. You have put yourself in such a risky position being a SAHM for so low. You aren't your partners next of kin as you aren't married! You wouldn't be able to make any medical decisions for him if he was in hospital, it would be his parents. If there is no will everything goes to next of kin, not you. You have no pension, even though out of family money there should be contributions for you going to a private one.

Please stand up for yourself and get yourself some protection. In the eyes of the law you are no more than roommates

Kshhuxnxk · 13/02/2022 09:54

I think you're way overreacting. Its sorted now. He has agreed to get married but you don't want to do it in a registry office when you could. Once kids go to school get yourself back into workplace cleaning whatever.

CarrieBlue · 13/02/2022 09:52

more for church and I want to do it in front of god)

God is everywhere, so you don’t need to be in a church and if you are actually a regular adherent the fees are often waived, we had to pay the standard fee to give notice at the register office but our minister just asked for a contribution as we worship at that church. He would charge a full fee to those who just wanted their wedding in the building of course.

Brefugee · 13/02/2022 09:51

It is the way it has always been done the man works and the women work when the childbearing and rearing is over.

That works only when there is some way of ensuring a minimum of financial support if it all goes tits up. Marriage is that legal way (not without problems but it is legally binding)

It should be taught in schools. Marriage benefits the financially weaker party, and the financially stronger party sometimes sees it as someone making a grab for their assets/income. That is how it can look. People contemplating becoming a SAHP should know things like claiming cb keeps your NI going etc.
Having children and not being married, looks to me from the countless posts here, as very precarious and not something I'd want for me or my children.

So, OP, armed with some good advice from this thread - what's your next move?

tootiredtobother · 13/02/2022 09:49

is he much older than you ? you can take out life insurance on anybody you like. that would be a lump sum eventually for you

Pyewhacket · 13/02/2022 09:42

@PrincessNutella

Honey, you have to get your ducks in a row. And the first duck is marriage. You can talk around it all you want, and I know you will because it is the most difficult of all the ducks, but either he will marry you or you are his unpaid breeder/baby-sitter. Stop wasting your own time, my dear. Or at least put some value on it. THIS YEAR.
.............. or what ?
Pyewhacket · 13/02/2022 09:38

@2022success

I know it sounds grabby but surely it goes Spouse, then children. not children.

But you aren't his spouse! To be brutally honest, you are "just the mother" of his children, and legally he doesn't owe you a bean Sad

Did you really not understand how precarious your situation is?

This, with bells on !.
PrincessNutella · 13/02/2022 09:31

Honey, you have to get your ducks in a row. And the first duck is marriage. You can talk around it all you want, and I know you will because it is the most difficult of all the ducks, but either he will marry you or you are his unpaid breeder/baby-sitter. Stop wasting your own time, my dear. Or at least put some value on it. THIS YEAR.

dottydodah · 13/02/2022 09:27

Insuretothecore. I think you are happy with your current situation as a SAHM ATM .This is fine in theory .However you seem to have no life plan set out .Women fought long and hard for our freedoms ,so we would not end up doing all the washing ,caring ,grunt work ,while our spouses climbed the ladder, and became financially secure at our cost.If you were unlucky he would go off with a younger model and you would be left high and dry! This happened to DMs friend in fact .She had to start again at 50! We are trying to help you so you are not in such a place ! Marriage was for protection of women and children originally .You say you were studying before DC arrived ,could you return to that at all? A cleaning job is fine ,but you are selling yourself short by limiting yourself. If you can get a better paid job why not? You have probably lost confidence in yourself ,which happens a lot with being home with DC.

TheBareTree · 13/02/2022 09:20

You need to make sure that your partner takes out life insurance to cover at least your mortgage in the event of his death, and that you are the beneficiary. It won’t cost much at all each month at his age.
You also need to makes sure he nominated you for any death in service payments. These will give you financial security if you aren’t married.

Whitney168 · 13/02/2022 09:17

@MichelleScarn

In fact why are you thinking about your partner dying? He's not yet 30, no health Issue?
Well, no KNOWN health issues. The fittest person I've ever known died at 44 walking in his own grounds on a Sunday morning.

However, even without any health issues, presumably he's not immune to e.g. road accidents or any of the other things that can kill folk?

BABAHOTEL · 13/02/2022 09:15

@Aposterhasnoname

But still what if the mortgage isn't paid and he's gone?

Firstly, surely you have life insurance that will pay off the mortgage if he died? I thought it was a condition of getting a mortgage, but maybe not. If you don’t have it, get it now.

Secondly, not all jobs are 9-5 Monday- Friday, I worked evenings and weekend when DD was young.

Not a condition of a mortgage but recommended

Agree regarding working around the children, weekends etc.

jacks11 · 13/02/2022 09:10

Well, I suppose it might be because he thinks you might have the opportunity of a new relationship if he were to die- maybe he wanted to ensure his pension went to his children just in case a new relationship meant blended family/more children for you (I don’t know if the latter is possible as you don’t mention your age).

rainbowandglitter · 13/02/2022 09:10

If you're unmarried you're not likely to receive a spouse pension when he dies. Lot of pension schemes only pay spouses pension to married spouses. The return of his contributions can go to whoever he decides but a spouses pension usually must go the married spouse.

oviraptor21 · 13/02/2022 09:04

@noirchatsdeux

Makes me sad that a woman of nearly 30 has the same views as my mother...who is 80...

She was a stay at home mother, she felt my father 'owed' her financial support for her whole life because she'd had children. Backfired massively on her when he left her for OW when I was 21 (he'd waited until my younger brother turned 18 so he wouldn't have to pay child support).

They were married, but had only owned the house for 3 years so hardly any equity. No pensions, savings, insurance...nothing. House had to be sold and the equity was split. My mother ended up with a lump sum of £10K, after a 23 year marriage.

She now lives in the Australian equivalent of a tiny housing association flat on a state pension.

If you aren't going to get married you need to get a job asap.

To be fair, this is a situation where neither party was going to get much financial reward out of the marriage.

OP - you are right, there are very many mums who don't go back to work until the youngest is at school, and who even then don't work full time. It just doesn't make economic sense or practical sense when childcare costs outweigh net income and when in reality it's really helpful to have someone available to look after DCs before/after school, in holidays, and when they're ill.

Your DP may have changed his beneficiaries but could easily change them back.
I hope the house is in both your names. Just being on the mortgage isn't necessarily enough.
And yes - it's much safer to be married. Just do the registry office bit now and have the party later.