Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you feel if your child as beneficiary of his pension instead of you?

187 replies

insuretothecore · 12/02/2022 22:19

stay at home mum for nearly a decade now while having children, earning potential has decreased, no pension contributions in this time while DH is putting money into a private pension on top of what is required. Not a lot, but obviously it builds over a lifetime.
He has put our children down to receive the money if he dies.
I have stayed at home and been mother and wife, my qualifications are now obsolete its been that long since I've been in the game, and it looks like DH thinks I should be left with nothing if he dies.
I have never felt so worthless. we aren't married either.

Yabu - children should be beneficiary
Yanbu - partner should be beneficiary

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HootOwl · 14/02/2022 17:07

[quote insuretothecore]@pitterpatterrain he has changed it now I have asked him to but my feeling is that I am hurt I wasn't even considered. Or told. I think these decisions are family decisions.
what if I still have the mortgage to pay or need a cleaner due to health or need to buy a motorised wheelchair or scooter thing in the future?
We aren't rich, we were barely scraping by at the time he did this.
but now are in a better position as he has had a promotion and is paid better now, but that's because I'm at home with the kids and looking after the home.

I finished my qualifications to get a dream, liw paying job (which was a compromise anyway as I couldnt be full dream job with children. Think nurse instead of dr or dental nurse instead of dentist) and started it but had to quit because DHs pays more and os obviously better for the family to have more money. He is working 60+ hours a week plus commute plus staying away whenever he is needed. So it's not really possible, I couldn't even manage 1 day a week because DHs schedule is so unpredictable. Its just the way things are for us and I don't mind on the whole.
ut now I feel like I'm just the mother. I dont deserve financial protection if the worst happens. I don't feel like a partner.

No he hasn't been contributing to a pension for me. We have just bought our first house now months) but when he put this dowm we were renting with no assets and minimal savings which were going to go towards the house we just got.

I know it sounds grabby but surely it goes Spouse, then children. not children.[/quote]
I don't understand these posts about how people can't possibly work because of their partner's schedule. How do you think single mothers manage it?

Theunamedcat · 13/02/2022 20:22

Happened to my family member they were married he had a lot of money she did work but spent money like anything because "they" were rich he left everything to the children she is allowed to stay in the house (I believe she has the house or at least the right to live there) but all the money and other assets gone to the children they were so grateful they didn't even help to put a gravestone on his grave it remains not done to this day because she can't afford it she was retirement age when he passed and only has a state pension the house was a shambles so all her money goes on repairs

Be careful of your wills they might hurt the ones you leave behind

notacooldad · 13/02/2022 20:16

In fact why are you thinking about your partner dying? He's not yet 30, no health Issue?

This is one of the most stupidest comments ever.

I work in a family support type job. You would be surprised, I think by the number of adults who have a young family that have died. Sure some have been from drug misadventure but other cases have been completely random or accidental. We’ve supported a family whose dad died in an industrial accident, a mum who was talking to her mates and two hours later had died from a brain haemorrhage. Someone else was murdered in an entirely unproved attack by people he didn’t know. There are more examples, the point is you never know when your time is up whether you are 9 days old, 29 year’s or 99.

Kite22 · 13/02/2022 18:10

You've had so much excellent advice on this thread OP.

I'm glad you asked the question and hope you take on board all the really good advice you've been given.

Bunnycat101 · 13/02/2022 15:12

You are in a precarious position. Aside from the pension do you have life insurance for each other? He would likely need cover if you died to cover childcare and you would need insurance to cover the mortgage.

What are the actual ages of your children? If pre-school age will you get free hours soon? I suspect you could make something work if you really needed/wanted to.

Elphame · 13/02/2022 15:02

As a (now non practising IFA) I am wincing at this thread.

You seriously need proper advice and not from the internet either. The fact that your partner hasn't even considered the position you'd be in financially should he die is worrying and you are indeed in a precarious position. Does he have decent life insurance? Are you the beneficiary of that? Does he even have a will?

insuretothecore · 13/02/2022 14:32

@Rainbowqueeen

Yes OP that would make me feel crap.

I hope it spurs you into action. In your shoes I would start looking for work immediately. CAB might be a good place to start to look at your options. Or a recruitment agency. You have mentioned cleaning. Would care work interest you - there are usually lots of jobs available. I’d try to start earning asap but come up with a longer term plan.

Is getting married an option? I’d discuss it with my partner and if he agrees, get it booked. No fuss, just get it done.

It’s great that you have realised things need to change while you are relatively young. So get to work on changing them. And 💐💐. You are not worthless.

Thank you @rainbowqueeen x (I don't give kisses os this means something)
OP posts:
CayrolBaaaskin · 13/02/2022 14:14

For all those telling you to get married- that doesn’t necessarily affect the beneficiary of a pension. For example you can still leave all your defined contribution pension to your children whether married or not. It passes outside your estate

youvegottenminuteslynn · 13/02/2022 14:04

@MichelleScarn

In fact why are you thinking about your partner dying? He's not yet 30, no health Issue?

Anyone who has kids should have a will that ensures they will be taken care of to their maximum benefit in the event of either parent's death. As soon as they have children. Just in case of the worst. It's sensible planning that parents should take seriously from day one.

Thecurtainsofdestiny · 13/02/2022 13:53

It's not just about pension is it? It's about both of you working together in partnership.

I was a sahm when children were small and had a long time out of work. Wanted back in so we discussed it and DH agreed to go part time so I could work long hours and study to progress my career.

We've both ended up " behind" our peers in terms of career progression but that seemed fairer to us that one of us forging ahead and the other losing the opportunity for personal development and earnings.

Can you discuss together how both of your needs can be met?

babyjellyfish · 13/02/2022 13:40

@MichelleScarn

In fact why are you thinking about your partner dying? He's not yet 30, no health Issue?
He could die in a car crash on his way to work tomorrow.

I know three people who were widowed that way.

babyjellyfish · 13/02/2022 13:39

OP, I think you're getting quite a lot of flack on here. The reason is because posters on Mumsnet get tired of saying the same thing over and over again to different people.

If you give up work to be a stay at home parent, or even go part-time, and are financially reliant on your partner, you are potentially making yourself very vulnerable. It means that you are contributing a lot of unpaid labour to the household, allowing your partner to carry on doing paid work. If you were married then you would be better protected in the event of your husband's death, and if you got divorced you would be entitled to a share of your husband's assets to reflect the unpaid contribution you have made. If you are not married then there are certain things you aren't entitled to (or aren't automatically entitled to) in the event of your partner's death, and you aren't entitled to anything if you split. The non-financial contribution you have made isn't recognised, because the law doesn't see you as anything more than flatmates with separate finances.

That said, if you are a low income family without a lot of assets, it may not make a huge amount of difference if you split. Divorcing a husband with assets of £500,000 means you get a share of £500,000. Divorcing a husband with £20 in the bank means you get bugger all. If your partner were to die, however, there are certain benefits you would only be entitled to if you were married, which would be very valuable to you on a low income.

Nothing you have said in your posts indicates that your partner doesn't want to marry you because he wants to protect his wealth. (Your posts don't seem to suggest that he actually has a lot of wealth to protect, although I could be wrong about that.) So if you would rather be married, you should sit down with him and point out all the ways in which your current situation makes you legally vulnerable, and say you would like to get married even if you just do a quick and dirty registry office wedding for £200.

Whether you get married or not, I think you should be making plans to re-enter the workforce. Even if it's not feasible until your older children are in school and your youngest is entitled to subsidised childcare. It's just not good to be financially dependent on a man, whether you are married to him or not.

Good luck.

UnexpectedItemInShaggingArea · 13/02/2022 12:38

You are incredibly financially vulnerable and you need to look after your own interests. That means either getting a job, getting married or putting legal agreements and life assurance policies in place to protect yourself.

If your relationship is good then I would make a joint appointment with a solicitor and a financial planner who will spell out your options to you both.

BobbinHood · 13/02/2022 12:35

If being a SAHM leaves you feeling worthless why have you done it?

Why would you be left with nothing? House? Life insurance? Occupational pension?

AngelinaFibres · 13/02/2022 12:33

@Tee20x

Mumsnet is a great resource. I don't know anyone with children who has both parents working before school age. childcare costs too much for it to even be an option.

I think this says more about the people you have around you and/or the community you live in. Where I live it's the norm for both parents to work before kids are of school age.

Even if at the time you're basically working for free you have the added bonus of pension contributions, financial security and will easily be able to get another job should things go tits up.

Times have changed Op. When my children were born in the early 90s the group of mums I was friendly with stayed at home until the youngest was at school. That was not unusual. But every one of us was married, owned a house jointly and had professional careers we could return to once the children were in Reception.All those things were crucial to me and a second friend when our husband's left us. She went back to accountancy and I went back to primary teaching. My DIL is about to have a baby. She is married,and owns the house with my son, but she is taking maternity leave and then returning to work. All her friends either have ,or will, do the same. OP you seem to have started in a vulnerable demographic and your choices have made you even more vulnerable. At the very least you need to get married. You may have to accept that a registry office is your best option in your precarious situation.The wish to do it in front of God seems at odds with having 3 children out of wedlock. If you wait until you can afford a church wedding, but your partner dies the week before you get there, you will be absolutely up a creek. After my, now ex husband, left, the marriage certificate was the most important piece of paper I owned. Had he died the same would also have been true. If you are married and your husband dies you are entitled to a lump of money from the government and then a regular payment ( not sure how much but certainly worth having) If you are not legally married you will get nothing.
FebruaryFest · 13/02/2022 12:03

Yes Angelina.
The minute you have kids you should think what happens to them if one or other parent dies.
I was a sahm but we had insurance on my life when they were young to cover full care so they and my DH wouldn't have been financially impacted if I'd snuffed it. Because it's so unlikely at that young age it's not expensive cover either.

Tee20x · 13/02/2022 12:01

Mumsnet is a great resource. I don't know anyone with children who has both parents working before school age. childcare costs too much for it to even be an option.

I think this says more about the people you have around you and/or the community you live in. Where I live it's the norm for both parents to work before kids are of school age.

Even if at the time you're basically working for free you have the added bonus of pension contributions, financial security and will easily be able to get another job should things go tits up.

AngelinaFibres · 13/02/2022 11:52

@MichelleScarn

In fact why are you thinking about your partner dying? He's not yet 30, no health Issue?
Because people of any age die. Accidents can happen to anyone at any time.
Antsgomarching · 13/02/2022 11:32

Its done, best thing to do is get married, look for work when you can, doesn’t matter what it is or how many hours just to get back into it and make sure your pension is being contributed too as well.

YANBU though, even if you aren’t married he should have thought of you first with small children.

FebruaryFest · 13/02/2022 11:24

Talking to each other is the key here and you are doing that. Plus he's changed the beneficiary of the pension already.
Keep moving forward to ensure your family is secure whatever life throws at you all.

KTheGrey · 13/02/2022 11:21

OP, you're dead on - you don't know what you don't know and Mumsnet is a great resource!
@mindutopia's advice seems excellent, and also you could afford to take out some insurance / a pension if you had some money of your own. But if not, some conversations about what would happen if either one of you was ill or injured or even died would be a good idea - I always think if you prepare for it that'll stop it happening.

Teeturtle · 13/02/2022 11:19

@MumGoneMild

I’d want everything to go to the kids, my partner of 20 years is capable of looking after himself and I think his will is the same to tbh
This isn’t partner, it is husband. And the children will grow up and probably be more easily able to earn than their parent pushing retirement age that hasn’t worked for a couple of decades.

If the children are still minors at death of parent (which most won’t be) then the remaining parent needs to be able to access money.

unicornsarereal72 · 13/02/2022 11:10

I am going to echo what others have said. Get life insurance for both of you. What will he do of something happens to you. Or you get a disability etc.

Can you take this time to study and up skill yourself ready to get back into working.

As previously mentioned you could work evenings or weekends but know that family time is important too.

I like many others worked since my children were babies. It wasn't a option to not too and my ex was in the navy. I never factored him into the childcare plans. What we did do was have the children so that there was only one lot of child care though.

McScreamysGhostPants · 13/02/2022 10:47

Op you sound incredibly passive in ash toss and very "woe is me". Yes it sticks that he didn't think of you but you should have expected it. He's been very clear that he doesn't want to marry you either. So you sit at home being a free nanny and he gets a proper life, working away and building his pension and you are sat at home worrying about having zero career or prospects and being left high and dry.

In your shoes I would absolutely be forcing him to marry me. We either marry or we separate. And if I was you I would be signing up to the OU and doing a part time degree or book keeping course or something. You need to make sure that you are ready for work as soon as your youngest kid is in school. Then pay 30% off your wage into a pension ( more if you can).

And none of the " but I can't do a degree, I live on a council estate/didn't do well in school " bollocks. I didn't get a single GCSE and left at 14 but I've gone on to get three dates while at home raising 4 kids and juggling the house. Plus I'm disabled with an autistic son. Anybody can do it. But you need to be pro active and go get it, it won't fall in your lap.

AChocolateOrangeaday · 13/02/2022 10:47

You don't want to work really do you OP?

At least be honest.

Every excuse in the book.