Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is 24 too young to settle down with a baby

338 replies

Stressedout65 · 12/02/2022 21:32

I know it depends on each individual, how they feel & what they want from life, but would you say 24 is a bit young these days

OP posts:
Averydifferentwoman · 13/02/2022 12:29

I spent many years not being tied down - no one gave a shit about me Grin which perhaps sounds harsh but it was true. I could have vanished and it wouldn’t have been noteworthy news.

Another way to look at being tied down is that you simply have people you love and who love you.

BellatrixOnABadDay · 13/02/2022 12:25

I get what you're saying too @BearOfEasttown, but for me, I never felt it as being 'tied down'. I genuinely didn't feel 'tied down' as such, and I personally didn't find looking after babies/toddlers that difficult. I loved it, I didn't get overly tired with sleepless nights, I will also say I was fortunate because I recovered quickly from my ELCS both times, I didn't have postnatal depression etc. It must be so tough after a difficult birth or with PND etc. the most difficult thing I had as babies was my second child had a bad tongue tie that didn't completely go but I still managed to BF.

Having babies/children is easy to me compared to dealing with my awful ex- agree with you on the tie to the man! But I couldn't have anticipated this, it's life and I deal with it. Could have happened with someone I had a child with at 34 or 44 indeed.

BearOfEasttown · 13/02/2022 12:23

@sadandcrazy

I think they say after 28 fertility starts to rapidly decline. I think 16 to 26 is peak time to conceive
Pretty sure your fertility doesn't fall off a cliff at 28! Hmm

I had mine at 31 and 33, and conceived both times within a few weeks of coming off the pill. Both smooth pregnancies, and problem-free deliveries.

BearOfEasttown · 13/02/2022 12:21

@Averydifferentwoman

You change between 30 and 40, too. I also imagine I’ll change between 40 and 50. I don’t really see that as a reason not to have a child.
But between THOSE ages, you are not really young.

Having a baby in your early to mid 20s is not something I would ever have wanted for my children OR myself. It's too young IMO.

The OP asked for peoples opinions. And that is mine.

MaterialWorld · 13/02/2022 12:21

I did it and don't regret it one bit. Needed all the energy to parent the way I wanted to and now I'm older I'm loving the independence I'm getting back. DH and I will travel as a couple once the youngest reaches 18 in a few years and we have the benefit of being able to do it with a bit more cash than a shoe string budget we had when we were in our early 20's.

It's not stopped us doing anything but has definitely slowed the pace of our careers down a bit. Still would do it that way round again though if we had our time again.

IsItTooHotInHere · 13/02/2022 12:19

I had my 1st son at 22, 2nd son at 24 - both planned, both with my husband.

With hindsight, I was too young, but now I'm 62, sons 40 and 38. Mortgage paid off years ago, so it worked out well for us

Averydifferentwoman · 13/02/2022 12:12

You change between 30 and 40, too. I also imagine I’ll change between 40 and 50. I don’t really see that as a reason not to have a child.

sadandcrazy · 13/02/2022 12:11

I think they say after 28 fertility starts to rapidly decline. I think 16 to 26 is peak time to conceive

BearOfEasttown · 13/02/2022 12:10

@BellatrixOnABadDay

It's actually more snide to suggest that someone choosing to have children in their mid 20's (shock horror!) must have a limited outlook in life, and not particularly intelligent/educated. I chose not to go to university myself, although I could have if I wanted to.

I agree with this. It doesn't mean someone lacks intelligence and is badly educated because they get married at 22-23 or younger and have a baby by 24. But I just don't understand why anyone would, as it seems very young to be 'tied down.' And yes, you are tied for some 2 decades to that child, and the commitment that goes with it. AND you are tied to that man. That is a BIG commitment when you are so young IMO. You change SO much as a person between 20 and 30...

BearOfEasttown · 13/02/2022 12:06

Well it's all subjective, but IMO, it is too young yes.

I would not have wanted this for my 2 DC (now mid to late 20s.) They are both engaged right now and living with their partner(s.)

I don't think there's any need to settle down and have babies at 24. Then again, it's worse (IMO) to wait til your 40s before 'trying for a baby...'

BellatrixOnABadDay · 13/02/2022 12:00

It's not a snide argument, to suggest their is a degree of middle class mumsnet privilege on threads like these. Lots of people, for all kinds of reasons, cannot go travelling, cannot ever afford to buy a home.

It's actually more snide to suggest that someone choosing to have children in their mid 20's (shock horror!) must have a limited outlook in life, and not particularly intelligent/educated. I chose not to go to university myself, although I could have if I wanted to. I was really good at English and History, and got A*s and A's at GCSE and A-level. I was just bored out of my brain of reading books, not for the enjoyment but to have to analyse every single paragraph 🥱 and all of the essays, I was desperate for a change. So I got a job, which has led me to my current job, where I earn the same good money as all the academics with PHD's, most of whom are a similar age to me, who surround me. We chose different routes; it doesn't make them more intelligent. They chose to stay in education longer, which is a perfectly good choice, as was mine. I'm an intelligent person who is still interested in history and literature, art and nature, and anything creative, and I hope to give my children the opportunities to do anything they want to and are interested in themselves.

lucylucyapplejuicy · 13/02/2022 11:58

I don't think so, but I knew I wanted children in my 20s and not 30s. I wouldn't say it held me back but I'm not much of a party animal

CaptainMyCaptain · 13/02/2022 11:46

No. But it depends on the person.

MargaretThursday · 13/02/2022 11:44

I was married and had my first at that age.
Would I recommend it?

There's advantages and disadvantages.
I did feel a little different at time as my school/uni friends were talking about looking at first school/nursery when my youngest was looking at secondary schools. I was, until I had my 3rd, often the youngest at all the toddler groups.

But I had a lot more energy to do things, and we had a lot of fun. We didn't have a car and walked miles with a buggy and hopped on and off buses/trains. We didn't have a huge amount of spare money-almost everything was second hand, although actually I quite like that so probably would have done that anyway. We never felt short of money because we'd never had any spare iyswim.

I'm now at the point where we're beginning to look forward to an empty nest and a bit of freedom. We'll be doing the travelling that friends did in their 20s, but with a bit more money!

So it's swings and roundabouts really.

The one thing I did find was getting into work was difficult because I didn't work after uni. So I think I'd advise people to try and get a couple of years worth of savings and work before having a child, but don't wait too long. I know too many people who thought they could wait and then had difficulty conceiving.

Averydifferentwoman · 13/02/2022 11:41

@TracyMosby I do understand, or I think I understand, what you mean, which is that women - regardless of their social background, should not ‘settle’ (with the inference of it being making do) but I’m not entirely sure that I agree.

I am fairly intelligent in that I have a degree and it is a ‘good’ one - 2:1. However, my degree is in English Literature and as such, like many in my cohort, I went into teaching. I earn reasonably well, but I just won’t ever make ‘big’ money without going into senior management which I really don’t want to do.

When my income is combined with DH, it goes a lot further. I don’t think it’s possible to be truly financially independent as a woman without earning really well, or having the potential to. I don’t see that I have somehow failed as a feminist in this: it’s just the way modern life is set up where two incomes are needed.

The OP is 24, not 17, and there is time here to have built a career. Perhaps more to the point, there is time afterwards. A friend of mine had three children aged 21 (a baby at 19 followed by twins) and went to university at 24, when they were all at school. (She is a midwife now! Grin) it’s not the way I’d have done it but it certainly isn’t ‘wrong.’

And she benefited from having her own parents and indeed grandparents around to help. Traditionally, higher educated and higher earning women do have children later on, but then pay for childcare because their own families often can’t.

To be honest the more I think of it the more I think having a baby at 40 has more disadvantages than baby at 24. And as I’ve said I had my first, and to date only, child aged 40. Birth and recovery and night feeds all been fine but I’ll still be 80 when he’s my age. I may never know my grandchildren, or only fleetingly.

I don’t care because I adore having him and I’m so grateful but I’m not sure that I somehow gained massively from not having him ten years prior!

MaryShelley1818 · 13/02/2022 11:34

I think times have changed. Ime women who had children in late teens/early 20s were mostly because that's all they were going to do with their life (generalising, there's obviously exceptions).
These days women have realised there's more they can do with their lives than just be a mother/housewife and they have equal opportunities to men.
I had mine at 39 & 42 so obviously on the older side but all of my friends were at least in their 30s, had degrees, own homes, good careers and had lived first! They're generally able to offer their children a better lifestyle and better opportunities.

TracyMosby · 13/02/2022 11:32

I mean, in other words some of these posts are very idealised upper middle class responses, aren’t they? Where you go to university and graduate and then mum and dad fund another few years exploring South America or Australia or wherever, possibly with a bit of temping in London or similar to convince oneself that actually you do have life experience?

It saddens me seeing the same snide arguments every single time a version of this thread pops up. Always a class division is made making having any sort of sight beyond your limited life experiences only possibly for the middle classes. And how life experience means travel. It isn't, or shouldn't be, about that at all.

We see time and time again posts on these boards from women who find themselves single, or heartbreakingly wanting to be single, in their thirties or forties, with children, no career, no training, no help and no way of being independent. They've never been independent.

Getting life experience doesn't just mean a degree and 6 months backpacking from Queensland to Sydney. It means getting to the point where you can function as an independent adult. A point where you have systems in place / savings / started a pension / have qualifications, training and experience in a job. It doesnt mean you've been on holiday to the med every year, spent five years getting drunk at the weekend and now dont know what else to do. The more we make it sound like getting your life in order before you start having children is just for the middle classes, the greater the divide becomes.
Getting qualifications, putting the necessary hours into a career path at the start of it, saving, buying a house are all significantly harder when there are children’s needs to consider. So those women having children before theyve matured into functioning and capable adults themselves first will almost always stay left behind.

Is 25 too young to get married? No. Not if you are a functioning and equal team.
Is 25 too young to settle? Absolutely.

Averydifferentwoman · 13/02/2022 11:28

I wonder, if someone has a reason as to why they won’t travel (don’t enjoy it, money, pets, etc) - would we then deem it acceptable to have children?

blessings2022 · 13/02/2022 11:24

Definitely too young, so much of the world to see. Try and do and see as much as you can and start thinking about having children at 28/29.

PugInTheHouse · 13/02/2022 11:19

I also had my own house too so that made a difference. I did my professional exams whilst working but I think if you go to uni it would be very different. IME people who work straight out of school or college are much more mature at 24 than someone who has been to uni. Now I employ people myself it is massively noticeable.

rooarsome · 13/02/2022 11:18

I had a baby at that age and at the time I didn't see myself as young. I'm in my 30s now and we have another 2 children- but with hindsight I really was very young.

MissTrip82 · 13/02/2022 11:18

For me it wouldn’t have been ok; I was just finishing med school with years of training ahead of me,

For others it would be fine.

There are good and bad things about every age.

PugInTheHouse · 13/02/2022 11:16

I was 25 when I got pregnant. I was a qualified accountant by then so was easy to go back into a decent job when the DCs were older.

I was married at 22, I have done plenty of travelling and had pretty wild teenage years so I didn't feel like I missed out. I'm 42 now and the kids are now teenagers so I can enjoy doing lots of what I want now also.

Orchid876 · 13/02/2022 11:14

It depends how financially stable you are. IMO it’s better to get an established career and have bought a home before having children, as doing these things later would be more difficult. Of course it will depend on circumstances, that wouldn’t be the right course of action for everyone, but no one can deny that life is just easier with secure finances and housing.

Nimello · 13/02/2022 11:11

Also my mum and dad have been happily married for over 50 years and are still young enough not to need 'looking after'. Dad still works f/t. There are loads and loads of good things about having children when you're young.