Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is 24 too young to settle down with a baby

338 replies

Stressedout65 · 12/02/2022 21:32

I know it depends on each individual, how they feel & what they want from life, but would you say 24 is a bit young these days

OP posts:
EmpressCixi · 13/02/2022 16:35

@MsAgnesDiPesto
Wow, no need to be rude - I was asking a genuine question. All my men were ‘good

I wasn’t being rude. My luck in finding a good partner to raise a family with doesn’t imply anything wrong with you, your relationships, your exes or anything like that. Funny you’d take a statement about “some of us” to be casting shade on you.

If you hadn’t found a good man to be a parent with, then why did you say they were all awful?

You said All the men I chose to be with at that age would have been awful fathers at that point in our lives, and I can’t imagine still being with any of them now, 25 years later.

In fact my comment about luck is not rude as it doesn’t even refer to you, but you saying directly to me:
Maybe being tied together by children makes you more inclined to stay even if the relationship changes.

Is downright rude. You’re curious whether people grow apart or together and yet when I say happily married 27 years, one and same father of all my children, your response to ME specifically is to imply I’m in a bad relationship and only stay because of the children.

FredBair · 13/02/2022 16:33

Yes far too young at 24, plenty of time later for babies.

Slightly less so for women than men.
It's true the brain isn't fully developed until about 24.
Lots just starting their careers at 22/23 so hardly ready to be tied down to one place and the expense of babies.
I have two DC 23 and 26 and I can see neither being ready for children for years yet although both in stable relationships.

24 is plenty time to have tasted travel and freedom and adventure

Perhaps not to this cohort.
DC2 planned to travel the world after graduation but covid put paid to that and they ended up starting a career.

MusicByTheLake · 13/02/2022 16:29

I’d be interested to know how many of you who had children at 24 are still happily in relationships with their fathers? All the men I chose to be with at that age would have been awful fathers at that point in our lives, and I can’t imagine still being with any of them now, 25 years later.

We are still together 24 years later. I’ve already posted on here that we met at 18, bought a house together at 22 and had our first baby at 24. We had lots of fun, including holidays together before we had a child. Neither of us wanted to backpack around the world though. Life and fun didn’t stop when we had a child, it was just different. We had our second child 5 years later and my partner has been such a good father to our children. My own father was abusive and never did any actual parenting, only discipline, which was usually unnecessary and more about his own anger. My partner is the complete opposite. We’ve been through so much together and he’s my best friend as well as my partner.

Graphista · 13/02/2022 16:24

Sorry meant to also include I have friends who are child free by choice too, some of them are in the military too and are more interested in furthering their careers - nothing wrong with that at all!

Graphista · 13/02/2022 16:23

Being in a relationship isn't mandatory at any age op.

Parenthood isn't either.

If someone does want to be a parent then there are pros and cons to all ages.

I was married at 22 and ttc at 24 but it wasn't successful for another 4 years when I had dd.

Everyone's circumstances are different.

I knew there was something wrong with me gynaecologically but didn't get a diagnosis until after my 2nd mc.

If I'd ignored the symptoms totally (as my GPs did!) and waited until my 30's to ttc then it's highly likely I'd have never been a mother. That would have broken me.

Within my close circle there is everything from teen mums to those who had their 1st in their 40's for a variety of reasons. Some personal circumstances, some medical reasons - everyone's situation is different

Your son seems to have a good head on his shoulders imo. He's getting himself a secure job in a time of EXTREME financial and employment insecurity and when in the next few years things are likely to get worse!

It's a career with great opportunities not only for training, education and advancement (not just within his work area but anything he's interested in) but also for travel and the opportunity to get involved in charity, sports and all sorts!

Support him and be proud of him.

Most of one side of my family is military and if I could have I'd have joined up myself (medically excluded unfortunately) my ex was army too.

I don't miss the ex but boy I do miss military life!

It's a great community too.

It sounds like your sons friends aren't becoming fathers particularly by choice and that the pregnancies were unplanned and the couples aren't in great positions financially which is gonna be tough for them.

I'd be using their situations to drum into him about contraception to be honest!

In reality with all that considered statistically the chances are that not only will those relationships not last, by the time the children are 5 the fathers will likely have little to do with them sadly.

Your son sounds very clear minded and sensible. That's a good thing.

Isonthecase · 13/02/2022 15:56

I did it and personally think it would have been a lot easier financially if we'd waited 5 years. We could have moved up the housing leader and built up equity by doing work ourselves to get a nice family house before kids instead of having to wait until they're out of full time childcare which means we won't make the most of it.

SirChenjins · 13/02/2022 15:50

When you take a sabbatical and a career break, or short term contracts, you aren’t working, @SirChenjins*

That’s correct - and you can go travelling. You’re not on holiday.

ufucoffee · 13/02/2022 15:44

Nope. I know lots of people still with husbands they met at school and who had children young. Each to their own.

Anonymous48 · 13/02/2022 15:43

I don't know whether to vote YABU or YANBU, but I do think 24 is young to settle down and have a baby. Unless there are some unusual circumstances there is no reason to get tied down that young. Enjoy being young and childfree for a few more years!

Averydifferentwoman · 13/02/2022 15:42

@SirChenjins

No, you can’t. You can work full time, and go on holiday

No, you can take sabbaticals, career breaks, work remotely, take short term contracts and travel in between…

And my other points?

When you take a sabbatical and a career break, or short term contracts, you aren’t working, @SirChenjins

I’m not sure what your other points are.

@MsAgnesDiPesto to be fair you were pretty rude yourself.

sofakingcool · 13/02/2022 15:15

I was 23 when DS was born and very quickly a single mum. I found the early days fairly easy, but was in a fortunate position that I worked in childcare so not only had a bit of an understanding (changing nappies etc wasn't new to me!) but I also got very cheap childcare for DS!

Over the years it feels like we've grown up together. He's now 18 and I'm 41, he's about to fly to nest off to Uni, and whilst he has got a younger brother (13) I feel it's now DH and my turn to have a bit of life.

On a negative, I'd say do what you want to do before you consider children - so if your career is not where you'd like it, look if you want to change it/ study first. If you wanted the chance to travel, do it! Neither impossible with children, but far easier without! I always wished I'd gone to Uni to train to be a midwife, I could do it now but studying isn't for me now really.

So my advice after all that waffle - if the time is right for you, go for it. There are pro's and cons whatever age you choose to have children Thanks

Pyewhacket · 13/02/2022 14:57

I was 23 when I had my first. Totally unplanned honeymoon baby. And I was working abroad at the time. I guess we were lucky because we had childcare as part of our package. In fact I had three by the time I was 28, which is why I chose to be sterilised. They're teenagers now and its still busy but I don't regret a minute of it.

enjoyingscience · 13/02/2022 14:55

I was 25 when I had DS1, and am so, so glad I had him when I did. It hasn’t held back my career at all (although I’m lucky I had a good stable job where I could progress steadily in between mat leaves- I left once my youngest was 3 and moved on another leap).

Some of my friends are only just starting their families now at 40, and I don’t think I was any less capable or ready than they are now.

That said, some of the graduates I work with who are older than 25 in some cases o wouldn’t trust with a goldfish, so it’s definitely personality dependant!

iwishu · 13/02/2022 14:51

If that's what you want then do it!
You know what's more important to you than anyone else saying what you should do.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 13/02/2022 14:51

24 is plenty time to have tasted travel and freedom and adventure if you feel like you've satisfied that urge by 24.

Ponoka7 · 13/02/2022 14:49

It was right for me. I was incredibly broody and had met my husband. I didn't want anything else. It's great having grown up children in my 50's and I'm enjoying my GC, because it was right for my middle DD as well. My other two children don't want children.
As said there's a lot of privilege on this thread. The majority of people won't own houses, or have enough money for travelling in their early 20's. If you meet someone you can make a life with, why would you reject that?

BottlingBurpsForGrandma · 13/02/2022 14:48

I had my first baby at 23 and my last baby at 30. I am thrilled that I could space my children how WE wanted, not rushed into a smaller age gap by time running out. When I am 50 my children will all be finished at uni (assuming 3 year undergraduate course).

SirChenjins · 13/02/2022 14:47

[quote Maneandfeathers]@MsAgnesDiPesto I am. I was never particularly into young bad boys though. DH has always been a sensible family man from a very young age, still is Grin[/quote]
I don’t think it’s a choice of either ‘Young bad boys’ or ‘sensible family man from a young age’ - there’s a whole middle ground. I’m still in tough with some boyfriends from my early twenties, all lovely family men, but I wouldn’t have wanted to marry them - none of us were ready to settle and have children by 24. We’d not long graduated, we were travelling, getting established with our careers, going out with friends and so on.

It’s horses for courses though.

SirChenjins · 13/02/2022 14:43

No, you can’t. You can work full time, and go on holiday

No, you can take sabbaticals, career breaks, work remotely, take short term contracts and travel in between…

And my other points?

Maneandfeathers · 13/02/2022 14:41

@MsAgnesDiPesto I am. I was never particularly into young bad boys though. DH has always been a sensible family man from a very young age, still is Grin

MsAgnesDiPesto · 13/02/2022 14:36

I am at 27yrs happily married to father of all my children. Perhaps some of us were luckier than you, and found a good man sooner in life?

Wow, no need to be rude - I was asking a genuine question. All my men were ‘good’ - just not right in the long term, or as young fathers at 24ish. I enjoyed all my relationships in my earlier twenties, though. I’m just interested I how much people change after that age, and whether as you grow it’s more common to grow apart or together. Maybe being tied together by children makes you more inclined to stay even if the relationship changes.

My DH and I have been together for over 20 years and been through a painful journey of infertility, caused by something which means I would never have been able to have children, but we didn’t know that till later. He would have been the right man to have children with at the right stage in both our lives, though.

EmpressCixi · 13/02/2022 14:30

@MsAgnesDiPesto

I’d be interested to know how many of you who had children at 24 are still happily in relationships with their fathers? All the men I chose to be with at that age would have been awful fathers at that point in our lives, and I can’t imagine still being with any of them now, 25 years later.
I am at 27yrs happily married to father of all my children. Perhaps some of us were luckier than you, and found a good man sooner in life?
MsAgnesDiPesto · 13/02/2022 14:27

I’d be interested to know how many of you who had children at 24 are still happily in relationships with their fathers? All the men I chose to be with at that age would have been awful fathers at that point in our lives, and I can’t imagine still being with any of them now, 25 years later.

dottydodah · 13/02/2022 14:27

Apparently the optimum time physically for a baby! Sadly not for young women wishing to have a Career or go travelling .I know someone who was pregnant at this age and all has gone well so far .However planning a pregnancy is a slightly different thing IMO

EmpressCixi · 13/02/2022 14:12

It’s young but not too young.
Many of us left home at 16/17 so have already had lots of fun and travel by 24.
You can also have fun and travel with babies/children. It’s not a question of have fun and travel OR have a baby, can do both.