Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if Americans actually like hersheys chocolate

187 replies

OfstedOffred · 12/02/2022 19:37

Colleague returned from a trip to the states and brought various sweets back including Hershey chocolate.

I tried a bit and it tastes terrible. I mean really. I have a sweet tooth so can cope with how sugary it is but there's a weird sicky flavour I can't place.

Is this how Americans like chocolate? Or is it just that international brands maybe don't get imported there or are expensive?

It hasnt gone down well at work. Huge bag and after everyone tried it once no one went back for more Grin

OP posts:
OhWhyNot · 14/02/2022 10:30

Yes have had s’mores

My nephew and nieces were so excited for ds to try them he liked it I didn’t. But he likes Oreos too

Canaloha · 14/02/2022 10:29

@phoenixrosehere

Hersheys is rank, so is a lot of American food though to be fair.

Have you tried all American food or just the American food in the U.K.?

I studied in America for a year, I actually prefer the versions of American food we have here. I'm sure many home cooked meals are delicious, the food when eating out was horrible imo and ceetain groceries super expensive whilst the stuff filled with goodness knows what was of course quite cheap. I used to be overweight and had BED so I'm not adverse to unhealthy food but just didn't find it very nice, as I'm sure they wouldn't find a lot of our food particularly great.
mycatisannoying · 14/02/2022 10:28

Disgusting stuff. YANBU.

phoenixrosehere · 14/02/2022 10:20

Hersheys is rank, so is a lot of American food though to be fair.

Have you tried all American food or just the American food in the U.K.?

queenofarles · 14/02/2022 10:16

Have any of you tried s'mores with real graham crackers, Hershey's, and toasted marshmallows?
But that’s just masking the taste of Hershey’s.

Furbulousnous · 14/02/2022 06:37

‘ Have any of you tried s'mores with real graham crackers, Hershey's, and toasted marshmallows?

I think they would change your mind about Hershey's.’

Oh,god Smores! Mu US family love them- the first time I tried them I thought they were a disgusting mess about to give me diabetes! My opinion hasn’t changed. Even our kids think they’re too sweet.
No thanks!

Furbulousnous · 14/02/2022 06:35

They love it! But all their choc tastes a bit like that TBH so they’re used to it, as would we be if we’d had it since childhood

WanderingFruitWonderer · 14/02/2022 05:43

I'm a vegan, so couldn't try it, but it sounds yucky. Funnily enough, now I'm vegan, and used to dairy-free chocolate, all milk chocolate tastes unpleasant to me. I ate a bit (quality brand too) by accident recently (long story) and it tasted so weird, like the smell of a farm or something, to me! Whereas I used to love milk chocolate in my pre-vegan days. So, I guess our taste buds must really change, and we get used to things. Marmite is another example of this - I love the stuff, having been brought up on it; but my French brother-in-law is horrified by it! He thinks we're mad! 😂

endofagain · 14/02/2022 05:31

@mathanxiety

Have any of you tried s'mores with real graham crackers, Hershey's, and toasted marshmallows?

I think they would change your mind about Hershey's.

I had one recently. Everybody raved about them but tbh I wouldn't have another. I think it is a question of what tastes you establish early on. That said, I was brought up in a village in a pretty dull part of England where the most exciting treat was fish and chips. I never tried food from other countries/ cultures until I was in my 20s. I eat just about everything now. Not fried crickets or fresh durian though.
loislovesstewie · 14/02/2022 05:15

Someone 'treated' me to some Hershey's chocolate years ago; never again. It does taste like vomit. As far as I am concerned nothing beats a good Belgian choc, although I am quite partial to a Yorkie as well.

Canaloha · 14/02/2022 04:49

Hersheys is rank, so is a lot of American food though to be fair.

onedayoranother · 14/02/2022 04:39

I grew up in the States and I recall you were either a Hersey's or Nestle fan. I don't like Herseys at all. I expect it's what you were brought up with.

mathanxiety · 14/02/2022 04:14

Have any of you tried s'mores with real graham crackers, Hershey's, and toasted marshmallows?

I think they would change your mind about Hershey's.

CeratopsofthePharoahs · 13/02/2022 21:51

There are many things I do like about America. Ford Mustangs, the cup measuring system, Nascar, New York, BBQ ribs and more.
However, Hersheys is minging. It really does taste like vomit.

This of an American trying British chocolate bars sums it up pretty well.

XenoBitch · 13/02/2022 21:34

Not RTF, but I have tried it and it tastes like vomit. I guess Americans are used to that.

queenofarles · 13/02/2022 21:26

PrincessNutella honestly, it’s nothing to do with history or being sneery to others food or culture.
lots of US chocolates use banned or restricted ingredients in UK and EU,
That’s why we find many cereals, bread , sweets and chocolates very synthetic, there is no cap on the percentage of PGPR used in the US , but the uk has a limit and I think EU countries have banned them all together, also some of the food dyes used in US chocolates are totally banned here Like red 40.

MissConductUS · 13/02/2022 20:24

and they make good hash brownies

Was that an autocorrect fail or did you actually mean "hash brownies"? 😁

Abhannmor · 13/02/2022 19:41

American chocolate is the alcohol free beer of confectionery. Their bread disintegrates upon contact with butter. I love root beer though and they make good hash brownies.

schnubbins · 13/02/2022 19:41

I lived in the USfor five years and stopped eating chocolate or sweets when I was there .Everything tasted awful especially Hershey's .even my kids didn't eat the sweets there when they arrived first .They eventually did find a few types of sweets or candy that they liked but in general it was always spat out.

nightwakingmoon · 13/02/2022 19:29

@PrincessNutella

I feel as if there is a disappointing lack of curiosity and openmindedness on this thread. I am not saying anyone should like Hershey's chocolate. I don't love it myself. But tasting the foods of another culture can be a visceral way of experiencing something about another culture, and there is often a fascinating history behind them that can open a door into another world, whether it is the foods of the wealthy or the junk food of the poor or everything in between. I see 138 messages so far, the great majority pretty much sneering at the tastes of another country, and very few asking "What's the why?" which is the only really interesting question. WHY is it that a certain people eats the foods they do? How did they acquire a taste for such a thing? Is there any food that we eat that we might have an equivalent taste for? And might other peoples view us in the same way? And are there any other countries that have similarly odd food products? Etc. These are interesting ways to talk about a foreign food and how you feel about it. Not just "Foreigners are stupid."
You can’t have remotely read the full thread at all before saying this, as I posted an article upthread about the reasons and history of why US chocolate tastes different, and lots of posters have been discussing it. Hmm
HopingForMyRainbowBaby · 13/02/2022 19:08

I'm not American but I love Hershey's chocolates

ThirdElephant · 13/02/2022 19:05

Sorry, the above should be tagged

@Anonymous48

ThirdElephant · 13/02/2022 19:04

You don't know what you're talking about, do you?

Candy is a generic term for sweet treats, like chocolate bars, lollipops, sweets, etc. Anything like that would be categorized as candy. Chocolate is a subset of candy.

I know that, but I was in under the impression it didn't contain enough cocoa to be legally classified as chocolate.

mobile.twitter.com/qikipedia/status/1226898620613644289

I don't know how accurate that is though, or where I heard it originally. Hence why I queried it.

IcedPurple · 13/02/2022 18:58

@PrincessNutella

I feel as if there is a disappointing lack of curiosity and openmindedness on this thread. I am not saying anyone should like Hershey's chocolate. I don't love it myself. But tasting the foods of another culture can be a visceral way of experiencing something about another culture, and there is often a fascinating history behind them that can open a door into another world, whether it is the foods of the wealthy or the junk food of the poor or everything in between. I see 138 messages so far, the great majority pretty much sneering at the tastes of another country, and very few asking "What's the why?" which is the only really interesting question. WHY is it that a certain people eats the foods they do? How did they acquire a taste for such a thing? Is there any food that we eat that we might have an equivalent taste for? And might other peoples view us in the same way? And are there any other countries that have similarly odd food products? Etc. These are interesting ways to talk about a foreign food and how you feel about it. Not just "Foreigners are stupid."
I think you may be overthinking this a tad.

It's just nasty 'chocolate'.

PrincessNutella · 13/02/2022 18:54

I feel as if there is a disappointing lack of curiosity and openmindedness on this thread. I am not saying anyone should like Hershey's chocolate. I don't love it myself. But tasting the foods of another culture can be a visceral way of experiencing something about another culture, and there is often a fascinating history behind them that can open a door into another world, whether it is the foods of the wealthy or the junk food of the poor or everything in between. I see 138 messages so far, the great majority pretty much sneering at the tastes of another country, and very few asking "What's the why?" which is the only really interesting question. WHY is it that a certain people eats the foods they do? How did they acquire a taste for such a thing? Is there any food that we eat that we might have an equivalent taste for? And might other peoples view us in the same way? And are there any other countries that have similarly odd food products? Etc. These are interesting ways to talk about a foreign food and how you feel about it. Not just "Foreigners are stupid."