Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Colleague sacked for abuse, shocked

186 replies

Cheesestring11 · 12/02/2022 16:13

She was caught on camera verbally abusing an elderly man with dementia, and sacked with immediate effect.

I'm shocked, I got on well with her, she wasn't perfect but I thought she had a good heart generally.

Haven't spoken to her in over a week, but I believe the event happened this week.

Not sure what to do really, just shocked that she could have done it, everyone makes mistakes but that was just nasty. Would you cut contact with her?

OP posts:
ritamiller · 12/02/2022 17:48

yes and the difference is carers get to leave after half an hour

They are there for 12 hour shifts and go from 1 bad patient to the next, where are you getting the 30 minutes from?

cuno · 12/02/2022 17:45

Maintaining contact to get her side of the story is mad. She was fired for gross misconduct because she abused a service user. It is not your place to establish the facts and go meddling. That extends to gossiping about it amongst colleagues as well. It would be unprofessional to reach out to her to hear her out, from the company's perspective you would be contacting a known abuser whose victim you care for, so you could get yourself dragged into this mess and affect your own career by doing so.

There was CCTV of the incident. Therefore there should be solid evidence of what has happened and it cannot be misconstrued. If still, it's all a big fix and she was perfectly justified in her actions, then she is within her rights to appeal and I'm sure if she wants to clear her name she will do so. Even then, if she finds the process has not been fair, she can take this to tribunal. And with CCTV evidence of it all, this would truly clear her name if she was wrongly fired.

Even if you speak to her, and she gives you a good story. What can you do with that exactly? Lots of abusers will twist it around to make the victim look responsible. So you won't even know if it's true or not. Pointless exercise and too much risk.

Also, in my experience of care, if you're a bit snippy on a one off because you've been pushed to the limits, this would not lead to gross misconduct. Perhaps you would get a warning, some extra training, but I very much doubt you would be fired for it. We are human after all and sometimes mistakes do happen. But abuse is not a mistake. As a care worker, I have never been abusive verbal or otherwise because I've had a hard day, and trust me I've had plenty of hard days! And as hard as it is, you do get to go home at the end of it, even if you're doing back to back sleep-ins. So it isn't really comparable to people who have to deal with it relentlessly in their own home with their relatives.

Furthermore, I'd be disgusted if someone reached out to a member of staff who sexually abused someone in their care to hear their side of the story. So let's not do that in other cases of abuse whether there is a chance of them being untrue or not.

I am not saying you will do any of this OP, but I am shocked at people suggesting to find out the other side of the story.

Porcupineintherough · 12/02/2022 17:41

@ritamiller yes and the difference is carers get to leave after half an hour.

People with dementia can be difficult, aggressive and annoying. So can those with mental health issues. So can those with learning difficulties. So can small children.

It's not ok to abuse them.

labyrinthlaziness · 12/02/2022 17:39

It is a real shock when we learn something like this, because we hope we would just 'know' if someone was like this, but the truth is sometimes we don't. Is good this was found out though.

Have a Brew for the shock and be glad you won;t have to work with this person again.

endlesssighing · 12/02/2022 17:33

It can be difficult when we find out friends are not who we thought they were. I understand your confusion, I imagine it’s hard to correlate the story with the colleague you know.

Unfortunately many people only display their true identities to vulnerable or weaker people who cannot protect themselves.

As much as you want to reach out, I wouldn’t. A sharp, clean break is best. I imagine she may have been told by management she isn’t allowed to contact anyone.

Try to move on, unfortunately these things happen and you’ve just got to keep your head down and hope their replacement is much nicer.

Nocutenamesleft · 12/02/2022 17:31

No way would I stay in contact with her

Out of lots of things in the world. That’s up there on stuff I could never ever forgive. Never

I wouldn’t ever contact her again. disgusting behaviour.

Fujimora · 12/02/2022 17:29

A lot of people who have an opion on this have probably never had to deal with it

I have had to deal with this and I know exactly how challenging people with dementia can be. I have often walked away, or left the room but I would never have verbally abused the individual concerned. And I am not a career care worker with training.

Young babies and children can also be very challenging. But nobody would ever make excuses for parents or kindergarten staff verbally abusing them. Why the double standard with the elderly?

x2boys · 12/02/2022 17:29

[quote EmpressCixi]@Itsalmostanaccessory

I’m not condoning verbal abuse of the elderly at all. I’m just saying get the facts. If the OPs friend who has been a lovely person for years has suddenly told an OAP to get his fucking hands off her...and sacked for it because he’s gone....ooooh I have dementia...then my sympathy is with her. They’re not all harmless. My best friends daughter who works in a care home was beaten in the face by a woman with dementia just last month, ended up with split lip and a black eye. I’d personally be more understanding of a knew jerk VERBAL reaction to physical or sexual assault than your “no excuse” idiocy, clearly you’ve never run afoul of a dementia sufferer when they are violent or predatory.[/quote]
Your right lots of Dementia patients are not harmless I worked on both the acute mental health,wards and Dementia wards as a nurse ,there was was far more violence and agression on the elderly wards ,but that can be part of dementia aa can sexual disinhibition,it's extremely hard work and not everyone is cur out for it but under no circumstances should a staff member be verbally or physically abusive

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 12/02/2022 17:27

People refusing to wash and dress is a big part of working in nursing homes. You learn to deal with it without being verbally abusive even when you are in a tight schedule

Wrongkindofovercoat · 12/02/2022 17:23

I have visited residential homes and patients homes where they have refused a proper wash for a over week, a lot of people feel uncomfortable getting undressed in front of strangers and people with dementia are no different. It can take time to build a rapport with someone so they trust you enough to provide intimate care. If someone refuses, you walk away and try again later, pointless to escalate the situation or get angry with them.
I know of a few families who have cameras in their elderly vulnerable relatives homes, both to monitor them and also the behaviour of visiting care staff.

ritamiller · 12/02/2022 17:23

It may be challenging and exhausting but after having looked after my mum with dementia and dad with alzheimers for years before them going into a home, I never lost it with them

There is a big difference between looking after your parents than being on a tight time schedule and having to look after dozens.

Theunamedcat · 12/02/2022 17:23

Obvious cut contact get a moral compass

UniversalAunt · 12/02/2022 17:22

You need to determine whether you are shocked that she has done this or shocked that she has been caught then sacked?

I assume that she had to account for her actions shown on the video & from that the employer decided to terminate her contract with immediate effect. Her dismissal had to be fair & I again assume that her employer would give her the opportunity to state any mitigations (e.g. they grabbed me hard, it really hurt & here are my bruises. Sorry, but in pain & shock, I spoke out harshly) to clear up any misunderstanding or misinterpretations,

Your decision is about if you want or need to know what happened, do you feel compelled to find out from her what she said happened?
If she admitted that she did do it, would you want to have further contact?

Caring for someone with dementia can be very challenging, but your colleague is trained & paid to do a job, has professional distance & gets to go home after their shift. Zero tolerance of abuse of the vulnerable is alert of that.

ancientgran · 12/02/2022 17:20

I have an elderly relative in care, she has severe dementia and is horrendously inappropriate with male carers. Sometimes the care home will get a nice young male member of staff to deal with her when she is being aggressive with female staff but the price of that is that the young man will have very inappropriate stuff to deal with. I feel uncomfortable with it but I can see it makes life easier for everyone else as she will go from aggressive to flirty and giggly and the young guys seem to take it with good grace. I'm not sure I would be able to blame them if they lost it with her one day, not physical obviously but if they shouted at her I think I'd understand.

So for me circumstances would matter.

TakeMe2Insanity · 12/02/2022 17:20

@TabithaTittlemouse

Why would you question it???
This!
Ellowyn · 12/02/2022 17:20

@EmpressCixi

I’d want her side of the story first. Some of those harmless dementia elderly think they’re 20 and it’s 1960 and think they can still legally cop a feel (sexually assault you).
Years ago in the local post office one of the local elderly men, who was still allowed to wander around the village, was laughing to himself inside. He clearly had dementia and everyone sort of kept an eye on him, as people do in small communities. Anyway, as I walked passed him, he touched me on my bum with his finger - which made him laugh even more, bless him. I ignored it as I naturally understood he'd lost his inhibition and no harm was done. I recently told a woman about this, including his condition, and she said she would have 'punched him in the face anyway'. Some people are heartless.
notanothertakeaway · 12/02/2022 17:17

@Cheesestring11

He didn't touch her or say anything inappropriate to her I believe, but he just refused to have a wash or something he was meant to have. I won't be contacting her again from now on in any case
A professional carer would try to persuade, or try again tomorrow, not verbally abuse a vulnerable patient
gingerhills · 12/02/2022 17:15

@ritamiller

I'm going to go against the grain here and say get the facts 1st. Whilst I am not condoning abuse for a second I am saying we all have our limits and can snap sometimes.

What was said in the verbal abuse? There is a difference if for example she was doing it all the time to it being a 1 off and just having a very bad day and saying 'ffs put the shoes on', again that's not ok but we are all human and capable of cracking sometimes.

If it was the latter I wouldn't class her as a monster or necessarily cut contacts because she fucked up. But in a professional environment you can and will be fired for this often so you just have to not snap even in the most challenging times.

BTW I nursed my own father through dementia so know exactly how challenging and exhausting it can be,

This is a fair answer. If you knew her to be a good soul, maybe get all the facts. She could have been having the day or week or month from hell. Carers are terribly paid, so there's often financial stress on top of hard work, long hours, understaffing,. If the man had been abusive or suggestive, which is possible, because dementia disinhibits, then she may have snapped.
cuno · 12/02/2022 17:15

@Weirdwonders

None of us know anything about the incident or your colleague or so we can’t really comment can we. Nothing more unedifying that watching MN pile on. Get down a care home yourselves and do some shifts for minimum wage if it’s that easy.
I already work in care, thank you very much.
ritamiller · 12/02/2022 17:12

I don't know if it was physical, sexual or verbal abuse

the op said verbal.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 12/02/2022 17:11

After working in nursing homes for so long I honestly think the majority will just employ anyone. No it's not easy but it's no excuse to be abusive to someone who vulnerable.

Many people would find working with toddler's hard but we don't excuse people who verbally abuse them. Why is it different if its a vulnerable adult?

Frigginintheriggin · 12/02/2022 17:11

Firstly make sure its not just gossip.
When you know its a fact absolutely call her. Tell her she's a cunt.
Hang up and block her number. Job done.

ritamiller · 12/02/2022 17:11

None of us know anything about the incident or your colleague or so we can’t really comment can we

This and as I said none of us know the mgmt, were they trying to get rid of her or did they have beef with her?

Cheesestring11 · 12/02/2022 17:10

But it's true it does make me wonder what else she may have been doing ..

OP posts:
LuluBlakey1 · 12/02/2022 17:10

I'd not want anything else to do with her. She was caught on camera so it was there to see. I don't know if it was physical, sexual or verbal abuse byt the man in question was extremely vulnerable and you have to ask yourself what kind of person abuses someone, and someone very vulnerable. It's disgusting. There's no excuse.

Swipe left for the next trending thread