Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Colleague sacked for abuse, shocked

186 replies

Cheesestring11 · 12/02/2022 16:13

She was caught on camera verbally abusing an elderly man with dementia, and sacked with immediate effect.

I'm shocked, I got on well with her, she wasn't perfect but I thought she had a good heart generally.

Haven't spoken to her in over a week, but I believe the event happened this week.

Not sure what to do really, just shocked that she could have done it, everyone makes mistakes but that was just nasty. Would you cut contact with her?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SweetFelicityArkright · 15/02/2022 16:42

@Chocolateis1ofyour5aday

If a camera was set up to catch her or any other colleagues abusing vulnerable residents then there must have been a reason for the family or home to do this - and your colleague got caught. As someone whose nonverbal vulnerable DF was in a home and attacked by another patient I'd bin your pal! No bloody excuse for it, no matter how frustrated she got!
Most homes now have CCTV in public places. They help a lot when incidents happen like someone falling when no one has witnessed it to determine mechanism of the fall, if they hit their head etc. They also assist when the condition of a resident is changing or deteriorating, because it's there, on camera to be seen, and there can't then be the usual 'oh the staff can't be bothered to deal with them so they're whining about it'. It also shows where all staff are at any given time.

As for covert camera's in rooms, I've encountered a few, and yes, they're useful for picking up on situations like this where it may not be apparent and having something done about it. They're also good at developing an overall picture of someone, because care staff cannot be with each resident 24/7 and I have known one be used to affect a move of a resident that was in the wrong setting, but the social worker was dragging their feet with arranging a new, more suitable placement, which affected not only the resident involved, but others too.
There's so much more to bad care than bad care assistants, but as others have pointed out, pushing people into this line of work and treating those who choose it badly isn't going to resolve that situation, it makes it worse.

Chocolateis1ofyour5aday · 15/02/2022 13:34

If a camera was set up to catch her or any other colleagues abusing vulnerable residents then there must have been a reason for the family or home to do this - and your colleague got caught. As someone whose nonverbal vulnerable DF was in a home and attacked by another patient I'd bin your pal! No bloody excuse for it, no matter how frustrated she got!

Wreath21 · 15/02/2022 13:16

Of course the other way the Tories are likely to try solving the care home staffing crisis will be a brand new moral panic about how awful it is that 'people' (and let's be clear about this, they mean 'women') don't provide care for the sick and elderly at home these days because they are too 'selfish'.

Wreath21 · 15/02/2022 13:13

[quote AutomaticMoon]@SweetFelicityArkright

www.homecareinsight.co.uk/care-worker-pay-drops-below-that-of-cleaners-skills-for-care-report-finds/[/quote]
You're absolutely right: people will bellow and stamp and virtue-signal about how awful it is that people in care homes are often mistreated - but you hear a lot less about how awful it is that people with no aptitude for the work are being pressured to take it up.
There is this mindset that the shortage of care workers should be fixed by forcing the 'benefit scroungers' and the idle, frivolous, selfish poor, to take on the jobs... rather than pay staff properly and treat them with respect. Which is not really very good for the patients.

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 14/02/2022 16:08

[quote Merlin3189]**@UnshakenNeedsStirring* , @Kikibabes*
If they were your loved one and you had taken care of them, first they might not be in a care home, and if you'd given up and put them in care, you might be more understanding.
Even if it were my mother or father, I hope I'd have much more sympathy and understanding for the sacked person than most MNers have shown. I can't believe the extremely critical comments come from people who have any experience of this situation.[/quote]
And whos going to pay my mortgage while I care for my loved one at home! You think caring for someone is easy?

Vapeyvapevape · 14/02/2022 10:57

We have a family member in a care home and have 3 ongoing incidents of abuse against them- one serious enough to get the police involved, it's appalling and I agree that it needs to be seen as a proper profession and not just something anyone can do.

Kikibabes · 14/02/2022 10:45

[quote Merlin3189]**@UnshakenNeedsStirring* , @Kikibabes*
If they were your loved one and you had taken care of them, first they might not be in a care home, and if you'd given up and put them in care, you might be more understanding.
Even if it were my mother or father, I hope I'd have much more sympathy and understanding for the sacked person than most MNers have shown. I can't believe the extremely critical comments come from people who have any experience of this situation.[/quote]
I actually used to work in a care home- it wasn't necessarily a dementia specific place but there was plenty of residents with the diagnosis- I simply think that caring for someone is a calling & it's not something everyone can do 🤷🏻‍♀️- it's always been my mantra to treat others as u would like to be treated and when I was working in the care setting I ALWAYS treated the residents like they were my grandparents because I would hate to think my grandparents would have been treated any different had they been in a home- thankfully neither grandparent maternal or paternal has to go into one but unfortunately i no longer have them here- so yes I absolutely do have caring experience and I stand by my comment 🤷🏻‍♀️

Member869894 · 14/02/2022 07:49

I'd want to hear what she did first.

Augustmummy · 14/02/2022 07:10

Was she a friend before a colleague? Do you know what she said that got her fired?

If she’s just a colleague, obviously bin her off. Friends are friends, work colleagues are just people we are forced into a room with. I wouldn’t bother with her unless she was a good friend before the incident and if that was the case I’d try to find out what happened. If just a colleague, forget her and move on. Not your concern.

Ifigotherewillbedouble · 14/02/2022 05:13

@ritamiller

I'm going to go against the grain here and say get the facts 1st. Whilst I am not condoning abuse for a second I am saying we all have our limits and can snap sometimes.

What was said in the verbal abuse? There is a difference if for example she was doing it all the time to it being a 1 off and just having a very bad day and saying 'ffs put the shoes on', again that's not ok but we are all human and capable of cracking sometimes.

If it was the latter I wouldn't class her as a monster or necessarily cut contacts because she fucked up. But in a professional environment you can and will be fired for this often so you just have to not snap even in the most challenging times.

BTW I nursed my own father through dementia so know exactly how challenging and exhausting it can be,

Nursing your own father is VERY different to choosing to work and BE PAID for looking after someone else’s father. I cared for my grandfather and also cared for my own child who had significant caring needs - no way would I be interested in anyone else’s excuses for providing less than the care anyone deserves.
Merlin3189 · 13/02/2022 23:02

@UnshakenNeedsStirring , @Kikibabes
If they were your loved one and you had taken care of them, first they might not be in a care home, and if you'd given up and put them in care, you might be more understanding.
Even if it were my mother or father, I hope I'd have much more sympathy and understanding for the sacked person than most MNers have shown. I can't believe the extremely critical comments come from people who have any experience of this situation.

SweetFelicityArkright · 13/02/2022 23:01

This is probably the most sensible thing that I've read about the care industry in a long while, taken from the link @AutomaticMoon posted.

“The government must end the care crisis by showing it’s ready to end a bargain-basement service that puts profits above care and treats staff like numbers on a spreadsheet.”

Care is seen as a job anyone can do, which is justification for the poor pay and treatment of care workers. Well this is what happens when anyone does the job. And the reason that anyone can do the job is because caring for the elderly, disabled and vulnerable is not valued, because they are not valued.

I have worked 4 short staffed shifts this week, I worked 6 shifts in total. The residents are paying for their care, yet on 4 days this week they've not had enough carers to do that properly, no matter how hard I work or how good I am, I'm not two people. Where has the money that should have paid that last carer gone? Have myself and my colleagues received extra? No.
Have the residents received a refund? No.
It's been kept by the company.
On every single one of those 6 shifts I have to be at work 15 minutes (changed into uniform, ready to work) before the start of my shift time for handover. I get paid from the start of my shift, not for the handover, but I'd say it's a pretty essential part of my job, communication is so important in care, yet not important enough to pay for for the provider.
I worked some very difficult shifts through covid, 24 hours, 10-14 days without a day off, for 6 hours one day I was the only carer there, I had the cook helping me with essential care tasks that took two people. Saved a fortune on the wage bill for the company, and I wasn't the only one in that situation by a long shot. I got paid nmw for all those shifts, so did the cook and others.
Through the 'Recruitment and retention' scheme from the government paid to providers, I have received a £25 voucher.
CQC and safeguarding aware (had to be) and the silence is deafening.

New recruits are 'trained' with 2/3 shadow shifts and about 3 hours of DVDs and questions. Even if they've never done care before. Then off they go.

I have an administration of medication certificate, do you know how long my training took? 30 minutes online and I have an official certificate meaning I can administer medication to someone who is prescribed it, I am responsible for administering 'as and when' medication that sedates people when they are very anxious, or morphine to someone who is in pain - but who cannot communicate that to me, I have to be able to read the signs, the situation, know the person.
And I got 30 minutes training and watched doing my first round. I have nearly 20 years experience and I care about the people I look after, I understand what I'm doing and feel confident, and I still feel that it's bloody inadequate training considering the stakes.

Bad carers need to be stamped out, but what will make a much larger positive change is training people properly, valuing the training and development they undergo (and actually making it available!) - I have an nvq 3, the equivalent of 2 a levels, and I'm on the same wage as someone with no nvq or experience, giving the CQC real teeth, not allowing care companies to abuse their staff and then throw them under the bus when something goes wrong and most of all, stopping them profiting from exploiting the elderly and vulnerable and their carers.
There is no political or societal will to do it though. So incidents like this will never stop, no matter how much people shout about how disgusting it is when it's brought to light.

DitzyFlake · 13/02/2022 22:56

Sometimes people do awful things they regret but I would like to think we could be compassionate and forgiving. She seems to have paid by losing her job - if you genuinely liked her I am sure there may be a bit more to the story. She may have behaved wrongly you should speak to her and reach your own conclusions.

Mol70 · 13/02/2022 22:40

Maybe the old man was being persistently abusive to her and she snapped? Shouted if he was gone deaf? My dad is 90 , has Parkinson's and is very grumpy and rude, always was. He expects to be treated like an emporer, his carers , my mother and my siblings pander to him. I had to care for him a lot during lockdown. One day I shouted " could you be any more rude?" Does that make me a horrible person?

Kikibabes · 13/02/2022 22:11

@UnshakenNeedsStirring

You sound crazy. What if that elderly person was your loved one? Would you still feel the same if she abused your parents or grandparents?
👏🏻 EXACTLY THIS!
Swear · 13/02/2022 21:38

@Bertiebiscuit

Block her and never have contact with her again - she is toxic now, and no excuse could justify this, she should not have been working with vulnerable people, so it's good she got caught before she did worse - having anything to do with her will only compromise you
There is a massive, massive shortage of carers in the UK, post Brexit. How many people do you think are queuing up to care for old people with dementia?
Merlin3189 · 13/02/2022 21:33

I wouldn't be too quick to judge so harshly. I've seen someone sacked for improper behaviour when I thought they'd been a little less than perfect under extreme provocation (which I witnessed.) If you saw it and you think it was bad, then you can judge: if all you know is the comments of a manager, I'd want to give them at least the opportunity to give their account.
Even if they agreed they were wrong, I'd want to give them at least some sympathy. Caring for people whose behaviour is incredibly appalling, can get extremely stressful and even the best of us can lose it. You expect her to continually accept abuse and return only loving care, but she offends you once and that's the end of your relationship?

Silvers11 · 13/02/2022 20:58

You have been told what happened rather than witnessing it as far as I can gather from your posts so the first thing I would say is, if you like her and were friends before this happened then perhaps you ought to find out from her what actually happened before you judge her too harshly?

You say you thought that generally she has a good heart - so maybe she does and simply isn't cut out for a caring role. Dementia sufferers are very difficult and stressful to deal with and you don't know until you ask her what exactly happened. Clearly she did not behave on that occasion as the professional she was employed to be and quite rightly has lost her job as a result.

But if that was a one off and depending on what she actually said and did and the reason why she lost her temper it only makes her unfit to carry out the role she was in and she may still be a nice person who 'cracked' under enormous strain. We often don't know the private stresses our workmates are under.

On the other hand, she may have been behaving unkindly lots of the time, to lots of elderly people for a while, in which case, why do you even need to ask whether you should cut contact? You aren't going to know until you ask her though . THEN is the time to make up your mind about what you want to do going forward in my opinion

Bertiebiscuit · 13/02/2022 20:49

Block her and never have contact with her again - she is toxic now, and no excuse could justify this, she should not have been working with vulnerable people, so it's good she got caught before she did worse - having anything to do with her will only compromise you

IcyWinterWonderland · 13/02/2022 20:48

I am glad she has lost her job

Tzimi · 13/02/2022 20:33

Even the nicest person can be pushed too far sometimes. What were the circumstances? She may have been pushed beyond her limits, to make her abuse the patient.

JoanWilderbeast · 13/02/2022 19:52

It's easy to be a paragon of virtue if it's hypothetical.

AutomaticMoon · 13/02/2022 19:50

@wingscrow

To those who are trying to explain/excuse this woman's behaviour: she was caught on camera...there is clear evidence.

If she could not handle the stress of the job she should not be working with vulnerable adults.

As for the OP: why on earth would you want to be in contact with someone like this?

You do know that there’s going to be more of this happening, not less, by forcing people into care work who cannot cope in the environment? And they’re being forced to, if they’re job seekers they are pushed into these jobs for minimum wage (or even no pay for sleep shifts where you’re not actually sleeping)

Paying care workers LESS than cleaners is not acceptable. People in this country value a clean house more than a sufficiently remunerated carer looking after their relatives. This job is treated like a joke by employers, I don’t understand why people are surprised about all the heinous outcomes. It’s BS that people care, like @SweetFelicityArkright said, it’s not real care, if it was actual concern, people would demand that care workers are trained properly and paid living wage, at least.

And DWP should stop pushing psychopathic people onto this ‘career path’ just so they can survive. Like Felicity said, managers couldn’t care less of the quality of carer, they only care for quantity, being available for 60-70 hours per week, no life of your own, as it’s the only way you can earn enough money doing this job, breaking your back to fill shifts due to the chronic shortages.

I’ve worked in quite a few different environments in my life, the care home was THE most toxic and harmful. I’d rather be homeless than ever end up in such an abusive situation. I’ve worked in restaurants, bars, night clubs, clothes manufacturing, hairdressers, building sites, offices, I’ve never encountered such awful and sadistic people like the staff and managers in the care home. Not all the staff were bad, but it only takes a few to ruin the atmosphere for the whole house.

Jk987 · 13/02/2022 19:32

The OP has not done anything wrong so stop treating her like the perpetrator. She's shocked and she's come on here for support. When in shock you can be in a state of disbelief. This is why women often don't leave their husbands immediately after abuse or an affair.