Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does this sound normal behaviour for a ten year old?

131 replies

Missmummy88 · 12/02/2022 15:22

My son has always had big melts downs, think big toddler tantrums screaming shouting etc - then when he hit about 5-6 he would get angry and swipe things off sides push over chairs/laundry’s baskets. Now he is ten and he’s still being distrucyive but now very verbally abusive.

This happens most days.

Today he was angry with me because I told him his two hour tech was over (he has another hour at lunch). This is an arrangement he is aware of - I didn’t just rip tech away.

He then started rolling eyes, stomping about etc went upstairs where he’s 6 yo brother was playing Lego and with 2 minutes screaming and crying from my 6yo with a gash to the head where ten year old has thrown a book at him.

I tell him off & tell him he has now lost his lunch time hour. He loses it, starts telling me to fuck off you big fat idiot why do you hate everyone. Etc etc. From past experience I know this is escalating behaviour so I remove myself and 6yo to a safe space - he then let’s rip. Four boxes of Lego tipped everywhere - stuff thrown across the room and then he comes in with a piece of paper saying fuck off written on.

I ignore and when he leaves my room 6yo schrubches up and puts in bin.

Ten year old comes in demanding his paper screaming you fucking idiots multiple times.

He then walks around the house behind me about how awful a mum I am etc.

(I’m not awful just average - try my hardest like we all do!)

About one minute later he’s completely snapped out of it & is getting his shoes on to go to his friends house.

This is a common occurrence- meltdowns & verbal abuse.

He does get punished by removal of privileges like tech / no football cards etc. I just don’t do it while he’s melting as from experience he just gets worse so I wait until he’s calm to talk to him about it.

He has an asd assessment next week which I’ve paid for privately as school don’t see any of this behaviour.

I know this isn’t normal but does it sound like asd or does he just hate me?!

OP posts:
dinkybella77 · 13/02/2022 15:38

It's the screens. Lots of parents I have spoken to have had this experience, although not to the extent you describe. Shouting, frustration and aggressive behaviour after gaming. They are v addictive.

Are there other times when he shows this behaviour? What are the triggers? Transitioning to come away from the screen as others have mentioned seems to be the issue in this scenario

Cleothecat75 · 13/02/2022 14:31

@Chely

Our 11 year old is awaiting assesment but he wouldn't behave like that, especially not towards me. I think you need to seek professional help ASAP. This kind of behaviour will continue to escalate if you don't find ways to manage it early.
Can you really not see that everyone is different and all Every person who has asd Will present differently. The quote ‘if you’ve met one person with additional needs, then you’ve met one person with additional needs’ is so true.

My dd only presents in an aggressive way towards me, because I am her safe place. She has trust that I won’t abandon her when she needs help the most.

She has only ever had one anxiety attack at school and that was towards me after school had completely overwhelmed her - she held it together until I got there and then let it all out. The shock on the faces of the staff who witnessed it was massive. They finally believed what I had been saying and afterwards said how distressing they found It to witness.

Dd was diagnosed over 12 months ago and we still haven’t received any support or help despite being on waiting lists. I’ve been trying to get help for her for over half of her life and she’s 12 now, so if you are able to give me any pointers on where to access this magical support you suggest op uses, I’d be really grateful for the tips. As I said earlier (and it’s something you need to prepare for if your dc is waiting for assessment and might need support), there is very little support out there.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 13/02/2022 14:27

We don't know whether the child can stop himself or not. You are assuming and guessing, just like everyone else.

You are right - I should have said he probably already knows it is unacceptable and he probably can't stop himself but if he has autism he may not even have made that connection yet. In any case if he doesn't already know it's unacceptable then punishment alone is not likely to make that connection for him.

that behaviour has to stop. It isn't actually compulsory to provide a magic solution every time one comments on MN, you know.

It's not compulsory to provide a solution, no, but it's deeply unhelpful to say that kind of thing if you don't have any ideas how to improve it.

I agree that the OP needs to take steps to protect her younger son from his brother's anger. From what she says it's an immediate lash out rather than a long-term grudge so if she can predict her older son's reaction and focus on protecting her youngest at the times when her older son is most likely to lash out - for example, when she has just taken away his screen time! - that should make it more possible.

I know one parent who taught her DD to run out of the house and go to a neighbour when her older brother started getting agitated and angry. That's probably the most extreme I've met.

Mistyplanet · 13/02/2022 14:26

Doesn't sound normal but 2 hours gaming doesn't sound good for him. Does he have any physical activity or other things he can do at the weekend? My active 9 year old has to have a range of activities in place to get through the weekend peacefully. If i let him game for hours his behaviour would definitely be worse. Sounds like hes addicted to it and you should try cutting it down and give him other outlets.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 13/02/2022 14:20

@OakRowan

You let him go to his friend's house after all that, especially after he had cut your other younger son's head open throwing something at him? Wow.
I agree you don't punish other families though especially if they had already booked and paid for an activity.

Also gets him out of the situation and able to calm down.

I agree about the "sudden death" to tech time, especially as so many games don't appear to have pause buttons. But I also agree that if he can't cope with stopping, then he needs not to play it at all or at least much less often.

whydobirds · 13/02/2022 13:42

@xxlostxx

I have taught so many kids whose parents had been told the kids had no SEN and it was all down to parenting. Schools in my area are the gatekeepers for assessment so if you can't get them to agree it is necessary, you're stuffed.

Every. Single. One of those children has since gained a diagnosis.

I was told DS didn't have ADHD because he didn't misbehave in class. Guess what...and methylphenidate changed his life.

DD couldn't have autism cos she had friends. Guess what...and she also probably has ADHD, but she now also has OCD, an eating disorder, trashed mental health and a tic disorder from the stress of mainstream, particularly the refusal of her secondary to believe that her (diagnosed) condition meant she had any needs in school.

'Oh well we don't see it'
'She's melting down every morning and evening'
'Yes but we don't see it, she's top of her class'
Ffs.

One of my ex students wasn't autistic because they were well behaved and clever and the fact their secondary attendance dropped to 20% and the only days they were in school were days they were dragged there kicking and screaming was down to the parents.

There is nowhere near enough understanding of SEN in mainstream education or in society.

Even with a diagnosis there are plenty of school staff who will ignore strategies given as 'they don't see it'.

Even when DS had his interview for PIP, they were taking the fact he has stellar GCSE results to suggest that he doesn't need help. Yes he is blisteringly intelligent but his disabilities mean he is incapable of independent life.

It really angers me. So many kids are being failed because it is easier to blame the parents than to listen to them, and people find it easier to adhere to the 90s red top tabloid stereotypes of ND than to actually educate themselves.

xxlostxx · 13/02/2022 13:22

@emsmar

If the school don't see it - it's definitely a home problem.
Such a common misconception, even among many teachers. Quite depressing really! I'm all too familiar with the scenario OP has described. School would hear none of it, put it down to parenting. I pursued the long, lengthy process with Camhs for assessment regardless, and from the first meeting they said the behaviours all pointed towards ASD. DD did get an ASD diagnosis. Just excellent at masking at school!
whydobirds · 13/02/2022 13:15

This sounds way more than "naughty" though Orlando, and at an age where most children no longer exhibit behaviours like this.
It is completely dysregulated. A NT child would learn after a few removals of privileges that it wasn't worth the behaviour. A ND child can't help it and no amount of punishment will address it. They need help learning the tools with which to regulate their behaviour. OP doesn't mention that her younger child exhibits this which suggests it's not necessarily down to parenting - although even if he is diagnosed ND she will be told by many professionals that it's her parenting before they accept his level of need, ime.

whydobirds · 13/02/2022 13:10

Reading your OP again what you could try next time is a timer he can see for his tech time, with lots of notice that it is going to end, followed by a deep pressure activity, like isometric exercises. Try a weighted blanket for him. In my own kids and those I work with I would generally expect issues with sudden change (if adhd there's time blindness so knowing he has two hours will mean nothing) and overstimulation.

Loss of the next thing he was expecting may have exacerbated it too.

That is in no way a criticism - before DS was diagnosed (asd/adhd) he was overstimulated and had a huge violent meltdown which led to me not giving him the cake he was expecting. Meltdown got worse and more violent. I should have addressed the first meltdown with deep pressure, then carried on the day as normal. What would happen if, when he started to lose control, you held him and squashed him in a really tight hug while repeating something calmly (its ok, its ok, will this matter in five years or similar) if he's screaming? That used to really work for ds, you'd literally feel the tension drain out of him in a few minutes. I had to do that once when picking him up from a holiday club. Another child had broken his lego creation and he had melted down to the point they had to remove him to a separate room so he didn't hurt people. I went up to him, squashed him, he was screaming about the lego and thrashing and I just kept looking into the far corner and repeating in a monotone 'will it matter in five years' while squeezing. Then suddenly, all his emotions dissipated and he said 'no' and all was well. Holiday club staff were all 'how did you DO that' like I was a magician. It is worth a try...

Oh and ask school, what is he like socially. How does he play. Most of the kids I know with ASD and ADHD mask like troopers at school - the idea that ADHD presents the same in all settings is rubbish- but you'll see the executive dysfunction in the latter and the social dysfunction/rigidity of thinking in the former. You'll also see the sensory need. He will likely be struggling to some degree at school, but there seems to be such a rigid interpretation of how neurodiversity presents, among some school staff so the slightly atypical presentations get missed. I currently teach a kid who wasn't diagnosed til 16, which has had an awful impact on his education.

OrlandointheWilderness · 13/02/2022 12:52

My dd was naughty coming off iPad so I removed it. A couple of times I took it away for a week and then after a gentle chat and warning for 6 months. She has been wonderful without it.

whydobirds · 13/02/2022 12:50

If he has ASD then deep pressure activities might help him regulate. I used to have to physically squash DS. Now at 17 he carries a stress ball and squeezes that hard if he feels he is beginning to get stressed. Also assuming it is ASD punishing him won't make him not able to melt down. When he's calm can he tell you what the triggers were? So for example if it's sudden change you could give plenty of notice of what is happening and how. Could also be that he is finding school very stressful.
Tools like Zones of Regulation can help kids with recognising when they're about to blow.

If ADHD, medication can potentially really help with regulation too. It would be best to specifically ask for referral for dual diagnosis based on the dysregulation + executive dysfunction as often only one condition will be referred for and then you've got to go back in the queue for the second, whereas they can be diagnosed in the same single process.

boringcreation · 13/02/2022 12:32

@emsmar

If the school don't see it - it's definitely a home problem.
What kind of thing is that to say? A lot of kids mask at school
user1493494961 · 13/02/2022 11:57

I would put all his tech stuff in the bin.

romdowa · 13/02/2022 11:52

As a person with asd and adhd my only advice is to try and stop the meltdown before it happens. Punishing him after is pointless, it's like punishing him for breathing , he really can't help it.
Finding his triggers will be key here, talking about how to help him in the meltdown if its unavoidable. Discovering if he is sensory seeking or avoiding will also help you to figure out what he needs. So people with asd who need sensory input to calm down might liked to be hugged while melting Down while a person with avoidance needs space , a calm place to wait until the feelings pass. Things like ear defenders and weighted blankets can help.

GloGirl · 13/02/2022 11:48

@Lovemusic33

Am I the only parent of dc with ASD that doesn’t see this kind of behaviour? My dc wouldn’t dare swear at me or throw things around the house. I have to say I’m pretty relaxed with tech time, I do pick my battles but my dc rarely push boundaries.

Some kids can swear and shout without have ASD or ADHD, the same as not all kids with ASD/ADHD are naughty and having ASD/ADHD is no excuse to behave this way.

I am 100% confident your child will have behaviours mine would never do either.

Everyone's circumstances, boundaries, peer groups, family support networks etc are different, not just their parenting styles.

We are all managing as best we can, is there any need to write what could be considered a very smug post on someone's thread who is clearly struggling and asking for help?

Impulse control can differ depending on the impulses. Explosive behaviour can change depending on sensory needs. Verbal aggression can be common if thats what you see and hear at school etc.

7eleven · 13/02/2022 11:45

@CoastalWave did you even read the part where I stated I wasn’t talking about the OP Hmm

Lovemusic33 · 13/02/2022 11:21

Am I the only parent of dc with ASD that doesn’t see this kind of behaviour? My dc wouldn’t dare swear at me or throw things around the house. I have to say I’m pretty relaxed with tech time, I do pick my battles but my dc rarely push boundaries.

Some kids can swear and shout without have ASD or ADHD, the same as not all kids with ASD/ADHD are naughty and having ASD/ADHD is no excuse to behave this way.

CoastalWave · 13/02/2022 11:21

@Chely

Our 11 year old is awaiting assesment but he wouldn't behave like that, especially not towards me. I think you need to seek professional help ASAP. This kind of behaviour will continue to escalate if you don't find ways to manage it early.
And here we go with the perfect parents who somehow thing that the fact 'their' child wouldn't do that, makes them a better parent.

OP - ignore.

CoastalWave · 13/02/2022 11:20

@7eleven

Teacher of 25 years and lotS of experience working with children with SEN. Not specifically commenting on OP.

All children, whatever their wiring, can behave badly. Really pisses me off when parents insist on attributing all unacceptable behaviour to conditions. SOMETIMES kids just need discipline and not have their parents claim “My dc was really deregulated when he stabbed his friend with a pencil.”

As a fellow teacher, really pisses me off that some teachers in our educational system clearly have zero understanding of SEND.

Did you even READ the post?

This isn't bad behaviour. This is behaviour directly caused by how they are wired.

CoastalWave · 13/02/2022 11:18

This sounds exactly like my son - he's 7.

He's being assessed for ADHD. There's definitely something not right. He doesn't behave badly - he literally meltdowns and can't help it.

My daughter has never ever done this. Same upbringing exactly.

It's bloody hard work and it's even more hard work when people think it's due to bad parenting.

Chely · 13/02/2022 11:12

Our 11 year old is awaiting assesment but he wouldn't behave like that, especially not towards me.
I think you need to seek professional help ASAP. This kind of behaviour will continue to escalate if you don't find ways to manage it early.

7eleven · 13/02/2022 11:07

Umm maybe the same part where I said I wasn’t talking about the OP?

Iggly · 13/02/2022 10:21

@Missmummy88

This is something I really struggle with none of the parenting books help. I’m clueless. I dread the weekends but put up a brave face but it’s really breaking me
I’m not surprised OP.

It doesn’t sound normal. My dd does kick off but we ignore and it calms down quickly. It’ll be good or tiredness and she knows it’s unacceptable to act out in anger, although it’s ok to feel angry etc. it’s just about how to express it. We had long discussions about it when she’s calm. The same with ds.

There are certain behaviours which lead to a complete screen ban so she knows where the line is.

Polyputthekettleon · 13/02/2022 10:17

I have no answers OP, and I am sorry you are going through this. I also feel so very sorry for your 6 year old having to go through this. Its his home too and he should be able to live there without fear. How very sad for him. I wouldn't have let your son go to his friends after such an outburst , esp as you can't guarantee that he will not carry his anger over to his friends house. I think it's a bit dangerous.

Wfhquery · 13/02/2022 10:07

@7eleven

Teacher of 25 years and lotS of experience working with children with SEN. Not specifically commenting on OP.

All children, whatever their wiring, can behave badly. Really pisses me off when parents insist on attributing all unacceptable behaviour to conditions. SOMETIMES kids just need discipline and not have their parents claim “My dc was really deregulated when he stabbed his friend with a pencil.”

Yes but they need to learn techniques how to regulate themselves that is what’s going to help long term. If they can’t regulate no amount of punishment is going to magically enable them to be able to do something they can’t do. I agree it can’t just be used as an excuse and parents need to be doing something to try and improve things. Mine is in a specialist school now and they do a lot of work on emotional regulation, sensory etc, that is going to help him a lot more in life than the way his mainstream school dealt with things which actually made things worse