Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does this sound normal behaviour for a ten year old?

131 replies

Missmummy88 · 12/02/2022 15:22

My son has always had big melts downs, think big toddler tantrums screaming shouting etc - then when he hit about 5-6 he would get angry and swipe things off sides push over chairs/laundry’s baskets. Now he is ten and he’s still being distrucyive but now very verbally abusive.

This happens most days.

Today he was angry with me because I told him his two hour tech was over (he has another hour at lunch). This is an arrangement he is aware of - I didn’t just rip tech away.

He then started rolling eyes, stomping about etc went upstairs where he’s 6 yo brother was playing Lego and with 2 minutes screaming and crying from my 6yo with a gash to the head where ten year old has thrown a book at him.

I tell him off & tell him he has now lost his lunch time hour. He loses it, starts telling me to fuck off you big fat idiot why do you hate everyone. Etc etc. From past experience I know this is escalating behaviour so I remove myself and 6yo to a safe space - he then let’s rip. Four boxes of Lego tipped everywhere - stuff thrown across the room and then he comes in with a piece of paper saying fuck off written on.

I ignore and when he leaves my room 6yo schrubches up and puts in bin.

Ten year old comes in demanding his paper screaming you fucking idiots multiple times.

He then walks around the house behind me about how awful a mum I am etc.

(I’m not awful just average - try my hardest like we all do!)

About one minute later he’s completely snapped out of it & is getting his shoes on to go to his friends house.

This is a common occurrence- meltdowns & verbal abuse.

He does get punished by removal of privileges like tech / no football cards etc. I just don’t do it while he’s melting as from experience he just gets worse so I wait until he’s calm to talk to him about it.

He has an asd assessment next week which I’ve paid for privately as school don’t see any of this behaviour.

I know this isn’t normal but does it sound like asd or does he just hate me?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
eeek88 · 16/02/2022 00:03

I teach 10-year-olds and no this is not normal behaviour. I’m glad you’re getting him assessed because it sounds as if he is really struggling. Must be very difficult for all of you.

It’s actually surprisingly common for kids to be perfect at school and nightmares at home. The pressure of behaving and conforming all day at school can be exhausting for some kids and they meltdown afterwards through exhaustion. Home is his safe place where he knows you’ll love him whatever happens so unfortunately this is where he lets off steam.

As others have said, try to help him with the transition between activities with timers, 5 minute warnings and pre-agreed rewards/punishments. When he’s calm, talk to him about how you can help him and work together to improve his behaviour, making it clear that you’re doing it because you love him and know that life is going to be very difficult for him if he continues to explode with rage whenever things don’t go his way.

I suspect he may respond well to quite a black-and-white approach, and it may help for you to explain your thought process when he’s calm and able to listen eg. ‘We’re all feeling upset because you got so angry earlier. When you did xyz that hurt my feelings and hurt your brother’s head. I don’t want you to do this again so I need to find a way to stop you doing it. I’m wondering whether I should cancel your play date as a punishment- but then that punishes your friend too, which isn’t fair. So instead I have decided to reduce your screen time to 30 mins twice a day / [insert appropriate punishment]. Next time you feel really angry, how can you make yourself feel better without hurting your family? Would it help to hit a punchbag instead? [or jump on trampoline, cry, shout in bedroom for 1 min, whatever you think might work]’

I know some parents who are really amazing at talking to their autistic kids (not saying yours is, but if he’s wired up a little differently it’s worth applying the same logic) and giving them the skills to articulate their distress in such a way that it doesn’t make the situation worse. I think it boils down to the following:

  1. helping them be prepared (for the unexpected, for change, etc) 2)listening to them, and teaching them how to articulate themselves
  2. explaining a world that doesn’t make sense (hence thinking aloud to help them understand why you’re reacting the way you are)

I often ‘think aloud’ when a pupil has unwittingly been very offensive to other children and I think it’s effective. It tells them exactly what they did wrong and why, it rationalises the punishment, and also shows the other kids that you’re dealing with the problem.

Good luck. You sound like a very loving mum at the end of your tether so I hope you get some answers!

Soontobe60 · 15/02/2022 22:14

@AmaryllisNightAndDay
Sometimes, having 1:1 support can be detrimental because it doesn’t allow children to work things out by themselves. And yes, I know not all children will be able to self learn, and some need close supervision a great deal of the time. But that close support needn’t be velcroed to the child!
I don’t mean to be condescending, but you sound like a fabulous parent!

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 15/02/2022 10:15

Did you find these strategies useful?

Oh yes, but there's no one size fits all, we adapted and figured out what worked for him Parenting courses do help because you can discuss your child's specifics and how to adapt - if the leader's any good that is.

The pre-diagnosis bit was the worst, you can't know how to discipline effectively until you know what the child's issues are. And there's more to a diagnosis than just a name. The name is useful (especially if it brings the right help!) but it's only a starting point for understanding what's not working. The real gold was the investigations behind the diagnosis because they told us some of what DS didn't understand and the connections he wasn't making and we could figure out more by finding out more about his condition and especially from talking to other parents.

For a simple example, just knowing your very clever DC is being literal-minded and not sarcastically taking the piss saves you from accusing them of "disrespect" and a round of misplaced "consequences".

Sounds like you’re committed to finding ways to accommodate your child’s difficulties.

DS has grown up and graduated and left home now Smile but yes, that's what we did. The clinical psychologist told DH and me that we had to manage DS's issues for him until he was able to manage them for himself. So as much as possible (and it wasn't always possible!) we kept him calm enough to think. No-one learns while they're in a disorganised mental state they just do what ever releases the mental pressure like having a meltdown or chucking a book at their brother's head. Logic and consequences are out the window til they calm down which is what the OP has already found and that's where Explosive Child comes in. But when you've done the best prevention and you still see the storm coming, sometimes all you can do is batten down the hatches and try to keep everyone safe til it passes. Introduce "consequences" at the wrong time and you add to the mental chaos and drag the tantrum/ rudeness/ aggression/ danger etc out longer. Teaching and learning happen at calm times.

sometimes he can just be naughty

Daily meltdowns and throwing a book at his brother's head are not "just being naughty". And my DS could be naughty - once he complained that he didn't want his school one-to-one because he never had a chance to misbehave like the others! His teacher agreed that was a fair point and they pulled the one-to-one back a bit.

kittensinthekitchen · 15/02/2022 00:25

@Foxglovesandlilacs86

What happens when he does this? What are the consequences? If he doesn’t do it at school then sounds like it’s lack of discipline/respect.
Yawn.

Educate yourself.

worriedatthemoment · 14/02/2022 21:01

@TheFormidableMrsC what so don't punish him fir hurting another child
My cousins son has asd he has always been punished along with his brothers and sisters , maybe in a slightly different way but there are consequences and sometimes he can just be naughty
Surely if you did this at school there would be consequences regardless of a diagnosis

Soontobe60 · 14/02/2022 20:40

@AmaryllisNightAndDay

CAMHS in my LA won’t even accept a referral for assessment of ASD of a child demonstrating such behaviours at home until the parent has completed Triple P.

Oh well, it all helps to slow down referrals and stop the system getting overwhelmed. And "Triple P didn't help much" would be another indication that there's something worth investigating.

To be fair you can probably adapt Triple P. I did mix'n'match with DS - some Explosive Child, some ASC (post diagnosis), some mainstream, and an "Incredible Years" at our children's hospital. Mainstream just didn't touch the sides on his most challenging behaviour. After referral but while DS was waiting for NHS assessment the GP pointed me at a mainstream parenting group (can't remember if it was Triple P or some other validated programme) and the leader encouraged me to use the Explosive Child strategies I'd already picked up as well.

Did you find these strategies useful? Sounds like you’re committed to finding ways to accommodate your child’s difficulties.
Foxglovesandlilacs86 · 14/02/2022 14:31

What happens when he does this? What are the consequences? If he doesn’t do it at school then sounds like it’s lack of discipline/respect.

ambushedbywine · 14/02/2022 14:30

This sounds similar to my child but he is younger so no hormones in the mix. He has autism.
I would suggest working together on regulation skills. I’m not saying there shouldn’t be consequences but punishment won’t teach him how to manage his feelings. He needs help to do that. Look at things like
Making a safe place
Zones of regulation
Possible sensory calming ideas
Triggers and working together to help him manage these

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 14/02/2022 14:26

CAMHS in my LA won’t even accept a referral for assessment of ASD of a child demonstrating such behaviours at home until the parent has completed Triple P.

Oh well, it all helps to slow down referrals and stop the system getting overwhelmed. And "Triple P didn't help much" would be another indication that there's something worth investigating.

To be fair you can probably adapt Triple P. I did mix'n'match with DS - some Explosive Child, some ASC (post diagnosis), some mainstream, and an "Incredible Years" at our children's hospital. Mainstream just didn't touch the sides on his most challenging behaviour. After referral but while DS was waiting for NHS assessment the GP pointed me at a mainstream parenting group (can't remember if it was Triple P or some other validated programme) and the leader encouraged me to use the Explosive Child strategies I'd already picked up as well.

SerotoninAnswerMySoul · 14/02/2022 14:18

I think it is hard to give advice in this situation, as if he is NT then removing personal screens (eg tablets/phones) would likely be the answer as it can cause really bad behaviour and tantrums (unfortunately know this from experience!) and some kids are far more relaxed without those devices at all. But if he has additional needs and this isn't purely related to screen time, the advice would be totally different (some great advice above to do with PDA/self regulating with screens and timers etc).

If this behaviour is only ever linked to screen time, you could see if he is happier without screen time for a while. But the best thing to do I think is to proceed with the assessment so you can figure out why these meltdowns happen and structure your responses accordingly. As others mentioned, it probably would also be good to think of ways to stop ds 10 meltdowns being scary for ds 6. Some others mentioned using a quiet or safe space to direct ds 10 to when he is having a meltdown. That sounds sensible to me.

I hope you manage to get the support you need as this sounds like a difficult situation to figure out.

CoastalWave · 14/02/2022 13:12

@BlackeyedSusan

ASD.

Try prevention.
Regular calming activities (most days)
Keep blood sugar up
Keep fluid intake up
Keep noise levels down.

Don't leave the DC's together. Your job to keep them separate and protect the little one. If your older one is getting wound up intervene with whatever calms him before it gets to level five. (mine goes on their phone)

He can learn to control meltdowns but that comes with age/development and the ability to recognise when they are getting agitated and take preventative steps themself. It will probably be a while yet and not perfect.

My teen is getting there.

Remember you need to parent differently with a ND kid.

(Violence still has consequences in that they are removed from the trigger)

Try praising any effort to control/prevent meltdowns (mine is learning to get a snack)

Do not talk or reason when in meltdown. He has gone into emotions only mode. A firm hug may help. Or foot/hand massage/ or food or a safe space under a desk say. You have to find his thing.

Good luck.

Great post thank you.
BettyBag · 14/02/2022 12:12

I had war with my NT son at that age over tech. I changed approach because it became like forbidden fruit. He was obsessed for 2 weeks then had a normal relationship with it after that.

My younger son has ASD I didn't know at the time but I did the same approach and didn't set limits. That was like... 8 years ago and I am still waiting for him to normalise. What it made me realise is that it's fine. He's completely well adjusted child who smashed his GCSEs and is doing very well at his A Levels. The way his ASD is he was never going to be into sport and socialising like my elder child, he was given loads of opportunities outside of tech and engaged with them all but was obviously very bored. He likes what he likes, computer programming, playing old computer games and watching videos about science.

That said neither of my boys had any interest in social media, influencers or teen/tween targeted youtubers. If that was the case I may have taken a different approach.

Soontobe60 · 14/02/2022 11:51

@xxlostxx
Sorry, I didn’t realise you were a paediatrician or child psychiatrist!
CAMHS in my LA won’t even accept a referral for assessment of ASD of a child demonstrating such behaviours at home until the parent has completed Triple P. But hey, I’ve only got 30 years experience in SEN

stayathomer · 14/02/2022 00:32

I can't comment on the diagnosis but I can say two of my children act horrifically as a direct result of gaming/youtube and we've had to work hard to get it under control by shoving them outside instead, pushing them to read/do art/play board games/build lego ... yes tech is great teaches them problem solving yada yada yada but actually in real life it over stimulates kids too much and they can't handle it. Best of luck with it all op

xxlostxx · 14/02/2022 00:13

@Soontobe60

No, it doesn’t sound like ASD, and frankly it’s insulting to children whom DO have an ASD diagnosis to compare his behaviour with their disability. Out of interest, when he put his shoes on to go to his friend, after assaulting his brother and verbally abusing you both, what did you do? I think you need to get a referral for the Triple P parenting programme. Which if he DID get a diagnosis, you’d be expected to do anyway.
It sounds very much like ASD to me any many other posters on this thread. My dd does have a diagnosis. I think your experience of autism and how it can present is very limited. And as for triple P course, it is generally aimed for parents of NT children, the strategies are unlikely to work with a child who is ND.
BlackeyedSusan · 13/02/2022 22:56

@Lovemusic33

Am I the only parent of dc with ASD that doesn’t see this kind of behaviour? My dc wouldn’t dare swear at me or throw things around the house. I have to say I’m pretty relaxed with tech time, I do pick my battles but my dc rarely push boundaries.

Some kids can swear and shout without have ASD or ADHD, the same as not all kids with ASD/ADHD are naughty and having ASD/ADHD is no excuse to behave this way.

One of my autistic kids doest swear or throw things round the house either....

Same parent, same condition, different presentations.

Soontobe60 · 13/02/2022 20:25

@Missmummy88

We have a great support network - stable and loving relationship with his dad, grandparents all local and involved , I have some lovely friends and am good friends with his friends parents. Me and his dad both work (me part time) & no financial issues. On paper all good but in reality our home feels like a war zone.

I let him go because it had been arranged for weeks and friends mum had already booked swimming so didn’t feel it fair to ruin their day too!

He has some sensory issues a bit picky with food but not extreme. Sleeps well. Terrible organisational skills - loses everything - Forgets everything. Etc

Letting him go was a big big mistake. What message have you sent to his brother whom he assaulted? That it’s ok to use violence, mummy will let me off.
Soontobe60 · 13/02/2022 20:23

No, it doesn’t sound like ASD, and frankly it’s insulting to children whom DO have an ASD diagnosis to compare his behaviour with their disability.
Out of interest, when he put his shoes on to go to his friend, after assaulting his brother and verbally abusing you both, what did you do?
I think you need to get a referral for the Triple P parenting programme. Which if he DID get a diagnosis, you’d be expected to do anyway.

paname · 13/02/2022 20:18

I have an ASD son who is 10 and is obsessed by tech. You're going to have to get much firmer boundaries OP. He needs tools and a calm down routine. Maybe a swing in his bedroom that he twist up in and then spin? Things to squeeze? Things that are safe to throw? A punching bag? Find out what the sensory need is and then provide it. Tell him his behaviour is way out of court but you're going to help him to find a different way. You need to redirect him to his "calm down" space when he starts to get wound up. I'd also take all tech away until the hurting people stops. Tell him it's your job to keep everyone safe and he can't control himself when tech time is over so it's gone. Withstand the tantrum but don't give in.

siestaingsnake · 13/02/2022 19:48

Sounds like my autistic nephew
good luck with your assessment
supportive friends
strategies take time take time to figure out and sometime you think you've cracked it and then BAM!!
N is an adult now and we have learned most of the signs of a blow up stewing but you cannot predict what the world will say to them at school or college and then they come home to you and sometimes it's bedtime or 3 weeks later randomly the damn breaks and your left going wtf!!!!

BlackeyedSusan · 13/02/2022 19:43

@emsmar

If the school don't see it - it's definitely a home problem.
Nope. Not necessarily. School couldn't see dd's autism either. Funnily enough the assessor could and pointed out that the things the sendco had written on the form should have caused them to see the issue.
thegreenlight · 13/02/2022 19:40

I really wish people wouldn’t say that children with asd/adhd in happy homes save their worst behaviour for home. This is not true and very hurtful! We have always parented the child we have had and anticipate difficult situations and diffuse. He is a nightmare at school, especially now he feels his teacher doesn’t like him. He is currently undergoing a dual diagnosis privately as its a 4 year wait here. I have struggled since he was a baby to think of myself as a good mum because he can’t behave the same as everyone else at school. I now realise that I regulate him and am in fact a really good mum. Please don’t make assumptions. OP - I recommend looking into a diagnosis. The pieces may just fall into place.

BlackeyedSusan · 13/02/2022 19:38

ASD.

Try prevention.
Regular calming activities (most days)
Keep blood sugar up
Keep fluid intake up
Keep noise levels down.

Don't leave the DC's together. Your job to keep them separate and protect the little one. If your older one is getting wound up intervene with whatever calms him before it gets to level five. (mine goes on their phone)

He can learn to control meltdowns but that comes with age/development and the ability to recognise when they are getting agitated and take preventative steps themself. It will probably be a while yet and not perfect.

My teen is getting there.

Remember you need to parent differently with a ND kid.

(Violence still has consequences in that they are removed from the trigger)

Try praising any effort to control/prevent meltdowns (mine is learning to get a snack)

Do not talk or reason when in meltdown. He has gone into emotions only mode. A firm hug may help. Or foot/hand massage/ or food or a safe space under a desk say. You have to find his thing.

Good luck.

CustardCreamsAndMintTea · 13/02/2022 19:25

My kids are not NT and there is no way I would let anyone trash the house, distespect family like that and then toddle off with their friends.

Things aren't always easy in our house, but if my kids were trashing the house and couldn't control themselves enough to clean it up and show remorse I would be seriously worried they would lose control in the swimming pool and potentially put themselves and others at risk.

I appreciate the other parent had paid, but you should have called and lied, said your kid was sick last minute and then arranged to take the kids out in return the following week.

OverCCCs · 13/02/2022 19:10

@whydobirds

This sounds way more than "naughty" though Orlando, and at an age where most children no longer exhibit behaviours like this. It is completely dysregulated. A NT child would learn after a few removals of privileges that it wasn't worth the behaviour. A ND child can't help it and no amount of punishment will address it. They need help learning the tools with which to regulate their behaviour. OP doesn't mention that her younger child exhibits this which suggests it's not necessarily down to parenting - although even if he is diagnosed ND she will be told by many professionals that it's her parenting before they accept his level of need, ime.
“ A NT child would learn after a few removals of privileges that it wasn't worth the behaviour.” A good point, but I’d emphasize this really only applies in cases where the parent does actually remove privileges and/or the child cares more about the particular privilege lost than they desire to keep up the poor behaviour.

A parent who gives in or doesn’t give consequences that the child minds enough is likely to see the behaviour repeat over and over again. In such cases, the NT child might learn it WAS worth the behaviour.

Swipe left for the next trending thread