Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my neighbours not to hang dead animals from their fence?

246 replies

Bdg212 · 12/02/2022 15:08

New neighbours like to shoot. That’s their choice, but they hang the animals they kill from their front garden fence for all to see. It’s usually pheasants and sometimes rabbits. Aibu to think this is pretty inconsiderate behaviour? I’m veggie and find it quite upsetting. There are kids about too.

OP posts:
Bdg212 · 13/02/2022 17:52

This thread isn’t about the ethics of eating meat. Don’t know why folk are trying to turn it onto a debate on veganism just cause I’m veggie. People are way too keen to jump on the vegan and made a point to shove their meat eating in our faces. I’m a quiet peaceful person, I don’t go round telling people what they should or should not eat.

OP posts:
balalake · 13/02/2022 17:49

I think even if you eat meat, reasonable to ask. I'd be surprised if they agreed but if they do, good.

Bdg212 · 13/02/2022 17:47

@Giraffesandbottoms

Perhaps you could recognise that other people may feel differently to you and try to meet them halfway

You come across as not wanting to recognise or do this either!

Where would you think that? I have maintained that I respect their choice to hunt. Just would like to walk down the street without having to look at dead animals hanging off a fence. Is that too much to ask?
OP posts:
Notjustanymum · 13/02/2022 17:31

There are some rules (for hygiene and vermin reasons) in the UK - there’s a guide here: www.food.gov.uk/sites/default/files/media/document/wildgamephotos.pdf
If you think that the way they’re hanging their game is compromising either, contact a local councillor. Foxes and other vermin can climb fences and publicly displaying rotting corpses could be considered to be pretty antisocial towards health and hygiene!

Giraffesandbottoms · 13/02/2022 17:29

Perhaps you could recognise that other people may feel differently to you and try to meet them halfway

You come across as not wanting to recognise or do this either!

Xenia · 13/02/2022 13:43

Some town people have no understanding of how the countryside is. Obviously people can express their views (and I am very pro shooting and meat etc) but we don't all have to agree with those who do not want anyone to eat meat.

Bdg212 · 13/02/2022 12:52

@Giggorata

Yes, we do that, unless we're having guests, when we pluck them in the more usual way.

We frequently arrive home to find braces of pheasants or couples of rabbits hanging off our gates, thanks to nice shooting friends.
Our drive gates are on the pavement, so people walk past them at head height. If anyone complained I’m afraid I’d just giggle at them…

That response sounds terribly unkind. Perhaps you could recognise that other people may feel differently to you and try to meet them halfway.
OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 13/02/2022 12:11

@samsam123

why so many comments ' thats rural life so ok' why is it ok shooting wildlife isnt ok, its vile whether you live in a town or village.
It’s not wildlife.

Pheasants = bred for slaughter (like chickens)

Rabbits = pest control, meat as a byproduct

Moles = pest control (trapped not shot)

SamphiretheStickerist · 13/02/2022 12:00

@samsam123

why so many comments ' thats rural life so ok' why is it ok shooting wildlife isnt ok, its vile whether you live in a town or village.
Well, regardless of your own dietary preferences growing food, meat or plant based, requires the killing of some animals. If you can't accept the reality of that become an airatarian.
samsam123 · 13/02/2022 11:46

why so many comments ' thats rural life so ok' why is it ok shooting wildlife isnt ok, its vile whether you live in a town or village.

SamphiretheStickerist · 13/02/2022 11:13

We used to get all sorts hung on our fence. Mushrooms, hares, rabbits, game birds. The local forager was always very generous and the local shoot and lampers would leave something as an apology for the noise. If you didn't like it you said something to a local farmer and it would stop. New next door neighbours asked us and we passed the message on. They got cakes instead 🙂

It's part and parcel of living rurally in an area where every bit of ground is put to use. It's how many dairy farmers round here remain just about solvent. If you don't like the thought of it them tough. That's your opinion. No more right or wrong than that of people who quite literally live off the land.

SpikeySmooth · 13/02/2022 10:54

We used to know a gamekeeper in my childhood so we got the odd kill to eat.

My mum used to hang them in the shed. Made great stews in the winter.

We are disconnected from where our food comes from but some people choose not to eat meat for a variety of reasons so out of respect for them, I'd say OPs neighbour should hang them out of public sight.

Giggorata · 13/02/2022 10:45

Yes, we do that, unless we're having guests, when we pluck them in the more usual way.

We frequently arrive home to find braces of pheasants or couples of rabbits hanging off our gates, thanks to nice shooting friends.
Our drive gates are on the pavement, so people walk past them at head height. If anyone complained I’m afraid I’d just giggle at them…

Crazykatie · 13/02/2022 09:55

I don’t bother with plucking and dressing pheasants, much quicker to skin and take breast and legs, not messy at all.

Skinnydog · 13/02/2022 09:52

I def know the difference between partridge and pheasant, partridge very sweet and smaller we see them occasionally, pheasants tend to see when I’m driving and normally at the side of the road debating whether to run or freeze at the last second

DeeCrepid · 13/02/2022 09:49

The shooting season ended at the end of January.

OrlandointheWilderness · 13/02/2022 08:48

@Monopolyiscrap

Plucking and disembowelling pheasants is a horrible job. You get gifted pheasants because the people shooting do not want to actually do this to eat them. They just want to kill live things for fun.
I know a lot of people who shoot. Most of my friends, my bf and I. Can categorically say this is complete rubbish. I love having decent fresh meat, it isn't a horrible job plucking and cleaning and is a damn sight better than buying 2 for £5 chickens or cheap badly reared meat from the supermarket. We only free range, local meat usually direct from the farmer and game. I would rather live off pasta that eat chickens that have suffered 21 days of overcrowded agony before being slaughtered and yet people who shoot are the ones who are judged.
EdithStourton · 13/02/2022 08:27

And regarding buzzards: I can't speak for every shoot, but there are loads of buzzards, kites and kestrels over our local shoots.

EdithStourton · 13/02/2022 08:26

@Skinnydog

Pheasants are not native wildlife, they’ve actually replaced our own native version and as someone else said sadly I agree with the buzzards but that’s a whole other argument. Pheasants you see running around are either the minority who survived, ones who’ve wandered further than expected. They are literally reared as chicks in big pens, go to bigger more naturalistic enclosures and released. It’s a sport, some are eaten, some aren’t depending on who’s shot them.
There is no native UK version of the pheasant - you might be thinking of the grey partridge which has suffered a massive decline due to agricultural changes, so the ones you see running about are red -legged partridges. They go wild very easily - there is a covey on the shoot I beat on which seems to be self-sustaining. Efforts are underway to build up the grey partridge population again.

I've beaten on two shoots, and have a friend who beats on another, and all the game that is shot on those shoots is eaten. Guns take some, beaters take some, the rest is processed (or not) and passed around to friends and neighbours. That's usually when you see game hanging out of doors - it's either awaiting collection or has just been dropped off.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 13/02/2022 02:08

One of my friends had chickens - when the chicks grew and some turned out to be roosters, they were dispatched and then had to be plucked and drawn.

I went over to help out with the plucking but refused pointblank to put my hand inside and get the innards out - luckily I have large hands and my friend has small ones, so she got that job Grin

I can't remember if she gave the innards to the dogs - is that a good thing to do, or not? If it is, she did - she would have researched it first, she was very conscientious about that.

Skinnydog · 13/02/2022 00:42

Fair point about not killing for fun, I personally have no issue with shooting to get dinner but I personally wouldn’t kill for fun either. Crabbing is my limit and we’re gentle and release after. No offence intended just discussing

justasking111 · 12/02/2022 23:20

Pheasant is okay but not my favourite. We had mallard tonight that was good. Hanging game outdoors like this is odd, drives dogs crackers for a start, never mind cats.

crosstalk · 12/02/2022 23:19

As a current vegetarian who used to shoot and eat pigeon, pheasant and rabbit I know how to hang and store them but a front garden fence is ridiculous. Yes, you do hang them to season them as other meat is hung. But in the cool not on a front garden fence where cats, dogs, foxes, birds and badgers will have a field day. And where game will rot in the heat rather than season in the cold. Your neighbours seem like perfomance numpties rather than genuine country people. Have they even cleaned them out? Grief.

Monopolyiscrap · 12/02/2022 23:02

By the way killing a pheasant is only poaching if it is done on private land. I would not kill a pheasant. But it would be really easy for me to kill one wandering about country lanes. I see them all the time.

Monopolyiscrap · 12/02/2022 22:59

@Skinnydog

Find the whole hate animal killers stance very odd, presumably you’re vegan, don’t use make up or medicine as it’s all been tested on animals, don’t use perfume, deodorant toiletries, again tested on or made from them, whether you like it or not your home was some animals habitat, your food you eat involved pest control. It’s impossible to be human and not have any animals die because of you
I don't kill animals for enjoyment.
Swipe left for the next trending thread