Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be agog at this incentive to Work from office?

155 replies

GretaGip · 12/02/2022 12:24

DS1's chum is 18 months through a Grad Role and has just secured another job with a different company

They are incentivised to work in the office 4 days a week by 15% of their salary, with a minimum of £10,000. It's not included in income for pensionable purposes.

AIBU to think this is not normal??

I'm feeling quite old and out of touch Grin

OP posts:
UniversalAunt · 12/02/2022 17:05

‘ Some people have a very rose-tinted view of the value they're adding to the business!’

Yes indeed.
Which is why being in the office enough is important, it smooths off employees rough edges/estimation of their ‘add value’ to the business & helps networking.

Come any levelling, bonus distribution, restructuring reviews, if your ‘reputation/presence/face’ does not easily come to mind, then you are at a disadvantage. The other side of that is that you don’t so easily come to mind when the proverbial hits the fan 😉.

UniversalAunt · 12/02/2022 16:59

Due to the nature of my work across ICT sector, I had extended periods of WFH. It is not for everyone.

In the short term, the argument of unit based productivity gains works well. But in time, overall organisational productivity rate slows or stalls..

WFH is great for getting through your own task list, also for your team. Collaborative teleworking online has come along way in the past few years & Covid drove this update into many organisations. Right now, many people & organisations are harvesting the benefits of this new efficiency. But it won’t last unless there is a deeper shift in organisational design & this will lead to revision of the business model & restructuring.

As an example, if people are to deliver 100% on a 37 hours over a 4 day week, then working day will be extended to allow for meetings & project delivery deadlines. Covid WFH is not the same as usual operational WFH - it will be different.

In my experience, part-time workers often work longer than their contracted hours to keep up, & those WFH found it a challenge to keep & work & home life truly separate.

It can be very helpful to be there to pop out to pick up the kids & give them tea, or get some exercise, but the work is there waiting there for when they are free. Often people WFH from home caught up in the evening or at weekends.

WFH is not a bed of roses, thorns lurk.

Mundra · 12/02/2022 16:46

As I said in my first post- I didn't hire these people, they don't work for me. The person complaining to me didn't hire them either, and would be more than happy if they walked tbh. Some people have a very rose-tinted view of the value they're adding to the business!

sanbeiji · 12/02/2022 16:40

@MissConductUS Accounting degrees are also a thing in the UK.
Big4 is a good choice, guaranteed career promotion until you earn 80K in London at least. Provided you pass the exams and don't mess up badly.

UniversalAunt · 12/02/2022 16:39

Highly paid quick entry specialist roles in ICT are cyclical.

The one-time paper based ICT trade rags would have an informal barometer of how much of the issue would be given to recruitment agencies & job adverts. In good full-fat times, the ads would begin before the middle pages/staples. In stricter leaner times the issue would have overall fewer pages as the job related ad revenue had dropped,, & the ads would start well past the staples.

Of course, this is not so obvious as we all live & breathe online…

MissConductUS · 12/02/2022 16:39

@Player20868

What industry IS this?! I really want to be able to tell my nephews what business niche to aim for so they don't make my mistake and spend their lives working for the public sector....(I don't actually think it's a mistake, but it galls me beyond words that people like professional pixel-mover-arounder-finance-bods and marketing "influencers" get paid so far over the odds it's obscene while the people who actually prop up society get paid peanuts and derided by the national media and our so-called "leaders" into the bargain.)
In my son's case, he's graduating with a degree in accounting (that's a thing in the US) and going to work in the tax department at a big four accounting firm. It is not an easy degree and demand for accounting graduates exceeds the supply.
sanbeiji · 12/02/2022 16:38

[quote Mundra]@sanbeiji
@Monopolyiscrap

Why would you pay people the same amount to do 80% of their usual work? The pay is above industry average already btw. These are people who flit from job to job, they don't seem to stay anywhere longer than 12mo. If they were amazingly committed and dynamic, perhaps you'd be motivated to meet them halfway? But as it is, they'll just go elsewhere in 6mo time anyway. It would be perfectly easy to replace them now with people that work 5 days.[/quote]
Good on them for knowing their worth.
If they're that easy to replace, then why were you happy to hire them despite changing jobs so often? Especially if the pay's above industry average. Surely you had better candidates to choose from if this was a red flag for you.

I don't know what industry you're in. But in mine, a year's a long time. Enough to gain qualifications, or specific experience that's highly valued in the open market. Companies can't often match the salary (it's easier to pay a new hire 10K more, than to give an existing one the same pay rise). So people leave.
I know graduates who have gone from 25-75K in 3 years. In London especially this isn't uncommon.

Spidey66 · 12/02/2022 16:37

@RedskyThisNight

This is just a version of London weighting I guess?
That's my opinion as well. Surely it's to offset commuting etc? I think it's fine.

A colleague of mine hasn't been asked to return to the office. It doesn't bother me as her role can be done from home, she loves wfh and I hate it (one day a week is fine) but I am jealous that she's saving so much time and money on commuting!

UniversalAunt · 12/02/2022 16:34

‘ The company benefits from being to rent and heat less office space so it’s a win-win really.’

Fixed costs won’t reduce any time soon. Contacts for floor space already in place, empty rooms still need to be heated.

Is your office unpleasantly cold or hot on Monday ? Are the loos short of water in the pan on Monday? If not, that is because the heating/air con is on over the weekend, basic maintenance & repairs are done.

It’s not that simple.

Mundra · 12/02/2022 16:27

@SarahBellam No- they want to work 4 days for the salary they're on now for 5 days. They already WFH whenever they want.

sanbeiji · 12/02/2022 16:26

@Player20868

What industry IS this?! I really want to be able to tell my nephews what business niche to aim for so they don't make my mistake and spend their lives working for the public sector....(I don't actually think it's a mistake, but it galls me beyond words that people like professional pixel-mover-arounder-finance-bods and marketing "influencers" get paid so far over the odds it's obscene while the people who actually prop up society get paid peanuts and derided by the national media and our so-called "leaders" into the bargain.)
Software engineering, then move into a specific niche like cloud/infrastructure or security consulting, Pays loads
UniversalAunt · 12/02/2022 16:25

Golden Hello payments are not unknown for tip top workplace performing grads, & that was before Covid & mandatory wfh.

The grad employment market is cyclical.
Right now, the market is distorted by Covid recovery & companies restructuring as they build back.

It’ll pass.

Mundra · 12/02/2022 16:24

@sanbeiji
@Monopolyiscrap

Why would you pay people the same amount to do 80% of their usual work? The pay is above industry average already btw. These are people who flit from job to job, they don't seem to stay anywhere longer than 12mo. If they were amazingly committed and dynamic, perhaps you'd be motivated to meet them halfway? But as it is, they'll just go elsewhere in 6mo time anyway. It would be perfectly easy to replace them now with people that work 5 days.

Player20868 · 12/02/2022 16:18

What industry IS this?! I really want to be able to tell my nephews what business niche to aim for so they don't make my mistake and spend their lives working for the public sector....(I don't actually think it's a mistake, but it galls me beyond words that people like professional pixel-mover-arounder-finance-bods and marketing "influencers" get paid so far over the odds it's obscene while the people who actually prop up society get paid peanuts and derided by the national media and our so-called "leaders" into the bargain.)

Gwenhwyfar · 12/02/2022 16:18

WFH is very bad for me. In the opposite scenario, if my organisation paid lots extra to induce me to work from home I still wouldn't.

Monopolyiscrap · 12/02/2022 16:17

Qualified nurses are okay paid. HCAs are appallingly paid.

sanbeiji · 12/02/2022 16:14

@Wreath21

Employees being able to demand more pay and better conditions is a good thing, of course - and there is apparently some discussion going on about whether a four-day working week should become the norm (without major pay cuts). But I think it will take a while to stabilise - and that, if we are not careful, we will still end up with a great many necessary jobs continuing to be underpaid and undervalued, with more 'unskilled' people being coerced to do them by the threat of starvation (ie the Universal Credit bully-into-unsuitable-jobs approach).

I did see one fucking idiot suggesting that jobs like care work, for instance, should be some kind of workfare where people percieved as workshy and disobedient should be compelled to take them - which would, of course, be absolutely fucking lovely for the people in need of the care...

I'm one of the 'privileged' ones and the gulf is mindblowing. Young people with the right skillset walking into 60-70K jobs. In the meantime care workers, nurses etc underpaid. The fact that 'some' people, who are privileged, are getting better terms makes no sense when the other half of the country is being worked to death for little pay.
LyricalBlowToTheJaw · 12/02/2022 16:10

@Wreath21

Employees being able to demand more pay and better conditions is a good thing, of course - and there is apparently some discussion going on about whether a four-day working week should become the norm (without major pay cuts). But I think it will take a while to stabilise - and that, if we are not careful, we will still end up with a great many necessary jobs continuing to be underpaid and undervalued, with more 'unskilled' people being coerced to do them by the threat of starvation (ie the Universal Credit bully-into-unsuitable-jobs approach).

I did see one fucking idiot suggesting that jobs like care work, for instance, should be some kind of workfare where people percieved as workshy and disobedient should be compelled to take them - which would, of course, be absolutely fucking lovely for the people in need of the care...

I think I know the thread you mean. It was an impressively shit for brains take.
Wreath21 · 12/02/2022 16:09

Employees being able to demand more pay and better conditions is a good thing, of course - and there is apparently some discussion going on about whether a four-day working week should become the norm (without major pay cuts). But I think it will take a while to stabilise - and that, if we are not careful, we will still end up with a great many necessary jobs continuing to be underpaid and undervalued, with more 'unskilled' people being coerced to do them by the threat of starvation (ie the Universal Credit bully-into-unsuitable-jobs approach).

I did see one fucking idiot suggesting that jobs like care work, for instance, should be some kind of workfare where people percieved as workshy and disobedient should be compelled to take them - which would, of course, be absolutely fucking lovely for the people in need of the care...

miltonj · 12/02/2022 16:05

When I was that age, there was a human poo outside the office doors and our incentive for work that day, was whatever team did the worst had to clean it up. So I'd say, in comparison, that's a brilliant incentive.

Toanewstart23 · 12/02/2022 16:00

This honestly warms my soul

sanbeiji · 12/02/2022 15:59

@Monopolyiscrap it's becoming v common. DP's new job pays a London salary, office twice a month max we live in the North West.
When I'm looking to move jobs that's probably what I'll do. I have no desire to live anywhere near London ever again.

BearOfEasttown · 12/02/2022 15:49

[quote D0lphine]@BearOfEasttown

I think employees, particularly youngsters, are realising their worth. They aren't staying in jobs long if it's not working for them and will happily jump until they find something they want to do.

I think the attitude shift is really interesting and defo a good thing for workers. Not so much for HR and business owners![/quote]
Yeah too right @D0lphine My 2 DD (mid 20s,) would NEVER tolerate this now, and I am pretty sure the employer(s) would struggle to get away with it.

It affected my mental health tbh, and the job was a very stressful one with a very bossy, go-getting employer. In addition, I was a young woman in a world where women were expected to 'break through the glass ceiling' and were expected to 'have it all' and above all, complain about nothing, and accept any shit dished out at you, and just be grateful you had such a 'great' job with an employer who wanted you to 'make the best of yourself.'

I was OK at first (first 5 or 6 years or so,) but their attitude changed massively towards me, when I had my kids (less than 2 years apart.) They treated me differently, and I am pretty sure they hated having a 'mommy' working for them, who, (SHOCKER!) put her family before her job.

I left after 11 years there, and got something a lot more low-key, part time, less pay, less chance of a high flying corporate ladder career etc..... Leaving that company was the best day of my life! My kids were soooo much happier too when I went part time, and was there a LOT more of the time for them.

SarahBellam · 12/02/2022 15:40

@Mundra

Someone told me this week that some of their employees were demanding a 4 day week for no downgrade of pay. I found that shocking.
Why? Surely if they are continuing to deliver the same volume and quality of work they should be paid the same. The company benefits from being to rent and heat less office space so it’s a win-win really.
D0lphine · 12/02/2022 15:39

@BearOfEasttown

I think employees, particularly youngsters, are realising their worth. They aren't staying in jobs long if it's not working for them and will happily jump until they find something they want to do.

I think the attitude shift is really interesting and defo a good thing for workers. Not so much for HR and business owners!