Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Chicken Pox

88 replies

Chely · 12/02/2022 12:23

Would you intentionally take your child to see another child with chicken pox so they catch it?

YABU - no way!

YANBU - yes, best they have it young.

OP posts:
BooksAndHooks · 12/02/2022 14:35

No if I particularly wanted them to have immunity and they hadn’t already had it I would have them vaccinated. Mine have dreadful scars, I have a very deep one on my face so not something I would do intentionally. Unfortunately mine caught it before they could have the vaccine.

JassyRadlett · 12/02/2022 14:35

@grey12

Definitely yes!!!!

Actually I got a bit upset because DD2's best friend had it this week but DH was visiting (he works abroad) so I couldn't risk the kids being unwell

If you can get the kids to have chickenpox young, but after 1yo, then it's ideal Wink not only are symptoms milder but you know it can cause infertility, right?

To me, ideal is protecting them from getting it at all, and also preventing them from a higher risk of shingles in later life.

I accept I’m out of step with the majority though…

grey12 · 12/02/2022 14:33

Definitely yes!!!!

Actually I got a bit upset because DD2's best friend had it this week but DH was visiting (he works abroad) so I couldn't risk the kids being unwell

If you can get the kids to have chickenpox young, but after 1yo, then it's ideal Wink not only are symptoms milder but you know it can cause infertility, right?

Porfre · 12/02/2022 14:30

I've just checked bot
Its website.

Its £140 for the full course or £75 for one vaccine.

Porfre · 12/02/2022 14:29

Luckily it was around £75 a dose when I did it

JassyRadlett · 12/02/2022 14:27

@Chely

At £140 per child the vaccine is not affordable to many, especially with cost of living rises atm.

Our eldest had it at 6yr, caught at school and not very unwell or many spots. She passed to 2nd, 13mth old with lots of spots which left scars but not very unwell. I was pregnant with 3rd at the time and she got it the next year at 7mth old, lots of spots but not very unwell and no scars. Our twins 6yr and 6mth old have not had it yet, will probably catch it at school at some point.

Yes, it’s a total scandal that protecting our kids from chicken pox as they do in the US, Australia, Germany etc is only available to those who can afford it.

The NHS website on the issue is perilously close to misinformation, too, particularly on the idea that circulating chicken pox in children reduces the risk of shingles to adults. Even if you leave aside the dodgy ethics of using children as human booster doses for adults, and therefore setting them up for an increased risk of shingles themselves, the data from countries that have been vaccinating for years and studies doesn’t show any consistent link.

And even if we were ok with the idea of making kids sick to protect adults, and were totally ignoring the actual evidence… a shingles vaccine for adults exists.

It’s a disgusting, dishonest argument.

Porfre · 12/02/2022 13:50

I got both mine vaccinated. They were around 2-3 years old.

At least I dont have to worry about this. I wouldn't worry about them having exposure to chicken pox now, would just assume either it would just strengthen their immunity, or they would get an ultra mild version if they did get it.

Chely · 12/02/2022 13:49

At £140 per child the vaccine is not affordable to many, especially with cost of living rises atm.

Our eldest had it at 6yr, caught at school and not very unwell or many spots. She passed to 2nd, 13mth old with lots of spots which left scars but not very unwell. I was pregnant with 3rd at the time and she got it the next year at 7mth old, lots of spots but not very unwell and no scars. Our twins 6yr and 6mth old have not had it yet, will probably catch it at school at some point.

OP posts:
notforonesecond · 12/02/2022 13:47

Not a chance. Both of mine were vaccinated at 1. Both doses as soon as they were allowed. Totally worth the money.

MadgeRussell · 12/02/2022 13:43

Got mine vaccinated too. When I was a kid I was also allergic to the actual virus that causes chicken pox and had a terrible time.

TreeLawney · 12/02/2022 13:43

I would never do this but would get them vaccinated. My ds still has long term health implications from the chickenpox he had as a baby. He’s 7 now. I still get flashbacks from the 2 weeks we spent in hospital.

dementedpixie · 12/02/2022 13:40

Other countries give MMRV where V is the varicella vaccine against chickenpox

watchtheglitterdustswirl · 12/02/2022 13:27

@LoseLooseLucy

I may have been misinformed dementedpixie, I was told it wasn't available until the child was 10? I absolutely will have it done now if it's possible, my son is autistic too so the itching would be near impossible to manage if he did get it.
No, both of mine were vaccinated at 13m and then 15m, as early as I could get them done (they must be 4 weeks clear of their MMRs).

This was recently (one five years ago and one two years ago).

JassyRadlett · 12/02/2022 13:13

No worries @Lou98, it’s so easy for these things to take hold! I still kick myself for not vaccinating my eldest (he got it just before he turned 2, it was on my ‘to do’ list, sigh…)

I got it when I was 21 and it was appalling.

Lou98 · 12/02/2022 13:07

@HamCob @JassyRadlett thank you both! I'll definitely look at the vaccine when my Son is old enough to get it then. As I say it was just on here I seen it and he's still under 1 so I hadn't looked too much in to it but it did make me wonder! Good to know that Boots do it too!

Footnote · 12/02/2022 13:07

If you cared about your child having immunity to chickenpox, wouldn’t you choose the means of obtaining it that didn’t make them ill and at risk of hospitalisation, i.e. the vaccine?

JassyRadlett · 12/02/2022 13:04

@Lou98

My Son is only 9 months so not thought about it yet but I'm sure I read on here the vaccine is only effective for 10 years or something like that? Surely it's then more of a risk if they get it as an adult. Can anybody tell me if that's true? If not then I'd like to get my Son vaccinated when he's older but after reading it on here it put me off!
No. This is an old myth, based on the early evidence from mass vaccination in other countries where it was shown that immunity lasted at least ten years - which aligned with how long the mass vaccination programme had been running. That was twisted to ‘only’ ten years by those with I assume motivations to undermine the vaccine.

As the vaccine has been around longer, that window keeps getting bigger too. The two dose vaccine is also more effective (and may last longer) than single dose.

There are also not huge outbreaks of chicken pox in adults in countries that have been vaccinating for many years now.

There is good evidence, however, that the vaccine is less effective when given in the teens or adulthood than in childhood.

HamCob · 12/02/2022 13:02

@Lou98

My Son is only 9 months so not thought about it yet but I'm sure I read on here the vaccine is only effective for 10 years or something like that? Surely it's then more of a risk if they get it as an adult. Can anybody tell me if that's true? If not then I'd like to get my Son vaccinated when he's older but after reading it on here it put me off!
I asked this at boots and was told that they don't have any long term evidence yet as to how long it lasts. It would be possible to have the vaccine again though later in life if evidence showed that immunity wore off.
RoRoYoYo · 12/02/2022 13:01

YABU. Mine have both had chickenpox and also been vaccinated. However if they hadn't then I wouldn't be taking them. Two of my friends have had DC in hospital with chickenpox.

minipie · 12/02/2022 12:56

No there is no evidence the jab wears off any quicker than natural immunity. Either can wear off but just as likely either way.

Many other countries offer the jab as standard for all children, it’s a great shame we don’t IMO.

NurseDread · 12/02/2022 12:56

Yabvu. Get them vaccinated

minipie · 12/02/2022 12:55

Yes the vaccine can be done from age 1. I think they need two jabs to be fully covered, iirc. Many private medical clinics offer it.

Lou98 · 12/02/2022 12:54

My Son is only 9 months so not thought about it yet but I'm sure I read on here the vaccine is only effective for 10 years or something like that? Surely it's then more of a risk if they get it as an adult.
Can anybody tell me if that's true?
If not then I'd like to get my Son vaccinated when he's older but after reading it on here it put me off!

3xmonsters · 12/02/2022 12:54

We vaccinated recently at Boots for our 6year old. So nice to know she doesn't have to get it.

October2020 · 12/02/2022 12:52

Vaccine is from 1+. We went to Epicare.