Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send cat joke to friend who had elderly cat put to sleep 5 weeks ago

138 replies

dizzydizzydizzy · 12/02/2022 07:29

I am in a WhatsApp group with 3 friends. We send each other cat jokes - cartoon type things that you might find on a birthday card. One of them who I am very close to has been very annoyed with my recently but I don't know why. (I have asked). She sent me a very angry text message last week and has generally given me the cold shoulder. The same person had her elderly cat put to sleep 5 weeks ago, after a long and happy life. She has messaged the group back to say not to send her cat jokes because they are too upsetting and she can't even walk down the cat food aisle in the supermarket without crying.

YABU = sending somebody a cat joke 5 weeks after the death of a cat is insensitive
YANBU = the upset is being used as a stick to beat me with and has more to do with her campaign against me than any genuine inability to cope.

OP posts:
Svara · 12/02/2022 10:34

Also some people have a deeper relationship with their animals that you seem to.
I also don't think this is fair. I loved my cat and I still miss her. I buried her myself in my garden and she has primroses planted on her grave. Adopting our two new rescue cats did help a lot though.

ShittyFingers · 12/02/2022 10:34

I sent someone a dog joke and their elderly dog died later that day. To make it even worse the joke was aimed at her dog specifically. She found it funny but then later that day it died. I felt awful

StScholastica · 12/02/2022 10:30

YABVU

LampLighter414 · 12/02/2022 10:29

Send her some Minion jokes as an apology

Elieza · 12/02/2022 10:26

It would have been better:

for her to withdraw from the group (although if she doesn’t have much company that would isolate her further and she’ll already feel lonely having lost her companion of presumably many years and any true friends wouldn’t want this).

OR

To ask the group please not to send cat memes to her as she’s still grieving but happy to get other memes

OR

for the group to decide, enmasse without being told, to not send cat memes for a few months and send dog ones or something instead until she starts coming through her grief.

When a companion of a long time is suddenly there no more it’s very sad. Some peoples pets are like their fur babies to them. They love them more than their actual family!

I’m a suck-it-up-and-get-on-with it type of person and the death my cat really threw me for many months and is still ongoing. It can really hit you hard. No matter how professional and stoic you try and be.

Wednesdayafternoon · 12/02/2022 10:24

Value your friend more then the joke.
Whether or not any of us think it's unreasonable, she's upset and grieving and has asked you all to stop.

Svara · 12/02/2022 10:24

[quote Keepitonthedownlow]@svara what a ridiculous argument. So if you expect your parents to die before you you wouldn't be upset because it's expected.

Also some people have a deeper relationship with their animals that you seem to. Not everyone has a cat shaped hole that is easily filled. Everyone is different.[/quote]
I never said you wouldn't be upset. If you lost a child, for most people it would be much much harder than losing a parent in their 80s. My grandmother is 87 and I will miss her terribly when she goes, but I know it will happen. If I lost a parent at an early age or my 15 year old that would be completely different. I do think you mentally prepare yourself for losing an elderly parent or an older cat.

That's just speaking about expectation and mental preparation, I don't personally equate human lives with cat lives, though I recognise that some do.

rainrainraincamedowndowndown · 12/02/2022 10:20

I really don't understand why you can send a joke about cat, knowing they recently lost their cat. That's truly insensitive. How could you? Really shocking, tbh.

lucythejuicy · 12/02/2022 10:19

It depends on the joke?

nettie434 · 12/02/2022 10:19

One of them who I am very close to has been very annoyed with my recently but I don't know why. (I have asked). She sent me a very angry text message last week

So are you saying that she is using the cat joke to criticise you but is actually annoyed about something else? As your friend won't even tell you what the problem is, then it's impossible to know. Perhaps it's because she felt you weren't sympathetic enough about the death of her cat in the first place?

I'd apologise to the group for upsetting her. If you want to keep up the friendship I'd send her some flowers and a card saying you're sorry. If you don't, then I'd just carry on as if there's nothing wrong (avoiding cat jokes) because that's all you can do if someone won't tell you why they have upset you.

DelorisVC · 12/02/2022 10:17

I’m really sorry to hear of the loss of your Dad op.
I doubt you need any extra stress or unnecessary drama at this point in your life.

IsItTooHotInHere · 12/02/2022 10:16

yabu

Keepitonthedownlow · 12/02/2022 10:15

@svara what a ridiculous argument. So if you expect your parents to die before you you wouldn't be upset because it's expected.

Also some people have a deeper relationship with their animals that you seem to. Not everyone has a cat shaped hole that is easily filled. Everyone is different.

DelorisVC · 12/02/2022 10:14

Loosing a cat is not like loosing a child. In no way shape or form.
I did however really struggle with the loss of our cat. It was so much harder than anyone in my family imagined it could be.
I hated walking past the cat food aisle because it reminded me she was gone. Especially if I went into auto piglet and wandered down there automatically.
I don’t think you’ve been too insensitive though. It sounds like a genuine mistake and I don’t you deserved an angry response from her.

Keepitonthedownlow · 12/02/2022 10:13

YABVU she is grieving and will likely be for some time!!!!

username1293948 · 12/02/2022 10:12

Yabu. If someone tells you something upsets them, don’t then try and PROVE that it doesn’t Confused

Juniper68 · 12/02/2022 10:12

Like losing a child! Shock How scary to even think that.

Svara · 12/02/2022 10:09

@Dibbydoos

YABU it's completely insensitive - our pets are our family, its like losing a child. Get over yourself and quickly. I'd apologise profusely.
No, it's not even close to the same. You get a cat expecting it to live 15 years, knowing you will lose it. You don't expect that your child will go before you. I was very sad when we lost our cat at only three as I'd thought I had another decade or more, but even then I would never compare it to a child! We waited 10 weeks then got new cats. They didn't replace the cat we lost but they filled the cat shaped hole in our lives.
ThirdElephant · 12/02/2022 10:08

@LetHimHaveIt

I don't think that at all, thanks. But I recognize that there are, for want of a better term, 'social yardsticks', which only allow our problems to affect others to a certain degree. Laws surrounding noise nuisance, for instance, don't suit me at all, because I fucking hate people who play music in their garden at any time. And I suspect they don't suit night workers. But they seem to suit most of the population, so I muddle along. And most employers give time off for the death of a relative (and give more or less depending on the degree of consanguinity) and not for pets. Because most people feel more for a person with whom they: shared DNA/a language/years and years of life experiences; could recount stories of childhood; could share a joke; could sob on a shoulder; could go on holiday; could see a film; could buy a house . . . than a cat. So, no - I don't think peculiar over-sensitivity to the death of a cat should allow a woman to intentionally be a dick to someone who wasn't intentionally being a dick to them.
That's the issue though- the social yardstick doesn't work for mental health and, especially if someone is close to you, it's generally best practice to be mindful of people's individual quirks and sensitivities. For example, I've a friend who's extremely needle-phobic, so I don't mention any needle-involving medical procedures in a group in which she's present. Because her comfort is important to me, despite the fact I don't personally understand her feelings on the matter. If I decided that the social yardstick means it shouldn't be a problem for her and therefore decided to conduct myself as if it weren't a problem for her, I would be the dick, as you put it.

As lots of PP have shown- sensitivity around the death of a pet is fairly common. Just because you don't get it, that doesn't mean it's irrelevant or peculiar and can be safely ignored. If this friend of OP was very close to her cat, I'd expect OP to have been able to work out that this might not be the time for cat jokes.

LethargicActress · 12/02/2022 10:08

YANBU. There must be other things going on in this woman’s life that either mean she is over reacting to the death of her cat, or she has some other reason for not being able to cope with something so normal.

IncompleteSenten · 12/02/2022 10:02

Sending her cat jokes is insensitive whether or not she is annoyed for some other reason too.

Juniper68 · 12/02/2022 10:01

@3luckystars

Why would she be walking down the cat aisle anyway now.

She’s just upset. Don’t be hard on yourself as everyone is different, but I would apologise for upsetting her and put it behind me.

I thought that. Unless she has other cats?
saleorbouy · 12/02/2022 10:01

YANBU. She's an adult and needs to get over her loss. There a bigger issues in many people's lives and they manage to carry on.
She sounds a bit over sensitive to me.

Squirrelsbizaare · 12/02/2022 10:00

Has she actually asked in the group for people to stop posting, or has she just said the joke About a cat has upset her.
If it's the latter, surely that's when the friend group step in and express a bit of sympathy, or support. It's a loss and she is still grieving.
I can't see how you have taken from that, she has started a campaign against you ?

middleager · 12/02/2022 10:00

YABVU.